Dobbin
#81
(12-01-2024, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Some odd comments on here.

Apparently we don't have a goal scorer...and yet Maja is the second highest goal scorer in the Championship to date.

What we lack is other goal scorers, only 5 different goal scorers so far, that's absurd.

From what I have seen this season we very rarely control midfield, and too much of the game is played in our half. Even against Portsmouth, there was a concerning lack of control in the first half, when Portsmouth were able to put a lot of pressure on our defence.

Long advocated for an extra body in midfield, playing 433. The three on current form would be Mowatt, Styles and Molumby, although I slightly worry about the quality of passing in that trio.

The forward 3 pick themselves.

And therein lies the problem. We can't expect to do well thus season when so many of our players are individually not playing well. Particularly our forward options, why are Wallace, Dobbins, Diangana, Swift and Johnstone playing so ineffective.

We have lost defenders to injury, but we have found solutions to those problems. But from an attacking perspective only Fellows, Grant and Maja are contributing.

I agree with Birdman, the ultimate responsibility lies with Corberan, currently the performances and results are mediocre at best and joyless to watch. The current run is unsustainable, and at some stage draws will turn into either wins or losses. Which way it breaks will determine Corberans  future at the club.

But if he does go, it is not guaranteed that things will improve. My view is that they would get worse. It's only Corberans abilities as a good coach of defences that is stopping us from being in a relegation fight.

I might be wrong on that, other opinions are available.
Super post.

Particularly the one-paced midfield and the fact all flair players bar Tom are out of form.
Reply
#82
(12-01-2024, 08:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Some odd comments on here.

Apparently we don't have a goal scorer...and yet Maja is the second highest goal scorer in the Championship to date.

What we lack is other goal scorers, only 5 different goal scorers so far, that's absurd.

From what I have seen this season we very rarely control midfield, and too much of the game is played in our half. Even against Portsmouth, there was a concerning lack of control in the first half, when Portsmouth were able to put a lot of pressure on our defence.

Long advocated for an extra body in midfield, playing 433. The three on current form would be Mowatt, Styles and Molumby, although I slightly worry about the quality of passing in that trio.

The forward 3 pick themselves.

And therein lies the problem. We can't expect to do well thus season when so many of our players are individually not playing well. Particularly our forward options, why are Wallace, Dobbins, Diangana, Swift and Johnstone playing so ineffective.

We have lost defenders to injury, but we have found solutions to those problems. But from an attacking perspective only Fellows, Grant and Maja are contributing.

I agree with Birdman, the ultimate responsibility lies with Corberan, currently the performances and results are mediocre at best and joyless to watch. The current run is unsustainable, and at some stage draws will turn into either wins or losses. Which way it breaks will determine Corberans  future at the club.

But if he does go, it is not guaranteed that things will improve. My view is that they would get worse. It's only Corberans abilities as a good coach of defences that is stopping us from being in a relegation fight.

I might be wrong on that, other opinions are available.

Excellent post, especially the bit in bold which people would do well to remember should we ever get rid of Carlos.

Agree. And we have to remember that there's probably no money for new (and that doesn't automatically mean better) players.
Patience...is a virtue not many of us football supporters have.
Reply
#83
(12-01-2024, 08:26 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Some odd comments on here.

Apparently we don't have a goal scorer...and yet Maja is the second highest goal scorer in the Championship to date.

What we lack is other goal scorers, only 5 different goal scorers so far, that's absurd.

From what I have seen this season we very rarely control midfield, and too much of the game is played in our half. Even against Portsmouth, there was a concerning lack of control in the first half, when Portsmouth were able to put a lot of pressure on our defence.

Long advocated for an extra body in midfield, playing 433. The three on current form would be Mowatt, Styles and Molumby, although I slightly worry about the quality of passing in that trio.

The forward 3 pick themselves.

And therein lies the problem. We can't expect to do well thus season when so many of our players are individually not playing well. Particularly our forward options, why are Wallace, Dobbins, Diangana, Swift and Johnstone playing so ineffective.

We have lost defenders to injury, but we have found solutions to those problems. But from an attacking perspective only Fellows, Grant and Maja are contributing.

I agree with Birdman, the ultimate responsibility lies with Corberan, currently the performances and results are mediocre at best and joyless to watch. The current run is unsustainable, and at some stage draws will turn into either wins or losses. Which way it breaks will determine Corberans  future at the club.

But if he does go, it is not guaranteed that things will improve. My view is that they would get worse. It's only Corberans abilities as a good coach of defences that is stopping us from being in a relegation fight.

I might be wrong on that, other opinions are available.

Excellent post, especially the bit in bold which people would do well to remember should we ever get rid of Carlos.

I disagree that we’d be in a relegation fight under a different manager - this squad is still comfortably capable of an upper mid table finish - unless we appoint another Bruce. 

The key question is whether CC’s style is the best suited to get results from this group.

I don't necessarily disagree with you about the squad being capable of being a top half team, perhaps a top 6  team.

But there are a number of players who are so out of form at this moment, that currently this squad is not one that can finish top half.
Reply
#84
(12-01-2024, 08:53 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:26 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Some odd comments on here.

Apparently we don't have a goal scorer...and yet Maja is the second highest goal scorer in the Championship to date.

What we lack is other goal scorers, only 5 different goal scorers so far, that's absurd.

From what I have seen this season we very rarely control midfield, and too much of the game is played in our half. Even against Portsmouth, there was a concerning lack of control in the first half, when Portsmouth were able to put a lot of pressure on our defence.

Long advocated for an extra body in midfield, playing 433. The three on current form would be Mowatt, Styles and Molumby, although I slightly worry about the quality of passing in that trio.

The forward 3 pick themselves.

And therein lies the problem. We can't expect to do well thus season when so many of our players are individually not playing well. Particularly our forward options, why are Wallace, Dobbins, Diangana, Swift and Johnstone playing so ineffective.

We have lost defenders to injury, but we have found solutions to those problems. But from an attacking perspective only Fellows, Grant and Maja are contributing.

I agree with Birdman, the ultimate responsibility lies with Corberan, currently the performances and results are mediocre at best and joyless to watch. The current run is unsustainable, and at some stage draws will turn into either wins or losses. Which way it breaks will determine Corberans  future at the club.

But if he does go, it is not guaranteed that things will improve. My view is that they would get worse. It's only Corberans abilities as a good coach of defences that is stopping us from being in a relegation fight.

I might be wrong on that, other opinions are available.

Excellent post, especially the bit in bold which people would do well to remember should we ever get rid of Carlos.

I disagree that we’d be in a relegation fight under a different manager - this squad is still comfortably capable of an upper mid table finish - unless we appoint another Bruce. 

The key question is whether CC’s style is the best suited to get results from this group.

I don't necessarily disagree with you about the squad being capable of being a top half team, perhaps a top 6  team.

But there are a number of players who are so out of form at this moment, that currently this squad is not one that can finish top half.

One or two players out of form is low confidence, every player out of form suggests a much bigger issue.
Reply
#85
But that's the point isn't it "We're capable of being an upper mid table team"...we're 7th! If we win the next game then we could be 5th and all of a sudden the table looks good again.

I don't trust us to get anyone in that would give us and instant boost and I think it's likely that we'll start winning games soon because that's what has happened in the past.
Reply
#86
(12-01-2024, 09:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:53 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:26 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Some odd comments on here.

Apparently we don't have a goal scorer...and yet Maja is the second highest goal scorer in the Championship to date.

What we lack is other goal scorers, only 5 different goal scorers so far, that's absurd.

From what I have seen this season we very rarely control midfield, and too much of the game is played in our half. Even against Portsmouth, there was a concerning lack of control in the first half, when Portsmouth were able to put a lot of pressure on our defence.

Long advocated for an extra body in midfield, playing 433. The three on current form would be Mowatt, Styles and Molumby, although I slightly worry about the quality of passing in that trio.

The forward 3 pick themselves.

And therein lies the problem. We can't expect to do well thus season when so many of our players are individually not playing well. Particularly our forward options, why are Wallace, Dobbins, Diangana, Swift and Johnstone playing so ineffective.

We have lost defenders to injury, but we have found solutions to those problems. But from an attacking perspective only Fellows, Grant and Maja are contributing.

I agree with Birdman, the ultimate responsibility lies with Corberan, currently the performances and results are mediocre at best and joyless to watch. The current run is unsustainable, and at some stage draws will turn into either wins or losses. Which way it breaks will determine Corberans  future at the club.

But if he does go, it is not guaranteed that things will improve. My view is that they would get worse. It's only Corberans abilities as a good coach of defences that is stopping us from being in a relegation fight.

I might be wrong on that, other opinions are available.

Excellent post, especially the bit in bold which people would do well to remember should we ever get rid of Carlos.

I disagree that we’d be in a relegation fight under a different manager - this squad is still comfortably capable of an upper mid table finish - unless we appoint another Bruce. 

The key question is whether CC’s style is the best suited to get results from this group.

I don't necessarily disagree with you about the squad being capable of being a top half team, perhaps a top 6  team.

But there are a number of players who are so out of form at this moment, that currently this squad is not one that can finish top half.

One or two players out of form is low confidence, every player out of form suggests a much bigger issue.

There's probably a handful of players out of form.

But even if everyone was on top form, think central midfield is an area of concern,  that can be masked to a certain extent by strengths in other areas.
Reply
#87
(12-01-2024, 09:34 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 09:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:53 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:26 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 08:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Excellent post, especially the bit in bold which people would do well to remember should we ever get rid of Carlos.

I disagree that we’d be in a relegation fight under a different manager - this squad is still comfortably capable of an upper mid table finish - unless we appoint another Bruce. 

The key question is whether CC’s style is the best suited to get results from this group.

I don't necessarily disagree with you about the squad being capable of being a top half team, perhaps a top 6  team.

But there are a number of players who are so out of form at this moment, that currently this squad is not one that can finish top half.

One or two players out of form is low confidence, every player out of form suggests a much bigger issue.

There's probably a handful of players out of form.

But even if everyone was on top form, think central midfield is an area of concern,  that can be masked to a certain extent by strengths in other areas.

We lost two stand out players in the summer in key positions for a CC team.  They havnt been replaced, despite the initial wave of excitement over recruitment.   In hindsight, what might we have accomplished last year with a fit Maja making up the spine with Yok and Kippers.
Reply
#88
(12-01-2024, 09:10 AM)Sliced Wrote: But that's the point isn't it "We're capable of being an upper mid table team"...we're 7th! If we win the next game then we could be 5th and all of a sudden the table looks good again.

I don't trust us to get anyone in that would give us and instant boost and I think it's likely that we'll start winning games soon because that's what has happened in the past.

And in fairness, most of the fans here are not calling for CC’s head - most realise he’s doing a more than acceptable job and that ultimately it’s just a few tweaks needed to get us going again. The concern is that the last 12 games (ie: quarter of a season) we’ve been in relegation form and if anything our performances are getting worse, not better.

I don’t think there are many managers who’d have done a better job than CC has over the last 2 years, however there are definitely managers who’d get more from this squad than he has over the last couple months, hence questions are being rightly asked.
Reply
#89
(12-01-2024, 10:26 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 09:10 AM)Sliced Wrote: But that's the point isn't it "We're capable of being an upper mid table team"...we're 7th! If we win the next game then we could be 5th and all of a sudden the table looks good again.

I don't trust us to get anyone in that would give us and instant boost and I think it's likely that we'll start winning games soon because that's what has happened in the past.

And in fairness, most of the fans here are not calling for CC’s head - most realise he’s doing a more than acceptable job and that ultimately it’s just a few tweaks needed to get us going again. The concern is that the last 12 games (ie: quarter of a season) we’ve been in relegation form and if anything our performances are getting worse, not better.

I don’t think there are many managers who’d have done a better job than CC has over the last 2 years, however there are definitely managers who’d get more from this squad than he has over the last couple months, hence questions are being rightly asked.
About where I’m at with additional concerns that the football is by and large about as enjoyable as it was for large parts under Pulis, and the same thing will happen in the end. Fans will tolerate dull when winning but not when it stops producing results
Reply
#90
(12-01-2024, 12:11 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 10:26 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 09:10 AM)Sliced Wrote: But that's the point isn't it "We're capable of being an upper mid table team"...we're 7th! If we win the next game then we could be 5th and all of a sudden the table looks good again.

I don't trust us to get anyone in that would give us and instant boost and I think it's likely that we'll start winning games soon because that's what has happened in the past.

And in fairness, most of the fans here are not calling for CC’s head - most realise he’s doing a more than acceptable job and that ultimately it’s just a few tweaks needed to get us going again. The concern is that the last 12 games (ie: quarter of a season) we’ve been in relegation form and if anything our performances are getting worse, not better.

I don’t think there are many managers who’d have done a better job than CC has over the last 2 years, however there are definitely managers who’d get more from this squad than he has over the last couple months, hence questions are being rightly asked.
About where I’m at with additional concerns that the football is by and large about as enjoyable as it was for large parts under Pulis, and the same thing will happen in the end. Fans will tolerate dull when winning but not when it stops producing results
Not necessarily. This is West Barcelona Albion here, as villa fans called us.  Hodgson copped criticism as did SGM and even Val (We were 4th when he was sacked!). Personally, I find a well organised side good to watch and believe it is more frustration that drives the moans.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: