Dobbin
#71
Worst we've ever had. No question.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#72
(11-30-2024, 10:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Worst we've ever had. No question.

Better than Bruce is all he's winning so far.

Oh I yearn for those dreadful limping to promotion under Slav days, when we'd bang in 3 or 4 quite often
.. and yet some would still revel in the limping.

FFS, CC has done fuck all, except be better than Bruce, and that was a bloody low bar.

I'll stay in my world where playing attractive football, and scoring more goals than the opposition a D then limping over the line is derided... If the alternative is a bunch of pragmatic bollox justified because well any fucking reason...

Oh yeah, best since Roy... Yep
Reply
#73
(11-30-2024, 10:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Worst we've ever had. No question.

I'm just happy to have a good lot of replies and comments, usually when I say something the thread stops dead Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#74
(11-30-2024, 10:30 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-30-2024, 10:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Worst we've ever had. No question.

Better than Bruce is all he's winning so far.

Oh I yearn for those dreadful limping to promotion under Slav days, when we'd bang in 3 or 4 quite often
.. and yet some would still revel in the limping.

FFS, CC has done fuck all, except be better than Bruce, and that was a bloody low bar.

I'll stay in my world where playing attractive football, and scoring more goals than the opposition a D then limping over the line is derided... If the alternative is a bunch of pragmatic bollox justified because well any fucking reason...

Oh yeah, best since Roy... Yep

In fairness, we had easily the best player in the division that season. Just look at what Sainz is doing for Norwich.
Reply
#75
(11-30-2024, 10:44 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-30-2024, 10:30 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-30-2024, 10:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Worst we've ever had. No question.

Better than Bruce is all he's winning so far.

Oh I yearn for those dreadful limping to promotion under Slav days, when we'd bang in 3 or 4 quite often
.. and yet some would still revel in the limping.

FFS, CC has done fuck all, except be better than Bruce, and that was a bloody low bar.

I'll stay in my world where playing attractive football, and scoring more goals than the opposition a D then limping over the line is derided... If the alternative is a bunch of pragmatic bollox justified because well any fucking reason...

Oh yeah, best since Roy... Yep

In fairness, we had easily the best player in the division that season. Just look at what Sainz is doing for Norwich.

Found by??... Oh yeah, the manager... Still only limped over the line, to be maligned on here forever since...
Reply
#76
(11-30-2024, 10:49 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-30-2024, 10:44 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-30-2024, 10:30 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-30-2024, 10:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Worst we've ever had. No question.

Better than Bruce is all he's winning so far.

Oh I yearn for those dreadful limping to promotion under Slav days, when we'd bang in 3 or 4 quite often
.. and yet some would still revel in the limping.

FFS, CC has done fuck all, except be better than Bruce, and that was a bloody low bar.

I'll stay in my world where playing attractive football, and scoring more goals than the opposition a D then limping over the line is derided... If the alternative is a bunch of pragmatic bollox justified because well any fucking reason...

Oh yeah, best since Roy... Yep

In fairness, we had easily the best player in the division that season. Just look at what Sainz is doing for Norwich.

Found by??... Oh yeah, the manager... Still only limped over the line, to be maligned on here forever since...

Are you the poster who was absolutely devastated beyond all rational reason when Bilic was deservedly sacked and went on and on about it for months afterwards?
Reply
#77
(11-30-2024, 10:30 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-30-2024, 10:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Worst we've ever had. No question.

Better than Bruce is all he's winning so far.

Oh I yearn for those dreadful limping to promotion under Slav days, when we'd bang in 3 or 4 quite often
.. and yet some would still revel in the limping.

FFS, CC has done fuck all, except be better than Bruce, and that was a bloody low bar.

I'll stay in my world where playing attractive football, and scoring more goals than the opposition a D then limping over the line is derided... If the alternative is a bunch of pragmatic bollox justified because well any fucking reason...

Oh yeah, best since Roy... Yep

Do you not consider taking a team from bottom of the table to just missing out on a play off place on the last day of the season to be an achievement? Or getting into the playoffs last season to be an achievement? All whilst having pretty much no money to spend, losing some of our best players and inheriting a squad and infrastructure riddled with the effects of years of mismanagement.

Whilst this has been a frustrating season so far and entertainment levels are extremely low let’s not re-write history. Carlos has done a lot more than ‘be better than Steve Bruce’.
Reply
#78
Some odd comments on here.

Apparently we don't have a goal scorer...and yet Maja is the second highest goal scorer in the Championship to date.

What we lack is other goal scorers, only 5 different goal scorers so far, that's absurd.

From what I have seen this season we very rarely control midfield, and too much of the game is played in our half. Even against Portsmouth, there was a concerning lack of control in the first half, when Portsmouth were able to put a lot of pressure on our defence.

Long advocated for an extra body in midfield, playing 433. The three on current form would be Mowatt, Styles and Molumby, although I slightly worry about the quality of passing in that trio.

The forward 3 pick themselves.

And therein lies the problem. We can't expect to do well thus season when so many of our players are individually not playing well. Particularly our forward options, why are Wallace, Dobbins, Diangana, Swift and Johnstone playing so ineffective.

We have lost defenders to injury, but we have found solutions to those problems. But from an attacking perspective only Fellows, Grant and Maja are contributing.

I agree with Birdman, the ultimate responsibility lies with Corberan, currently the performances and results are mediocre at best and joyless to watch. The current run is unsustainable, and at some stage draws will turn into either wins or losses. Which way it breaks will determine Corberans future at the club.

But if he does go, it is not guaranteed that things will improve. My view is that they would get worse. It's only Corberans abilities as a good coach of defences that is stopping us from being in a relegation fight.

I might be wrong on that, other opinions are available.
Reply
#79
(12-01-2024, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Some odd comments on here.

Apparently we don't have a goal scorer...and yet Maja is the second highest goal scorer in the Championship to date.

What we lack is other goal scorers, only 5 different goal scorers so far, that's absurd.

From what I have seen this season we very rarely control midfield, and too much of the game is played in our half. Even against Portsmouth, there was a concerning lack of control in the first half, when Portsmouth were able to put a lot of pressure on our defence.

Long advocated for an extra body in midfield, playing 433. The three on current form would be Mowatt, Styles and Molumby, although I slightly worry about the quality of passing in that trio.

The forward 3 pick themselves.

And therein lies the problem. We can't expect to do well thus season when so many of our players are individually not playing well. Particularly our forward options, why are Wallace, Dobbins, Diangana, Swift and Johnstone playing so ineffective.

We have lost defenders to injury, but we have found solutions to those problems. But from an attacking perspective only Fellows, Grant and Maja are contributing.

I agree with Birdman, the ultimate responsibility lies with Corberan, currently the performances and results are mediocre at best and joyless to watch. The current run is unsustainable, and at some stage draws will turn into either wins or losses. Which way it breaks will determine Corberans  future at the club.

But if he does go, it is not guaranteed that things will improve. My view is that they would get worse. It's only Corberans abilities as a good coach of defences that is stopping us from being in a relegation fight.

I might be wrong on that, other opinions are available.

Excellent post, especially the bit in bold which people would do well to remember should we ever get rid of Carlos.
Reply
#80
(12-01-2024, 08:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 07:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Some odd comments on here.

Apparently we don't have a goal scorer...and yet Maja is the second highest goal scorer in the Championship to date.

What we lack is other goal scorers, only 5 different goal scorers so far, that's absurd.

From what I have seen this season we very rarely control midfield, and too much of the game is played in our half. Even against Portsmouth, there was a concerning lack of control in the first half, when Portsmouth were able to put a lot of pressure on our defence.

Long advocated for an extra body in midfield, playing 433. The three on current form would be Mowatt, Styles and Molumby, although I slightly worry about the quality of passing in that trio.

The forward 3 pick themselves.

And therein lies the problem. We can't expect to do well thus season when so many of our players are individually not playing well. Particularly our forward options, why are Wallace, Dobbins, Diangana, Swift and Johnstone playing so ineffective.

We have lost defenders to injury, but we have found solutions to those problems. But from an attacking perspective only Fellows, Grant and Maja are contributing.

I agree with Birdman, the ultimate responsibility lies with Corberan, currently the performances and results are mediocre at best and joyless to watch. The current run is unsustainable, and at some stage draws will turn into either wins or losses. Which way it breaks will determine Corberans  future at the club.

But if he does go, it is not guaranteed that things will improve. My view is that they would get worse. It's only Corberans abilities as a good coach of defences that is stopping us from being in a relegation fight.

I might be wrong on that, other opinions are available.

Excellent post, especially the bit in bold which people would do well to remember should we ever get rid of Carlos.

I disagree that we’d be in a relegation fight under a different manager - this squad is still comfortably capable of an upper mid table finish - unless we appoint another Bruce. 

The key question is whether CC’s style is the best suited to get results from this group.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)