Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
We needed to win today and we didn't. A big psychological blow.
A question:
Do people feel that Carlos has taken us as far as he can, or is the team performing at the expected level?
I'd also agree that any discussions of the PL are irrelevant. PL football is a world away from the Championship and really isn't currently our concern.
Posts: 8,115
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
(11-30-2024, 05:15 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:13 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Johnstone sucked balls in both play off legs. Clearly not up to it. But let’s rewrite history yeah?
So did many of our players?
He was a very good player for us second half of last season and a fan favourite. Yeah, hindsight is great, but something is clearly wrong with him and others because he's not the only one out of form and confidence, and it is the managers job to sort that. If he doesn't, he'll pay the price.
His form in the close of last season was very poor and I can’t believe you can’t see that. £3m that would have been better spent up top.
Meanwhile keep loving-in on a failing player and manager.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
(11-30-2024, 05:09 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Beyond Maja, we have nothing up top. I don’t know how many of you have ever kicked a ball but to my experience of it all it is strike forces that win game after game.
You can't say such outrageous things like that on here Hawks. The purists expect no goals
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(11-30-2024, 05:16 PM)TartanRug Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems somewhat strange to simultaneously call the manager out fir not winning games and at the same time giving up all hope when certain players are on the pitch.
We are not in position where we can afford not to give game time to players like Wallace, Dobbins. So if they are not good enough, is it any surprise we are not winning more games.
I don't think we have come to terms with how Bang average (by championship standards) we are.
This is a valid point.
We have plenty of people on here calling almost all our players shit and crap, yet they expect us to win every game?
I don't think some key players, Wallace, Swift and Johnstone especially are offering enough compared to their abilities, which badly needs looking at. Swift was superb and everything he was known for until that injury last season, it wasn't a horrendous one, so what changed? Wallace isn't that old that he should have fallen off a cliff like this. Johnstone looks a shadow of the player that came into us last season.
What has happened? And if it is something Carlos has done or is doing, he needs to rethink it, and if not, then his position is untenable because this is not going to just get better by itself. Dobbins clearly isn't ready for this level of football yet, but at our level sometimes you do need to accept these players get minutes, they only get better by actually playing too. However he seems to have no confidence either. Only attackers we have that seem to have confidence in themselves are Grant, Maja and Fellows, and neither are a solution to the problem since Fellows only creates from out wide and isn't a playmaker, Maja needs to be the focal point, and Grant, for his hard work, effort and determination, we know isn't a class footballer that is going to dominate play.
Good post Birdie.
We aren't going to win games with only 5 or 6 players performing anything like decent.
I have to question some of our recruitment even on our budget, I'm not sure if it's CC or the recruitment dept who are recommending some of these players but whoever it is needs to improve the hit rate. Or am I just expecting too much from the bargain bin? Obviously we needed a striker and have done for ages but signing Cole is a sign of where we are at.
I do look at Carrick at Boro who has had a supportive board behind him for his whole spell there, I've no doubt CC would be doing better than now with that backing
Cole was a pointless signing, and that's just not what we needed. If we were that limited, we'd have been better promoting academy kids like Faal and Cleary, and going for quality over quantity. However I can not see how Wallace is a better option than Cole, and that is one thing I do not understand what CC is thinking.
Posts: 8,115
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
(11-30-2024, 05:19 PM)MrBater Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:09 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Beyond Maja, we have nothing up top. I don’t know how many of you have ever kicked a ball but to my experience of it all it is strike forces that win game after game.
You can't say such outrageous things like that on here Hawks. The purists expect no goals
The purists can go and fuck themselves and masturbate into an ‘oh, we have a foreign manager’ bucket. Because this is what it is, as it was with Pepe Mel who didn’t have a clue either. The difference was that back then we had players with the stones to deal with it.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(11-30-2024, 05:18 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:15 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:13 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Johnstone sucked balls in both play off legs. Clearly not up to it. But let’s rewrite history yeah?
So did many of our players?
He was a very good player for us second half of last season and a fan favourite. Yeah, hindsight is great, but something is clearly wrong with him and others because he's not the only one out of form and confidence, and it is the managers job to sort that. If he doesn't, he'll pay the price.
His form in the close of last season was very poor and I can’t believe you can’t see that. £3m that would have been better spent up top.
Meanwhile keep loving-in on a failing player and manager.
No love in.
I just don't do hyperbole when analysing things.
Yes, I'd have spent 3 million up top, mind where and who? Goalscorers are a rare and expensive commodity, we need more than one since too many of our players don't score. If all our players chipped in with a goal more often we'd be doing better, but we're utterly reliant on a handful of players that can score.
Carlos has a LOT of work to do, he needs to see why Wallace, Swift, Johsntone and even Grady have completely lost everything that made them excellent players at this level and fix it. There are noises that the players always responded well to the coach he lost in the summer, in the same way Pulis relied on his assistant a lot for man management, if that is the case, he had better find a way to fix it, either by changing his style, or finding another coach who can bridge that gap.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(11-30-2024, 05:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:16 PM)TartanRug Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems somewhat strange to simultaneously call the manager out fir not winning games and at the same time giving up all hope when certain players are on the pitch.
We are not in position where we can afford not to give game time to players like Wallace, Dobbins. So if they are not good enough, is it any surprise we are not winning more games.
I don't think we have come to terms with how Bang average (by championship standards) we are.
This is a valid point.
We have plenty of people on here calling almost all our players shit and crap, yet they expect us to win every game?
I don't think some key players, Wallace, Swift and Johnstone especially are offering enough compared to their abilities, which badly needs looking at. Swift was superb and everything he was known for until that injury last season, it wasn't a horrendous one, so what changed? Wallace isn't that old that he should have fallen off a cliff like this. Johnstone looks a shadow of the player that came into us last season.
What has happened? And if it is something Carlos has done or is doing, he needs to rethink it, and if not, then his position is untenable because this is not going to just get better by itself. Dobbins clearly isn't ready for this level of football yet, but at our level sometimes you do need to accept these players get minutes, they only get better by actually playing too. However he seems to have no confidence either. Only attackers we have that seem to have confidence in themselves are Grant, Maja and Fellows, and neither are a solution to the problem since Fellows only creates from out wide and isn't a playmaker, Maja needs to be the focal point, and Grant, for his hard work, effort and determination, we know isn't a class footballer that is going to dominate play.
Good post Birdie.
We aren't going to win games with only 5 or 6 players performing anything like decent.
I have to question some of our recruitment even on our budget, I'm not sure if it's CC or the recruitment dept who are recommending some of these players but whoever it is needs to improve the hit rate. Or am I just expecting too much from the bargain bin? Obviously we needed a striker and have done for ages but signing Cole is a sign of where we are at.
I do look at Carrick at Boro who has had a supportive board behind him for his whole spell there, I've no doubt CC would be doing better than now with that backing
Cole was a pointless signing, and that's just not what we needed. If we were that limited, we'd have been better promoting academy kids like Faal and Cleary, and going for quality over quantity. However I can not see how Wallace is a better option than Cole, and that is one thing I do not understand what CC is thinking.
Cleary won’t make it in league football. He’s been very ineffective at Walsall this season and is pretty much only getting game time in the EFL trophy now. I like Faal but he’s barely got a sniff at Wrexham so far. In reality both are probably miles off the level we need.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(11-30-2024, 05:25 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:16 PM)TartanRug Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (11-30-2024, 05:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems somewhat strange to simultaneously call the manager out fir not winning games and at the same time giving up all hope when certain players are on the pitch.
We are not in position where we can afford not to give game time to players like Wallace, Dobbins. So if they are not good enough, is it any surprise we are not winning more games.
I don't think we have come to terms with how Bang average (by championship standards) we are.
This is a valid point.
We have plenty of people on here calling almost all our players shit and crap, yet they expect us to win every game?
I don't think some key players, Wallace, Swift and Johnstone especially are offering enough compared to their abilities, which badly needs looking at. Swift was superb and everything he was known for until that injury last season, it wasn't a horrendous one, so what changed? Wallace isn't that old that he should have fallen off a cliff like this. Johnstone looks a shadow of the player that came into us last season.
What has happened? And if it is something Carlos has done or is doing, he needs to rethink it, and if not, then his position is untenable because this is not going to just get better by itself. Dobbins clearly isn't ready for this level of football yet, but at our level sometimes you do need to accept these players get minutes, they only get better by actually playing too. However he seems to have no confidence either. Only attackers we have that seem to have confidence in themselves are Grant, Maja and Fellows, and neither are a solution to the problem since Fellows only creates from out wide and isn't a playmaker, Maja needs to be the focal point, and Grant, for his hard work, effort and determination, we know isn't a class footballer that is going to dominate play.
Good post Birdie.
We aren't going to win games with only 5 or 6 players performing anything like decent.
I have to question some of our recruitment even on our budget, I'm not sure if it's CC or the recruitment dept who are recommending some of these players but whoever it is needs to improve the hit rate. Or am I just expecting too much from the bargain bin? Obviously we needed a striker and have done for ages but signing Cole is a sign of where we are at.
I do look at Carrick at Boro who has had a supportive board behind him for his whole spell there, I've no doubt CC would be doing better than now with that backing
Cole was a pointless signing, and that's just not what we needed. If we were that limited, we'd have been better promoting academy kids like Faal and Cleary, and going for quality over quantity. However I can not see how Wallace is a better option than Cole, and that is one thing I do not understand what CC is thinking.
Cleary won’t make it in league football. He’s been very ineffective at Walsall this season and is pretty much only getting game time in the EFL trophy now. I like Faal but he’s barely got a sniff at Wrexham so far. In reality both are probably miles off the level we need.
Agreed.
Cole isn't playing though, so it'd have had the same effect, was my point!
Posts: 2,843
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
I totally understand that CC was the best coach we could have had when he took over. He had nothing to work with and from the relegation zone, almost got us almost into the playoffs
However his negative, pragmatic approach to games against teams we should be beating has been doing my head in.
It's not a recent thing.
In his first full season 23/24, we had chance after chance of overhauling the top 2 but blew things time and again.
We limped into the playoffs but as soon as I realised we'd be up against Southampton I knew we wouldn't make it.
I utterly dislike Russell Martin but you’ve got to hand it to him. His team won games when they could've dropped points because they went for it. OK they’ll probably be back in the Championship next season but at least they'll have some money to spend.
This season we won 5 out of the first 6. Again our form has dropped off a cliff. 1 win in 12. In terms of fewest defeats we're joint top with Blades and Burnley. But in a league of victories we're joint 8th alongside 5 other teams. Wins give you 3 points, draws give you 1. If in 6 games you win 3 and lose 3, you're 50% better off than 6 draws.
I know this is obvious but surely CC understands it?
Posts: 2,008
Threads: 113
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
4
Carlos is now pissing me off. I lauded him as a genius and said he rarely makes a mistake, unfortunately he’s making loads now. His absolute stubbornness in informing his players to just keep the ball, if you don’t take a risk then you will struggle to score goals - it’s infuriating to keep watching us turn back instead of play it forward. We take risk at back but don’t take risks going forward. We are playing in the championship, if you give it away, you’ve a good chance you’ll get it back.
They moved to 4-4-2 second half and we just got pinned back and didn’t react, Molomby should have been bought on much earlier - no idea why he isn’t starting, I don’t rate him but at least he can be progressive with the ball. Why Dobbin? He’s done nothing to show he should be starting, Mikey has been poor but he’s constantly been in and out, how can you gain confidence if you are always in and out.
Why did he move to 5-3-2 - why not just take Mowatt off for Molomby and Racic for Swift and move up the pitch in a different way.
Why did Maja get taken off - he’s the only goalscorer - we should be trying to win.
The players are trying, I don’t blame them, I blame the tactics and the freedom in which they are allowed to play at the moment.
|