Assisted dying legislation.
#91
(11-29-2024, 01:25 PM)Morley Wrote: I agree with Diane Abbot which is something I never thought I'd say. 

"Is a judge supposed to second guess doctors? Will a judge make decisions on the basis of paperwork, or will there be a hearing in an open court? Where will be the capacity in the criminal justice system to deal with all this," she asks.

"Far from being a genuine safeguard, the involvement of a judge could just be a rubber stamp," she says.

Abbott continues by saying robust safeguards for the sick and dying are absolutely vital to protect them from predatory relatives, or the state, or themselves.

None of that is a reason for voting against the First Reading. The whole point of Parliament is to ensure legislation has adequate safeguards by the time it reaches the statute book. There are many in Parliament speaking against the bill today simply because they lack the capacity and willingness to engage in one of the fundamental questions of our age.

Politicians proved themselves useless at statecraft over Brexit. They're at risk of doing the same over this.

I feel exceptionally strongly that individuals ought to be given the agency over end of life. I lost my father and mother in law in circumstances bordering on the horrific in NHS hospitals. I'm sure that had a bearing on my Aunt's decision to travel to Switzerland to end her own life.

I suspect politicians will let down millions of us today by voting against this bill and kicking the issue into the long grass again.
Reply
#92
(11-29-2024, 01:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-29-2024, 01:25 PM)Morley Wrote: I agree with Diane Abbot which is something I never thought I'd say. 

"Is a judge supposed to second guess doctors? Will a judge make decisions on the basis of paperwork, or will there be a hearing in an open court? Where will be the capacity in the criminal justice system to deal with all this," she asks.

"Far from being a genuine safeguard, the involvement of a judge could just be a rubber stamp," she says.

Abbott continues by saying robust safeguards for the sick and dying are absolutely vital to protect them from predatory relatives, or the state, or themselves.

None of that is a reason for voting against the First Reading. The whole point of Parliament is to ensure legislation has adequate safeguards by the time it reaches the statute book. There are many in Parliament speaking against the bill today simply because they lack the capacity and willingness to engage in one of the fundamental questions of our age.

Politicians proved themselves useless at statecraft over Brexit. They're at risk of doing the same over this.

I feel exceptionally strongly that individuals ought to be given the agency over end of life. I lost my father and mother in law in circumstances bordering on the horrific in NHS hospitals. I'm sure that had a bearing on my Aunt's decision to travel to Switzerland to end her own life.

I suspect politicians will let down millions of us today by voting against this bill and kicking the issue into the long grass again.

+1, agree with all of that Proth. 

This topic needs serious debate by serious parliamentarians. Not a short shallow debate.

Quite a clear majority in favour of the bill moving forwards. Now we need to see Parliament at it's very, very best.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#93
I watched my mother starve herself to death in an NHS hospital rather than prolong her own agony, after she had fallen and suffered a bleed to the brain. According to nurses we spoke to in her ward, this happens a lot and is a conscious decision to die by the patient. If this law had it been in place it might, maybe even probably, would have helped. I completely get people's misgivings but my own experience would guide me towards voting for this bill.
Reply
#94
I watched my fiance die through LACK OF CARE. All this does is make jobs easier and lower palliative cost.

NO-ONE will convince me this is a good idea and I’d rather suffer to prove it than not.
Reply
#95
(11-29-2024, 02:41 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I watched my fiance die through LACK OF CARE. All this does is make jobs easier and lower palliative cost.

NO-ONE will convince me this is a good idea and I’d rather suffer to prove it than not.

This is the exact kind of testimony I hope is heard in the future debates.

I would hope that these issues are separated. Palliative care must improve irrespective if this bill.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#96
Palliative care? She was 42 and died because no one was available to scan her lungs.
Reply
#97
(11-29-2024, 02:44 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Palliative care? She was 42 and died because no one was available to scan her lungs.

I am truly sorry to hear thatband such failings in healthcare shouldn't happen.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#98
(11-29-2024, 02:46 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-29-2024, 02:44 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Palliative care? She was 42 and died because no one was available to scan her lungs.

I am truly sorry to hear thatband such failings in healthcare shouldn't happen.

Yet you shamelessly use it as a backdrop for your argument with absolutely no basis other than the worst stories. 

What about those who can be saved. 

I’m sorry. This is legal murder and every MP whom has voted for it hasn’t only voted for bad care, they have voted for death.
Reply
#99
(11-29-2024, 02:49 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-29-2024, 02:46 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-29-2024, 02:44 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Palliative care? She was 42 and died because no one was available to scan her lungs.

I am truly sorry to hear thatband such failings in healthcare shouldn't happen.

Yet you shamelessly use it as a backdrop for your argument with absolutely no basis other than the worst stories. 

What about those who can be saved. 

I’m sorry. This is legal murder and every MP whom has voted for it hasn’t only voted for bad care, they have voted for death.

Sorry you think that but I can assure you I absolutely have not done that Hawks. And never would. I am trying to see health care, end of life palliative care and assisted dying as three independent processes. The latter should in no way provide short cuts for the former 2, and if it was decided that the risk of that was too high during the debates to come I would be completely against the bill.

I am completely unsure what I think about it as I have stated m, that why I am glad our elected legislators are going to have time to debate and scrutinise things further.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
Hawks, your experience is as bad as things get, but I'm not sure how it fits in with the bill which is for terminally I'll people with a life expectancy of less than 6 months?

Unless that was your girlfriend's situation?? Or did the lack of scan contribute to her falling into that category?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: