Assisted dying legislation.
#81
(11-13-2024, 04:19 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 03:54 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 03:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address. 

On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist. 

‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf.  People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.

Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die. 

It's not about being disabled and being a burden.

Josh, I apologise that I made my remarks to you specifically as this is a wider point and tbh I like you so you’re one of the posters I don’t wish to be unnecessarily rude to. 

The point as pointed out by numerous charities and individuals (there are links on here by me and Squid making our concerns very clear what the issues are) within the disabled community is they don’t trust this proposed legislation to be the end of the debate. They see it as I do to some extent the slippery slope for over reach of the state, coercion by an ever increasingly ableist society and health professionals to put pressure on some of the most vulnerable in society and or those that care for them to make choices they wouldn’t have done previously.

This is not aimed at you Josh but if this was any other group in society be they ethnic minorities or those with mental illness problems rheue concerns would not just be met with a shrug of the shoulders like those with disabilities are on here and beyond.
I get your concerns Derek, but, if it was down to individual choice, then that would include people with disabilities. It couldn't be done without their consent. 
I don't think for one minute anyone on here is advocating forced suicide.

Even on this very thread, there is someone arguing that someone choosing to die because the quality of care provision is so poor, is still choosing to die and therefore not being forced. I disagree.

I would also add, that some might find it a struggle to believe how much people with disabilities/learning disabilities face to get decent care now and that there can already be pressures to put DNR orders in place when the same discussion would never be had with someone able bodied.

Exactly great post Squid. The argument oh well if you can’t get the care you need here’s some pills to take away the problem and if you don’t want to take them erm….well, anyway tara for now.
Reply
#82
(11-13-2024, 03:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.

We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.

I don't see the correlation personally.

You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address. 

On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist. 

‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf.  People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.

Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die. 

It's not about being disabled and being a burden.

Josh, I apologise that I made my remarks to you specifically as this is a wider point and tbh I like you so you’re one of the posters I don’t wish to be unnecessarily rude to. 

The point as pointed out by numerous charities and individuals (there are links on here by me and Squid making our concerns very clear what the issues are) within the disabled community is they don’t trust this proposed legislation to be the end of the debate. They see it as I do to some extent the slippery slope for over reach of the state, coercion by an ever increasingly ableist society and health professionals to put pressure on some of the most vulnerable in society and or those that care for them to make choices they wouldn’t have done previously.

This is not aimed at you Josh but if this was any other group in society be they ethnic minorities or those with mental illness problems rheue concerns would not just be met with a shrug of the shoulders like those with disabilities are on here and beyond.

No need to apologise, I haven't taken anything you have said as being personal or anything - far from it. I can see where you're coming from. I think your concerns are valid, but they do relate to issues that may or may not arise, and they're more about how the law is regulated and practiced rather than the law itself. Unfortunately we live in a shit vile world where any law will have scum bags finding loopholes and abusing any power they may have. That's just a fact of life, isn't it? 

I admit I am coming from this issue from an emotional place. The state my girlfriend was in for the weeks leading up to her nan's death was truly upsetting to see, all parties would have benefitted from a quicker and more humane death. I'm actually getting a bit upset typing this - just thinking about the recordings of her nan screaming in pain. I am aware that single personal incident shouldn't warrant a change in the law alone, but it's a scene, I have no doubt, that is being repeated up and down the country, all throughout the year, every year, despite the best and most loving care. 

Yes, I am aware of the potential for people to force relatives to sign their own death, but this is where the practice and application of the law comes in. If it is done correctly, the patient is sound of mind, and two independent professionals agree that they're sound of mind, they don't have long to live, and the process is as safeguarded as possible, then I see no reason why assisted dying should not be made law in exceptional circumstances. To be clear, my view is this is a last resort, when there is clearly no life for the patient, there is absolutely zero chance their medical condition will improve, and they're living in in-sufferable pain, and they're sound of mind at the time they make the decision, especially if the patient has signed a power of attorney type document earlier in their life making clear that this is their wish. The power of attorney could be named as a GP, perhaps, definitely someone who is not connected personally to the patient. That's the law I want to see in place right now. 

I do think further laws about dementia need to be implemented, too. But that is a very grey area, and I've no idea how that could be safeguarded in a similar way to what I've just mentioned.

Ultimately, under the current law, people are suffering un-imaginable pain, when their life is at an end. As a society there needs to be a way for people to die with as much dignity and in as little pain as possible.
Reply
#83
(11-13-2024, 04:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 04:19 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 03:54 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 03:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die. 

It's not about being disabled and being a burden.

Josh, I apologise that I made my remarks to you specifically as this is a wider point and tbh I like you so you’re one of the posters I don’t wish to be unnecessarily rude to. 

The point as pointed out by numerous charities and individuals (there are links on here by me and Squid making our concerns very clear what the issues are) within the disabled community is they don’t trust this proposed legislation to be the end of the debate. They see it as I do to some extent the slippery slope for over reach of the state, coercion by an ever increasingly ableist society and health professionals to put pressure on some of the most vulnerable in society and or those that care for them to make choices they wouldn’t have done previously.

This is not aimed at you Josh but if this was any other group in society be they ethnic minorities or those with mental illness problems rheue concerns would not just be met with a shrug of the shoulders like those with disabilities are on here and beyond.
I get your concerns Derek, but, if it was down to individual choice, then that would include people with disabilities. It couldn't be done without their consent. 
I don't think for one minute anyone on here is advocating forced suicide.

Even on this very thread, there is someone arguing that someone choosing to die because the quality of care provision is so poor, is still choosing to die and therefore not being forced. I disagree.

I would also add, that some might find it a struggle to believe how much people with disabilities/learning disabilities face to get decent care now and that there can already be pressures to put DNR orders in place when the same discussion would never be had with someone able bodied.

Exactly great post Squid. The argument oh well if you can’t get the care you need here’s some pills to take away the problem and if you don’t want to take them erm….well, anyway tara for now.
Again I think we would unanimously agree that better care for the old, infirm and disabled would be ideal, but there would still be people who are beyond that and have a horrible quality of life.
Reply
#84
Anyone listening to the parliamentary debate?

It's pretty refreshing to listen to a grown up debate free of party bias. Lots of thought provoking discussion from both sides of the argument.
Reply
#85
Parliament at its very best. But away from PMQ's 90% of the work in that place is like this.

We just see the worst too often in the MMM and in other places.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#86
(11-29-2024, 11:16 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Anyone listening to the parliamentary debate?

It's pretty refreshing to listen to a grown up debate free of party bias. Lots of thought provoking discussion from both sides of the argument.

Yes and yes
Reply
#87
(11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.

We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.

I don't see the correlation personally.

You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address. 

On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist. 

‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf.  People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.

Props to anyone feeling comfortable enough to get involved in this is debate, which for me is a struggle, but the post above is the closest to how I feel about it.
Reply
#88
It is so important to under stand this is not a vote on enshrining this into law today.

It should overwhelmingly passed at second reading. If its not it is just parliament shutting down the debate on this huge issue.

MPs and Lords have many other chances to votes against things down the line.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#89
I agree with Diane Abbot which is something I never thought I'd say.

"Is a judge supposed to second guess doctors? Will a judge make decisions on the basis of paperwork, or will there be a hearing in an open court? Where will be the capacity in the criminal justice system to deal with all this," she asks.

"Far from being a genuine safeguard, the involvement of a judge could just be a rubber stamp," she says.

Abbott continues by saying robust safeguards for the sick and dying are absolutely vital to protect them from predatory relatives, or the state, or themselves.
Reply
#90
Just re-reading through parts of this Fred. 

It's actually brilliant to read an actual adult debate. Fair play all. It's a contentious issue and it's been debated maturely.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: