Ian Pearce & Team
#11
(11-27-2024, 09:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I think having the turnover of players that we did in the summer and being competent and competitive this season is a brilliant achievement.

MJ is fine, and will come good. I have no doubts. The problem for him is the strange over expectations that many lay at his door.

Heggem and Styles have been brilliant so far considering we've asked both to do various jobs that they maybe wouldn't usually.

Racic has softened the blow of losing Okay somewhat but hasn't quite settled yet.

Cannot judge Diakite and Frabotta yet, but they are more long term signings and ones we have brought in with a view of developing and working with as they if good ages and contract lengths.

McNair and Holgate were brought in as emergency back ups and both have had to step in. McNair was looking solid but got crocked. Then Holgate is a liability but is trying hard. Luckily he will be back on the bench next game.

Bobbins, the less said the better I think.

Good to see a realistic post on the recruitment.

We've had to shop in the bargain basement, you are not going to find many wrongly priced items in there. Most clubs go backwards when you have to drastically cut costs. At the moment, we are on course to match past season so recruitment has been far from a disaster.
Reply
#12
We may be writing off numerous players but remember we all wrote off Grant….

Some of these new signings need time and a run of games before they can be properly judged. Diakete in particular.

Dobbin I don’t think will ever come good. Thank God he’s only a loan signing.
Reply
#13
Some you win and some you lose. We have struck absolute gold with Heggem. I’m more bothered about the wasted shit loan.

Stoke got Koumas, Boro got Doak and Sheff U Rak-Sakyi and we got Dobbin FFS. Good loans get you promotion.
Reply
#14
(11-27-2024, 10:30 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-27-2024, 09:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I think having the turnover of players that we did in the summer and being competent and competitive this season is a brilliant achievement.

MJ is fine, and will come good. I have no doubts. The problem for him is the strange over expectations that many lay at his door.

Heggem and Styles have been brilliant so far considering we've asked both to do various jobs that they maybe wouldn't usually.

Racic has softened the blow of losing Okay somewhat but hasn't quite settled yet.

Cannot judge Diakite and Frabotta yet, but they are more long term signings and ones we have brought in with a view of developing and working with as they if good ages and contract lengths.

McNair and Holgate were brought in as emergency back ups and both have had to step in. McNair was looking solid but got crocked. Then Holgate is a liability but is trying hard. Luckily he will be back on the bench next game.

Bobbins, the less said the better I think.

Good to see a realistic post on the recruitment.

We've had to shop in the bargain basement, you are not going to find many wrongly priced items in there. Most clubs go backwards when you have to drastically cut costs. At the moment, we are on course to match past season so recruitment has been far from a disaster.

Also, trying to achieve such a high turnover of players in a single window is a huge ask.  There’s bound to be a mixed bag of success.  I think we could well see another 3/4 players turning over in January.  Taylor back on loan to replace McNair would be an obvious one.  I think Dobbin’s loan should be cancelled (if possible).  I can see Wallace getting a move and possibly Swift too although that wouldn’t worry me either way as he’s still got something to offer.  Diangana might get a move but barely worth it as he’s out of contract in the summer anyway. 

Frabatta was signed on a 3-year contract….send him to Cardiff!
Reply
#15
(11-27-2024, 11:14 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Some you win and some you lose. We have struck absolute gold with Heggem. I’m more bothered about the wasted shit loan.

Stoke got Koumas, Boro got Doak and Sheff U Rak-Sakyi and we got Dobbin FFS. Good loans get you promotion.

This is true. But i doubt we could have afforded any of those three, either the loan fee or wages, sadly.
Reply
#16
(11-27-2024, 11:14 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Some you win and some you lose. We have struck absolute gold with Heggem. I’m more bothered about the wasted shit loan.

Stoke got Koumas, Boro got Doak and Sheff U Rak-Sakyi and we got Dobbin FFS. Good loans get you promotion.

Agree, can be the difference maker.  Look at the impact of Hutchinson, who we were linked with before taking on Sarmiento.....who himself at least had moments.

We can get it right. Harvey Barnes for example is one of the most exciting talents I've seen at the Albion.  He stays that year and we get promoted.

I have no beef with Dobbin.  He has shown he can carry the ball at speed and seems to have a good attitude but we need end product from our loans. Think he goes back at Crimbo and we have another pop.

Edit. Just read the post from Mr Fizz. Fair play, this is often not taken into account when comparing loans. I still think a change if possible though.
Reply
#17
(11-27-2024, 11:35 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(11-27-2024, 11:14 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Some you win and some you lose. We have struck absolute gold with Heggem. I’m more bothered about the wasted shit loan.

Stoke got Koumas, Boro got Doak and Sheff U Rak-Sakyi and we got Dobbin FFS. Good loans get you promotion.

This is true. But i doubt we could have afforded any of those three, either the loan fee or wages, sadly.

Plus, the player has to want to come to us on loan, for whatever reason, some don`t.

(11-27-2024, 11:14 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Some you win and some you lose. We have struck absolute gold with Heggem. I’m more bothered about the wasted shit loan.

Stoke got Koumas, Boro got Doak and Sheff U Rak-Sakyi and we got Dobbin FFS. Good loans get you promotion.

Heggem is class, I have always felt that a club with our resources needs to look in Scandinavia / Eastern Europe, some good players there.
Reply
#18
(11-27-2024, 11:59 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(11-27-2024, 11:35 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(11-27-2024, 11:14 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Some you win and some you lose. We have struck absolute gold with Heggem. I’m more bothered about the wasted shit loan.

Stoke got Koumas, Boro got Doak and Sheff U Rak-Sakyi and we got Dobbin FFS. Good loans get you promotion.

This is true. But i doubt we could have afforded any of those three, either the loan fee or wages, sadly.

Plus, the player has to want to come to us on loan, for whatever reason, some don`t.

(11-27-2024, 11:14 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Some you win and some you lose. We have struck absolute gold with Heggem. I’m more bothered about the wasted shit loan.

Stoke got Koumas, Boro got Doak and Sheff U Rak-Sakyi and we got Dobbin FFS. Good loans get you promotion.

Heggem is class, I have always felt that a club with our resources needs to look in Scandinavia / Eastern Europe, some good players there.

It's easier to find defensive nuggets than attacking ones.
Reply
#19
Fine margins and all that.

We're 40% or so into the season so too early to assess much. Only thing that stands out is Dobbin, but CC sees enough to think he's worth cameos. Maybe he'll come good, but don't see it so far.
Reply
#20
(11-27-2024, 09:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I think having the turnover of players that we did in the summer and being competent and competitive this season is a brilliant achievement.

MJ is fine, and will come good. I have no doubts. The problem for him is the strange over expectations that many lay at his door.

Heggem and Styles have been brilliant so far considering we've asked both to do various jobs that they maybe wouldn't usually.

Racic has softened the blow of losing Okay somewhat but hasn't quite settled yet.

Cannot judge Diakite and Frabotta yet, but they are more long term signings and ones we have brought in with a view of developing and working with as they if good ages and contract lengths.

McNair and Holgate were brought in as emergency back ups and both have had to step in. McNair was looking solid but got crocked. Then Holgate is a liability but is trying hard. Luckily he will be back on the bench next game.

Bobbins, the less said the better I think.

I echo that 1st line. Some of these are squad fillers and probably signed to keep us competitive while undergoing a complete overhaul. To equal last season's position with the FFP rules remaining unbreached and the takeover issues still not a year old, is all we realistically can ask. The fact there a a couple of potential gems in there more than makes up for the odd duffer that will be swiftly turned over.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: