Substitutes 60-80 mins
#1
Firstly I enjoyed the match, this is a general observation about the games becoming non events as we and almost every other team robotically make 4 or five subs making the games disjointed and akin to a friendly. It makes us weaker and I can’t say I’ve seen many teams we’ve played, suddenly perform better either. 

Just another identikit tactic to add to the homogenised football, clubs in the U.K. now play.
Reply
#2
I'm sick of it. The move from 3 subs to 5 has made the game far worse from the perspective of a spectator. As always, we were not consulted about this. Done to help the big prem clubs during COVID.
Reply
#3
I think we have a good manager who for the most part knows what he’s doing, and gets it right more often than he doesn’t. However, I agree completely with this sentiment. I can understand wanting to give players a break for fitness reasons with one eye on the next game, but it shouldn’t be at the expense of the current match. Fellows and Johnston may have been tired but they were still having an impact, in fact both after 70 minutes looked better than Jed and Dobbin who were fresh.

If you’re pushing to try and win the game then I don’t know why you’d weaken the team. If the players coming off were struggling or knackered then I would have understood it.


Also we bring Wallace on every game and he’s a liability, but we do the same thing again and again.
Reply
#4
I think CC left it as long as he could today. Mowatt looked shot after he chased back v Sainz. And Fellows rarely lasts more than 60. There is plenty of evidence of players picking up fatigue based injuries after 60 mins, so that must play into managers thoughts. Especially with their key players.

The big issue was lack of options. Not having Grady, regardless of form is a blow. Not having a decent CF option. Jed being done. And Bobbins being, well, bobbins. It made it tough.

Work to be done in January, definitely.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#5
(11-23-2024, 05:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Firstly I enjoyed the match, this is a general observation about the games becoming non events as we and almost every other team robotically make 4 or five subs making the games disjointed and akin to a friendly. It makes us weaker and I can’t say I’ve seen many teams we’ve played, suddenly perform better either. 

Just another identikit tactic to add to the homogenised football, clubs in the U.K. now play.

Agree 100% Derek, but we don’t have to do it! Fellows has his best game for months, as does Mickey and they get replaced by Wallace and fucking Grommit when we are massively on top? Why? They’ve just had 2 weeks off so they can’t be that tired. If it’s about metrics, then they clearly don’t apply to the likes of Furlong and Heggem who play 90 mins week in week out. And what does Maja gain from playing 10 mins less?
They didn’t take Borja Sainz off despite him running for 90 odd minutes.
Reply
#6
(11-23-2024, 06:05 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I think CC left it as long as he could today. Mowatt looked shot after he chased back v Sainz. And Fellows rarely lasts more than 60. There is plenty of evidence of players picking up fatigue based injuries after 60 mins, so that must play into managers thoughts. Especially with their key players.

The big issue was lack of options. Not having Grady, regardless of form is a blow. Not having a decent CF option. Jed being done. And Bobbins being, well, bobbins. It made it tough.

Work to be done in January, definitely.

Every team makes the same plethora of changes every match and I haven’t seen any evidence it has made us or the opposition stronger. It certainly hasn’t stopped us getting injuries.
Reply
#7
Our squad is much weaker than last season but the workload is the same. I agree with Lurker, this must have been the latest he's made the subs.

It's a judgement call regards Wallace who is really struggling. I'd have taken Grant off so one of the wingers could stay on given he played Jed up front anyway.

We definitely drop a couple of levels when the starters are removed if we've not got a Grady level player on the bench.
Reply
#8
Those subs lost us all the momentum. We were massively on top, pressing to win the game and then we weren’t.

You can’t tell I Grant going off on 89 mins is “metrics”. We needed a goal and he took the only realistic goal option off.

The subs just made us weaker.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#9
I don't disagree with the subs needing to be made, but I do wonder about putting them all on the pitch at the same time. Staggering them out a bit may help us and the players.
Reply
#10
(11-23-2024, 06:26 PM)Squid Wrote: I don't disagree with the subs needing to be made, but I do wonder about putting them all on the pitch at the same time. Staggering them out a bit may help us and the players.

There are only 3 'windows' to make the 5 subs. Not including halftime.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: