Farmers
#71
(11-20-2024, 02:14 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-20-2024, 01:39 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-20-2024, 01:38 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-20-2024, 01:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-20-2024, 01:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Farmers and land owners should be treated like everyone else, there should be no assumption that they are entitled to keep land or family business’s. They are already getting preferential treatment even after these changes. I’ve lost my violin it’s so small.

Treat them the same, just give them fair notice.

Ask how many Dentists, Doctors etc pay fair tax? Loads of them using "tax schemes" such as Remuneration Trusts and the like to avoid paying anything for decades.

Thieves has picked the wrong fight here. The public are with the Farmers.

I wouldn't be so sure about that.

So sure about what, Squid?

That the public are backing the farmers. To many this seems like a loophole for the wealthy that is long-overdue closure.

The daily mail does not = the public.  Rolleyes

Tax due if parents hand on £3m house: £940k
Tax due if parents hand on a £3m farm: £0
A reminder of significant tax advantage to farmers vs everyone else AFTER these changes
Reply
#72
54% of farmers voted for Brexit. Be careful what you vote for!
Reply
#73
A sensible view

https://bsky.app/profile/torstenbell.bsk...chat3f5s22
Reply
#74
Thought New Labour were going after the big corporations that pay very little tax
The Bankers & the yuppy types ?

Farmers are asset rich but basically poor in terms of earning a crust

I guess if the farmers have to sell up land
Means the UK will import even more food from abroad (prices will increase)
The land will be bought buy huge corporations & used as a loss so to avoid paying more tax

Suely the simple solution would have been for Labour to say
The uk is skint
We will increase IT by 1p in the pound or 10p for those earning over 100000

Forget all thses back door taxes
Reply
#75
Sorry edit. Only skimmed. It's a looonnggg thread.

It does feel like minimum financial gain for a lot of political pain, but maybe Labour is just giving a big fuck you to two of the demographics that most heavily supported the Tories across their 14 tawdry years and voted Brexit. I mean I dont suggest that seriously, do I?

Possibly all worth it to see that loud mouthed cunt Clarkson handed his ass on a plate by Victoria Derbysire, and Farage not allowed to speak because of his links to Brexit, which let's face it the REAL farming community know fucked them over much more than any tax.

Personally not sure that the Clarkson, Farage, Tories, Big Tractors and Barbour look would have won them much support outside of the allready existing RW media kabal and readership?

It all felt a bit entitled and seems pretty fair to me....as long as they make sure the big landowners dont have loopholes to escape through.
Reply
#76
This is creating a hell of a lot of noise for the sake of just £200 million. Daft decision by the government, just like the WFA.
Reply
#77
(11-20-2024, 07:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: This is creating a hell of a lot of noise for the sake of just £200 million. Daft decision by the government, just like the WFA.

Proth, we dont often agree in this area but I'm with you here.  

Not saying either decision was fundamentally wrong, but it's a lot of heat to take for scraps.

Feels a bit....we're doing it because we can.  Fair enough, four more years to come. Figuring these particular groups will vote Tory anyway in four years so might as well shake em down for few coppers on the way.

Would love to know if their IS a strategy. Can't see it.
Reply
#78
Who’d have thought the right wing press owned by offshore billionaires would be against the Labour Party and publicise every minutiae as loudly as possible for the masses to gobble up. It’s hardly a rate increase, its taking away an allowance that is being abused by many.
Reply
#79
(11-20-2024, 07:30 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Who’d have thought the right wing press owned by offshore billionaires would be against the Labour Party and publicise every minutiae as loudly as possible for the masses to gobble up. It’s hardly a rate increase, its taking away an allowance that is being abused by many.

I suppose we do need to take any reporting on the protests in that context.  

Be I interesting to see if the next stop the oil and/or public worker strike marches get the same kind of coverage.  And imagine if a War in Gaza protest had used tractors to push police out of the way. Daily Mail would have spunked in its pants.
Reply
#80
(11-20-2024, 07:30 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Who’d have thought the right wing press owned by offshore billionaires would be against the Labour Party and publicise every minutiae as loudly as possible for the masses to gobble up. It’s hardly a rate increase, its taking away an allowance that is being abused by many.

It calls into question the judgement (again). If you know what you're going to get, why play into their hands? Particularly for so little money.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)