Posts: 987
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.
We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.
I don't see the correlation personally.
You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address.
On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist.
‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf. People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.
Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die.
It's not about being disabled and being a burden.
But it will go that way, that is the problem and you can't say it won't because it already has in Canada and this very thread has people defending that.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(11-13-2024, 12:39 PM)Morley Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.
We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.
I don't see the correlation personally.
You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address.
On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist.
‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf. People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.
Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die.
It's not about being disabled and being a burden.
But it will go that way, that is the problem and you can't say it won't because it already has in Canada and this very thread has people defending that.
It hasn't in Switzerland.
Posts: 987
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(11-13-2024, 12:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (11-13-2024, 12:39 PM)Morley Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.
We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.
I don't see the correlation personally.
You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address.
On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist.
‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf. People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.
Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die.
It's not about being disabled and being a burden.
But it will go that way, that is the problem and you can't say it won't because it already has in Canada and this very thread has people defending that.
It hasn't in Switzerland.
And you can prove that without any doubt? Not 1 person ever has been forced to end their life when they didn't want too? Because for me 1 would be too many.
Posts: 9,648
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
11-13-2024, 01:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2024, 01:17 PM by Josh1873.)
I'd counter argue that, as horrific and indefensible as forcing someone to end their life is, is that there's no doubt people under today's law purposely prolonging patients and family members lives while they're terminally ill and in immense pain. All in the name of evil.
Ultimately the world is full of sick, sadistic psychopaths. There will be unnecessary deaths caused by scumbags no matter what laws are passed or not passed.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(11-13-2024, 12:54 PM)Morley Wrote: (11-13-2024, 12:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (11-13-2024, 12:39 PM)Morley Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address.
On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist.
‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf. People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.
Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die.
It's not about being disabled and being a burden.
But it will go that way, that is the problem and you can't say it won't because it already has in Canada and this very thread has people defending that.
It hasn't in Switzerland.
And you can prove that without any doubt? Not 1 person ever has been forced to end their life when they didn't want too? Because for me 1 would be too many.
The court cases from people being denied access to assisted suicide in Switzerland allay doubt in my mind. The Swiss model operating outside the hospital system is also pertinent.
Posts: 7,724
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Eugenics via the backdoor, or giving dignity and choice to the terminally ill? YOU DECIDE.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
11-13-2024, 03:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2024, 03:26 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.
We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.
I don't see the correlation personally.
You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address.
On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist.
‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf. People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.
Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die.
It's not about being disabled and being a burden.
Josh, I apologise that I made my remarks to you specifically as this is a wider point and tbh I like you so you’re one of the posters I don’t wish to be unnecessarily rude to.
The point as pointed out by numerous charities and individuals (there are links on here by me and Squid making our concerns very clear what the issues are) within the disabled community is they don’t trust this proposed legislation to be the end of the debate. They see it as I do to some extent the slippery slope for over reach of the state, coercion by an ever increasingly ableist society and health professionals to put pressure on some of the most vulnerable in society and or those that care for them to make choices they wouldn’t have done previously.
This is not aimed at you Josh but if this was any other group in society be they ethnic minorities or those with mental illness problems rheue concerns would not just be met with a shrug of the shoulders like those with disabilities are on here and beyond.
Posts: 8,005
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-13-2024, 03:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.
We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.
I don't see the correlation personally.
You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address.
On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist.
‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf. People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.
Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die.
It's not about being disabled and being a burden.
Josh, I apologise that I made my remarks to you specifically as this is a wider point and tbh I like you so you’re one of the posters I don’t wish to be unnecessarily rude to.
The point as pointed out by numerous charities and individuals (there are links on here by me and Squid making our concerns very clear what the issues are) within the disabled community is they don’t trust this proposed legislation to be the end of the debate. They see it as I do to some extent the slippery slope for over reach of the state, coercion by an ever increasingly ableist society and health professionals to put pressure on some of the most vulnerable in society and or those that care for them to make choices they wouldn’t have done previously.
This is not aimed at you Josh but if this was any other group in society be they ethnic minorities or those with mental illness problems rheue concerns would not just be met with a shrug of the shoulders like those with disabilities are on here and beyond. I get your concerns Derek, but, if it was down to individual choice, then that would include people with disabilities. It couldn't be done without their consent.
I don't think for one minute anyone on here is advocating forced suicide.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
11-13-2024, 04:19 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2024, 04:22 PM by Squid.)
(11-13-2024, 03:54 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (11-13-2024, 03:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:54 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.
We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.
I don't see the correlation personally.
You are opening the door to the disabled and others feeling ‘obliged’ by loved ones and or society to assist them dying so they aren’t a ‘burden’. Laws have unforeseen/unplanned consequences beyond what they looked to address.
On the one hand you slate or at least are cynical of the state, politicians and the NHS even society regularly on here and yet you are advocating they can be trusted to not amend the law further in the future to suit the fittest and most able as society and politicians change/become ever more populist.
‘Safeguards will be put in place, it will be a robust law’ blah blah is used to suggest this is a just law and yet have you ever questioned why those in the disabled community do not trust these proposed changes? The fact our society and law makers have proven over many years that they cannot be trusted to make these decisions without prejudice should be a massive red flag to its implementation. The lack of trust is down to lived experience not some vague notion on their behalf. People can argue safeguards can be put in place, laws won’t be tweaked further in the future but forgive those who may be on the sharp end of this in 5, 10, 20yrs if they don’t trust or believe those who say it’ll be fine and there is nothing to worry about.
Derek, this conversation is about those who are dying, have limited time left, are in insufferable pain, and want to CHOOSE to die.
It's not about being disabled and being a burden.
Josh, I apologise that I made my remarks to you specifically as this is a wider point and tbh I like you so you’re one of the posters I don’t wish to be unnecessarily rude to.
The point as pointed out by numerous charities and individuals (there are links on here by me and Squid making our concerns very clear what the issues are) within the disabled community is they don’t trust this proposed legislation to be the end of the debate. They see it as I do to some extent the slippery slope for over reach of the state, coercion by an ever increasingly ableist society and health professionals to put pressure on some of the most vulnerable in society and or those that care for them to make choices they wouldn’t have done previously.
This is not aimed at you Josh but if this was any other group in society be they ethnic minorities or those with mental illness problems rheue concerns would not just be met with a shrug of the shoulders like those with disabilities are on here and beyond. I get your concerns Derek, but, if it was down to individual choice, then that would include people with disabilities. It couldn't be done without their consent.
I don't think for one minute anyone on here is advocating forced suicide.
Even on this very thread, there is someone arguing that someone choosing to die because the quality of care provision is so poor, is still choosing to die and therefore not being forced. I disagree.
I would also add, that some might find it a struggle to believe how much people with disabilities/learning disabilities face to get decent care now and that there can already be pressures to put DNR orders in place when the same discussion would never be had with someone able bodied.
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Why have MPs suddenly got cold feet about assisted dying?
Following publication of the private members’ bill to allow the terminally ill to request help in ending their life, parliamentary support for this popular issue of conscience appears to be fast ebbing away, says John Rentoul
Wednesday 13 November 2024 15:54 GMT
Streeting says assisted dying bill passing into law will come at expense of other NHS services
The last time the House of Commons voted on assisted dying nine years ago, a proposal to legalise it was defeated by a three-to-one margin. It was a free vote, and the Conservatives, who tended to be opposed to the idea, had a small majority, while Labour MPs, who were more likely to support it, found themselves easily outvoted.
Now Labour has a huge majority, and the Tories have fewer seats than at any time in the party’s history. What is more, public opinion seems to be overwhelmingly in favour of assisted dying. Supporters of changing the law like to quote an opinion poll from 2019 that found 84 per cent of the public supported it.
So when Kim Leadbeater, the independent-minded Labour MP, came top of the ballot for private members’ bills, it seemed that the time had come for the next great step forward for liberal reform. Many of the advances in the law – on capital punishment, divorce, abortion and the decriminalisation of homosexuality – have come from free votes in parliament, and often through private members’ bills, allowing governments and parties to manage their internal divisions on “matters of conscience”.
There will be free votes this time, too, although it helps the reformers’ cause that Keir Starmer himself supports assisted dying – and indeed had promised Esther Rantzen, its highest-ranking celebrity advocate, that MPs would be given the chance to vote on it.
But then came the doubts. Wes Streeting, the health secretary, who voted for reform in 2015, said he had changed his mind. He told Labour MPs privately that he thought palliative care in the NHS “isn’t good enough” to give people a “genuine choice” at the end of life. Shabana Mahmood, the justice secretary and a practising Muslim, repeated her opposition to it on grounds of the sanctity of life. As did Jonathan Reynolds, the business secretary, who is a practising Christian.
At this point, Simon Case, the cabinet secretary, intervened to remind ministers of the convention that they do not campaign for or against issues put to a free vote. He was too late. I am told that Streeting’s words had quite an effect on many of Labour’s new MPs.
Most of them are instinctively in favour, but take their responsibility to make the right decision seriously. Many of them feel that they are being rushed to decide an immensely complex and difficult issue, with only two weeks between the publication of the bill and the first vote.
Yesterday, Peter Prinsley, the new Labour MP for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket, who is the first ear, nose and throat surgeon to be elected to parliament, spoke in support of Leadbeater’s bill. But he said: “What I have observed, because I’ve had many conversations about this over the last few weeks, is that older MPs are more inclined to support this and younger MPs are less inclined. And I think that is just a feature of this parliament – we have a lot of new young MPs. So I’m not as confident of this thing passing as I was before I started having these conversations.”
It did not help that the text of the bill, as finally published, seemed to describe a term that advocates of reform have long sought to avoid, namely “assisted suicide”. The bill says that “the coordinating doctor may … assist that person to ingest or otherwise self-administer the substance”, but “the final act of doing so must be taken by the person to whom the substance has been provided”.
Assisted dying – or assisted suicide – is one of those causes that seems to have wide support, but it is shallow. Most people want to avoid pain and suffering in death, but once the mechanics are spelt out, the doubts crowd in. The experience of people in Canada and the Netherlands being put under pressure to end their lives should also be a warning of unintended consequences.
Today, Streeting defied Case’s advice again, setting out why he thought the bill would divert resources from other NHS services. “To govern is to choose. If parliament chooses to go ahead with assisted dying, it is making a choice that this is an area to prioritise for investment.”
This was followed by Alec Shelbrooke, a Conservative MP, asking Starmer at Prime Minister’s Questions to give the bill more time on the floor of the House. Starmer said he thought the bill had “sufficient time” as it was.
It is beginning to feel as if support is ebbing fast. Nine years ago, nearly one MP in three failed to take part in the vote at all. There may be more abstainers this time, as new MPs shy away from committing themselves, while others will do what they should do if they are unsure that the legislation will make life (or death) better for people, and vote against.
|