Assisted dying legislation.
#21
(11-12-2024, 10:46 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 10:13 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: We’ve created a society where people are kept alive often well beyond what nature would’ve ordinarily enabled and alongside that come many complications, burdens, misery and stress that goes well beyond just the individual concerned. We have to be brave enough to evolve what goes alongside that and as many have said it is long overdue

I agree. 

I would also say that at some point in the future, with ever aging populations and slow birth rates that nations won't be able to afford to look after everyone. It probably will happen. I'm definitely one who thinks that if my life eventually becomes worthless by my reckoning and I've just had enough I would want the plug pulled to alleviate people having to care for me be it financially or otherwise. This is definitely a leap on from those who are "end of life" but it's something that will need to be considered.

The demographic pyramid is titanically screwed and will only get worse. Alongside other impending challenges to society and humanity it’s why I can’t get too worked up about things like Trump. Worrying about short term individuals is minuscule compared to the real pressures the human race will have to face up to shortly.

Also in agreement with what you say at the end there. I wouldn’t wish some of the things I’m having to deal with now on my own kids, ever, and would sooner have the choice without such frameworks as are in this bill.
Reply
#22
(11-12-2024, 10:46 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 10:13 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: We’ve created a society where people are kept alive often well beyond what nature would’ve ordinarily enabled and alongside that come many complications, burdens, misery and stress that goes well beyond just the individual concerned. We have to be brave enough to evolve what goes alongside that and as many have said it is long overdue

I agree. 

I would also say that at some point in the future, with ever aging populations and slow birth rates that nations won't be able to afford to look after everyone. It probably will happen. I'm definitely one who thinks that if my life eventually becomes worthless by my reckoning and I've just had enough I would want the plug pulled to alleviate people having to care for me be it financially or otherwise. This is definitely a leap on from those who are "end of life" but it's something that will need to be considered.

It's exactly those sorts of Malthusian leaps I'm concerned about. Straight from assisted dying to help those who are at the end of their lives, to assisted dying to help those who are financially inconvenienced by someone staying alive.
Reply
#23
(11-12-2024, 11:19 AM)Squid Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 10:46 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 10:13 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: We’ve created a society where people are kept alive often well beyond what nature would’ve ordinarily enabled and alongside that come many complications, burdens, misery and stress that goes well beyond just the individual concerned. We have to be brave enough to evolve what goes alongside that and as many have said it is long overdue

I agree. 

I would also say that at some point in the future, with ever aging populations and slow birth rates that nations won't be able to afford to look after everyone. It probably will happen. I'm definitely one who thinks that if my life eventually becomes worthless by my reckoning and I've just had enough I would want the plug pulled to alleviate people having to care for me be it financially or otherwise. This is definitely a leap on from those who are "end of life" but it's something that will need to be considered.

It's exactly those sorts of Malthusian leaps I'm concerned about. Straight from assisted dying to help those who are at the end of their lives, to assisted dying to help those who are financially inconvenienced by someone staying alive.

It's not an illegitimate fear but one that would need to be passed by the commons and HoL.  I assume all MPs will get a free vote on something like this.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#24
Maybe a few years ago I would have said a definite yes but having seen now how the disabled were treated during Covid with DNR’s disproportionately used at the whim of the state against them be they children or adults, I find the idea the thin end of the wedge.

It’s well meaning now, but the idea of fundamentally changing our laws from protecting the sanctity of life to this muddying of the waters whilst we have populist agitators (you can insert any insult you wish here) like Farage and co waiting in the wings is scaring/alarming the disabled community and imo with just cause. We are already seeing the way language is being used about the disabled changing from one of understanding and support to how much per person does this person cost the state, (Labour should hang their head in shame at continuing this demonisation) and you can see if we as a country let the shyster populist in, that language will potentially have consequences far beyond the current proposed bill.

In short I wouldn’t trust the state, politicians or many within our communities to not change the law as we move forward to the detriment of the disabled community.
Reply
#25
It's incredibly complex. Two years ago we watched a dear family friend in her early 50s die of cancer. She was in agony at the end and there were interventions going on in hospital to prolong the agony.

As my wife said at the time, you wouldn't treat a pet like this.

The last few weeks were torture. In cases like this then surely being put out of agony is the kindest thing to do.
Reply
#26
(11-12-2024, 11:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe a few years ago I would have said a definite yes but having seen now how the disabled were treated during Covid with DNR’s disproportionately used at the whim of the state against them be they children or adults, I find the idea the thin end of the wedge.

It’s well meaning now, but the idea of fundamentally changing our laws from protecting the sanctity of life to this muddying of the waters whilst we have populist agitators (you can insert any insult you wish here) like Farage and co waiting in the wings is scaring/alarming the disabled community and imo with just cause. We are already seeing the way language is being used about the disabled changing from one of understanding and support to how much per person does this person cost the state, (Labour should hang their head in shame at continuing this demonisation) and you can see if we as a country let the shyster populist in, that language will potentially have consequences far beyond the current proposed bill.

In short I wouldn’t trust the state, politicians or many within our communities to not change the law as we move forward to the detriment of the disabled community.

Have you seen the (unpublished and never enacted) COVID rationing criteria that came out of the enquiry last week?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#27
(11-12-2024, 11:57 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: It's incredibly complex. Two years ago we watched a dear family friend in her early 50s die of cancer. She was in agony at the end and there were interventions going on in hospital to prolong the agony.

As my wife said at the time, you wouldn't treat a pet like this.

The last few weeks were torture. In cases like this then surely being put out of agony is the kindest thing to do.

I bitterly regret allowing them to give my mum life extending treatment after 3 years with stage 4 cancer. It extended her life by around 3 months no doubt but in reality all it extended was suffering, and an ending dosed up to the eyeballs on morphine and fentanyl. The whole issue is around the western obsession with time over quality and until we rethink that we will end up with the mess we have currently regarding end of life care, where the only winners are pharmaceutical companies
Reply
#28
(11-12-2024, 11:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe a few years ago I would have said a definite yes but having seen now how the disabled were treated during Covid with DNR’s disproportionately used at the whim of the state against them be they children or adults, I find the idea the thin end of the wedge.

It’s well meaning now, but the idea of fundamentally changing our laws from protecting the sanctity of life to this muddying of the waters whilst we have populist agitators (you can insert any insult you wish here) like Farage and co waiting in the wings is scaring/alarming the disabled community and imo with just cause. We are already seeing the way language is being used about the disabled changing from one of understanding and support to how much per person does this person cost the state, (Labour should hang their head in shame at continuing this demonisation) and you can see if we as a country let the shyster populist in, that language will potentially have consequences far beyond the current proposed bill.

In short I wouldn’t trust the state, politicians or many within our communities to not change the law as we move forward to the detriment of the disabled community.

With the exception of  (Labour should hang their head in shame at continuing this demonisation) I have to agree with most of that and it is indeed the thin end of the wedge
Reply
#29
(11-12-2024, 12:07 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 11:57 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: It's incredibly complex. Two years ago we watched a dear family friend in her early 50s die of cancer. She was in agony at the end and there were interventions going on in hospital to prolong the agony.

As my wife said at the time, you wouldn't treat a pet like this.

The last few weeks were torture. In cases like this then surely being put out of agony is the kindest thing to do.

I bitterly regret allowing them to give my mum life extending treatment after 3 years with stage 4 cancer. It extended her life by around 3 months no doubt but in reality all it extended was suffering, and an ending dosed up to the eyeballs on morphine and fentanyl. The whole issue is around the western obsession with time over quality and until we rethink that we will end up with the mess we have currently regarding end of life care, where the only winners are pharmaceutical companies

I totally agree.
Reply
#30
(11-12-2024, 11:57 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 11:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe a few years ago I would have said a definite yes but having seen now how the disabled were treated during Covid with DNR’s disproportionately used at the whim of the state against them be they children or adults, I find the idea the thin end of the wedge.

It’s well meaning now, but the idea of fundamentally changing our laws from protecting the sanctity of life to this muddying of the waters whilst we have populist agitators (you can insert any insult you wish here) like Farage and co waiting in the wings is scaring/alarming the disabled community and imo with just cause. We are already seeing the way language is being used about the disabled changing from one of understanding and support to how much per person does this person cost the state, (Labour should hang their head in shame at continuing this demonisation) and you can see if we as a country let the shyster populist in, that language will potentially have consequences far beyond the current proposed bill.

In short I wouldn’t trust the state, politicians or many within our communities to not change the law as we move forward to the detriment of the disabled community.

Have you seen the (unpublished and never enacted) COVID rationing criteria that came out of the enquiry last week?

No but here’s some links…

Article One 
Article 2
Article Three

Sorry but I don’t trust this bill to be the end of the conversation for some vulnerable groups.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)