Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
(11-10-2024, 11:11 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (11-10-2024, 10:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: Was I watching the wrong match with these pathetic ratings for Palmer. Apart from some of his distribution he had a decent game. A 4 is pathetic he he certainly wasn’t that, same as Mowatt he kept things ticking over without being at his best.
Johnston great first half but nowhere to be seen second half 7 at most.
Isn’t football a strange game it’s all about opinions and mine are different to some on here.
No way was Palmer a 4. Think Josh's judgement may be clouded by the fact he chose to punch and not catch a cross just prior to Hull's goal (I agree with Josh on this, tbf), but he was still assured in rest of the game.
If doing ratings then each players starts with a 5 as a base score. If they have a poor game then it's lower. A good game it's higher.
I've yet to see the goal back, so I'm happy to be proven wrong, but I do believe he was partly at fault for their goal due to punching not catching. His distribution was also woeful, how many times does he kick the ball out of play, or put his team mates under unnecessary pressure with a hospital pass? There was also that goal kick that went out for a corner!
From memory he made one save from a well hit free kick that was straight at him, and he had the excellent catch (which would have been a far more difficult and dangerous catch than the one would have been for their goal, btw) in injury time.
I like him, he's a great GK for us, so don't take this as some sort of vendetta. But he really does need to work on his distribution. It's awful. If he can't kick a ball then stop him having it.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(11-11-2024, 06:26 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-10-2024, 11:11 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (11-10-2024, 10:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: Was I watching the wrong match with these pathetic ratings for Palmer. Apart from some of his distribution he had a decent game. A 4 is pathetic he he certainly wasn’t that, same as Mowatt he kept things ticking over without being at his best.
Johnston great first half but nowhere to be seen second half 7 at most.
Isn’t football a strange game it’s all about opinions and mine are different to some on here.
No way was Palmer a 4. Think Josh's judgement may be clouded by the fact he chose to punch and not catch a cross just prior to Hull's goal (I agree with Josh on this, tbf), but he was still assured in rest of the game.
If doing ratings then each players starts with a 5 as a base score. If they have a poor game then it's lower. A good game it's higher.
I've yet to see the goal back, so I'm happy to be proven wrong, but I do believe he was partly at fault for their goal due to punching not catching. His distribution was also woeful, how many times does he kick the ball out of play, or put his team mates under unnecessary pressure with a hospital pass? There was also that goal kick that went out for a corner!
From memory he made one save from a well hit free kick that was straight at him, and he had the excellent catch (which would have been a far more difficult and dangerous catch than the one would have been for their goal, btw) in injury time.
I like him, he's a great GK for us, so don't take this as some sort of vendetta. But he really does need to work on his distribution. It's awful. If he can't kick a ball then stop him having it.
Starting score is 6 imo, as per Champ Man/FM. Then adjust from there.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
Styles (MotM), Heggem, Grant, Furlong all 8's
Palmer and Fellows 6, the rest of the starters 7
Subs did ok.
Diangana, yet again, the lowest scorer for me though. I just don't see how we get an upturn from him now, he just seems shot.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
(11-11-2024, 07:14 AM)Jacko Wrote: (11-11-2024, 06:26 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-10-2024, 11:11 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (11-10-2024, 10:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: Was I watching the wrong match with these pathetic ratings for Palmer. Apart from some of his distribution he had a decent game. A 4 is pathetic he he certainly wasn’t that, same as Mowatt he kept things ticking over without being at his best.
Johnston great first half but nowhere to be seen second half 7 at most.
Isn’t football a strange game it’s all about opinions and mine are different to some on here.
No way was Palmer a 4. Think Josh's judgement may be clouded by the fact he chose to punch and not catch a cross just prior to Hull's goal (I agree with Josh on this, tbf), but he was still assured in rest of the game.
If doing ratings then each players starts with a 5 as a base score. If they have a poor game then it's lower. A good game it's higher.
I've yet to see the goal back, so I'm happy to be proven wrong, but I do believe he was partly at fault for their goal due to punching not catching. His distribution was also woeful, how many times does he kick the ball out of play, or put his team mates under unnecessary pressure with a hospital pass? There was also that goal kick that went out for a corner!
From memory he made one save from a well hit free kick that was straight at him, and he had the excellent catch (which would have been a far more difficult and dangerous catch than the one would have been for their goal, btw) in injury time.
I like him, he's a great GK for us, so don't take this as some sort of vendetta. But he really does need to work on his distribution. It's awful. If he can't kick a ball then stop him having it.
Starting score is 6 imo, as per Champ Man/FM. Then adjust from there.
See, a 6 is a good score of above average in my mind. Maybe this is on me!
Posts: 1,801
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
7
(11-11-2024, 09:14 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Styles (MotM), Heggem, Grant, Furlong all 8's
Palmer and Fellows 6, the rest of the starters 7
Subs did ok.
Diangana, yet again, the lowest scorer for me though. I just don't see how we get an upturn from him now, he just seems shot.
I agree with comments on Diangana, doesn’t seem like even getting close to assists or goals.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(11-11-2024, 09:14 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Styles (MotM), Heggem, Grant, Furlong all 8's
Palmer and Fellows 6, the rest of the starters 7
Subs did ok.
Diangana, yet again, the lowest scorer for me though. I just don't see how we get an upturn from him now, he just seems shot. Agree re Diangana. He was poor although did help Styles defensively to some degree.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-11-2024, 09:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (11-11-2024, 09:14 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Styles (MotM), Heggem, Grant, Furlong all 8's
Palmer and Fellows 6, the rest of the starters 7
Subs did ok.
Diangana, yet again, the lowest scorer for me though. I just don't see how we get an upturn from him now, he just seems shot. Agree re Diangana. He was poor although did help Styles defensively to some degree. Such a shame because he is the type of player that can really get you out of your seat. He really does have everything when he's on top of his game. Unfortunately, despite hoping every time he plays that this will be the turning point, I now don't think that it will ever happen for us.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
I can't believe how poor Grady has become. The ball bounces off him, he can't control it, he can't pass, he can't really defend, he's weak and gets pushed off the ball. He really is a shadow of the player we first saw during his loan spell.
He shouldn't really get near the team bar a high number of injuries/suspensions.
Posts: 988
Threads: 43
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
0
(11-11-2024, 10:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't believe how poor Grady has become. The ball bounces off him, he can't control it, he can't pass, he can't really defend, he's weak and gets pushed off the ball. He really is a shadow of the player we first saw during his loan spell.
He shouldn't really get near the team bar a high number of injuries/suspensions.
I think his poor decision making and awareness around him is terrible and that influencies all the above
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
He needs to go in the summer for the sake of both parties.
|