When we win - Stat correlations
#11
(10-30-2024, 09:25 AM)Sliced Wrote: It's interesting to see the stats, but there's a couple of issues here.

(1) Firstly you're implying here that correlation is the same as causation, which it's not. Decisions are not being made based on all of the above because it's the statistical equivalent of throwing spaghetti at a wall and seeing what sticks. Corberan or whoever will have identified how he wants to play and what he wants to improve possibly while taking stats into account, but there's no way he's saying "right lads, less progressive passes please because when we do that we get better results".

Secondly, we've won 5 games this season, that's not enough to get anything meaningful from. Especially given that the manner of the victories haven't been consistent. The way we played against Plymouth was vastly different to the way we played against QPR and Pompy for example.

(2) Thirdly this doesn't take into account anything about how the opposition play. Our victories this season have been against the teams in 17th, 19th, 21st, 23rd and 24th; and they were all in the first 6 games of the season. (3) Both these are more informative because it suggests that we struggle to be effective in the way we want to against the stronger teams, and right now we are on a bad run because we're struggling to put the ball in the net.

1) I am not suggesting any causation. In fact quite the opposite I have merely crunched the numbers and looked for correlations. I am not suggesting that CC should set us up to play deep, play direct passes out wide and don't cross, as that's not how the game works. In fact I mention in the OP about how we need to find solutions for when teams drop into a low block, and mentioned how I think that's why he has tried MJ and GD instead of the more direct, running styles of TF and KG who require more space.  

2) Again quite the opposite. The point I was making is it seems like we are substantially and directly affected by how the opponent lines up and approaches the game. The stats suggest we tend not to do well when teams roll over and allow us to dictate, we do seem to do better when teams press up the pitch and have their fair share of possession. 

3) I am not sure its about how "good" an opponent is. For example the Middleborough performance was a good one and Millwall was a poor one (offensively) but they are both good teams who are underperforming against their level of statistical output. The difference was Boro came out and went toe to toe with us and were better on the day. Where Millwall dropped deep, went long and direct on transition and allowed us no space. Its that tactical difference which is killing us at times from a performance perspective.

This is what is concerning; we are not good enough to beat the better teams consistently when we go head to head. But we struggle to break down teams when they drop in, which the majority of teams in the league do against us, Blackburn included who are only a place behind. Which is why I think we do need to keep working on being dominant in possession & keep working on patterns of play to unlock deep defences.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#12
I don't really want to start too much of an argument about this, but there's a few inconsistencies. You said you don't know how "good" an opponent is but then say "we are not good enough to beat the better teams consistently".

I'm not really sure what "underperforming against their level of statistical output" means? xG for/against doesn't show how good a team is it just tells you something about how they play. Results are the only metric of how good a team has been this season because football is about getting points.

The point remains, we've scored 2 goals in 5 games and haven't won in 6. When we have won it's been against teams in the bottom 8 (of which all but one of those would still be in the bottom half even if they had beaten us). Against Cardiff we had 12 corners, 17 shots, the majority from within the penalty area. We are getting in the positions, we're even getting the shots away. Our problems stem from a lack of confidence. We get that win and we'll start to play without second guessing every movement, pass, shot. That's the fundamental issue and its' the main difference between when we were winning games and now that we aren't.
Reply
#13
The one thing this OP does is show you just how easy it is to do your homework on a side. And that's exactly what teams have done to us. They've worked us out and how we like to play. That is why it's absolutely imperative that you have plan B and C ready to go to give you the best possible chance of winning so you can adapt to certain opposition tactics.

Imo this is where I am left a bit frustrated. I don't feel that have changed things up at all. It's always the same formation with like for like replacement subs playing to the same tactics. For example I'd like to see us go 3 at the back in certain games. Then push Styles/Frabotta -Furlong/Fellows further up. Admittedly this is now unlikely as we have 1 fit centre half but even with a full complement we've hardly tried it.

In summary you need to be adaptable to win games and I feel we are a bit rigid.
Reply
#14
(10-30-2024, 10:10 AM)Peachy Wrote: The one thing this OP does is show you just how easy it is to do your homework on a side. And that's exactly what teams have done to us. They've worked us out and how we like to play. That is why it's absolutely imperative that you have plan B and C ready to go to give you the best possible chance of winning so you can adapt to certain opposition tactics.

Imo this is where I am left a bit frustrated. I don't feel that have changed things up at all. It's always the same formation with like for like replacement subs playing to the same tactics. For example I'd like to see us go 3 at the back in certain games. Then push Styles/Frabotta -Furlong/Fellows further up. Admittedly this is now unlikely as we have 1 fit centre half but even with a full complement we've hardly tried it.

In summary you need to be adaptable to win games and I feel we are a bit rigid.
I actually think it might be more likely you know. Holgate and Heggem have played half a game apiece at CH, so them as a partnership, in a 4, could be very risky. If you throw Furlong in there it offers more protection.

You are right though, we do seem shy when it comes to mixing things up. Even switching the wingers only happens when there's a full moon. Whilst I'm all for playing to our strengths, we also have to react to the opposition's defence against them.
Reply
#15
(10-30-2024, 10:10 AM)Peachy Wrote: The one thing this OP does is show you just how easy it is to do your homework on a side. And that's exactly what teams have done to us. They've worked us out and how we like to play. That is why it's absolutely imperative that you have plan B and C ready to go to give you the best possible chance of winning so you can adapt to certain opposition tactics.

Imo this is where I am left a bit frustrated. I don't feel that have changed things up at all. It's always the same formation with like for like replacement subs playing to the same tactics. For example I'd like to see us go 3 at the back in certain games. Then push Styles/Frabotta -Furlong/Fellows further up. Admittedly this is now unlikely as we have 1 fit centre half but even with a full complement we've hardly tried it.

In summary you need to be adaptable to win games and I feel we are a bit rigid.

I think we have changed, but its not worked, YET. 

MJ and Grady are vastly different to Grant and Fellows. Grant and Fellows are runners who need space and to be isolated against a defender to do their thing. Where MJ and Grady both are happy to work in tight areas and try and play cute little one/twos etc. 

I have however called for us to try something different in the defensive and midfield lines to change the balance. The injuries may force that. Which after seeing Styles contribution v Cardiff I am quite optimistic about.

(10-30-2024, 10:00 AM)Sliced Wrote: I don't really want to start too much of an argument about this, but there's a few inconsistencies. You said you don't know how "good" an opponent is but then say "we are not good enough to beat the better teams consistently".

I'm not really sure what "underperforming against their level of statistical output" means? xG for/against doesn't show how good a team is it just tells you something about how they play. Results are the only metric of how good a team has been this season because football is about getting points.

The point remains, we've scored 2 goals in 5 games and haven't won in 6. When we have won it's been against teams in the bottom 8 (of which all but one of those would still be in the bottom half even if they had beaten us). Against Cardiff we had 12 corners, 17 shots, the majority from within the penalty area. We are getting in the positions, we're even getting the shots away. Our problems stem from a lack of confidence. We get that win and we'll start to play without second guessing every movement, pass, shot. That's the fundamental issue and its' the main difference between when we were winning games and now that we aren't.

This is why I have never progressed well professionally, I cant explain myself very well! No arguments needed  Big Grin

By "better teams" I mean the ones that tend to dominate games, score goals and go more man-for-man. Over the last few years; Leicester, Leeds, Burnley, Southampton, Ipswich, Sheff Utd. We always seem to play relatively well and we have close games statistically, but of course you are not going to win all of these games because you're playing against the "better" teams. Luckily what CC has always done is found ways of picking up lots of results against the other teams. 

I suppose what we disagree on is how you measure how good a team is. I put more importance on the measurables and the things that teams do consistently and repeatably. So results, whilst the most important, don't always tell the full, truthful story. 

I completely agree regarding the Cardiff performance. We shows signs of being able to breakdown their deep block and the link up play between the front 3 and the fullbacks seemed more fluid at times. That why, as I have said, I am not too concerned about the results as I can see logic in the correlations and see what CC has tried to do. 

You're right that finishing is a massive issue. We are in the bottom 4 when it comes to the number of goals against our xG and that correlates with our % of shots on target which are we second bottom.  Funnily enough people talk about us "getting shots off" quicker, but we are 4th in terms of number of shots. What we haven't done since the opponents tactical shift has been create good quality chances enough. But as we both agree, against Cardiff there were good signs. Keep the faith. 
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#16
Still no pretty graph B+
Reply
#17
(10-30-2024, 11:34 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Still no pretty graph B+

Arf, I struggle to explain myself half the time. Imagine me trying to bundle together a graph?
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#18
Superfluous statistics?
Reply
#19
(10-30-2024, 06:07 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Superfluous statistics?

Perhaps... But it does paint a picture, imagine how much data actually gets analysed professionally at the club? 

I bet it would boil some piss on here  Big Grin
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#20
(10-30-2024, 06:30 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-30-2024, 06:07 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Superfluous statistics?

Perhaps... But it does paint a picture, imagine how much data actually gets analysed professionally at the club? 

I bet it would boil some piss on here  Big Grin

The physical red line data they get from the halters boils piss nvm all this stuff.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)