Starmer to talk sense?
#31
You have to include a provisional figure (which would have been based on the offer made). You can’t miss big chunks out of a budget because you haven’t got the final bill.
Reply
#32
(10-29-2024, 11:51 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You have to include a provisional figure (which would have been based on the offer made). You can’t miss big chunks out of a budget because you haven’t got the final bill.

So how is it a black hole, and what did Labour budget? Where were these plans in their manifesto?
Reply
#33
If you haven’t budgeted for something at all, including a provision, then there will be an expenditure that will materialise without the income to cover it - a black hole.

Because Labour won’t have seen the actual figures and it is general accounting practice with budget to include everything, it would be reasonable to assume it was included. They prepared their manifesto on that basis, which is reasonable without being allowed to see the full figures. There are other items that weren’t included apparently including no provision for the Post Office or Blood transfusion scandals payouts. The OBR will confirm more over the next day or so.
Reply
#34
(10-29-2024, 12:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: If you haven’t budgeted for something at all, including a provision, then there will be an expenditure that will materialise without the income to cover it - a black hole.

Because Labour won’t have seen the actual figures and it is general accounting practice with budget to include everything, it would be reasonable to assume it was included. They prepared their manifesto on that basis, which is reasonable without being allowed to see the full figures. There are other items that weren’t included apparently including no provision for the Post Office or Blood transfusion scandals payouts. The OBR will confirm more over the next day or so.

Labour saw all the key numbers, the OBR confirmed so. 

If it wasn't there, why go and spunk all that cash so early without any strings? All these public services need reform - Labour has admitted as much.

Since giving Junior Doctors 16% without strings, waiting lists have gone up. That's worked out well.
Reply
#35
Key numbers are different to specific provisions.

So the Tory’s were offering 11% and it had already cost nearly £2bn, the 16% solved an immediate problem and get them back to work it seems reasonable.

And I suspect the rise in waiting lists is a bit more complicated and a longer term cause than 1 element needed to solve it. On your logic if we get rid of all doctors the waiting lists should disappear
Reply
#36
(10-29-2024, 12:32 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Key numbers are different to specific provisions.

So the Tory’s were offering 11% and it had already cost nearly £2bn, the 16% solved an immediate problem and get them back to work it seems reasonable.

And I suspect the rise in waiting lists is a bit more complicated and a longer term cause than 1 element needed to solve it. On your logic if we get rid of all doctors the waiting lists should disappear

It hasn't cost £2bn though.  The Doctors weren't paid whilst striking. "wooden dollars" yet again. Adding a few more to the waiting list doesn't cost actual money - but it does cause real pain to those waiting.

If the waiting lists is more complicated, then tie in the key workers to productivity improvements, and base future rises on this. It isn't rocket science.
Reply
#37
It appears to have been rocket science for quite a while. I’m not certain how you increase productivity when you are haemorrhaging staff abroad and not attracting people into the profession in the 1st place.
Reply
#38
(10-29-2024, 01:23 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It appears to have been rocket science for quite a while. I’m not certain how you increase productivity when you are haemorrhaging staff abroad and not attracting people into the profession in the 1st place.

It's not rocket science. 

Most people commit to a career in medicine, and train for many years. They don't go abroad to drive buses. You can make it a captive audience.

Subsidise their education, and in return they sign to work for an extra number of years - or return their tuition fees ( I had to do this in finance). Pay them a very fair wage (an increase on today's wage), but don't let them perform private consultations to jump the NHS queues. That's the kind of investment in the NHS that I would support.
Reply
#39
When you can’t get them into training in the 1st place you have an uphill struggle. Medical student applications are down 20% since 2020.
Reply
#40
(10-29-2024, 01:23 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It appears to have been rocket science for quite a while. I’m not certain how you increase productivity when you are haemorrhaging staff abroad and not attracting people into the profession in the 1st place.

Can we please nail this "haemorrhaging staff abroad and not attracting people into the profession in the 1st place" BS for what it is please?

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/insight-and...e-nutshell
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: