Israel
(10-22-2024, 03:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 01:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 01:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 12:57 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Several friends' kids in North London had been going to school behind razor wire and security guards a long time before Hamas kicked off the latest spate of violence. Anti-semites infiltrated the top of Labour Party for 4 years whilst Israel was at relative peace.

So perhaps it isn't just the "arrogance and superiority complex" of the current Israeli regime that brings out the worst in "people".

Do you not ever contemplate why this has been so?
 20+ years ago I worked with an anarchist/activist type that never stopped banging on about injustice in Palestine. So much so I looked into what he was talking about and could see the obvious problem. When you refer to Israel being at "relevant peace" that was probably while they were bulldozing Palestinian settlements.
This multi-page thread is going around in circles, or actually, one circle. Both sides have an entitlement to the land. Both sides refuse to accept the other.

The kids that go to JFS are not Israeli ultranationalists or "Greater Israel" activists, the people harassing those kids are anti-semitic scumbags.

Well, yes quite. What on Earth has the Israeli action in the occupied territories got to do with Jewish kids in Golders Green or Kenton or Barnet? Anti-Semitism, that's what - a tale as old as time.

This is what happens when some "people" see fit to import historical tribal disputes into our country - and then they're given succour by others who should know better on the Left of politics in particular. I saw it first hand at the election count in Brum in July, and it's going to get worse if it's not challenged.

Clearly you missed my first line. "Did you not ever contemplate why this is so?"
 And I'm certainly not "offering succour" to those that threaten innocent people. 
I will repeat my last line. Both sides refuse to accept the other  (In regard to the disputed land). I will continue to criticize both sides in this matter, not just the one.
But I did see the election fiasco in Birmingham and agree it was abominable.
Reply
(10-22-2024, 04:35 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 04:08 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Proth has some good Jewish friends. Perhaps he could gain an equal number of Palestinian friends? Might shift perspective to balance?

I worked in property for 15 years with funds raising money across the UK and Middle East so I have a huge number of UK friends with Israeli roots (obviously) and several with Iraqi roots, Egyptian roots, Saudi roots and Emirati roots. 

I can tell you that the only kids who have always had to go to school behind razor wire are the Jewish ones. The only community whose High Streets need voluntary organisations like Shomrim to help keep people safe are the Jewish ones. There is no perspective to be balanced.

Jesus Christ
Reply
(10-22-2024, 05:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 03:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 01:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 01:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 12:57 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Several friends' kids in North London had been going to school behind razor wire and security guards a long time before Hamas kicked off the latest spate of violence. Anti-semites infiltrated the top of Labour Party for 4 years whilst Israel was at relative peace.

So perhaps it isn't just the "arrogance and superiority complex" of the current Israeli regime that brings out the worst in "people".

Do you not ever contemplate why this has been so?
 20+ years ago I worked with an anarchist/activist type that never stopped banging on about injustice in Palestine. So much so I looked into what he was talking about and could see the obvious problem. When you refer to Israel being at "relevant peace" that was probably while they were bulldozing Palestinian settlements.
This multi-page thread is going around in circles, or actually, one circle. Both sides have an entitlement to the land. Both sides refuse to accept the other.

The kids that go to JFS are not Israeli ultranationalists or "Greater Israel" activists, the people harassing those kids are anti-semitic scumbags.

Well, yes quite. What on Earth has the Israeli action in the occupied territories got to do with Jewish kids in Golders Green or Kenton or Barnet? Anti-Semitism, that's what - a tale as old as time.

This is what happens when some "people" see fit to import historical tribal disputes into our country - and then they're given succour by others who should know better on the Left of politics in particular. I saw it first hand at the election count in Brum in July, and it's going to get worse if it's not challenged.

Clearly you missed my first line. "Did you not ever contemplate why this is so?"
 And I'm certainly not "offering succour" to those that threaten innocent people. 
I will repeat my last line. Both sides refuse to accept the other  (In regard to the disputed land). I will continue to criticize both sides in this matter, not just the one.
But I did see the election fiasco in Birmingham and agree it was abominable.

No, I read your first line - and I'll ask the question again - what has the Israel / Palestine conflagration ever had to do with Jewish children at school in the UK? I wasn't accusing you of anything btw.
Reply
I don’t think anyone struggles to answer that question, they just struggle to understand what point you’re trying to make by repeatedly asking it.

If it’s that it’s unfair that they are on the receiving end of abuse or threats as a result - no shit Sherlock. No one has ever suggested any different.
Reply
(10-22-2024, 06:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 05:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 03:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 01:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 01:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Do you not ever contemplate why this has been so?
 20+ years ago I worked with an anarchist/activist type that never stopped banging on about injustice in Palestine. So much so I looked into what he was talking about and could see the obvious problem. When you refer to Israel being at "relevant peace" that was probably while they were bulldozing Palestinian settlements.
This multi-page thread is going around in circles, or actually, one circle. Both sides have an entitlement to the land. Both sides refuse to accept the other.

The kids that go to JFS are not Israeli ultranationalists or "Greater Israel" activists, the people harassing those kids are anti-semitic scumbags.

Well, yes quite. What on Earth has the Israeli action in the occupied territories got to do with Jewish kids in Golders Green or Kenton or Barnet? Anti-Semitism, that's what - a tale as old as time.

This is what happens when some "people" see fit to import historical tribal disputes into our country - and then they're given succour by others who should know better on the Left of politics in particular. I saw it first hand at the election count in Brum in July, and it's going to get worse if it's not challenged.

Clearly you missed my first line. "Did you not ever contemplate why this is so?"
 And I'm certainly not "offering succour" to those that threaten innocent people. 
I will repeat my last line. Both sides refuse to accept the other  (In regard to the disputed land). I will continue to criticize both sides in this matter, not just the one.
But I did see the election fiasco in Birmingham and agree it was abominable.

No, I read your first line - and I'll ask the question again - what has the Israel / Palestine conflagration ever had to do with Jewish children at school in the UK? I wasn't accusing you of anything btw.

Well, stating the obvious, nothing. Wrong is wrong, wherever/whenever.
Reply
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre...oliticians
Reply
(10-22-2024, 06:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 05:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 03:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 01:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 01:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Do you not ever contemplate why this has been so?
 20+ years ago I worked with an anarchist/activist type that never stopped banging on about injustice in Palestine. So much so I looked into what he was talking about and could see the obvious problem. When you refer to Israel being at "relevant peace" that was probably while they were bulldozing Palestinian settlements.
This multi-page thread is going around in circles, or actually, one circle. Both sides have an entitlement to the land. Both sides refuse to accept the other.

The kids that go to JFS are not Israeli ultranationalists or "Greater Israel" activists, the people harassing those kids are anti-semitic scumbags.

Well, yes quite. What on Earth has the Israeli action in the occupied territories got to do with Jewish kids in Golders Green or Kenton or Barnet? Anti-Semitism, that's what - a tale as old as time.

This is what happens when some "people" see fit to import historical tribal disputes into our country - and then they're given succour by others who should know better on the Left of politics in particular. I saw it first hand at the election count in Brum in July, and it's going to get worse if it's not challenged.

Clearly you missed my first line. "Did you not ever contemplate why this is so?"
 And I'm certainly not "offering succour" to those that threaten innocent people. 
I will repeat my last line. Both sides refuse to accept the other  (In regard to the disputed land). I will continue to criticize both sides in this matter, not just the one.
But I did see the election fiasco in Birmingham and agree it was abominable.

No, I read your first line - and I'll ask the question again - what has the Israel / Palestine conflagration ever had to do with Jewish children at school in the UK? I wasn't accusing you of anything btw.

Since this thread is about the Israel/Palestinian "conflagration", not Jewish schoolchildren in the UK, do you want to start a new thread about the latter instead of sidetracking this thread which is about the former?
Reply
Quite.
Proths whole world outlook is based upon whataboutery. His view on Israel is wholly binary and, to me at least, is becoming increasingly objectionable.

This for example.

"There is no perspective to be balanced."

Where do you go with that level of lack of insight in terms of a rational debate? Like Hawks has done, I shall desist from discussing Israel with Proth as he has no sense of reason on this. Good luck to those of you prepared to waste your time continuing to do so. There are none so blind as those who refuse to see. Or in Proths case, at least have one eye very slightly open.
Reply
It’s the same as every other person that has only ever had yelling “anti semitism” as a stock answer for debate about complex issues involving Israel. Once you peel past that thin veneer, they flap around and throw the toys because to do otherwise means facing the reality of their ill conceived stance.

See Ponty for the same lack of reasoned debate.
Reply
Meanwhile overnight airstrikes in Iraq and Syria...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)