Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
10-06-2024, 06:32 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2024, 06:34 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
This is an interesting thread and some great insights into how we generally set up at home.
Firstly CC is generally on the side of caution. As managers like Ferguson and Clough said its defences that win you leagues. It does not mean that the team is necessarily boring.
However, we seldom look like sticking 4 past a team. Think Blackburn home last season was possibly the best attacking performance in CCs time so far.
What was clear to me yesterday was the unwillingness to play a pass or cross that would probably be cleared more often than not was really notable. We seemed more intent on keeping possession and threading a killer pass through the watertight defence than take a chance.
It doesn’t help that Maja is all alone, and the battering ram approach Dike possesses possibly could have been the difference.
However, I think CC got it wrong with the substitutions yesterday and we needed to get another up front and be a shade more adventurous. I really wouldn’t have been against one of the big lads at the back switching up front, if needs be.
I’d like to add too how unimaginative we are with set pieces. It was the one thing we excelled at under Pulis and the only thing I miss from then.
Ajayi, Barts and Heggem are all real sizeable players who cause a threat by their mere presence.
I really hope CC works on a solution as we are currently lacking in ideas in games where the opposition simply want the point they start with.
As an aside, I think it took about 25 minutes yesterday before Millwall got anywhere near the Brummie end. They epitomised parking the bus.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(10-06-2024, 06:05 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Furlong going off the boil is very bad for us. It's why Fellows has struggled more, which means the attack as a whole struggles. Really good point Birdie. No overlaps yesterday bar one with a pea roller cross and no tucking into midfield.
In three games he has gone from best RB in the division to looking bang average.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
The thing with relying on stats to prove or justify any tactic or selection is humans aren’t robots and form is not an exact science. The human element of the game is what makes it interesting, It’s what separates it from more formulaic, technical sports, it’s why relying on them too heavily leads to Val-Ball ineffectiveness once found out.
I don’t share the view that teams cannot mix tactics up because the games too fast. It’s hardly beyond the wit or ability physical and mental to ask the team to hit longer down the channels or speed the play up. If you can change formation you can change other elements within the management of games. I keep hearing we can bring Dike in as a battering ram. If this is true it’s going to take an eternity to get the player anywhere near the door let alone knock it down in some games.
Also going back to the point about set pieces, whether create enough of them or not is a moot point when we are so poor at them relatively speaking, given the types of players we have at our disposal. That is something than can and should be improved pn regardless of how difficult it may or may not be to change other elements of the game as it unfolds.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(10-06-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The thing with relying on stats to prove or justify any tactic or selection is humans aren’t robots and form is not an exact science. The human element of the game is what makes it interesting, It’s what separates it from more formulaic, technical sports, it’s why relying on them too heavily leads to Val-Ball ineffectiveness once found out.
I don’t share the view that teams cannot mix tactics up because the games too fast. It’s hardly beyond the wit or ability physical and mental to ask the team to hit longer down the channels or speed the play up. If you can change formation you can change other elements within the management of games. I keep hearing we can bring Dike in as a battering ram. If this is true it’s going to take an eternity to get the player anywhere near the door let alone knock it down in some games.
Also going back to the point about set pieces, whether create enough of them or not is a moot point when we are so poor at them relatively speaking, given the types of players we have at our disposal. That is something than can and should be improved pn regardless of how difficult it may or may not be to change other elements of the game as it unfolds.
I'll find links, but it's elite coaches saying it, not my opinion.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
10-06-2024, 07:53 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2024, 07:54 PM by Josh1873.)
I'd love to have followed the game in the days before widespread media and TV. Imagine turning up to a game and knowing next to nothing about the opposition. I love that idea.
Nowadays you pretty much get two teams playing a very similar style cancelling each other out. Whereas way back when, styles were (I imagine) very different.
I think it'd be ace to watch your team play and set up to their strengths, rather than worry about the opposition (because they didn't know much about them!).
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(10-06-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The thing with relying on stats to prove or justify any tactic or selection is humans aren’t robots and form is not an exact science. The human element of the game is what makes it interesting, It’s what separates it from more formulaic, technical sports, it’s why relying on them too heavily leads to Val-Ball ineffectiveness once found out.
I don’t share the view that teams cannot mix tactics up because the games too fast. It’s hardly beyond the wit or ability physical and mental to ask the team to hit longer down the channels or speed the play up. If you can change formation you can change other elements within the management of games. I keep hearing we can bring Dike in as a battering ram. If this is true it’s going to take an eternity to get the player anywhere near the door let alone knock it down in some games.
Also going back to the point about set pieces, whether create enough of them or not is a moot point when we are so poor at them relatively speaking, given the types of players we have at our disposal. That is something than can and should be improved pn regardless of how difficult it may or may not be to change other elements of the game as it unfolds.
1) As always, with stats, it depends on whether you make decisions implicitly on the back of raw data or you just use it as a tool to inform your decision making to avoid any biases.
2) Changing tactics - Of course you can ask your players to do different things. In fact you can ask them to do what ever you want. But they would not have likely worked at it, thus,it's unlikely to be efficient or effective. The game is won and lost in the fine margins and those repeatable behaviours and patterns are what win you games more often than not. There are obviously exceptions, of course.
3) We are joint second in terms of goal creating actions from dead ball passes and 8th for shot creating actions from dead ball passes. Only Derby have a really high percentage of SCA/GCA from dead ball passes so far.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-06-2024, 07:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-06-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The thing with relying on stats to prove or justify any tactic or selection is humans aren’t robots and form is not an exact science. The human element of the game is what makes it interesting, It’s what separates it from more formulaic, technical sports, it’s why relying on them too heavily leads to Val-Ball ineffectiveness once found out.
I don’t share the view that teams cannot mix tactics up because the games too fast. It’s hardly beyond the wit or ability physical and mental to ask the team to hit longer down the channels or speed the play up. If you can change formation you can change other elements within the management of games. I keep hearing we can bring Dike in as a battering ram. If this is true it’s going to take an eternity to get the player anywhere near the door let alone knock it down in some games.
Also going back to the point about set pieces, whether create enough of them or not is a moot point when we are so poor at them relatively speaking, given the types of players we have at our disposal. That is something than can and should be improved pn regardless of how difficult it may or may not be to change other elements of the game as it unfolds.
I'll find links, but it's elite coaches saying it, not my opinion.
If you asked elite coaches a few years ago they would have said x,y,z wasn’t possible. Innovation in the game always happens and of course I’m not an expert but I am sceptical it’s not possible to ask a team to go to tactic b and hit a few more passes into the channels or cross from deep before the opposition get a chance to regroup etc.
Football seems to follow trends these day, I think that’s more group think than innovation or the practicalities of the game.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(10-06-2024, 07:53 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'd love to have followed the game in the days before widespread media and TV. Imagine turning up to a game and knowing next to nothing about the opposition. I love that idea.
Nowadays you pretty much get two teams playing a very similar style cancelling each other out. Whereas way back when, styles were (I imagine) very different.
I think it'd be ace to watch your team play and set up to their strengths, rather than worry about the opposition (because they didn't know much about them!).
For those of us over 45 or so we recall a very different game almost a different sport.
The biggest changes have been the quality of pitches making it far easier for better players. You never played football in the 40 yards from your goal.
Look at old footage from 40 plus years ago and the pitch was a great leveller. To add to this is sports science where fitness and stats are used. I would add that the change to the back pass to the keeper rule is a fantastic development.
On the whole it is a better sport.
That does not change the fact that most of our home games so far have been dull.
Posts: 516
Threads: 23
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
1
(10-06-2024, 09:06 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: In 5 games at the Hawthorns this season there’s been 3 goals. 2 1-0 wins for us the 1-0 defeat to Boro and a couple of truly dreadful 0-0s with barely any highlights for Sky to show. Watch yesterday’s highlights it’s laughable some of the tame efforts thee had to make do with.
On the whole I think Carlos is a defence specialist and all for the nick a goal mindset, but yesterday there was no imagination and no decent runs at all to give options in the last third.
I’m struggling to think of a more boring bunch of games than we’ve had. The Plymouth one is the only time I’ve felt quite pleased with the game.
I’m firmly behind CC but really think we need to show a lot more adventurous thinking at home. As the match wore on yesterday we got more and more clueless, considering we have pace in our side. Their keeper didn’t make a proper save all afternoon. I have to say I have been absolutely bored stiff at a lot of the home matches ,we certainly need to be more adventurous but I don’t think that’s carlos style
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
10-06-2024, 09:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2024, 09:53 PM by MrBater.)
(10-06-2024, 05:31 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (10-06-2024, 05:10 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (10-06-2024, 04:58 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The reason our centre backs have the ball a lot is because the other side are content with it. I know a guy that coached at a decent level, from a family with more than one pro footballer in and schooled in tactics etc. He pointed out things I had never considered. One of which was when watching Micah Richards, (for England or at villa), he said the opponents let him have the ball knowing everyone else likely to hurt them is covered. They just let him have the ball. No disrespect to Barts or Ajayi but this week when we have been chasing the game at the death, who has the ball the most? All the flair players are well marked and all 11 opponents compressed ahead of the danger area. That is why we need to mix up the tactics more.
Semi has the ability to pass the ball progressively, through the lines. He also has the ability to pass it poorly and recklessly. They are usually closely linked with non elite players.
Bart's rarely gives away possession has a great range of passing, but rarely if ever plays a risky, 'vertical' pass. This is the same with Heggem at fullback. I think he could play better passes from CB if he was recieving the ball facing forwards with time.
To vary the tactics you need to vary the personnel first. Having Dike back, if he can stay fit, would be a huge boost as we would have a target man to hit early and play off.
I don't disagree with a lot of what you say. I simply think our usual game of keeping possession can be varied a little. Yesterday's opponents didn't want the ball, or even to commit to attack. So a few balls hit hard through the channels risking losing possession, would not have been the end of the world. Overall, I have few complaints, you get these games in a 46 match slog. I've seen enough to suggest we'll be in the mix at the right end of the table so don't get too troubled at dropping the odd point.
It was the same with Val... Opposition let us have the ball and the tactic was stifled.
We need to be the team trying to dictate the play, not being the team stifled by having no ideas on how to adapt when our main plan is t working. We were told that CC is fluid and his team changes shape etc ... Not seen much of that though.
None of this is new though, it was the same last year, but we put it down to not being Carlos' team, this year that excuse does not cut it.
|