Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
10-01-2024, 10:39 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-01-2024, 10:39 AM by Borin' Baggie.)
(10-01-2024, 10:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:23 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:05 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 09:49 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-30-2024, 03:00 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: No I agree with you, it's wrong.
The point is that the party that were elected on a mandate of being whiter than white, aren't.
And some of us are criticised for saying "they are all the same"??
I care significantly more that a moron who said yesterday that she thinks we should wait until nuclear fusion becomes viable instead of supporting private sector investment into renewables was energy secretary a couple of months ago. I care significantly more about a government that has a small semblance of competence which the last government did not, there's things the current government have done that I don't like but I haven't seen them do anything counterfactual as of yet. I don't care about "optics", in fact I'd rather the Labour government do things competently but are unpopular and lose their majority in 2029 to a hung parliament.
Which semblance of competence are you referring to, exactly? I must have missed that
Undoing the moratorium on onshore wind, pushing though energy infrastructure developments that were being held up by local politics, reviewing the decision to scrap the Birmingham-Crewe and OOC-Euston sections of HS2, finally commissioning a review into social and primary care support, reopening dialogue with Spain over Gibraltar to avoid a cliff-edge scenario, defence and industry pact with Germany, running an energy auction properly instead of ignoring what industry was saying like the last government.
All off the top of my head. All things designed to fix issues left over from the last government. Nothing that will generate growth then.
Typical Labour idealism.
More transport capacity and cheap energy are two things that directly contribute to growth. They are both covered in that list. What are you on about?
If you seriously think that a centrist liberal who has never voted Labour in his life and wants them to lose the next election is being idealistic instead of objective in defending Labour then you need to give your head a wobble.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
10-01-2024, 02:23 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-01-2024, 02:25 PM by Kit Kat Chunky.)
(10-01-2024, 10:39 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:23 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:05 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 09:49 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I care significantly more that a moron who said yesterday that she thinks we should wait until nuclear fusion becomes viable instead of supporting private sector investment into renewables was energy secretary a couple of months ago. I care significantly more about a government that has a small semblance of competence which the last government did not, there's things the current government have done that I don't like but I haven't seen them do anything counterfactual as of yet. I don't care about "optics", in fact I'd rather the Labour government do things competently but are unpopular and lose their majority in 2029 to a hung parliament.
Which semblance of competence are you referring to, exactly? I must have missed that
Undoing the moratorium on onshore wind, pushing though energy infrastructure developments that were being held up by local politics, reviewing the decision to scrap the Birmingham-Crewe and OOC-Euston sections of HS2, finally commissioning a review into social and primary care support, reopening dialogue with Spain over Gibraltar to avoid a cliff-edge scenario, defence and industry pact with Germany, running an energy auction properly instead of ignoring what industry was saying like the last government.
All off the top of my head. All things designed to fix issues left over from the last government. Nothing that will generate growth then.
Typical Labour idealism.
More transport capacity and cheap energy are two things that directly contribute to growth. They are both covered in that list. What are you on about?
If you seriously think that a centrist liberal who has never voted Labour in his life and wants them to lose the next election is being idealistic instead of objective in defending Labour then you need to give your head a wobble.
Cheap energy? The price cap went up today, and the Pensioners will be paying more this winter. Meanwhile FGK has committed to net zero by 2030, which is going to inevitably cost the end user more money. We should have invested in Nuclear back in the 90's, and both red & blue governments are guilty of not doing that.
More transport capacity? Who is going to drive these trains now that Aslef has received their inflation busting pay rises without any change in working practices. There will just be even more train cancellations due to lack of drivers.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
10-01-2024, 02:45 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-01-2024, 02:49 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(10-01-2024, 02:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:39 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:23 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:05 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Which semblance of competence are you referring to, exactly? I must have missed that
Undoing the moratorium on onshore wind, pushing though energy infrastructure developments that were being held up by local politics, reviewing the decision to scrap the Birmingham-Crewe and OOC-Euston sections of HS2, finally commissioning a review into social and primary care support, reopening dialogue with Spain over Gibraltar to avoid a cliff-edge scenario, defence and industry pact with Germany, running an energy auction properly instead of ignoring what industry was saying like the last government.
All off the top of my head. All things designed to fix issues left over from the last government. Nothing that will generate growth then.
Typical Labour idealism.
More transport capacity and cheap energy are two things that directly contribute to growth. They are both covered in that list. What are you on about?
If you seriously think that a centrist liberal who has never voted Labour in his life and wants them to lose the next election is being idealistic instead of objective in defending Labour then you need to give your head a wobble.
Cheap energy? The price cap went up today, and the Pensioners will be paying more this winter. Meanwhile FGK has committed to net zero by 2030, which is going to inevitably cost the end user more money. We should have invested in Nuclear back in the 90's, and both red & blue governments are guilty of not doing that.
More transport capacity? Who is going to drive these trains now that Aslef has received their inflation busting pay rises without any change in working practices. There will just be even more train cancellations due to lack of drivers.
1. The price cap is lower now than it was this time last year, even with the subsidy now removed, you're looking at a £120 saving on typical household consumption plus (unlike last year) other distributors are charging below the cap now. Also, electricity is expensive in this country due to our reliance on gas and staying tied to gas is going to cost us a lot more than net zero. The costs associated with transitioning to net zero will also be significantly less if there are fewer barriers to building the necessary grid capacity to support it, lack of grid capacity is already a bottleneck for offshore wind from the North Sea - not the turbines but the transmission infrastructure. I've raised the issue of Thatcher abandoning investment into new nuclear in the 1980s due to the "dash for gas" before so I'm not going to cover that ground but I will say two new-gen EPR reactors are due online in the 2030s (would be more but the Tories decided to rip up the financing strategy for new nuclear that was created during the coalition to get Hinkley Point C approved for reasons unbeknownst to anyone including them) to a capacity of 6.5GWe which is equivalent to our currently installed nuclear as well as the trials for SMR going ahead with four companies named.
2. HS2 is going to be built. Those trains are going to run regardless. Either it runs from Euston to Crewe at a minimum - which frees up capacity on the WCML, the point in building it in the first place - or (the stupidly stripped-back plan from the last government) it runs from Old Oak Common to somewhere north of Birmingham and cuts capacity on the WCML. HS2 trains being as grade separated as possible (which Euston-Crewe would enable) makes them much more straightforward to staff without modal conflicts and Victorian signalling which would make training new drivers much easier.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(10-01-2024, 02:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 02:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:39 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:23 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Undoing the moratorium on onshore wind, pushing though energy infrastructure developments that were being held up by local politics, reviewing the decision to scrap the Birmingham-Crewe and OOC-Euston sections of HS2, finally commissioning a review into social and primary care support, reopening dialogue with Spain over Gibraltar to avoid a cliff-edge scenario, defence and industry pact with Germany, running an energy auction properly instead of ignoring what industry was saying like the last government.
All off the top of my head. All things designed to fix issues left over from the last government. Nothing that will generate growth then.
Typical Labour idealism.
More transport capacity and cheap energy are two things that directly contribute to growth. They are both covered in that list. What are you on about?
If you seriously think that a centrist liberal who has never voted Labour in his life and wants them to lose the next election is being idealistic instead of objective in defending Labour then you need to give your head a wobble.
Cheap energy? The price cap went up today, and the Pensioners will be paying more this winter. Meanwhile FGK has committed to net zero by 2030, which is going to inevitably cost the end user more money. We should have invested in Nuclear back in the 90's, and both red & blue governments are guilty of not doing that.
More transport capacity? Who is going to drive these trains now that Aslef has received their inflation busting pay rises without any change in working practices. There will just be even more train cancellations due to lack of drivers.
1. The price cap is lower now than it was this time last year, even with the subsidy now removed, you're looking at a £120 saving on typical household consumption plus (unlike last year) other distributors are charging below the cap now. Also, electricity is expensive in this country due to our reliance on gas and staying tied to gas is going to cost us a lot more than net zero. The costs associated with transitioning to net zero will also be significantly less if there are fewer barriers to building the necessary grid capacity to support it, lack of grid capacity is already a bottleneck for offshore wind from the North Sea - not the turbines but the transmission infrastructure. I've raised the issue of Thatcher abandoning investment into new nuclear in the 1980s due to the "dash for gas" before so I'm not going to cover that ground but I will say two new-gen EPR reactors are due online in the 2030s (would be more but the Tories decided to rip up the financing strategy for new nuclear that was created during the coalition to get Hinkley Point C approved for reasons unbeknownst to anyone including them) to a capacity of 6.5GWe which is equivalent to our currently installed nuclear as well as the trials for SMR going ahead with four companies named.
2. HS2 is going to be built. Those trains are going to run regardless. Either it runs from Euston to Crewe at a minimum - which frees up capacity on the WCML, the point in building it in the first place - or (the stupidly stripped-back plan from the last government) it runs from Old Oak Common to somewhere north of Birmingham and cuts capacity on the WCML. HS2 trains being as grade separated as possible (which Euston-Crewe would enable) makes them much more straightforward to staff without modal conflicts and Victorian signalling which would make training new drivers much easier.
1. So what did Tony Blair do to put all this back on track after Thatcher ruined it? He and Brown had plenty of opportunity but they ignored it.
2. HS2 is a massive white elephant. The time savings vs cost of tickets will see that it is as popular as the Toll Road. I find it hilarious that Labour is now trying to take some credit for finishing a failed and doomed Tory project, though.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(10-01-2024, 03:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 02:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 02:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:39 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Nothing that will generate growth then.
Typical Labour idealism.
More transport capacity and cheap energy are two things that directly contribute to growth. They are both covered in that list. What are you on about?
If you seriously think that a centrist liberal who has never voted Labour in his life and wants them to lose the next election is being idealistic instead of objective in defending Labour then you need to give your head a wobble.
Cheap energy? The price cap went up today, and the Pensioners will be paying more this winter. Meanwhile FGK has committed to net zero by 2030, which is going to inevitably cost the end user more money. We should have invested in Nuclear back in the 90's, and both red & blue governments are guilty of not doing that.
More transport capacity? Who is going to drive these trains now that Aslef has received their inflation busting pay rises without any change in working practices. There will just be even more train cancellations due to lack of drivers.
1. The price cap is lower now than it was this time last year, even with the subsidy now removed, you're looking at a £120 saving on typical household consumption plus (unlike last year) other distributors are charging below the cap now. Also, electricity is expensive in this country due to our reliance on gas and staying tied to gas is going to cost us a lot more than net zero. The costs associated with transitioning to net zero will also be significantly less if there are fewer barriers to building the necessary grid capacity to support it, lack of grid capacity is already a bottleneck for offshore wind from the North Sea - not the turbines but the transmission infrastructure. I've raised the issue of Thatcher abandoning investment into new nuclear in the 1980s due to the "dash for gas" before so I'm not going to cover that ground but I will say two new-gen EPR reactors are due online in the 2030s (would be more but the Tories decided to rip up the financing strategy for new nuclear that was created during the coalition to get Hinkley Point C approved for reasons unbeknownst to anyone including them) to a capacity of 6.5GWe which is equivalent to our currently installed nuclear as well as the trials for SMR going ahead with four companies named.
2. HS2 is going to be built. Those trains are going to run regardless. Either it runs from Euston to Crewe at a minimum - which frees up capacity on the WCML, the point in building it in the first place - or (the stupidly stripped-back plan from the last government) it runs from Old Oak Common to somewhere north of Birmingham and cuts capacity on the WCML. HS2 trains being as grade separated as possible (which Euston-Crewe would enable) makes them much more straightforward to staff without modal conflicts and Victorian signalling which would make training new drivers much easier.
1. So what did Tony Blair do to put all this back on track after Thatcher ruined it? He and Brown had plenty of opportunity but they ignored it.
2. HS2 is a massive white elephant. The time savings vs cost of tickets will see that it is as popular as the Toll Road. I find it hilarious that Labour is now trying to take some credit for finishing a failed and doomed Tory project, though.
1. Brown? Blair sure (same issue as Major with being obsessed with the dash for gas), but Brown? Brown's government was the first government since the 1970s to put forward a new nuclear programme, that was then scrapped after the 2015 election save for the two that were already in the pipeline. And I single out Thatcher specifically as it was her government that scrapped the new nuclear programme that was drawn up despite initially backing it, much harder to start a new programme up from scratch after it's been scrapped for 10 years.
2. HS2 is not about time savings. It's about upgrading capacity, the same reason motorways are built. The alternative is to four-track the WCML from Rugby all the way to Manchester on both trunks (Birmingham and Lichfield) which would not only cost a lot more but also take longer and cause a shit tonne more disruption due to the WCML needing to be closed. And HS2 Ltd was created in 2009. And what Labour are doing is trying to salvage it after the Tories messed it up so much to the point that their revised plans reduce capacity instead of adding to it.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(10-01-2024, 03:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 03:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 02:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 02:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 10:39 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: More transport capacity and cheap energy are two things that directly contribute to growth. They are both covered in that list. What are you on about?
If you seriously think that a centrist liberal who has never voted Labour in his life and wants them to lose the next election is being idealistic instead of objective in defending Labour then you need to give your head a wobble.
Cheap energy? The price cap went up today, and the Pensioners will be paying more this winter. Meanwhile FGK has committed to net zero by 2030, which is going to inevitably cost the end user more money. We should have invested in Nuclear back in the 90's, and both red & blue governments are guilty of not doing that.
More transport capacity? Who is going to drive these trains now that Aslef has received their inflation busting pay rises without any change in working practices. There will just be even more train cancellations due to lack of drivers.
1. The price cap is lower now than it was this time last year, even with the subsidy now removed, you're looking at a £120 saving on typical household consumption plus (unlike last year) other distributors are charging below the cap now. Also, electricity is expensive in this country due to our reliance on gas and staying tied to gas is going to cost us a lot more than net zero. The costs associated with transitioning to net zero will also be significantly less if there are fewer barriers to building the necessary grid capacity to support it, lack of grid capacity is already a bottleneck for offshore wind from the North Sea - not the turbines but the transmission infrastructure. I've raised the issue of Thatcher abandoning investment into new nuclear in the 1980s due to the "dash for gas" before so I'm not going to cover that ground but I will say two new-gen EPR reactors are due online in the 2030s (would be more but the Tories decided to rip up the financing strategy for new nuclear that was created during the coalition to get Hinkley Point C approved for reasons unbeknownst to anyone including them) to a capacity of 6.5GWe which is equivalent to our currently installed nuclear as well as the trials for SMR going ahead with four companies named.
2. HS2 is going to be built. Those trains are going to run regardless. Either it runs from Euston to Crewe at a minimum - which frees up capacity on the WCML, the point in building it in the first place - or (the stupidly stripped-back plan from the last government) it runs from Old Oak Common to somewhere north of Birmingham and cuts capacity on the WCML. HS2 trains being as grade separated as possible (which Euston-Crewe would enable) makes them much more straightforward to staff without modal conflicts and Victorian signalling which would make training new drivers much easier.
1. So what did Tony Blair do to put all this back on track after Thatcher ruined it? He and Brown had plenty of opportunity but they ignored it.
2. HS2 is a massive white elephant. The time savings vs cost of tickets will see that it is as popular as the Toll Road. I find it hilarious that Labour is now trying to take some credit for finishing a failed and doomed Tory project, though.
1. Brown? Blair sure (same issue as Major with being obsessed with the dash for gas), but Brown? Brown's government was the first government since the 1970s to put forward a new nuclear programme, that was then scrapped after the 2015 election save for the two that were already in the pipeline. And I single out Thatcher specifically as it was her government that scrapped the new nuclear programme that was drawn up despite initially backing it, much harder to start a new programme up from scratch after it's been scrapped for 10 years.
2. HS2 is not about time savings. It's about upgrading capacity, the same reason motorways are built. The alternative is to four-track the WCML from Rugby all the way to Manchester on both trunks (Birmingham and Lichfield) which would not only cost a lot more but also take longer and cause a shit tonne more disruption due to the WCML needing to be closed. And HS2 Ltd was created in 2009. And what Labour are doing is trying to salvage it after the Tories messed it up so much to the point that their revised plans reduce capacity instead of adding to it. 1. Brown was part of Blair's government t, so is complicit
2. It isn't about capacity. If it was, why name it High Speed. The Northern Engine believe if they can reach London quicker then they can move more business away from London.
Building capacity doesn't give you economic growth, without new business contracts to improve GDP.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(10-02-2024, 09:44 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 03:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 03:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 02:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 02:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Cheap energy? The price cap went up today, and the Pensioners will be paying more this winter. Meanwhile FGK has committed to net zero by 2030, which is going to inevitably cost the end user more money. We should have invested in Nuclear back in the 90's, and both red & blue governments are guilty of not doing that.
More transport capacity? Who is going to drive these trains now that Aslef has received their inflation busting pay rises without any change in working practices. There will just be even more train cancellations due to lack of drivers.
1. The price cap is lower now than it was this time last year, even with the subsidy now removed, you're looking at a £120 saving on typical household consumption plus (unlike last year) other distributors are charging below the cap now. Also, electricity is expensive in this country due to our reliance on gas and staying tied to gas is going to cost us a lot more than net zero. The costs associated with transitioning to net zero will also be significantly less if there are fewer barriers to building the necessary grid capacity to support it, lack of grid capacity is already a bottleneck for offshore wind from the North Sea - not the turbines but the transmission infrastructure. I've raised the issue of Thatcher abandoning investment into new nuclear in the 1980s due to the "dash for gas" before so I'm not going to cover that ground but I will say two new-gen EPR reactors are due online in the 2030s (would be more but the Tories decided to rip up the financing strategy for new nuclear that was created during the coalition to get Hinkley Point C approved for reasons unbeknownst to anyone including them) to a capacity of 6.5GWe which is equivalent to our currently installed nuclear as well as the trials for SMR going ahead with four companies named.
2. HS2 is going to be built. Those trains are going to run regardless. Either it runs from Euston to Crewe at a minimum - which frees up capacity on the WCML, the point in building it in the first place - or (the stupidly stripped-back plan from the last government) it runs from Old Oak Common to somewhere north of Birmingham and cuts capacity on the WCML. HS2 trains being as grade separated as possible (which Euston-Crewe would enable) makes them much more straightforward to staff without modal conflicts and Victorian signalling which would make training new drivers much easier.
1. So what did Tony Blair do to put all this back on track after Thatcher ruined it? He and Brown had plenty of opportunity but they ignored it.
2. HS2 is a massive white elephant. The time savings vs cost of tickets will see that it is as popular as the Toll Road. I find it hilarious that Labour is now trying to take some credit for finishing a failed and doomed Tory project, though.
1. Brown? Blair sure (same issue as Major with being obsessed with the dash for gas), but Brown? Brown's government was the first government since the 1970s to put forward a new nuclear programme, that was then scrapped after the 2015 election save for the two that were already in the pipeline. And I single out Thatcher specifically as it was her government that scrapped the new nuclear programme that was drawn up despite initially backing it, much harder to start a new programme up from scratch after it's been scrapped for 10 years.
2. HS2 is not about time savings. It's about upgrading capacity, the same reason motorways are built. The alternative is to four-track the WCML from Rugby all the way to Manchester on both trunks (Birmingham and Lichfield) which would not only cost a lot more but also take longer and cause a shit tonne more disruption due to the WCML needing to be closed. And HS2 Ltd was created in 2009. And what Labour are doing is trying to salvage it after the Tories messed it up so much to the point that their revised plans reduce capacity instead of adding to it. 1. Brown was part of Blair's government t, so is complicit
2. It isn't about capacity. If it was, why name it High Speed. The Northern Engine believe if they can reach London quicker then they can move more business away from London.
Building capacity doesn't give you economic growth, without new business contracts to improve GDP.
1. Nope, that's some reaching. The Chancellor is not in charge of planning energy infrastructure, only funding and the new nuclear programme hadn't got to that point until 2013/2014 when Hinkley Point C was ready to be signed off. Having been on the other side of that line in as a private sector stakeholder in public energy planning the Treasury don't get really involved until very late in the process.
2. It was named "High Speed" because the engineers and technical staff who set out the design parameters, the business case and the project plan aren't in charge of marketing it. HS2 is about capacity relief. The WCML between Rugby and Wolverhampton is the most congested section of mixed-use railway track in Europe, this has been known since the 1930s when there were initial plans to relieve capacity on the WCML by four-tracking it before WWII put that on an 80-year hiatus. It's also why the Chiltern Line was reopened 10-years after closure, and now the Chiltern Line is also at capacity. HS2 is about relieving services to free up capacity for services going through New Street or freight interchanging from Immingham to Southampton via Coventry enabling better usage and new transport corridors.
And building transport capacity absolutely does induce growth, especially when transport capacity is acting as a bottleneck which the WCML is. Same principles apply to power transmission capacity needed to support energy infrastructure. Growth opportunities aren't going to arrive if there isn't the capacity to facilitate the, those business contracts are contingent on the capacity being there otherwise they won't materialise. You're not going to invest in a factory or freight centre if there isn't the freight capacity to support it, you're not going to open an office unless you are confident you have access to enough workers - the thing that drives growth is infrastructure development as without it you're hamstringing opportunities for growth. Sam Bowman, formerly of the ASI, has put out a very decent essay that cleary highlights the infrastructure deficiencies in the UK and how that is holding us back and I highly suggest you read it.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(10-02-2024, 10:29 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-02-2024, 09:44 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 03:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-01-2024, 03:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-01-2024, 02:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: 1. The price cap is lower now than it was this time last year, even with the subsidy now removed, you're looking at a £120 saving on typical household consumption plus (unlike last year) other distributors are charging below the cap now. Also, electricity is expensive in this country due to our reliance on gas and staying tied to gas is going to cost us a lot more than net zero. The costs associated with transitioning to net zero will also be significantly less if there are fewer barriers to building the necessary grid capacity to support it, lack of grid capacity is already a bottleneck for offshore wind from the North Sea - not the turbines but the transmission infrastructure. I've raised the issue of Thatcher abandoning investment into new nuclear in the 1980s due to the "dash for gas" before so I'm not going to cover that ground but I will say two new-gen EPR reactors are due online in the 2030s (would be more but the Tories decided to rip up the financing strategy for new nuclear that was created during the coalition to get Hinkley Point C approved for reasons unbeknownst to anyone including them) to a capacity of 6.5GWe which is equivalent to our currently installed nuclear as well as the trials for SMR going ahead with four companies named.
2. HS2 is going to be built. Those trains are going to run regardless. Either it runs from Euston to Crewe at a minimum - which frees up capacity on the WCML, the point in building it in the first place - or (the stupidly stripped-back plan from the last government) it runs from Old Oak Common to somewhere north of Birmingham and cuts capacity on the WCML. HS2 trains being as grade separated as possible (which Euston-Crewe would enable) makes them much more straightforward to staff without modal conflicts and Victorian signalling which would make training new drivers much easier.
1. So what did Tony Blair do to put all this back on track after Thatcher ruined it? He and Brown had plenty of opportunity but they ignored it.
2. HS2 is a massive white elephant. The time savings vs cost of tickets will see that it is as popular as the Toll Road. I find it hilarious that Labour is now trying to take some credit for finishing a failed and doomed Tory project, though.
1. Brown? Blair sure (same issue as Major with being obsessed with the dash for gas), but Brown? Brown's government was the first government since the 1970s to put forward a new nuclear programme, that was then scrapped after the 2015 election save for the two that were already in the pipeline. And I single out Thatcher specifically as it was her government that scrapped the new nuclear programme that was drawn up despite initially backing it, much harder to start a new programme up from scratch after it's been scrapped for 10 years.
2. HS2 is not about time savings. It's about upgrading capacity, the same reason motorways are built. The alternative is to four-track the WCML from Rugby all the way to Manchester on both trunks (Birmingham and Lichfield) which would not only cost a lot more but also take longer and cause a shit tonne more disruption due to the WCML needing to be closed. And HS2 Ltd was created in 2009. And what Labour are doing is trying to salvage it after the Tories messed it up so much to the point that their revised plans reduce capacity instead of adding to it. 1. Brown was part of Blair's government t, so is complicit
2. It isn't about capacity. If it was, why name it High Speed. The Northern Engine believe if they can reach London quicker then they can move more business away from London.
Building capacity doesn't give you economic growth, without new business contracts to improve GDP.
1. Nope, that's some reaching. The Chancellor is not in charge of planning energy infrastructure, only funding and the new nuclear programme hadn't got to that point until 2013/2014 when Hinkley Point C was ready to be signed off. Having been on the other side of that line in as a private sector stakeholder in public energy planning the Treasury don't get really involved until very late in the process.
2. It was named "High Speed" because the engineers and technical staff who set out the design parameters, the business case and the project plan aren't in charge of marketing it. HS2 is about capacity relief. The WCML between Rugby and Wolverhampton is the most congested section of mixed-use railway track in Europe, this has been known since the 1930s when there were initial plans to relieve capacity on the WCML by four-tracking it before WWII put that on an 80-year hiatus. It's also why the Chiltern Line was reopened 10-years after closure, and now the Chiltern Line is also at capacity. HS2 is about relieving services to free up capacity for services going through New Street or freight interchanging from Immingham to Southampton via Coventry enabling better usage and new transport corridors.
And building transport capacity absolutely does induce growth, especially when transport capacity is acting as a bottleneck which the WCML is. Same principles apply to power transmission capacity needed to support energy infrastructure. Growth opportunities aren't going to arrive if there isn't the capacity to facilitate the, those business contracts are contingent on the capacity being there otherwise they won't materialise. You're not going to invest in a factory or freight centre if there isn't the freight capacity to support it, you're not going to open an office unless you are confident you have access to enough workers - the thing that drives growth is infrastructure development as without it you're hamstringing opportunities for growth. Sam Bowman, formerly of the ASI, has put out a very decent essay that cleary highlights the infrastructure deficiencies in the UK and how that is holding us back and I highly suggest you read it. Too long to read and reply to. I'll move on, we are poles apart on this, mate.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
10-02-2024, 04:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-02-2024, 04:30 PM by Protheroe.)
Posts: 6,717
Threads: 354
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
Whilst it's nice to see Proth quoting The Grauniad, Starmer is either dim, arrogant or has very poor judgment.
Morning Star or International Left Review next Proth?
|