Oasis
(09-03-2024, 11:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:25 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:23 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:19 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Proth defending greedy bastards and unethical practices shocker!

Pretty sure Proth is just trolling now, because there is no reasonable defence of this.

Citing “supply and demand” is just bullshit. The ticket prices, whilst high, were known in advance of the sale and people were able to make their own judgement calls on whether to pay them or not. Suddenly upping the price almost threefold mid-sale and forcing people to make a snap decision on whether to pay the extra or miss out is nothing more than greed and profiteering.

There was absolutely no need to do it and no defending it.

I don’t think he’s defending it. He’s explaining it’s based on supply and demand.

It’s a shoddy practice that needs regulating IMO, but it’s still based on supply and demand.
It's really not a difficult concept to grasp. Pretty sure people are throwing toys out the pram because they couldn't get a ticket to a show of brothers who (supposedly, but surely it's just for show) hate each other, are past it, and frankly aren't as good as folks make out.

It seems tricky for some to grasp tbh! It’s based on supply and demand, but it’s a shoddy practice.

The other point is this isn’t an Oasis issue as such. It’s been a problem for ages.

I didn’t even try and get tickets, but the point is about the industry itself, not this particular band. Pretty sure the same happened with Taylor Swift and others.

I had no issues with my Swift tickets. Prices we as advertised throughout. I had early access so no idea how the general sales went. 

This clamour for tickets for acts is ridiculous though. It reminds me of Peter Kay. Like Oasis, I think he's ace, but there's no way he justifies the clamour that we saw. 

It's another pos-lockdown symptom for me, where people get overly excited about tours (when lockdown eased) and it's carried on. Artists have latched onto that and taken advantage. Rightly or wrongly. 

If you put your house up for sale (value of 100k), and it received ridiculous views and demand, and someone offered 90k, most offered bang on the nose of 100k, but someone offered 200k, would you sell to one of the 100k offers because it was ethical? 

No, you wouldn't. Probably a loose analogy, but why would any body sell something for less than what they could get for it?
Reply
(09-03-2024, 11:32 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:27 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:19 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Proth defending greedy bastards and unethical practices shocker!

Pretty sure Proth is just trolling now, because there is no reasonable defence of this.

Citing “supply and demand” is just bullshit. The ticket prices, whilst high, were known in advance of the sale and people were able to make their own judgement calls on whether to pay them or not. Suddenly upping the price almost threefold mid-sale and forcing people to make a snap decision on whether to pay the extra or miss out is nothing more than greed and profiteering.

There was absolutely no need to do it and no defending it.

Where have I defended it?

You said it's nothing to do with supply & demand. I was correcting that misapprehension.

And I’m saying it was a cynical and calculated move that uses “supply and demand” as a cover for a deeply unethical and unnecessary practice.

Not that I would expect you to understand that.

Duffers you did state it wasn’t about supply and demand. It literally is, as Proth explained. Literally that is what dynamic pricing is.

He hasn’t said he agrees it’s ok. I think it’s shoddy too, but it’s a fact it’s based on supply and demand, which is all he explained.

I am still waiting for a satisfactory answer from anyone as to why “supply and demand” needs to be applied to gig tickets.

For decades for every single gig and festival that has ever existed there has been a set number of tickets available at a set price. Some gigs are always in incredibly high demand and sell out very quickly, but once they were all sold out that was it.

At no point did anyone ever feel the need to dynamically increase the price just because more people wanted to buy them. So why now?

It’s a scummy, bullshit practice and simply citing “supply and demand” is the flimsiest justification for it imaginable.
Reply
(09-03-2024, 11:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:25 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:23 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:19 AM)Duffers Wrote: Pretty sure Proth is just trolling now, because there is no reasonable defence of this.

Citing “supply and demand” is just bullshit. The ticket prices, whilst high, were known in advance of the sale and people were able to make their own judgement calls on whether to pay them or not. Suddenly upping the price almost threefold mid-sale and forcing people to make a snap decision on whether to pay the extra or miss out is nothing more than greed and profiteering.

There was absolutely no need to do it and no defending it.

I don’t think he’s defending it. He’s explaining it’s based on supply and demand.

It’s a shoddy practice that needs regulating IMO, but it’s still based on supply and demand.
It's really not a difficult concept to grasp. Pretty sure people are throwing toys out the pram because they couldn't get a ticket to a show of brothers who (supposedly, but surely it's just for show) hate each other, are past it, and frankly aren't as good as folks make out.

It seems tricky for some to grasp tbh! It’s based on supply and demand, but it’s a shoddy practice.

The other point is this isn’t an Oasis issue as such. It’s been a problem for ages.

I didn’t even try and get tickets, but the point is about the industry itself, not this particular band. Pretty sure the same happened with Taylor Swift and others.

I had no issues with my Swift tickets. Prices we as advertised throughout. I had early access so no idea how the general sales went. 

This clamour for tickets for acts is ridiculous though. It reminds me of Peter Kay. Like Oasis, I think he's ace, but there's no way he justifies the clamour that we saw. 

It's another pos-lockdown symptom for me, where people get overly excited about tours (when lockdown eased) and it's carried on. Artists have latched onto that and taken advantage. Rightly or wrongly. 

If you put your house up for sale (value of 100k), and it received ridiculous views and demand, and someone offered 90k, most offered bang on the nose of 100k, but someone offered 200k, would you sell to one of the 100k offers because it was ethical? 

No, you wouldn't. Probably a loose analogy, but why would any body sell something for less than what they could get for it?

And on the flip side, would you think it’s acceptable for, say, supermarkets to charge treble for bread and milk if they are running low? I wouldn’t.
Reply
(09-03-2024, 11:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I had no issues with my Swift tickets. Prices we as advertised throughout. I had early access so no idea how the general sales went. 

This clamour for tickets for acts is ridiculous though. It reminds me of Peter Kay. Like Oasis, I think he's ace, but there's no way he justifies the clamour that we saw. 

It's another pos-lockdown symptom for me, where people get overly excited about tours (when lockdown eased) and it's carried on. Artists have latched onto that and taken advantage. Rightly or wrongly. 

If you put your house up for sale (value of 100k), and it received ridiculous views and demand, and someone offered 90k, most offered bang on the nose of 100k, but someone offered 200k, would you sell to one of the 100k offers because it was ethical? 

No, you wouldn't. Probably a loose analogy, but why would any body sell something for less than what they could get for it?

A more accurate analogy would be agreeing a sale price of £100k with someone, waiting until someone was fully committed to the sale (incurring emotional and financial cost) and then saying on the day of comlpetion that the price is £200k, like it or leave it.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(09-03-2024, 11:37 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:32 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:27 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:19 AM)Duffers Wrote: Pretty sure Proth is just trolling now, because there is no reasonable defence of this.

Citing “supply and demand” is just bullshit. The ticket prices, whilst high, were known in advance of the sale and people were able to make their own judgement calls on whether to pay them or not. Suddenly upping the price almost threefold mid-sale and forcing people to make a snap decision on whether to pay the extra or miss out is nothing more than greed and profiteering.

There was absolutely no need to do it and no defending it.

Where have I defended it?

You said it's nothing to do with supply & demand. I was correcting that misapprehension.

And I’m saying it was a cynical and calculated move that uses “supply and demand” as a cover for a deeply unethical and unnecessary practice.

Not that I would expect you to understand that.

Duffers you did state it wasn’t about supply and demand. It literally is, as Proth explained. Literally that is what dynamic pricing is.

He hasn’t said he agrees it’s ok. I think it’s shoddy too, but it’s a fact it’s based on supply and demand, which is all he explained.

I am still waiting for a satisfactory answer from anyone as to why “supply and demand” needs to be applied to gig tickets.

For decades for every single gig and festival that has ever existed there has been a set number of tickets available at a set price. Some gigs are always in incredibly high demand and sell out very quickly, but once they were all sold out that was it.

At no point did anyone ever feel the need to dynamically increase the price just because more people wanted to buy them. So why now?

It’s a scummy, bullshit practice and simply citing “supply and demand” is the flimsiest justification for it imaginable.

I agree, I’m just saying the shoddy practice is clearly based on supply and demand, which is all Proth said. He didn’t pass judgment on whether it’s ok or not, and didn’t defend it.
Reply
How would people have reacted had Albion, shortly after the Wolves cup game tickets went on sale, suddenly said “actually loads of people want to go so we’re trembling the price”?
Reply
(09-03-2024, 11:33 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:29 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:25 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm really not sure what the argument is. Oasis knew that with relatively limited dates they could charge what they wanted. Heck, if tickets had started at £500 they'd have still sold out and the ridiculous meltdown for tickets would have still occurred.

Think it's too expensive? Fine. Don't buy a ticket. Don't go.

Thinks it's fair enough? Fine. Over pay and have a good time.

Of course the mortality of choosing to price tickets at a high price is questionable, but is it surprising? If you were expecting an Oasis reunion to cost £30 a ticket then yam a bit thick, tbf!

You’re missing the point here Josh.

The issue is less what the price was but that it changed midway through the sale. Had they announced in advance tickets would cost £350 then that would be less scummy as people could make the decision in advance whether to pay it or not.

Drastically upping the price midway through the sale is a cynical and calculated measure designed to pray on people’s fear of missing out. People who have waited years to see their favourite band reform are suddenly faced with the prospect of having to fork out an extra £200 per ticket or miss out altogether.

It fucking stinks.

It does. But it's not surprising. 

I don't buy the fact people were panicked into purchasing. It's not as if a gun was held to their head or it's a matter of life and death. You'd have selected the seats, saw the price, entered the details and paid for tickets. There would have been ample opportunity to think 'this is too much, I'm not paying that'. 

I think Oasis have taken the piss, of course they have, but the demand is there and they can. Does it make it right? I'm not sure. But because you've overpaid and claim it's the only chance to see Oasis (they'll come back in another 10 years and do the same again) doesn't make it wrong, either. Pay or don't. Simple.

As someone who doesn’t really care much about music or seeing it live (you’re own words) I wouldn’t expect you to understand how strong a motivator FOMO can be, especially in a situation like this where people are desperate to grab tickets that may sell out at any second.

Like any scam there will be people who fall for it and pay the money and others who will not. I was presented with the opportunity to pay £355 for a standing ticket and declined on general principle. That the gigs sold out shows that others did pay it.

The point remains that people shouldn’t have been put in that position to begin with.

Maybe I'm being a dick and missing your point, but respectfully disagree. 

I know peopl will laugh and take the piss, but seeing Taylor Swift meant a huge deal to me. I had to get a ticket, but if I was faced with a ticket price anywhere over £250 I'd have closed the browser down. 

I may not be into music, but I'm passionate about Taylor Swift and that's the one actually I really wanted to see (and I'm lucky to have done so in excellent seats too). 

It's a simply concept . Can you afford the price at checkout? Yes. Go ahead book. If not, then don't. I really do not see it the complication. It's not as if people were having a gun held to their head. It's not even a con because the price point is clear, at time it purchase, and no one, absolutely no one is forcing them to buy.

(09-03-2024, 11:40 AM)Duffers Wrote: How would people have reacted had Albion, shortly after the Wolves cup game tickets went on sale, suddenly said “actually loads of people want to go so we’re trembling the price”?

It'd have shaken me, mate, tbf.

(09-03-2024, 11:38 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I had no issues with my Swift tickets. Prices we as advertised throughout. I had early access so no idea how the general sales went. 

This clamour for tickets for acts is ridiculous though. It reminds me of Peter Kay. Like Oasis, I think he's ace, but there's no way he justifies the clamour that we saw. 

It's another pos-lockdown symptom for me, where people get overly excited about tours (when lockdown eased) and it's carried on. Artists have latched onto that and taken advantage. Rightly or wrongly. 

If you put your house up for sale (value of 100k), and it received ridiculous views and demand, and someone offered 90k, most offered bang on the nose of 100k, but someone offered 200k, would you sell to one of the 100k offers because it was ethical? 

No, you wouldn't. Probably a loose analogy, but why would any body sell something for less than what they could get for it?

A more accurate analogy would be agreeing a sale price of £100k with someone, waiting until someone was fully committed to the sale (incurring emotional and financial cost) and then saying on the day of comlpetion that the price is £200k, like it or leave it.

That happens (gazzumping) doesn't it. Again, it's shit, but what wouldn't you sell at the higher price if someone wants it so much? 

I think we can all agree we'd all take more money. But we also can see how much of a shithouse it is. And agree on that, too.

Ultimately money causes this. It's the root or all evil as they say. I see the issue, of course, but I don't see the issue with the issue. Money talks. If that all makes sense.
Reply
26 pages already all about money-grabbing from people with more money than sense.
Reply
(09-03-2024, 11:40 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:33 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:29 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:25 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-03-2024, 11:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm really not sure what the argument is. Oasis knew that with relatively limited dates they could charge what they wanted. Heck, if tickets had started at £500 they'd have still sold out and the ridiculous meltdown for tickets would have still occurred.

Think it's too expensive? Fine. Don't buy a ticket. Don't go.

Thinks it's fair enough? Fine. Over pay and have a good time.

Of course the mortality of choosing to price tickets at a high price is questionable, but is it surprising? If you were expecting an Oasis reunion to cost £30 a ticket then yam a bit thick, tbf!

You’re missing the point here Josh.

The issue is less what the price was but that it changed midway through the sale. Had they announced in advance tickets would cost £350 then that would be less scummy as people could make the decision in advance whether to pay it or not.

Drastically upping the price midway through the sale is a cynical and calculated measure designed to pray on people’s fear of missing out. People who have waited years to see their favourite band reform are suddenly faced with the prospect of having to fork out an extra £200 per ticket or miss out altogether.

It fucking stinks.

It does. But it's not surprising. 

I don't buy the fact people were panicked into purchasing. It's not as if a gun was held to their head or it's a matter of life and death. You'd have selected the seats, saw the price, entered the details and paid for tickets. There would have been ample opportunity to think 'this is too much, I'm not paying that'. 

I think Oasis have taken the piss, of course they have, but the demand is there and they can. Does it make it right? I'm not sure. But because you've overpaid and claim it's the only chance to see Oasis (they'll come back in another 10 years and do the same again) doesn't make it wrong, either. Pay or don't. Simple.

As someone who doesn’t really care much about music or seeing it live (you’re own words) I wouldn’t expect you to understand how strong a motivator FOMO can be, especially in a situation like this where people are desperate to grab tickets that may sell out at any second.

Like any scam there will be people who fall for it and pay the money and others who will not. I was presented with the opportunity to pay £355 for a standing ticket and declined on general principle. That the gigs sold out shows that others did pay it.

The point remains that people shouldn’t have been put in that position to begin with.

Maybe I'm being a dick and missing your point, but respectfully disagree. 

I know peopl will laugh and take the piss, but seeing Taylor Swift meant a huge deal to me. I had to get a ticket, but if I was faced with a ticket price anywhere over £250 I'd have closed the browser down. 

I may not be into music, but I'm passionate about Taylor Swift and that's the one actually I really wanted to see (and I'm lucky to have done so in excellent seats too). 

It's a simply concept . Can you afford the price at checkout? Yes. Go ahead book. If not, then don't. I really do not see it the complication. It's not as if people were having a gun held to their head. It's not even a con because the price point is clear, at time it purchase, and no one, absolutely no one is forcing them to buy.


But it wasn’t the price advertised, and that is the point. People go on expecting one price and are faced with a hugely marked up alternative and you give them a very limited window to make their choice.

As I keep saying, it’s a psychological con. You’re praying on people’s desire to see their favourite act and know that in the heat of the moment plenty will pay double or treble the amount for the exact same ticket you sold someone else five minutes ago.

The laws of supply and demand may well govern the principles of dynamic pricing. But there was absolutely no need, beyond greed, to introduce it in the first place.
Reply
My brother sums this up
"I saw em twice in the 90s and paid a tenner each time. That was a fiver too much"
Are
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)