Furlong
#21
(09-01-2024, 10:41 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(09-01-2024, 10:19 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(09-01-2024, 09:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Furlong as I said yesterday is the best full back in the league. The shite written on here about him and some of our other fullbacks has been ludicrous over the last few years. If you believed them, every goal we concede was ‘cuz (insert name) ball watching’ or some other parks football cliche.

I think he deserved the criticism.

The minute we brought in some competition in Pipa and now Holgate, he has stepped up a gear, responded and turned in consistently strong performances to become one of our most reliable players.

Fair play to the lad. Holgate's best route into the team might be as CB now.

Disrespectful if not actually offensive. You must be the sort of "fan" players don't want to play for FFS Sake! Describe for me the situation in which you wouldn't have a negative remark to make. If you can.

Offensive? Haha. It's literally why managers bring in other players to their squads. To generate competition. You know, to raise the levels. You wouldn't last 5 minutes in a dressing room!
Reply
#22
Offensive!? Come on now. Furlong has performed better when he has had competition. It may be coincidental but over the past year the improvement has been substantial. When he first came to use he was a liability, now he’s undroppable.
Reply
#23
(09-01-2024, 11:06 AM)Sliced Wrote: Offensive!? Come on now. Furlong has performed better when he has had competition. It may be coincidental but over the past year the improvement has been substantial. When he first came to use he was a liability, now he’s undroppable.

Can’t agree, anyone who played under some of the managers we’ve had like Bilic, Val and Bruce will always leave the defence vulnerable. Blaming our fullbacks for goals conceded has been a pastime of WBA fans for generations. The complete lack of decent coaching has been the reason we have struggled defensively over the years more than the ability of our players.
Reply
#24
(09-01-2024, 10:19 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(09-01-2024, 09:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Furlong as I said yesterday is the best full back in the league. The shite written on here about him and some of our other fullbacks has been ludicrous over the last few years. If you believed them, every goal we concede was ‘cuz (insert name) ball watching’ or some other parks football cliche.

I think he deserved the criticism.

The minute we brought in some competition in Pipa and now Holgate, he has stepped up a gear, responded and turned in consistently strong performances to become one of our most reliable players.

Fair play to the lad. Holgate's best route into the team might be as CB now.
That's completely bollocks.

Has regularly been underrated.
Reply
#25
(09-01-2024, 11:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-01-2024, 11:06 AM)Sliced Wrote: Offensive!? Come on now. Furlong has performed better when he has had competition. It may be coincidental but over the past year the improvement has been substantial. When he first came to use he was a liability, now he’s undroppable.

Can’t agree, anyone who played under some of the managers we’ve had like Bilic, Val and Bruce will always leave the defence vulnerable. Blaming our fullbacks for goals conceded has been a pastime of WBA fans for generations. The complete lack of decent coaching has been the reason we have struggled defensively over the years more than the ability of our players.

If he’d been amazing the entire time you wouldn’t have had to qualify it with “anyone who played under some of the managers we’ve had like Bilic, Val and Bruce will always leave the defence vulnerable”. 

Furlong has improved. Just because there are some posters who like to blame fullbacks for everything doesn’t make that statement untrue, and I’m not one of them, Whet he first came here Townsend was a much better player IMO, right now I wouldn’t take Townsend back in exchange for Furlong. 
Reply
#26
Furlong has been considerably better since Corberan has been here. He’s had decent spells before then but also dropped numerous stinkers, hence the criticism. He’s consistently 7+ out of 10 now and credit to him
Reply
#27
So Furlong is signing a new contract?

amazing start to the season if true, you really couldnt ask for much more !
Reply
#28
I think Furlong had very good spells under Val and Big Sam. I think he is a player who thrives when the coach can put a structure into the team and he has a clear role. Without this, his athleticism covers a lot of the flaws in this game, but the work CC has put in has turned him into a genuinely PL quality fullback, and one that is undoubtedly on form, the best in this division.

His positioning and all round game intelligence (when to run, when to release, when to take a man on) was always lacking but he is now so clear in his role he really has no weaknesses. He is fast, powerful, strong, good aerially, and is now showing a really good eye for a pass.

If the rumours of an impending extension are true it’s a huge coup, as even despite his age I think he’s a £7-10m player.
Reply
#29
(09-01-2024, 11:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-01-2024, 11:06 AM)Sliced Wrote: Offensive!? Come on now. Furlong has performed better when he has had competition. It may be coincidental but over the past year the improvement has been substantial. When he first came to use he was a liability, now he’s undroppable.

Can’t agree, anyone who played under some of the managers we’ve had like Bilic, Val and Bruce will always leave the defence vulnerable. Blaming our fullbacks for goals conceded has been a pastime of WBA fans for generations. The complete lack of decent coaching has been the reason we have struggled defensively over the years more than the ability of our players.

Or maybe it was just their fault, which it was, often. Most of the criticism has been just as deserved as the praise. Same with Townsend.
He’s been superb this season and was motm yesterday, that doesn’t mean he hasn’t been rubbish in the past.
I’ll agree re the coaching though, but a big part of that is Carlos’ demand for 2, competitive, players for each position
Reply
#30
(09-01-2024, 12:04 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(09-01-2024, 10:19 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(09-01-2024, 09:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Furlong as I said yesterday is the best full back in the league. The shite written on here about him and some of our other fullbacks has been ludicrous over the last few years. If you believed them, every goal we concede was ‘cuz (insert name) ball watching’ or some other parks football cliche.

I think he deserved the criticism.

The minute we brought in some competition in Pipa and now Holgate, he has stepped up a gear, responded and turned in consistently strong performances to become one of our most reliable players.

Fair play to the lad. Holgate's best route into the team might be as CB now.
That's completely bollocks.

Has regularly been underrated.

Well RSB, you wouldn't last 5 minutes in a dressing room either  Big Grin

The suggestion I read in Moore Than's post was that Furlong only picked up his form because there was competition. The kind of complete bollocks that we hear too much of from Baggies fans. "Damned with faint praise" is an expression that could have been invented for some of our fans.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)