Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(08-21-2024, 03:25 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Remember someone was asking an expert about Fernando Torres under-impressing at Chelsea and what he needed to do, where the ex-player said go back in a time machine as he's probably past his peak.
As Albion fans old enough to recall the Atkinson years will testify Regis was a beast in those early years. Despite a great career he was never as good as he was between 20-24 in those 77/78 to 81/82 seasons. Despite a great career at Cov, where he is seen as a legend too, he was never the standard he was with us.
That's the way it goes.
The likes of Leko and Harper never fulfilled their potential, but that happens to so many.
Regis and Cunningham are the sole reason i stayed a baggie while alot kf my school mates fugged off to the seal sanctuary . Big Cyrille and Laurie were just a joy to watch in their pomp you always expected something to happen,,and it usually did. Unfortunately injuries and the passage of time took its tolll laurie was never quite the same after breaking his leg at Newcastle and Cyrille had lost that explosive edge when he left us although still a very very good player.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
All were potentially good enough.
Combinations at differing levels for all of them of attitude, injuries, luck, ability to get playing time...
It's not a computer game, there isn't some secret stat behind each player saying how good they are, if they get through a Cat 1 academy, they are potentially good enough to play at the Championship at least. However, one thing that they need is exposure to first-team football, consistently and to learn and keep working when they get that breakthrough. The mantra I hear a lot is that you can't judge a player until they hit 100 competitive adult games, not many get to that early enough to develop, why quite often the ones that make it are the ones bought in for injury crisis and such, they get game time, hold their position down and stay, so often they were not the standouts in the youth teams.
Of the young players mentioned in this thread so far, and I am not going to repeat what I've said before, the one who was most unlucky and could complain about how we treated him as a club was Field, And a lot of that was down to Pardew and even Moore who preferred Harper since he was more athletic, but IMO, not as good a footballer. Bilic and Big Sam wanted him to play, but injuries stopped him, and he hadn't stepped up enough to cover for said injuries, it was best he moved on.
Edwards sort of burned his bridge under Covid when he broke club rules, and Big Sam was not impressed, Harper didn't apply himself, Leko didn't add anything to his game other than his pace and a couple of neat tricks.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
08-21-2024, 08:34 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-21-2024, 08:36 PM by Squid.)
(08-21-2024, 05:38 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Kyle Edwards is at Oxford
Not listed in the squad here:
https://www.oufc.co.uk/squad/62
Really sad as he was a genuine talent. That goal against Brentford was excellent.
IIRC, him and Dara went on loan to Exeter. Pretty sure at the time, Edwards was the one considered more likely to have a PL future.
I think unless you are superbly gifted, you have to have a lot of graft and patience to make it. More than a few footballers have had ups and downs in their career.
Also: I didn't mention Field because being a Championship first teamer is nothing to sniff at. Ditto the likes of Fitzwater and Kane Wilson, who also play first team football.
Going from being a bright hopeful to not even being in a lower league squad is more saddening.
Posts: 344
Threads: 47
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
In the formative years football is all that matters to the club and the youngsters. Education seems to be secondary and not just academic but social.
The American system of college sponsorship for sports men and women works. We need all our youngsters enrolled into some private/boarding school where they may have other opportunities as well as mix with some young people who are more likely to succeed and achieve in other areas. Controversial but firmly believe they would have a different mind set.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(08-21-2024, 09:13 PM)Geralous Wrote: In the formative years football is all that matters to the club and the youngsters. Education seems to be secondary and not just academic but social.
The American system of college sponsorship for sports men and women works. We need all our youngsters enrolled into some private/boarding school where they may have other opportunities as well as mix with some young people who are more likely to succeed and achieve in other areas. Controversial but firmly believe they would have a different mind set. It might well have got Saido away from that bunch of hangers on that used to sit waiting for him in his Range Rover wherever he went. That would have been a start.
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(08-21-2024, 09:13 PM)Geralous Wrote: In the formative years football is all that matters to the club and the youngsters. Education seems to be secondary and not just academic but social.
The American system of college sponsorship for sports men and women works. We need all our youngsters enrolled into some private/boarding school where they may have other opportunities as well as mix with some young people who are more likely to succeed and achieve in other areas. Controversial but firmly believe they would have a different mind set.
I agree wholeheartedly with this. I think secondary and Further & Higher Ed pathways alongside football are crucial. If they don't make League football , there's a part-time option alongside a decent career in another sector. If they do, they could be switched on enough to stay out of the Saido or Hughsie lane. A strong Academic education is crucial to personal development and needs to fit in firmly with the social. None of this, "why should I learn that" bollocks. It might be military like, but I believe that young folk need tight routine, or they do get bored and go off the rails. Especially when they first join Club Academies.
I'd also be interested to learn of what an Academy player learns of the Club, it's history, ethos and that of the local area. They need grounding in this IMO. Respect the people who will be supporting them if they 'make it'. Not all players have family/mates who are Albion fans or are themselves local.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
I do not know what the club do now, but the youngsters used to do day release at a local college, Sandwell, many years
ago. I read somewhere that Bayern Munich apprentices/ trainees are sent to local colleges to study part-time and if they fail their courses they are thrown out of the club.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
The education is compulsory and partly in-house.
Hence why the Foundation was turfed out the Tom Silk building a few years back.
It fascinates me with people like Heggen and Jonas Olsson that it is normal in some countries for footballers to also be middle class academics. When that happens over here is it an exception rather than a norm.
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(08-22-2024, 07:47 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The education is compulsory and partly in-house.
Hence why the Foundation was turfed out the Tom Silk building a few years back.
It fascinates me with people like Heggen and Jonas Olsson that it is normal in some countries for footballers to also be middle class academics. When that happens over here is it an exception rather than a norm.
I used to work at Sandwell Academy and the Academy Players (back then I recall the likes of Sawyers and Brown etc.) did BTEc's and other courses. They also did a course on the Laws of the game which was taught by a referee. Once a week they'd share our 'Learning Hub' and we'd be on the other side behind screens.
Posts: 25
Threads: 1
Joined: Dec 2019
Reputation:
0
Leko has had 2 bad ACL injuries and is still in rehab.Durability is often overlooked as a criteria in assessing players., but no player in the world has ever had reve reviews from the treatment table
|