Where did it go wrong for Harper, Edwards and Leko?
#21
(08-21-2024, 03:43 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Does it need to be analysed, they just weren't good enough.

I'm not saying the issues discussed aren't correct, relevant or didn't play its part, but the ultimate fact is they were good enough. Simple as that.

If you have something more interesting to discuss feel free.
Reply
#22
(08-21-2024, 01:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-21-2024, 12:59 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: NOt the same thing, but Nathan Ferguson is now without a club. Despite everything that happened at the end, I really feel for him.

His agent encouraged him to take the fast money and he ended up going against the advice that was best for him. 

Noone knows what would have happened had he not played injured that night against Cardiff and had he not had the operation we so strongly advised against, but given how his career seems to be going he may well have done the right thing taking the easy money.

Shame the FA bottled it on the compensation we were awarded.

I'd take him back here... pay as you play contract, see if the team can't get him back to some semblance of fitness. If nothing else, he can keep Dike company.

Ferguson has played 8 minutes of first team football since January 2020. The lad is well and truly broken.

(08-21-2024, 12:39 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Harper was all about attitude… big contract went to his head.

Leko and Edwards suffered from injuries, lack of regular game time and being used in multiple positions. Leko was also one of those players that had bags of pace and tricks so looked good in younger age groups, but zero intelligence on the field and was very soon found out.

Fully agree about Harper. As soon as he got that first big contract he just thought he’d made it and gave up. I’m amazed he’s even still in the league. Surely after Burton he’ll be down to the Conference.

I can imagine Leko looking fantastic as a 16 year old against players of that age. But he had no football brain, like Olly Burke, and just never developed from that age.
Reply
#23
Nathan Ferguson, George Thorne, Izzy Brown, Saido….

Do we curse kids who leave us under a cloud or something?
Reply
#24
(08-21-2024, 04:03 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-21-2024, 03:43 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Does it need to be analysed, they just weren't good enough.

I'm not saying the issues discussed aren't correct, relevant or didn't play its part, but the ultimate fact is they were good enough. Simple as that.

If you have something more interesting to discuss feel free.

I didn't mean my post to come across as arsey or to shoot down those offering reasons, apologies if it's come across that way.
Reply
#25
Kyle Edwards is at Oxford
Reply
#26
Harper and Leko were never any good, in my opinion. Neither ever looked good enough at u21 level, let alone a higher standard. Yes, they had an occasional good game between them in the first team, but that only flattered to deceive.

Obviously not the opinion of the club at the time though. The club seemed to hold great store by them.

I remember one of Leko's early games for the reserves, the first at the Hawthorns that season. Scouts from loads of other clubs came to look at him, or so the general gossip was on the night, and they were all sat in the East Stand. Almost as many as there were supporters in the Halfords! Don't think any of them bothered coming again.

Harper had a loan spell at Blackburn under Mowbray and never looked like he had improved one jot when he came back.

Edwards looked like he might have something about him initially but never progressed beyond that early impression.
Reply
#27
(08-21-2024, 04:03 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-21-2024, 03:43 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Does it need to be analysed, they just weren't good enough.

I'm not saying the issues discussed aren't correct, relevant or didn't play its part, but the ultimate fact is they were good enough. Simple as that.

If you have something more interesting to discuss feel free.
Exactly, the OP is What went wrong? The actual reasons have probably been mentioned although we'll never know 100%. The not good enough is too vague as clearly, for a while, they were plenty good enough. It is more a matter of character IMO. Leko had all the skill and tricks required, unfortunately he appeared to lack awareness in what is a team game. Edwards is a real shame as he was/maybe is Albion through and through. In this case I genuinely believe he may be the one that over-achieved early on. Harper is the big puzzle as he appeared a natural leader, I fear having his first big money deal derailed his ambition and that takes some coming back from. I think Spandau called it when he listed the many factors that all need to be in line.
Reply
#28
It'll be interesting to see where Louie Barry ends up.
Reply
#29
(08-21-2024, 04:56 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(08-21-2024, 01:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-21-2024, 12:59 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: NOt the same thing, but Nathan Ferguson is now without a club. Despite everything that happened at the end, I really feel for him.

His agent encouraged him to take the fast money and he ended up going against the advice that was best for him. 

Noone knows what would have happened had he not played injured that night against Cardiff and had he not had the operation we so strongly advised against, but given how his career seems to be going he may well have done the right thing taking the easy money.

Shame the FA bottled it on the compensation we were awarded.

I'd take him back here... pay as you play contract, see if the team can't get him back to some semblance of fitness. If nothing else, he can keep Dike company.

Ferguson has played 8 minutes of first team football since January 2020. The lad is well and truly broken.

(08-21-2024, 12:39 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Harper was all about attitude… big contract went to his head.

Leko and Edwards suffered from injuries, lack of regular game time and being used in multiple positions. Leko was also one of those players that had bags of pace and tricks so looked good in younger age groups, but zero intelligence on the field and was very soon found out.

Fully agree about Harper. As soon as he got that first big contract he just thought he’d made it and gave up. I’m amazed he’s even still in the league. Surely after Burton he’ll be down to the Conference.

I can imagine Leko looking fantastic as a 16 year old against players of that age. But he had no football brain, like Olly Burke, and just never developed from that age.

Oliver Burk has the best footballing agent in the world. FACT
Reply
#30
(08-21-2024, 05:55 PM)Albionmad Wrote: It'll be interesting to see where Louie Barry ends up.

Got friends who are Stockport fans who rate him really highly. That seems to have been the only successful loan spell he has had though. There’s no doubt he’ll have a decent league career but I imagine the nearest he’ll come to Barcelona again is a stag do with his mates.

(08-21-2024, 06:04 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(08-21-2024, 04:56 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(08-21-2024, 01:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-21-2024, 12:59 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: NOt the same thing, but Nathan Ferguson is now without a club. Despite everything that happened at the end, I really feel for him.

His agent encouraged him to take the fast money and he ended up going against the advice that was best for him. 

Noone knows what would have happened had he not played injured that night against Cardiff and had he not had the operation we so strongly advised against, but given how his career seems to be going he may well have done the right thing taking the easy money.

Shame the FA bottled it on the compensation we were awarded.

I'd take him back here... pay as you play contract, see if the team can't get him back to some semblance of fitness. If nothing else, he can keep Dike company.

Ferguson has played 8 minutes of first team football since January 2020. The lad is well and truly broken.

(08-21-2024, 12:39 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Harper was all about attitude… big contract went to his head.

Leko and Edwards suffered from injuries, lack of regular game time and being used in multiple positions. Leko was also one of those players that had bags of pace and tricks so looked good in younger age groups, but zero intelligence on the field and was very soon found out.

Fully agree about Harper. As soon as he got that first big contract he just thought he’d made it and gave up. I’m amazed he’s even still in the league. Surely after Burton he’ll be down to the Conference.

I can imagine Leko looking fantastic as a 16 year old against players of that age. But he had no football brain, like Olly Burke, and just never developed from that age.

Oliver Burk has the best footballing agent in the world. FACT

Players like Burke and Ravel Morrison keep getting contracts because some managers think that they may be the one to get the best from this player. I think it shows how thick certain managers are that they can’t see what your average fan can in that a lad like Burke has no football brain and you can’t train that into a player.

As Leko has shown, raw talent can take you so far in the game but to progress in the top two divisions you need so much more.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: