Great player, rubbish manager
#31
Sol Campbell
Mark Hughes
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#32
(08-12-2024, 07:16 AM)MrBater Wrote: I've always had a theory that great players rarely make good managers. Sure there's the outliers like Sir bobby, but in the main great player = crap manager.

I can't think of many great players that have made great managers.

Ancelotti is the first name that comes to mind, but struggling to think of others. Maybe Zidane?
Reply
#33
(08-12-2024, 09:34 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 07:16 AM)MrBater Wrote: I've always had a theory that great players rarely make good managers. Sure there's the outliers like Sir bobby, but in the main great player = crap manager.

I can't think of many great players that have made great managers.

Ancelotti is the first name that comes to mind, but struggling to think of others. Maybe Zidane?

Pep probably deserves a mention!
Reply
#34
(08-12-2024, 09:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 03:38 AM)Slowpoke Gonzalez Wrote:
(08-11-2024, 10:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Billy Wright. From the dark side but undoubtedly one of England's finest players, managed Arsenal into nowhereland. Bryan Robson, most influential player I've ever seen, seemed to have little if any idea. Hoddle (I wasn't a fan, the poncey flat pitch bully), terrible manager. And of course, Steve Bruce, great player but a lazy destructive influence as manager.

Hoddle had enough player testimonies to suggest that he was a good manager at a time. He was lauded for his coaching work at least.

Bruce was past it by the time he got to us, but he wasn't always a terrible manager. He'd been successful at a few different clubs. 

These two weren't out of their depth in the way that some of the other names on here were.

Bruce had gone by the time he got to us, but 4 promotions from the second tier suggests a successful past as a manager. 

The Great Escape confirms for a period, Robbo was a successful manager.

I'm not sure amassing 34 points, at the time the fewest total of points needed to avoid relegation (Is this still the case?) and surviving because other teams bottled their chance to stay up should be seen as a success. 

It was a fantastic occasion, and I'll never forget that day and how it unfolded, but for the last hand full of games, where we actually looked a decent outfit, it was an abysmal season. The following season and then the beginning of the 2006/7 season were equally abysmal.
Reply
#35
The season after the great escape was weird. Until February we looked safe and sound, Robson went to a coaching seminar, one I have seen since all about the use of the sole striker as Jose Mourinho was doing with Drogba at Chelsea.

Robson decided he wanted to emulated it, and did so, with Kevin Campbell who age had finally caught up with.

We then just slept until we got relegated, Robson confused why his new idea wasn't working, after all, at the seminar they said it worked.
Reply
#36
(08-12-2024, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The season after the great escape was weird. Until February we looked safe and sound, Robson went to a coaching seminar, one I have seen since all about the use of the sole striker as Jose Mourinho was doing with Drogba at Chelsea.

Robson decided he wanted to emulated it, and did so, with Kevin Campbell who age had finally caught up with.

We then just slept until we got relegated, Robson confused why his new idea wasn't working, after all, at the seminar they said it worked.

He also rested key players at the wrong time.

People forget that we were bottom and adrift at Christmas. You have to give Robson credit for that. It doesn't make him a managerial legend, but it means he can't be categorised as a good player who was a shit manager in my view. He said the Great Escape was his finest achievement in football, FFS.
Reply
#37
Before that seminar he'd found a way and style that worked for us. I don't think he was good, but he wasn't total shit, just, by his own admission, had little tactical awareness so relied on players doing things well themselves. Players liked him, other than the ones he'd randomly bomb to the reserves (Koumas).

Club shouldn't have tried to improve his weaknesses, his brain couldn't take it.
Reply
#38
(08-12-2024, 10:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Before that seminar he'd found a way and style that worked for us. I don't think he was good, but he wasn't total shit, just, by his own admission, had little tactical awareness so relied on players doing things well themselves. Players liked him, other than the ones he'd randomly bomb to the reserves (Koumas).

Club shouldn't have tried to improve his weaknesses, his brain couldn't take it.

Players liked him when he took them to Florida for a "Training Camp". How times have changed, the modern pro would be horrified by this  Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#39
(08-12-2024, 10:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 10:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Before that seminar he'd found a way and style that worked for us. I don't think he was good, but he wasn't total shit, just, by his own admission, had little tactical awareness so relied on players doing things well themselves. Players liked him, other than the ones he'd randomly bomb to the reserves (Koumas).

Club shouldn't have tried to improve his weaknesses, his brain couldn't take it.

Players liked him when he took them to Florida for a "Training Camp". How times have changed, the modern pro would be horrified by this  Big Grin Big Grin

Oh yes, proper old school management, played a game with all our players hungover FFS.
Reply
#40
(08-12-2024, 09:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 03:38 AM)Slowpoke Gonzalez Wrote:
(08-11-2024, 10:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Billy Wright. From the dark side but undoubtedly one of England's finest players, managed Arsenal into nowhereland. Bryan Robson, most influential player I've ever seen, seemed to have little if any idea. Hoddle (I wasn't a fan, the poncey flat pitch bully), terrible manager. And of course, Steve Bruce, great player but a lazy destructive influence as manager.

Hoddle had enough player testimonies to suggest that he was a good manager at a time. He was lauded for his coaching work at least.

Bruce was past it by the time he got to us, but he wasn't always a terrible manager. He'd been successful at a few different clubs. 

These two weren't out of their depth in the way that some of the other names on here were.

Bruce had gone by the time he got to us, but 4 promotions from the second tier suggests a successful past as a manager. 

The Great Escape confirms for a period, Robbo was a successful manager.

The Great Escape confirms nothing of the sort. Robbo took us to the bottom of the table and a freak set of results kept us up. Awful manager (world class player though)
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)