John Swift
#1
Need a big season from the fella.

Has all the ability to be one of the best players in the league and our star man. 

I think (and definitely hope) that this is the season he shows it.
Reply
#2
He is still with us for a very good reason
Reply
#3
I'd have thought he'd be one we'd be keen to get a fee for and off the wage bill. He's a talented player but I think he's been rather underwhelming in his two years at the club so far. If he is to stay at the club you'd hope that he'll be trying to put himself in the shop window for one last good contract next summer.
Reply
#4
(08-09-2024, 01:09 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I'd have thought he'd be one we'd be keen to get a fee for and off the wage bill. He's a talented player but I think he's been rather underwhelming in his two years at the club so far. If he is to stay at the club you'd hope that he'll be trying to put himself in the shop window for one last good contract next summer.

I agree he’s not lived up to the hype since arriving. But I’ve seen in flashes why he’s been recognised as one of this league best creative players. We need that consistently this season. 

I’ve been more disappointed in Jed’s overall contribution of the two. Jed doesn’t lack effort but I’ve not really seen any quality from him that made him arrive, like Swift, as one of the best players in this league. 

I also think it’s fair to compare considering both came in on ‘frees’, both came in at the same time and both came in with reputations of top Championship players.
Reply
#5
(08-09-2024, 01:09 PM)Ournextstriker Wrote: He is still with us for a very good reason

Is it because Diangana is injured?
Reply
#6
(08-09-2024, 01:16 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-09-2024, 01:09 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I'd have thought he'd be one we'd be keen to get a fee for and off the wage bill. He's a talented player but I think he's been rather underwhelming in his two years at the club so far. If he is to stay at the club you'd hope that he'll be trying to put himself in the shop window for one last good contract next summer.

I agree he’s not lived up to the hype since arriving. But I’ve seen in flashes why he’s been recognised as one of this league best creative players. We need that consistently this season. 

I’ve been more disappointed in Jed’s overall contribution of the two. Jed doesn’t lack effort but I’ve not really seen any quality from him that made him arrive, like Swift, as one of the best players in this league. 

I also think it’s fair to compare considering both came in on ‘frees’, both came in at the same time and both came in with reputations of top Championship players.

You make some very fair points there. It's a shame that Swift got his injury when he did last season as he seemed to be finally starting to show what he is capable of and chipping in with a good few goals.
Reply
#7
(08-09-2024, 01:16 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-09-2024, 01:09 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I'd have thought he'd be one we'd be keen to get a fee for and off the wage bill. He's a talented player but I think he's been rather underwhelming in his two years at the club so far. If he is to stay at the club you'd hope that he'll be trying to put himself in the shop window for one last good contract next summer.

I agree he’s not lived up to the hype since arriving. But I’ve seen in flashes why he’s been recognised as one of this league best creative players. We need that consistently this season. 

I’ve been more disappointed in Jed’s overall contribution of the two. Jed doesn’t lack effort but I’ve not really seen any quality from him that made him arrive, like Swift, as one of the best players in this league. 

I also think it’s fair to compare considering both came in on ‘frees’, both came in at the same time and both came in with reputations of top Championship players.

Fair points Dumbo.

I think we’d have seen far more from both had we had a fit Dike, or a more clinical BTA.

Both however have always had spells where they’ve been passengers in games, if either of them had been more consistent they’d have more than 5 mins of PL football between them.
Reply
#8
Out of contract in the summer, and we can't afford to keep him. He will be 29. Expect a big season from him as he chases his final big contract.
Reply
#9
I don’t think you can say Wallace has been a passenger in games. He’s been played in several different positions last season which will inevitably lead to him having fluctuating form. However at no time that I can remember has he been a passenger.
Reply
#10
Swift is one of 2 at most players in our squad who can change a game in the blink of an eye! 

**I can’t comment on the new guys**

His ability to open up teams is excellent, we just need more of him and him playing in the final third of the pitch. On too many occasions since he’s been here, he’s ’broke the lines’ or turned his man on the half way line or even deeper into our own half.  

If we can get him to do it 25-30 yards out, he’d be some player to have in the side. 

Morrison was a master at it, without the technical ability Swift has! Morrison was some player but was effective as he did most his work 30 yards out or at least drove the ball so he was 25-30 yards out. 

Swift could be very good this season. Let’s hope he is.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)