Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(08-06-2024, 08:49 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:24 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:18 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Cole is certainly not "a moneybag" recruitment, look at his age. You could also say the same about
Wildsmith.
There is of course one great "outlier" to the moneyball approach, name him?
Cole and Wildsmith are very much ‘moneyball’ recruitment though…..
Sorry spelling error there!
Why are they "moneyball" recruitment?
Brighton and Brentford mainly sign young players who they believe will improve. Some of these they
sell on and then they re-invest in young players. We did this with BTA, but mainly we buy experienced
players. I would classify young players as early 20s. Cole is 29, he might improve but that is not likely
his re-sale value is limited
Moneyball is about recruiting statistical outliers overlooked by others for low outlay. Nothing to do with age or potential future profit. It has become a catch all phrase for sensible recruitment based on those things, hence your misapprehension.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
I'd recommend watching the Moneyball film with Brad Pitt, it is very good.
Posts: 766
Threads: 130
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
6
08-06-2024, 09:02 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-06-2024, 09:02 AM by RonnieWallwork.)
(08-06-2024, 08:49 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:24 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:18 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Cole is certainly not "a moneybag" recruitment, look at his age. You could also say the same about
Wildsmith.
There is of course one great "outlier" to the moneyball approach, name him?
Cole and Wildsmith are very much ‘moneyball’ recruitment though…..
Sorry spelling error there!
Why are they "moneyball" recruitment?
Brighton and Brentford mainly sign young players who they believe will improve. Some of these they
sell on and then they re-invest in young players. We did this with BTA, but mainly we buy experienced
players. I would classify young players as early 20s. Cole is 29, he might improve but that is not likely
his re-sale value is limited
Value v statistical output
Moneyball recruitment isn’t just about age. If they’re young even better. It’s what they’re good at and what they’re not so great at and knowing in advance. Filling your team with exactly what you need in terms of tactics and patterns of play.
Sometimes it’s a gamble as if it was that easy, everyone would do it. But it’s been proven in many many sports to be successful.
(08-06-2024, 08:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:49 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:24 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:18 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Cole is certainly not "a moneybag" recruitment, look at his age. You could also say the same about
Wildsmith.
There is of course one great "outlier" to the moneyball approach, name him?
Cole and Wildsmith are very much ‘moneyball’ recruitment though…..
Sorry spelling error there!
Why are they "moneyball" recruitment?
Brighton and Brentford mainly sign young players who they believe will improve. Some of these they
sell on and then they re-invest in young players. We did this with BTA, but mainly we buy experienced
players. I would classify young players as early 20s. Cole is 29, he might improve but that is not likely
his re-sale value is limited
Moneyball is about recruiting statistical outliers overlooked by others for low outlay. Nothing to do with age or potential future profit. It has become a catch all phrase for sensible recruitment based on those things, hence your misapprehension.
+1
Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
Might be wrong, but in baseball they only really have the one level to scout out.... So it's probably easier to assess players like it.
Comparing a great moneyballer / (I prefer the moneybag typo from earlier!) from one league to another league is a damn lot harder to do.
Here's hoping it works.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(08-06-2024, 08:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:49 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:24 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:18 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Cole is certainly not "a moneybag" recruitment, look at his age. You could also say the same about
Wildsmith.
There is of course one great "outlier" to the moneyball approach, name him?
Cole and Wildsmith are very much ‘moneyball’ recruitment though…..
Sorry spelling error there!
Why are they "moneyball" recruitment?
Brighton and Brentford mainly sign young players who they believe will improve. Some of these they
sell on and then they re-invest in young players. We did this with BTA, but mainly we buy experienced
players. I would classify young players as early 20s. Cole is 29, he might improve but that is not likely
his re-sale value is limited
Moneyball is about recruiting statistical outliers overlooked by others for low outlay. Nothing to do with age or potential future profit. It has become a catch all phrase for sensible recruitment based on those things, hence your misapprehension.
We will agree to disagree. In North American team sport there is not really a transfer market, but there is a profit motive. When moneybag has been applied in a football context it is used to both improve recruitment and generate income from transfers. Transfer income is important because it enables you to re-invest in better players leading to a better team. The most noted exponents of this approach are Brighton and Brentford. Since the Pulis era we have not considered re-sale value, you can decide who has been the most successful team in recent years and which approach has worked best.
Posts: 2,344
Threads: 8
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
I've read Moneyball and some of Bill James's sabermetrics books as well as watching the film obsessively. The main difficulty for football as upposed to baseball is that they worked out pretty early that getting a player to first base was the best metric for getting runs/wins - plus their traditional scouting method (as alluded to in the film) was based around some weird stuff indeed (jawline, bat sound and how attractive their Mrs is). Football is a lot harder to map into a set of statistics and scouting is a lot more nuanced already. It would be interesting to find out what the Albion Analysis lads thought of the subject.
In short it's about recruiting undervalued players that are good enough for what you need. If you've done your job properly resale should look after itself.
Posts: 766
Threads: 130
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
6
(08-06-2024, 10:02 AM)Mr vertical Wrote: I've read Moneyball and some of Bill James's sabermetrics books as well as watching the film obsessively. The main difficulty for football as upposed to baseball is that they worked out pretty early that getting a player to first base was the best metric for getting runs/wins - plus their traditional scouting method (as alluded to in the film) was based around some weird stuff indeed (jawline, bat sound and how attractive their Mrs is). Football is a lot harder to map into a set of statistics and scouting is a lot more nuanced already. It would be interesting to find out what the Albion Analysis lads thought of the subject.
In short it's about recruiting undervalued players that are good enough for what you need. If you've done your job properly resale should look after itself.
+1 see my comments above
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(08-06-2024, 10:02 AM)Mr vertical Wrote: I've read Moneyball and some of Bill James's sabermetrics books as well as watching the film obsessively. The main difficulty for football as upposed to baseball is that they worked out pretty early that getting a player to first base was the best metric for getting runs/wins - plus their traditional scouting method (as alluded to in the film) was based around some weird stuff indeed (jawline, bat sound and how attractive their Mrs is). Football is a lot harder to map into a set of statistics and scouting is a lot more nuanced already. It would be interesting to find out what the Albion Analysis lads thought of the subject.
In short it's about recruiting undervalued players that are good enough for what you need. If you've done your job properly resale should look after itself.
I imagine football metrics will be things like ground covered, average position maps, passing profile etc. I imagine CC has a very clear idea what each player position will be able to achieve in this metrics.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
08-06-2024, 10:16 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-06-2024, 10:16 AM by SW4Baggie.)
(08-06-2024, 09:09 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:49 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:24 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: (08-06-2024, 08:18 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Cole is certainly not "a moneybag" recruitment, look at his age. You could also say the same about
Wildsmith.
There is of course one great "outlier" to the moneyball approach, name him?
Cole and Wildsmith are very much ‘moneyball’ recruitment though…..
Sorry spelling error there!
Why are they "moneyball" recruitment?
Brighton and Brentford mainly sign young players who they believe will improve. Some of these they
sell on and then they re-invest in young players. We did this with BTA, but mainly we buy experienced
players. I would classify young players as early 20s. Cole is 29, he might improve but that is not likely
his re-sale value is limited
Moneyball is about recruiting statistical outliers overlooked by others for low outlay. Nothing to do with age or potential future profit. It has become a catch all phrase for sensible recruitment based on those things, hence your misapprehension.
We will agree to disagree. In North American team sport there is not really a transfer market, but there is a profit motive. When moneybag has been applied in a football context it is used to both improve recruitment and generate income from transfers. Transfer income is important because it enables you to re-invest in better players leading to a better team. The most noted exponents of this approach are Brighton and Brentford. Since the Pulis era we have not considered re-sale value, you can decide who has been the most successful team in recent years and which approach has worked best.
Also worth adding younger players tend to cost more these days, and money isn't a luxury we can afford. We can prioritise those that we see the greatest return on further down the line, but we can't go out and buy 5-6 players for decent fees in the hope we can develop them. We need to patch up the squad with cheaper players that we believe have been overlooked - hence Devante Cole.
Under Ashworth we were pioneers when it came to scouting, and it's painful to see what he was able to do at BHA with greater freedom and investment.
We are not doing anything that half the Championship aren't already doing, but if we can do it better we can start to look forward to recruitment again. I've been scathing of our lazy recruitment for years, and all the things we're now doing, moving older players out, squeezing fees where we can and investing in players with headroom to grow should have been done when we appointed Val, but instead we spent heavily on short term wages and loans in the hope experience would get us over the line. Doing it once is fine, but to do it for 3 successive seasons is crazy.
|