WTF - a transfer ban?
#41
(08-05-2024, 08:09 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-05-2024, 07:55 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Hi all, a Bristol City fan in peace here.

I hope Weimann was good for you on loan here- great model pro. TGH scored a wonder goal v Middlesbrough and age is on his side..victim of his versatility in some ways I wonder  if he could play 10.

I'm a bit of an FFP nerd and can answer qs on your position but on Bristol  City we are quite okay thanks, by 2021 we were running into clear issues.

I won't blame Covid as we were spending too much. I also appreciate that going from Year 2 Parachutes and EFL cash to Solidarity Payments and EFL Cash can represent a huge swing.

We were..
2019-20...-£10m
2020-21..-£38m
Averaged-£24m

These wwre averaged for Covid and are the headline figure, before legitimate Covid add-backs and the standard P&S add-backs (Youth, Depreciation etc). My best guess for annual Add-backs for WBA is around £7m a year.

2021-22 -£28.5m
2022-23 -£22m

However we were proactively cutting the wage bill and our revenue was on the rise again. We have a strong Commercial off pitch Revenue both on Matchdays and not on Matchdays. The Amortisation bill was falling as well.

2022-23 included a) The Semenyo sale and b) A 13th month of costs. The latter wing be repeated as we moved our Reporting Period from May to June.

2023-24, perhaps saw further reductions minus Kalas, DaSilva among others. Wells renewed on lesser terms in December 2022 which perhaps spread his Amortisation costs too.. had 6 months less, it became 2.5 years. Scott went for £20-25m last year.

By my calculations we were narrowly inside to 2023 given the Semenyo otherwise we fail by millons, and the Scott sale gsve strong breathing space to 2024 and beyond.

Welcome

Unfortunately, the board member you need to answer this has been banned. Not sure who is in charge of the Finance for Dummies book now.

Thank you.

He got banned did he? What I would say is that the media have done a poor job in covering the evolution of the Rules at this level. To say the least.

The 18 month thing that Dorsett reported and I believe we may have been under something similar from Spring 2022 e.g. if not sooner, that was part of measured voted in by Clubs which I'll explain in my next Post. National and Local media have done a piss poor job with it, but Patel does seem a sensible and proactive owner for one.
Reply
#42
Nice one BCiP and welcome  Cool .
Reply
#43
Forget PL relegation a second that's another issue the two Leagues need to fix. See the Leicester issue for that...they need an Independent Body to cover both Leagues and perhaps ideally the EFL Regs in the PL.

*Takes a deep breath*

*''T' is the present year. Clubs are always in 'T'.
*The Assessment on March 1st is 2 years actual plus the present Year Forecast.
*If a club lose in 3 Years post Allowables up to 'T' in excess of £15m but less than £39m, then they must submit to the League by 31st March their FFP Forecast for T+1 and T+2.

That has been in play since 2016 btw.

Where it changes is that the EFL now as voted for by Owners btw, can intervene early to work with the Club to try and halt a breach before it happens. Or if the club don't want to play ball they don't want to play ball they can set a Budget or a limit on Incomings.

There is a further bit which was 2022 I think whereby the Clubs voted to outsource certain powers. The CFRU are the Club Financial Reporting Unit, who have lots of Financial Info and powers- they can propose Settlements, work with the League and are Independent more Independent anyway.

Then there is the CFRP- Club Financial Reporting Panel- who adjudicate on such disputes between League and Club. Again independent and while this sounds mutual the Business Plan can come with obligations attached too..Reading post a fail had to do X by March 1st or they would get the suspended -6 as indeed they did. I suspect had we not sold Semenyo we may have got a deduction, maybe even Stoke and Souttar. The Reading one was an Agreed Decision in Autumn 2021 with -6 then plus the suspended-6 based on the Business Plan and compliance at all times otherwise the League legitimately could've pushed for at least -12 at the Hearing.

However failing a Business Plan doesn't necessarily inhibit a club or offset from the consequences of failing FFP itself which can only be known post June 30th.
Reply
#44
BCIP, does Roland’s Mrs know?

Which underground lair does he keep you in?
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#45
(08-05-2024, 08:41 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Forget PL relegation a second that's another issue the two Leagues  need to fix. See the Leicester issue for that...they need an Independent Body to cover both Leagues and perhaps ideally the EFL Regs in the PL.

*Takes a deep breath*

*''T' is the present year. Clubs are always in 'T'.
*The Assessment on March 1st is 2 years actual plus the present Year Forecast.
*If a club lose in 3 Years post Allowables up to 'T' in excess of £15m but less than £39m, then they must submit to the League by 31st March their FFP Forecast for T+1 and T+2.

That has been in play since 2016 btw.

Where it changes is that the EFL now as voted for by Owners btw, can intervene early to work with the Club to try and halt a breach before it happens. Or if the club don't want to play ball they don't want to play ball they can set a Budget or a limit on Incomings.

There is a further bit which was 2022 I think whereby the Clubs voted to outsource certain powers. The CFRU are the Club Financial Reporting Unit, who have lots of Financial Info and powers- they can propose Settlements, work with the League and are Independent more Independent anyway.

Then there is the CFRP- Club Financial Reporting Panel- who adjudicate on such disputes between League and Club. Again independent and while this sounds mutual the Business Plan can come with obligations attached too..Reading post a fail had to do X by March 1st or they would get the suspended -6 as indeed they did. I suspect had we not sold Semenyo we may have got a deduction, maybe even Stoke and Souttar. The Reading one was an Agreed Decision in Autumn 2021 with -6 then plus the suspended-6 based on the Business Plan and compliance at all times otherwise the League legitimately could've pushed for at least -12 at the Hearing.

However failing a Business Plan doesn't necessarily inhibit a club or offset from the consequences of failing FFP itself which can only be known post June 30th.

Sheesh thats complicated for a monday morning. I'll re-read it on Wednesday.
Reply
#46
Welcome BCIP
Up the Gas!
Reply
#47
BCIP at last, we have been waiting.
Welcome.
Reply
#48
Gert lush
Reply
#49
What are the chances BCIP starts off sensibly enough and by Wednesday he's regaling us with what he's cooking, where he's been shopping, how far he has walked? Come Friday there'll be tales of sexual exploits, demands to see financial certificates before inevitably offering someone out by Saturday.
Reply
#50
Nope. Not at all.

I mainly came to offer an alternate take as to whether Bristol City in FFP trouble. We were, now it feels unlikely. Steve Lansdown along with Steve Gibson was pro the FFP push in 2019, they were like-minded and allies- is very unlikely a Club owned by either would flout FFP. Certainly not wilfully or recklessly.

EFL Meetings in Spring 2019 about Aston Villa, Derby and Sheffield Wednesday pertaining to the Stadium Transactions.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: