Underrated X1 and subs since 2000
#11
Thought Robert Koren was underrated.
Reply
#12
(08-05-2024, 03:26 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Thought Robert Koren was underrated.

Good shout.

Immaculate player, one who was always worth watching.
Reply
#13
No ones gonna like this, but James McClean was massively underrated when with us
Reply
#14
Felipe Teixeira too, so talented.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#15
Kuszczak- Hoult's understudy in that first season, but he was his superior at that point.

(08-05-2024, 03:26 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Thought Robert Koren was underrated.

The type of guy who'd be your mum's favourite player.
Reply
#16
(08-05-2024, 03:50 PM)Sliced Wrote: No ones gonna like this, but James McClean was massively underrated when with us

Nope. Four goals in 99 appearances for an attacking midfielder. Woeful stats, woeful player and also a walking giver of costly free kicks.

People forget how bad he was because he always "worked arrrd", but he was nowhere near good enough and players like that are the reason we slid inexorably towards relegation.
Reply
#17
James McClean wasn’t an attacking midfielder and playedpretty much every game the three seasons where we finished mid table before the slide. He wasn’t the best attacker but his contribution was derided because of his lack of goals/assists, yet when anyone else came in they would inevitably be worse, then McClean would come back.

I would say that the managers were the reason we got relegated, not the players. That relegation would never have happened if it weren’t for Pulis wanting a payoff (allegedly) and Pardew being terrible.
Reply
#18
Some interesting choices in that OP Lurker.
Reply
#19
Kuzsack

Lyttle
Tony Butler
Hegazi
Townsend

Teixeira
Gardner
Livermore
McClean

Bednar
Berahino
Reply
#20
(08-05-2024, 04:39 PM)Sliced Wrote: James McClean wasn’t an attacking midfielder and playedpretty much every game the three seasons where we finished mid table before the slide. He wasn’t the best attacker but his contribution was derided because of his lack of goals/assists, yet when anyone else came in they would inevitably be worse, then McClean would come back.

I would say that the managers were the reason we got relegated, not the players. That relegation would never have happened if it weren’t for Pulis wanting a payoff (allegedly) and Pardew being terrible.

I'll happily blame Pardew and Pulis, but our recruitment was largely very poor and emblematic of our decline and I include McClean in that. Just because we didn't have anyone better in that position doesn't mean he was good enough for us in the PL.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: