Lepkowski article
#11
(08-01-2024, 09:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I know why we have to do it, and for now it’s a solution, it’s it exactly difficult to understand. However in the long term any Championship club thinking they can become both competitive and self sufficient at best is kidding themselves in the current football environment. How many clubs are self sufficient/break even or make a profit in the Championship? How long can the current anti-competitive FFP rules be adhered to before being challenged by clubs such as ourselves, Leeds possibly, Blues etc.

The flex up and down in wages between the Prem and Championship will either make the two leagues a closed shop or see the same handful of teams go up and down until one of them makes a compete hash of promotion. The league will become even less competitive not fairer.

Not sure I agree it's impossible to be successful and self-sufficient... Norwich and Luton in recent times are showing it's feasible provided you make sensible decisions, and we did it for a long time before Lai and co broke our habit of making sensible decisions. When we got relegated we failed to invest the PPs into saleable assets we could develop, we went shit or bust throwing big money at ageing players which was called out by many on here as entirely the wrong thing.

We also don't have to be self-sufficient, we can lose around £13m a year without getting penalties... with our generated resources, some investment from Patel, and our academy continuing to generate players we will have as much chance as any club without parachute money at being successful in this division. 

BUT as Lepko rightly summarises, because of the farcical running of the club by the previous owners, the first 2 years of Shileen's time here will be heavily constrained in terms of investment, which is why we are seeing him focus targeted investment in infrastructure and the academy where it can give us a competitive edge in player recruitment and development.
Reply
#12
(08-01-2024, 09:43 AM)Fido Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 09:31 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 09:23 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Not exactly a fan of CL but his article here really hammers home why we need to do what is currently being done.

Let’s hope that those with their heads in the sand or who have lived in a cave for the past 2-3 years actually read it and the penny drops with them.   The “but we’re selling all our best players and buying rejects” whingers need a rapid reality check.

https://x.com/chrislepkowski/status/1818...7NobqYXxUQ

I read that this morning. It's a decent article tbf to Chris and he hasn't made any financial faux pars this time.

Here's the link direct to the article for peeps who don't have twitter

https://chrislepkowski.wixsite.com/the-f...-an-option

<spits tea all over the laptop screen>

Big Grin
Reply
#13
Good article. Thanks for sharing.
It won't shut up the Facebook moaners because they won't read it.
Sad times though.
Lai and his mates are the ones, if we want to blame someone.
Reply
#14
(08-01-2024, 10:22 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 09:43 AM)Fido Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 09:31 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 09:23 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Not exactly a fan of CL but his article here really hammers home why we need to do what is currently being done.

Let’s hope that those with their heads in the sand or who have lived in a cave for the past 2-3 years actually read it and the penny drops with them.   The “but we’re selling all our best players and buying rejects” whingers need a rapid reality check.

https://x.com/chrislepkowski/status/1818...7NobqYXxUQ

I read that this morning. It's a decent article tbf to Chris and he hasn't made any financial faux pars this time.

Here's the link direct to the article for peeps who don't have twitter

https://chrislepkowski.wixsite.com/the-f...-an-option

<spits tea all over the laptop screen>

Big Grin

Honestly, though, I've an image in my head of a moth keep flying towards a naked flame. It's actually flabbergasting.
Reply
#15
Not sure he is right about Grant and Diangana being negative equity - that would depend on any fee.

They're not carrying their full fee in the books otherwise we'd see £12m loss when Diangana's contract runs out and that would blow FFP.

Anything over £3m for either of them this season would at least break their value even in the books and in turn get rid of the wages.
Reply
#16
(08-01-2024, 11:01 AM)MGalea Wrote: Not sure he is right about Grant and Diangana being negative equity - that would depend on any fee.

They're not carrying their full fee in the books otherwise we'd see £12m loss when Diangana's contract runs out and that would blow FFP.

Anything over £3m for either of them this season would at least break their value even in the books and in turn get rid of the wages.

He is totally right on KFG and Diangana.

In round numbers for FFP they owe us roughly £6M and £3M  in FFP losses.
Reply
#17
(08-01-2024, 11:13 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:01 AM)MGalea Wrote: Not sure he is right about Grant and Diangana being negative equity - that would depend on any fee.

They're not carrying their full fee in the books otherwise we'd see £12m loss when Diangana's contract runs out and that would blow FFP.

Anything over £3m for either of them this season would at least break their value even in the books and in turn get rid of the wages.

He is totally right on KFG and Diangana.

In round numbers for FFP they owe us roughly £6M and £3M  in FFP losses.

Sorry - of course their costs are still hanging around in the previous years numbers.
Reply
#18
(08-01-2024, 12:14 PM)MGalea Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:13 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:01 AM)MGalea Wrote: Not sure he is right about Grant and Diangana being negative equity - that would depend on any fee.

They're not carrying their full fee in the books otherwise we'd see £12m loss when Diangana's contract runs out and that would blow FFP.

Anything over £3m for either of them this season would at least break their value even in the books and in turn get rid of the wages.

He is totally right on KFG and Diangana.

In round numbers for FFP they owe us roughly £6M and £3M  in FFP losses.

Sorry - of course their costs are still hanging around in the previous years numbers.

no worries  Big Grin
Reply
#19
(08-01-2024, 10:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 09:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I know why we have to do it, and for now it’s a solution, it’s it exactly difficult to understand. However in the long term any Championship club thinking they can become both competitive and self sufficient at best is kidding themselves in the current football environment. How many clubs are self sufficient/break even or make a profit in the Championship? How long can the current anti-competitive FFP rules be adhered to before being challenged by clubs such as ourselves, Leeds possibly, Blues etc.

The flex up and down in wages between the Prem and Championship will either make the two leagues a closed shop or see the same handful of teams go up and down until one of them makes a compete hash of promotion. The league will become even less competitive not fairer.

Not sure I agree it's impossible to be successful and self-sufficient... Norwich and Luton in recent times are showing it's feasible provided you make sensible decisions, and we did it for a long time before Lai and co broke our habit of making sensible decisions. When we got relegated we failed to invest the PPs into saleable assets we could develop, we went shit or bust throwing big money at ageing players which was called out by many on here as entirely the wrong thing.

We also don't have to be self-sufficient, we can lose around £13m a year without getting penalties... with our generated resources, some investment from Patel, and our academy continuing to generate players we will have as much chance as any club without parachute money at being successful in this division. 

BUT as Lepko rightly summarises, because of the farcical running of the club by the previous owners, the first 2 years of Shileen's time here will be heavily constrained in terms of investment, which is why we are seeing him focus targeted investment in infrastructure and the academy where it can give us a competitive edge in player recruitment and development.


The point about being allowed to lose £13m a year without getting penalties completely overlooks the fact that losses have to be funded by the shareholders.  Thats reckless and irresponsible. Mr Patel and other new owners of clubs are not going to go down those rabbit holes again.    That level of permissible losses is only going to be seen where owners have more money than sense.

(08-01-2024, 12:14 PM)MGalea Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:13 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:01 AM)MGalea Wrote: Not sure he is right about Grant and Diangana being negative equity - that would depend on any fee.

They're not carrying their full fee in the books otherwise we'd see £12m loss when Diangana's contract runs out and that would blow FFP.

Anything over £3m for either of them this season would at least break their value even in the books and in turn get rid of the wages.

He is totally right on KFG and Diangana.

In round numbers for FFP they owe us roughly £6M and £3M  in FFP losses.

Sorry - of course their costs are still hanging around in the previous years numbers.

Their fee is amortized over the duration of their contracts, so that either 1/6th (Grant) or 1/5th (Grady) are written off every year and are part of our historic losses.  The residual values are about £5m and £3m respectively.  If we sell them at any less than that over the next 12 months then we would make an FFP loss in that accounting period on them.
Reply
#20
(08-01-2024, 12:32 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 10:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 09:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I know why we have to do it, and for now it’s a solution, it’s it exactly difficult to understand. However in the long term any Championship club thinking they can become both competitive and self sufficient at best is kidding themselves in the current football environment. How many clubs are self sufficient/break even or make a profit in the Championship? How long can the current anti-competitive FFP rules be adhered to before being challenged by clubs such as ourselves, Leeds possibly, Blues etc.

The flex up and down in wages between the Prem and Championship will either make the two leagues a closed shop or see the same handful of teams go up and down until one of them makes a compete hash of promotion. The league will become even less competitive not fairer.

Not sure I agree it's impossible to be successful and self-sufficient... Norwich and Luton in recent times are showing it's feasible provided you make sensible decisions, and we did it for a long time before Lai and co broke our habit of making sensible decisions. When we got relegated we failed to invest the PPs into saleable assets we could develop, we went shit or bust throwing big money at ageing players which was called out by many on here as entirely the wrong thing.

We also don't have to be self-sufficient, we can lose around £13m a year without getting penalties... with our generated resources, some investment from Patel, and our academy continuing to generate players we will have as much chance as any club without parachute money at being successful in this division. 

BUT as Lepko rightly summarises, because of the farcical running of the club by the previous owners, the first 2 years of Shileen's time here will be heavily constrained in terms of investment, which is why we are seeing him focus targeted investment in infrastructure and the academy where it can give us a competitive edge in player recruitment and development.


The point about being allowed to lose £13m a year without getting penalties completely overlooks the fact that losses have to be funded by the shareholders.  Thats reckless and irresponsible. Mr Patel and other new owners of clubs are not going to go down those rabbit holes again.    That level of permissible losses is only going to be seen where owners have more money than sense.

Profit/losses vs cashflow, Prag and also the structure of the deals. 

The Dara deal was cheap, and funded on a "factoring type" agreement to punt cash into the club. Hopefully those days are behind us.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: