Starmer nailing himself to the centre...
#21
(07-25-2024, 10:30 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I think it can and does work for the majority of cases, when it is sustained. But i also know that some families just cannot be saved.

Also some people need to escape their families to save themselves.

Totally agree. I have spoken to probation experts who have told me how they know what is in store for kids, but nothing is done.

Seen quite a few things on Scandinavian attitudes to issues. They are far more intelligent and stop a cycle of crime etc, but they take time. The problem with too many here is they want a magic wand and immediate answers. Unfortunately too many idiots like this who have no idea how life works.
Reply
#22
(07-25-2024, 08:20 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I worked in well resourced and holistic interventions in the early 2000s for a decade and I can catergorically tell you it does work - when it is done properly (not reactive and piecemeal) and when the services required aren’t living hand to mouth for funding every twelve months. The only time in all the various charities I’ve worked for or with that staff contracts were ever more than a year long and the stability that gave filtered through everything.

Like everything in life, to achieve it requires persistence, a well delivered plan and time. Without foundations it doesn’t work, and that’s what your describing here because we’ve had none for 15 years

How much would it cost? Is the benefit derived greater than the cost of providing a family with a subsistence level of living in perpetuity?

Unfortunately, funding priorities tend to drive the residualisation of services in lean times. Labour appears to understand this at the moment.
Reply
#23
I doubt the suspended rebels are quaking in their boots.

The election showed that in their city heartlands Labour lost votes and particularly in constituencies where there was credible left opposition.

Corbyn won as an independent, Shaheen got as many votes as the official Labour candidate, despite having very little time to organise her independent campaign and there were other examples.

As things stand at the moment, all 7 would have a reasonable chance of holding their seats.

This might change, particularly if the Govt is seen as a success, particularly in issues that affect the economically vulnerable. But then we will all be winners.

It is the one thing that gives me some hope, how dependent the Govt is on real and visible improvement. Without it they are dead in the water.
Reply
#24
(07-24-2024, 06:41 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-24-2024, 05:36 PM)Jacko Wrote: He's just used the opportunity to get rid of (some of) the deadwood. Will forever amaze me that Burgon or Sultana ever got elected once nevermind multiple times...

Sultana was parachuted in to Coventry South against the wishes of the local party who wanted to nominate a local councillor.

But their CLP did not have a trigger and reselected her. nearly two years ago. It's possible that the modrates in the CLP have given up. If I remember I'll ask - I'm seeing a few ITK in a couple of days. She's not a grown up
Reply
#25
(07-25-2024, 03:33 PM)Pontificator Wrote:
(07-24-2024, 06:41 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-24-2024, 05:36 PM)Jacko Wrote: He's just used the opportunity to get rid of (some of) the deadwood. Will forever amaze me that Burgon or Sultana ever got elected once nevermind multiple times...

Sultana was parachuted in to Coventry South against the wishes of the local party who wanted to nominate a local councillor.

But their CLP did not have a trigger and reselected her. nearly two years ago. It's possible that the modrates in the CLP have given up. If I remember I'll ask - I'm seeing a few ITK in a couple of days. She's not a grown up

From what I've been told by a very Blairite Labour member mate of mine that lives in her constituency they warmed to her because apparently she's been a decent constituency MP, I know one Lib Dem in Cov that likes her as she helped out on a specific issue for them (not enough to get them to vote for her though).
Reply
#26
(07-25-2024, 01:50 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-25-2024, 08:20 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I worked in well resourced and holistic interventions in the early 2000s for a decade and I can catergorically tell you it does work - when it is done properly (not reactive and piecemeal) and when the services required aren’t living hand to mouth for funding every twelve months. The only time in all the various charities I’ve worked for or with that staff contracts were ever more than a year long and the stability that gave filtered through everything.

Like everything in life, to achieve it requires persistence, a well delivered plan and time. Without foundations it doesn’t work, and that’s what your describing here because we’ve had none for 15 years

How much would it cost? Is the benefit derived greater than the cost of providing a family with a subsistence level of living in perpetuity?

Unfortunately, funding priorities tend to drive the residualisation of services in lean times. Labour appears to understand this at the moment.

As a simple but pertinent example, they chopped our knife crime budget (20k - matched funding so 40k total) annually, where we had no incidents in those 6 years. Since then, at least 4 kids that i know of are now serving a combination of about 50 years in prison at well over a cost of £1m. You can go cheap on all these things and youll just get the bill later on.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#27
(07-26-2024, 06:13 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(07-25-2024, 01:50 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-25-2024, 08:20 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I worked in well resourced and holistic interventions in the early 2000s for a decade and I can catergorically tell you it does work - when it is done properly (not reactive and piecemeal) and when the services required aren’t living hand to mouth for funding every twelve months. The only time in all the various charities I’ve worked for or with that staff contracts were ever more than a year long and the stability that gave filtered through everything.

Like everything in life, to achieve it requires persistence, a well delivered plan and time. Without foundations it doesn’t work, and that’s what your describing here because we’ve had none for 15 years

How much would it cost? Is the benefit derived greater than the cost of providing a family with a subsistence level of living in perpetuity?

Unfortunately, funding priorities tend to drive the residualisation of services in lean times. Labour appears to understand this at the moment.

As a simple but pertinent example, they chopped our knife crime budget (20k - matched funding so 40k total) annually, where we had no incidents in those 6 years. Since then, at least 4 kids that i know of are now serving a combination of about 50 years in prison at well over a cost of £1m. You can go cheap on all these things and youll just get the bill later on.

This exactly CF, the crap that gets spouted despite the evidence is beyond parody.

Cut DWP funding therefore the benefits cheats don’t get investigated is translated into ‘the modern generation have broken the social contract’
Cut Police funding and the criminals take over the streets gets translated into they need tougher deterrent.
Cut social funds for youth and sports clubs and this generation dowesn’t have th respect that we were brought up with.
Cut the housing budgets and there are less houses therefor they go to the most in need and we create sink estates.

Yeah but austerity.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)