Starmer nailing himself to the centre...
#1
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c978m6z3egno

7, loony left, Corbyn supporters suspended after first major vote. 

I thought it would take over 12 months. But after listening to many of the speeches over the last 5 days of the kings speech debates, it looks like poor Old Kier may have his hands full with his "super majority"
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
Marginalising these MPs and their constituents as the "looney left" - which they aren't willabsolutely kill labour at the ballot boxes next time round.

With fewer votes than in 2017 and 2019 Starmer would be wise to remember that the real failing of the left was not mastering voter efficiency.

Pop quiz. Who do you think tweeted the following in 2020?

"We must scrap the inhuman Work Capability Assessments and private provision of disability assessments (e.g. ATOS), scrap punitive sanctions, two-child limit and benefits cap"
Reply
#3
To be fair if, Rebecca Long-Bailey and Zarah Sultana are not classed as "loony left" then I am not sure on who would be.

As somebody who has only lent my vote to Labour. I am happy with how they are doing. And with the swing to the right in the popular vote. Labour keeping more people in my bracket is more important than a few radical socialists who might start looking elsewhere, although I am not sure where.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#4
We're big on optics on this dump, and suspending people for not wanting kids in poverty isn't a good look but I broadly agree about the mass appeal.

Issue with being firmly in the centre is that you've got a lot of plates to keep spinning. The huge chunk of the electorate that made 'Corbynism' a thing still exist and will go elsewhere if there is too many instances like this. I'd say given how well the greens performed in many seats, a good chunk of them already have. This notion that it is a few "radical socialists" is false, look at 2017 and 2019 vote share.
Reply
#5
(07-24-2024, 07:00 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Marginalising these MPs and their constituents as the "looney left" - which they aren't willabsolutely kill labour at the ballot boxes next time round.

You're joking. These are some of the Campaign Group nutters who Labour would be well rid of permanently.

And who on Earth is marginalising their constituents as the "loony left"?
Reply
#6
(07-24-2024, 07:32 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We're big on optics on this dump, and suspending people for not wanting kids in poverty isn't a good look but I broadly agree about the mass appeal.

Issue with being firmly in the centre is that you've got a lot of plates to keep spinning. The huge chunk of the electorate that made 'Corbynism' a thing still exist and will go elsewhere if there is too many instances like this. I'd say given how well the greens performed in many seats, a good chunk of them already have. This notion that it is a few "radical socialists" is false, look at 2017 and 2019 vote share.

As you say the rise in the green and indy votes are those "radical socialist" types moving away from labour as Starmer is a centrist. But there's still loads of middle left labour voters who probably feel they want more socialism, but won't take their vote elsewhere because they have always and will always vote labour. 

In terms of optics, Starmer had to act quickly and harshly on early rebellion. As, if he didn't, it would grow quickly. It's not about suspending people for wanting to end child poverty, it's about ensuring his back benches don't start calling the shots. Much the same as the Tory back benches have since 2019.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#7
Another loony lefty
https://www.standard.co.uk/news/politics...20Standard.
Reply
#8
It costs £166k to raise a child to 18, on average, according to a report by Child Poverty Action Group, but we have to ensure responsible and decent people are encouraged to have families, who will bring people into the world who are a benefit to society. That means better childcare provisions for working parents etc.
It's incredibly complex, but simply all societies have to have children or we rely on immigration.
Reply
#9
(07-24-2024, 09:04 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It costs £166k to raise a child to 18, on average, according to a report by Child Poverty Action Group, but we have to ensure responsible and decent people are encouraged to have families, who will bring people into the world who are a benefit to society. That means better childcare provisions for working parents etc.
It's incredibly complex, but simply all societies have to have children or we rely on immigration.

Build some houses then, so people can actually afford to put down roots.

People aren't having kids because they can't afford to. It seems bizarre asking people who work who can't afford to have kids to pay even more in tax for people who already have kids they can't afford.
Reply
#10
(07-24-2024, 09:20 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-24-2024, 09:04 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It costs £166k to raise a child to 18, on average, according to a report by Child Poverty Action Group, but we have to ensure responsible and decent people are encouraged to have families, who will bring people into the world who are a benefit to society. That means better childcare provisions for working parents etc.
It's incredibly complex, but simply all societies have to have children or we rely on immigration.

Build some houses then, so people can actually afford to put down roots.

People aren't having kids because they can't afford to. It seems bizarre asking people who work who can't afford to have kids to pay even more in tax for people who already have kids they can't afford.

Totally agree. 

It's a crazy situation we have created. 

The problem is encouraging the right kind of people to have kids and discouraging the wrong type. That involves lots of groundwork.

As someone who once knew lots of people in probation and the CPS through my work that can't be reiterated enough.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: