To anyone still thinking of voting Tory…
(07-05-2024, 09:07 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: You make a big mistake in assuming that any move - especially appeasing or listening to the left - results in an axiomatic increase in the Labour share of the vote. It is possible that many voters chose the new more centralist party and did not vote for Labour last time because of Corbyn. The rise of fringe parties will I suspect have taken many Labour votes, not just Tory ones, from Corbyn's time. 

It is also distinctly possible that much of the Labour vote was tactical - i.e. hold your nose and vote Labour to get rid of the Tories in seats that Labour were more like to win. The demographic of the electorate is ageing and if Labour is to increase it's real share of the vote it has to appeal far more to the young - who it seems are still much less likely to vote. Persuading that age group that Labour is worth voting for has to be one of the party's main tasks.  If not then the current fringe parties are far more likely to increase their vote share and Labour and the Tories -  in the new volatile political state we now find ourselves in - will increasingly diminish their vote share.

IMO.

It was, you only need to look at vote share to realise that. Although there was arguably more encouragement for tactical voting in this election that I can ever remember previously so I suppose Labour can put some down to that. Labour got 3m fewer votes than 2017 and 600k less than their worst ever result in 2019. Kier Starmer saw his vote share halved in his own constituency. That is a move away from Starmer's Labour party by people who were Labour voters under the previous leadership and I'd bet that a good number of them were the younger people you refer to.

I'm not advocating for a move back left, I'm just saying there is a significant share of that vote that has remained with the party from 2017 and 2019 who will disappear as quickly as those who voted Tory previously. It's entirely plausible to say that the number of Tory voters who voted Labour this time is similar to the number of Labour voters from 2019 who've gone to the Greens, Lib Dems and Independents.
Reply
(07-05-2024, 09:36 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 09:07 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: You make a big mistake in assuming that any move - especially appeasing or listening to the left - results in an axiomatic increase in the Labour share of the vote. It is possible that many voters chose the new more centralist party and did not vote for Labour last time because of Corbyn.  The rise of fringe parties will I suspect have taken many Labour votes, not just Tory ones, from Corbyn's time. 

It is also distinctly possible that much of the Labour vote was tactical - i.e. hold your nose and vote Labour to get rid of the Tories in seats that Labour were more like to win. The demographic of the electorate is ageing and if Labour is to increase it's real share of the vote it has to appeal far more to the young - who it seems are still much less likely to vote. Persuading that age group that Labour is worth voting for has to be one of the party's main tasks.  If not then the current fringe parties are far more likely to increase their vote share and Labour and the Tories -  in the new volatile political state we now find ourselves in - will increasingly diminish their vote share.

IMO.

It was, you only need to look at vote share to realise that. Although there was arguably more encouragement for tactical voting in this election that I can ever remember previously so I suppose Labour can put some down to that. Labour got 3m fewer votes than 2017 and 600k less than their worst ever result in 2019. Kier Starmer saw his vote share halved in his own constituency. That is a move away from Starmer's Labour party by people who were Labour voters under the previous leadership and I'd bet that a good number of them were the younger people you refer to.

I'm not advocating for a move back left, I'm just saying there is a significant share of that vote that has remained with the party from 2017 and 2019 who will disappear as quickly as those who voted Tory previously. It's entirely plausible to say that the number of Tory voters who voted Labour this time is similar to the number of Labour voters from 2019 who've gone to the Greens, Lib Dems and Independents.

You ignore the huge number of young people became entitled to vote since 2019 - where did those votes go? 

And whilst I agree with many of your points but I simply can't agree that any great number of Tories voted Labour.  If they went anywhere it's clear they went to Reform, as did some Labour votes and potentially the votes of some of the young. Either way we agree that it is the young who have most to lose given the future that lies ahead. If they fail to become politicised - in the best sense of the word - then we are in trouble and only the far fringes of both sides can gain from that.
Reply
(07-05-2024, 09:55 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: You ignore the huge number of young people became entitled to vote since 2019 - where did those votes go? 

And whilst I agree with many of your points but I simply can't agree that any great number of Tories voted Labour.  If they went anywhere it's clear they went to Reform, as did some Labour votes and potentially the votes of some of the young. Either way we agree that it is the young who have most to lose given the future that lies ahead. If they fail to become politicised - in the best sense of the word - then we are in trouble and only the far fringes of both sides can gain from that.

All of the polling data would suggest that a Labour Party any further to the right of where it currently is (firmly in the centre) isn't likely to appeal to younger people either. Very much agree with your point here though and at present I'd say that Starmer appeals to young voters far less than the previous leader did, from my own experience anyway. There is a good proportion of younger voters who aren't engaged with politics who will vote Reform because its "funny" or because they saw Farage on I'm a Celebrity (great idea ITV).
Reply
(07-05-2024, 10:04 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 09:55 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: You ignore the huge number of young people became entitled to vote since 2019 - where did those votes go? 

And whilst I agree with many of your points but I simply can't agree that any great number of Tories voted Labour.  If they went anywhere it's clear they went to Reform, as did some Labour votes and potentially the votes of some of the young. Either way we agree that it is the young who have most to lose given the future that lies ahead. If they fail to become politicised - in the best sense of the word - then we are in trouble and only the far fringes of both sides can gain from that.

All of the polling data would suggest that a Labour Party any further to the right of where it currently is (firmly in the centre) isn't likely to appeal to younger people either. Very much agree with your point here though and at present I'd say that Starmer appeals to young voters far less than the previous leader did, from my own experience anyway. There is a good proportion of younger voters who aren't engaged with politics who will vote Reform because its "funny" or because they saw Farage on I'm a Celebrity (great idea ITV).

I don't think there is anything wrong with young voters supporting those fringe parties. Young people, by nature are rebellious and prickly. 

Seeing a huge youth movement towards the greens to balance the flow of older voters to reform would provide some real verve and debate within parliament if both get more seats in 5 years time. 

We just need to hope the Labour stay right and the tories choose to go left and they can hold the middle up between them.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(07-05-2024, 10:12 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 10:04 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 09:55 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: You ignore the huge number of young people became entitled to vote since 2019 - where did those votes go? 

And whilst I agree with many of your points but I simply can't agree that any great number of Tories voted Labour.  If they went anywhere it's clear they went to Reform, as did some Labour votes and potentially the votes of some of the young. Either way we agree that it is the young who have most to lose given the future that lies ahead. If they fail to become politicised - in the best sense of the word - then we are in trouble and only the far fringes of both sides can gain from that.

All of the polling data would suggest that a Labour Party any further to the right of where it currently is (firmly in the centre) isn't likely to appeal to younger people either. Very much agree with your point here though and at present I'd say that Starmer appeals to young voters far less than the previous leader did, from my own experience anyway. There is a good proportion of younger voters who aren't engaged with politics who will vote Reform because its "funny" or because they saw Farage on I'm a Celebrity (great idea ITV).

I don't think there is anything wrong with young voters supporting those fringe parties. Young people, by nature are rebellious and prickly. 

Seeing a huge youth movement towards the greens to balance the flow of older voters to reform would provide some real verve and debate within parliament if both get more seats in 5 years time. 

We just need to hope the Labour stay right and the tories choose to go left and they can hold the middle up between them.

It can't be underestimated that a good number of voters who would have been first timers in 2019 would have gone Green, Ind or Lib Dem because of the direction Starmer has taken the Labour Party. Any further and he risks losing those who stayed, and failing to attract any new ones just as quickly as he'd lose those who perhaps 'lent' him a vote this time.

Broadly agree though, best thing Starmer could do is keep his head down for a few months. Full Pulis, play the percentages, nothing outrageous just no betting scandals, dodgy contracts or clumsy tax avoidance and that will suffice for most people.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)