Starmer 9.6m 2024, Corbyn 12.9 m 2017
#11
I have been here before. Genuine belief when Blair and Obama won that things would change. They didn't. I have no excitement this morning and not a great deal of hope tbh.Starmer wont change much either imo. If he could embark on a national programme of 500k per year affordable housing, that would be a legacy and improve people's lives.
I'm not holding my breath though. But bringing some common decency and accountability to government would be something. What a low bar indeed those shape-shifting fuckers that were booted out have set.
Reply
#12
(07-05-2024, 08:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: One of the biggest majorities we've seen on what feels like a paper thin mandate.

You really, really, really have to hope he takes note of some of these figures and wins for Independent and Green candidates and acknowledges that there can be no further move to the right in the Labour party.

On the other hand theres hundreds of thousands of centre right voters who have loaned him our vote. He would be wise not to allow the loony left to rise too high over the next 5 years or those marginal seat will swing again.

The number of votes in 2017 and 2019 prove that there is some appetite for very moderate social democracy. Redistribution of wealth, improvements in public services and not filling our rivers full of shit. Starmer is lucky that not all of those who were to the left of the party deserted him. Any further move to the right will see that vote disappear to Independents and the Greens as quickly as the right will disappear back to the Tories and Reform. Like Dekka, I don't really feel like I can celebrate too much and I have serious concerns about the emergence of a Tory-Reform alliance.
Reply
#13
(07-05-2024, 08:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: One of the biggest majorities we've seen on what feels like a paper thin mandate.

You really, really, really have to hope he takes note of some of these figures and wins for Independent and Green candidates and acknowledges that there can be no further move to the right in the Labour party.

On the other hand theres hundreds of thousands of centre right voters who have loaned him our vote. He would be wise not to allow the loony left to rise too high over the next 5 years or those marginal seat will swing again.

The number of votes in 2017 and 2019 prove that there is some appetite for very moderate social democracy. Redistribution of wealth, improvements in public services and not filling our rivers full of shit. Starmer is lucky that not all of those who were to the left of the party deserted him. Any further move to the right will see that vote disappear to Independents and the Greens as quickly as the right will disappear back to the Tories and Reform. Like Dekka, I don't really feel like I can celebrate too much and I have serious concerns about the emergence of a Tory-Reform alliance.

Where do I sign up? 

It's when welfare starts to get out of hand and business start getting taxed to death I will revolt  Big Grin
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
(07-05-2024, 08:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: One of the biggest majorities we've seen on what feels like a paper thin mandate.

You really, really, really have to hope he takes note of some of these figures and wins for Independent and Green candidates and acknowledges that there can be no further move to the right in the Labour party.

On the other hand theres hundreds of thousands of centre right voters who have loaned him our vote. He would be wise not to allow the loony left to rise too high over the next 5 years or those marginal seat will swing again.

The number of votes in 2017 and 2019 prove that there is some appetite for very moderate social democracy. Redistribution of wealth, improvements in public services and not filling our rivers full of shit. Starmer is lucky that not all of those who were to the left of the party deserted him. Any further move to the right will see that vote disappear to Independents and the Greens as quickly as the right will disappear back to the Tories and Reform. Like Dekka, I don't really feel like I can celebrate too much and I have serious concerns about the emergence of a Tory-Reform alliance.

Where do I sign up? 

It's when welfare starts to get out of hand and business start getting taxed to death I will revolt  Big Grin

We have one of the lowest spends on welfare in Europe (Germany, France, the Scandinavian countries etc) and a tiny percent of welfare fraud. We do lose billions in business tax fraud though. The idea that the disabled or sick welfare payments are to blame for the problems in this country is rubbish.
Reply
#15
(07-05-2024, 08:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: One of the biggest majorities we've seen on what feels like a paper thin mandate.

You really, really, really have to hope he takes note of some of these figures and wins for Independent and Green candidates and acknowledges that there can be no further move to the right in the Labour party.

On the other hand theres hundreds of thousands of centre right voters who have loaned him our vote. He would be wise not to allow the loony left to rise too high over the next 5 years or those marginal seat will swing again.

The number of votes in 2017 and 2019 prove that there is some appetite for very moderate social democracy. Redistribution of wealth, improvements in public services and not filling our rivers full of shit. Starmer is lucky that not all of those who were to the left of the party deserted him. Any further move to the right will see that vote disappear to Independents and the Greens as quickly as the right will disappear back to the Tories and Reform. Like Dekka, I don't really feel like I can celebrate too much and I have serious concerns about the emergence of a Tory-Reform alliance.

Where do I sign up? 

It's when welfare starts to get out of hand and business start getting taxed to death I will revolt  Big Grin

We have one of the lowest spends on welfare in Europe (Germany, France, the Scandinavian countries etc) and a tiny percent of welfare fraud. We do lose billions in business tax fraud though. The idea that the disabled or sick welfare payments are to blame for the problems in this country is rubbish.

Nope it's not the issue and that's not what I really meant by welfare. 

No labour government has left power with unemployment lower than they found it. 
That sets the mood for a nation. 

My mother is on long term sick and will never work again. Do I want her being dragged through the ringer? No. But she has enough medical evidence to prove that her condition is degenerative and she has happily given this evidence to DWP. 

Now look at all her family (my uncles/cousins). Perpetually rinsing the system, that then spreads through 3 generations. 

Welfare should always be available and generous. But getting said welfare should be carefully and strictly monitored.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#16
(07-05-2024, 08:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: One of the biggest majorities we've seen on what feels like a paper thin mandate.

You really, really, really have to hope he takes note of some of these figures and wins for Independent and Green candidates and acknowledges that there can be no further move to the right in the Labour party.

On the other hand theres hundreds of thousands of centre right voters who have loaned him our vote. He would be wise not to allow the loony left to rise too high over the next 5 years or those marginal seat will swing again.

The number of votes in 2017 and 2019 prove that there is some appetite for very moderate social democracy. Redistribution of wealth, improvements in public services and not filling our rivers full of shit. Starmer is lucky that not all of those who were to the left of the party deserted him. Any further move to the right will see that vote disappear to Independents and the Greens as quickly as the right will disappear back to the Tories and Reform. Like Dekka, I don't really feel like I can celebrate too much and I have serious concerns about the emergence of a Tory-Reform alliance.

Where do I sign up? 

It's when welfare starts to get out of hand and business start getting taxed to death I will revolt  Big Grin

We have one of the lowest spends on welfare in Europe (Germany, France, the Scandinavian countries etc) and a tiny percent of welfare fraud. We do lose billions in business tax fraud though. The idea that the disabled or sick welfare payments are to blame for the problems in this country is rubbish.

The counties finances are a joke, wasted money is everywhere. Tories didn't address it and paid the price. Now it's labours turn. Sort it out quickly or get ready for a short spell in number  ten Sir Starmer.
Reply
#17
(07-05-2024, 08:41 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Labour offered very little hope or inspiration for many people including me and my family, the poll lead and now votes for them is a reflection of how unpopular the Tories are, it’s certainly not a ringing endorsement of the Labour Party. Their time in office will be short if they fail to make real positive change to the country. If they fail expect politics to lurch to the left and right extremes in politics.

Despite being extremely pleased to see the back of the current government I can’t be enthused or even relieved to see Labour in office given their ‘things can hopefully, but we aren’t promising , might, perhaps get better… but it’s going to take years before it does’ argument.

Correct.

Labour have a once in a generation size majority and have the ability to make massive changes to this country if they so wish - unfortunately with so many problems needing fixing and so little money to do it, I imagine in 5 years' time it will feel another opportunity missed.

People have loaned Labour their support and are tired of politicians not helping or supporting them. If Labour manage the next 18-24 months well, they could find themselves in power for the next couple decades, if they take this support for granted and start their usual cycle of infighting we could be voting again in a couple years and the likes of Reform will be rubbing their hands together. 

On paper Starmer should be in dreamland, but in real terms he has one of the toughest political tightropes to walk of any government in living memory.
Reply
#18
(07-05-2024, 09:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:41 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Labour offered very little hope or inspiration for many people including me and my family, the poll lead and now votes for them is a reflection of how unpopular the Tories are, it’s certainly not a ringing endorsement of the Labour Party. Their time in office will be short if they fail to make real positive change to the country. If they fail expect politics to lurch to the left and right extremes in politics.

Despite being extremely pleased to see the back of the current government I can’t be enthused or even relieved to see Labour in office given their ‘things can hopefully, but we aren’t promising , might, perhaps get better… but it’s going to take years before it does’ argument.

Correct.

Labour have a once in a generation size majority and have the ability to make massive changes to this country if they so wish - unfortunately with so many problems needing fixing and so little money to do it, I imagine in 5 years' time it will feel another opportunity missed.

People have loaned Labour their support and are tired of politicians not helping or supporting them. If Labour manage the next 18-24 months well, they could find themselves in power for the next couple decades, if they take this support for granted and start their usual cycle of infighting we could be voting again in a couple years and the likes of Reform will be rubbing their hands together. 

On paper Starmer should be in dreamland, but in real terms he has one of the toughest political tightropes to walk of any government in living memory.

Perfect analysis SW4
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#19
It's definitely a Tory loss kinda result rather than a Labour win.

Hopefully Starmer knows he's not as popular as results suggest and he's in power due to how much people dislike the Conservatives rather than liking him.

Glad they're gone, but not glad of the replacement.
Reply
#20
(07-05-2024, 08:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: One of the biggest majorities we've seen on what feels like a paper thin mandate.

You really, really, really have to hope he takes note of some of these figures and wins for Independent and Green candidates and acknowledges that there can be no further move to the right in the Labour party.

On the other hand theres hundreds of thousands of centre right voters who have loaned him our vote. He would be wise not to allow the loony left to rise too high over the next 5 years or those marginal seat will swing again.

The number of votes in 2017 and 2019 prove that there is some appetite for very moderate social democracy. Redistribution of wealth, improvements in public services and not filling our rivers full of shit. Starmer is lucky that not all of those who were to the left of the party deserted him. Any further move to the right will see that vote disappear to Independents and the Greens as quickly as the right will disappear back to the Tories and Reform. Like Dekka, I don't really feel like I can celebrate too much and I have serious concerns about the emergence of a Tory-Reform alliance.

It's interesting but maybe futile to analyse voting numbers and try to discern where public opinion lies in the old Left-or-Right? spectrum. Corbyn inspired inexplicable loyalty from Lefties who love being in opposition, but he would never have got elected. He came close in 2017 because many sensible people were voting to express discontent with the Brexit mess which (ironically) he could have helped to avoid. Boris said he'd sort it - his majority was based on that false promise, plus a justified antipathy towards Corbyn's Labour. Not simple Left-or-Right? thinking in either case.

I've always thought left and right meet around the other side. "Proper working people" used to vote Labour and many have flipped to Reform. When you're working in a unionised job voting Labour is maybe a no-brainer. When unions don't represent you or you're not working, then right wing thinking around tax, immigration and all that will have its appeal.

I think we've seen a massive vote against the Tories. Without Reform we'd have seen a bigger turnout which would have delivered Labour a working majority - what Farage has done is gift them 130-odd extra seats. What will he do with his chance to shine? I don't think he can be a credible force in Parliament and he'll be a lousy MP for Clacton (they feckin' deserve him, the place is a shit-hole btw). He and Lee Anderson will make proper arseholes of themselves every time they speak. I hope Reform will fizzle. We need a re-constructed and functioning Conservative Party in opposition, because the alternative is far worse.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: