Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
07-03-2024, 02:45 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-03-2024, 02:47 PM by Protheroe.)
The queue is building. #Change #Hope #Changeyhope #Hopeychange
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(07-03-2024, 02:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The queue is building. #Change #Hope #Changeyhope #Hopeychange
![[Image: 449466326_7719672831457457_4266895858253...e=668B49CD]](https://scontent-man2-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/449466326_7719672831457457_4266895858253840621_n.jpg?stp=dst-jpg_p180x540&_nc_cat=104&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=127cfc&_nc_ohc=2Ku_kR_4Nk8Q7kNvgFmIvgs&_nc_ht=scontent-man2-1.xx&oh=00_AYDlWVrhRa-eb49Q9mQNANhgtkCziz06vRP2Xf9KUCnRJg&oe=668B49CD)
Hi Proth,
Just wondering your views on what's needed? You've taken stick for being a Tory, albeit disaffected one.
Watching the Channel 4 documentary Skint it's clear beyond belief austerity has pushed us back years, with crumbling transport infrastructures and an unwillingness for many to invest in the UK due to near impossible planning regs and woefully inadequate housing. Also our taxes are at a record high in our working life times.
Unlike some voting Labour, I'm quite centrist and think business has to be backed, whilst people at the bottom should also have an opportunity to get on and get the help they need.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
07-03-2024, 04:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-03-2024, 04:09 PM by Protheroe.)
(07-03-2024, 02:59 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Just wondering your views on what's needed? You've taken stick for being a Tory, albeit disaffected one.
Watching the Channel 4 documentary Skint it's clear beyond belief austerity has pushed us back years, with crumbling transport infrastructures and an unwillingness for many to invest in the UK due to near impossible planning regs and woefully inadequate housing. Also our taxes are at a record high in our working life times.
Unlike some voting Labour, I'm quite centrist and think business has to be backed, whilst people at the bottom should also have an opportunity to get on and get the help they need.
I've listened to Ian Hartford for years on Radio 4. I also watched that documentary.
The key quote comes very early on "you have to look back to 2008", which is what I've been banging on about since, well 2008.
The main failure is that not once does he mention debt. Even when he got those lumps of cash out to demonstrate public spending he didn't state that 8.5% of government spending is now on debt interest - over £100 billion in 2022/23 and not forecast to fall much under £90 billion for the foreseeable future. He should really have explained that this is a primary driver of the rising tax burden.
So yes. You need growth, but you also need to ensure you're not letting debt get out of control - particularly as if you're not careful growth will cause inflation which feeds into higher debt interest.
He also hits the nail on the head when talking about long term investment; this isn't merely a British problem - it's a problem in many modern democracies. In America it's known as the Build Nothing Country - https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/the-build-nothing-country.
We need huge supply side reform - particularly on planning. We need to take housing land supply away from land promoters who happen to get lucky on the occasional speculative punt and start zoning land properly. For instance BB will agree with me about the Oxford - Cambridge - London axis where we need hundreds of acres of land zoned (and if necessary CPOd) for housing and lab space to support Life Sciences. We need to be clear on the taxation of windfall gains on such land getting zoning - even when I was still in property we could raise the value of agricultural land from £5,000 / acre to £300,000 / acre just be getting a warehouse consent - up to £1.25m / acre for a resi consent. Tax gains to pay for infrastructure.
Popular? No. Necessary? Absolutely.
We also need to address huge intergenerational inequality. That means getting those who've benefitted from the same sort of unearned windfall gains on housing (including me) to really take a good look at themselves and their responsibility towards society
Popular? God No. Necessary? Absolutely
As Matthew Syed put it in The Times earlier this week:
"Building railways, for example, represents a sacrifice in the here and now because the money to hire diggers and pay workers can’t be splurged on day-to-day consumption. But guess what: if we make this sacrifice, in a few years we will have extra connectivity to fuel growth. Similarly, weaning ourselves off low-wage immigration means paying workers more in the here and now, but it also means that we are not storing up vast fiscal liabilities and putting extra pressure on our physical infrastructure and (if these immigrants fail to integrate) cultural capital."
"We have a choice: do we resist the temptation to use the credit card today — which implies we will have less of everything else? Or do we max out the Amex, enjoy extra consumption and borrow again next year — saddling future generations with crippling interest payments and structural weakness? The latter choice is easier, but also — over time — insidious, chipping away at the vitality of a civilisation."
I have stated on here before that if you want the nice things you want in the future then we'll all have to agree to be a little bit poorer today.
You could say they're unpleasant truths.
EDIT: I was with a leading light in the property taxation field today who told me that in Whitehall Council Tax is known as the "Live Rail" which tells you all you need to know about the likelihood of reform there. It also tells you much of what you need to know about the challenge facing any party that truly wants to #change Britain. The vested interests in Whitehall can be just as insidious as those outside.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I agree a fair bit with Proth there. May disagree on the how, but the end result and the fact this has been a constant policy decision disaster since 2008 I totally agree with.
I think the really unpleasant truth is, that this system is near collapse, and we either start thinking about how we adapt ready for the next evolution of economics, or like we have since 2008, hang on to the old ideas and paradigms as it edges closer and closer to total collapse and total chaos.
Posts: 6,717
Threads: 354
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
I would say that there is still a lot of 1948 thinking and methods being used to try to solve 2024 problems. It needs to change and you can't solve current problems by using the same type of thinking that created them in the first place. We should be maxing use of tech and AI for a start
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
07-03-2024, 05:01 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-03-2024, 05:04 PM by Pontificator.)
(07-03-2024, 10:10 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I hope that the polls are correct and that this is the last we will ever see of the shysters, rogues and swivel eyed loons. 14 years of the most vile and reactionary government that I have ever seen in UK. From an ideological obsession with austerity, through to buses telling people to go home and preroguing parliament. Wasting billions on COVID kit that didn't work, giving contracts to their mates, then holding private parties. Telling the Unionists to rip up paperwork and throw it in the bin, knowing full well that said paperwork would need completing, and an Irish sea border was coming. From the ineptitude of Cameron and May, the lies and racism of Johnson and the fantasy economics of the lettuce Truss- it has been a shitshow and disaster throughout. Right until the very end their corruption continued with the betting scandal.
A party that was always far more interested in playing out its own internal psychodramas rather than delivering anything for the UK people. Hopefully now, they will crumble and fall away to non existence.
Starmer and Co won't set the country alight, but I hope they can bring back common decency to government. Which has been lacking for a very long time.
You forgot the near destruction of the criminal justice system
(07-03-2024, 10:31 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I think that I have been peeling onions whilst reading this.
It was the 64-70 Labour govt that gave me a free uni education for degree and 2 x masters degrees and a grant. Without them, I would be in a factory and on the same estate with my mates. That this opportunity is not available to today's yoof is a disgrace. 1.8m have student debt north of 50k; they will be mortgaged up to the eyeballs if they are lucky enough to scrape a deposit together. This needs reversing...and quickly.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/art...the-tories
Tuition Fees need to rise. I get sick of the misrepresentation of the student loan system. It needs reform but not reversing.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(07-03-2024, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-03-2024, 02:59 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Just wondering your views on what's needed? You've taken stick for being a Tory, albeit disaffected one.
Watching the Channel 4 documentary Skint it's clear beyond belief austerity has pushed us back years, with crumbling transport infrastructures and an unwillingness for many to invest in the UK due to near impossible planning regs and woefully inadequate housing. Also our taxes are at a record high in our working life times.
Unlike some voting Labour, I'm quite centrist and think business has to be backed, whilst people at the bottom should also have an opportunity to get on and get the help they need.
I've listened to Ian Hartford for years on Radio 4. I also watched that documentary.
The key quote comes very early on "you have to look back to 2008", which is what I've been banging on about since, well 2008.
The main failure is that not once does he mention debt. Even when he got those lumps of cash out to demonstrate public spending he didn't state that 8.5% of government spending is now on debt interest - over £100 billion in 2022/23 and not forecast to fall much under £90 billion for the foreseeable future. He should really have explained that this is a primary driver of the rising tax burden.
So yes. You need growth, but you also need to ensure you're not letting debt get out of control - particularly as if you're not careful growth will cause inflation which feeds into higher debt interest.
He also hits the nail on the head when talking about long term investment; this isn't merely a British problem - it's a problem in many modern democracies. In America it's known as the Build Nothing Country - https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/the-build-nothing-country.
We need huge supply side reform - particularly on planning. We need to take housing land supply away from land promoters who happen to get lucky on the occasional speculative punt and start zoning land properly. For instance BB will agree with me about the Oxford - Cambridge - London axis where we need hundreds of acres of land zoned (and if necessary CPOd) for housing and lab space to support Life Sciences. We need to be clear on the taxation of windfall gains on such land getting zoning - even when I was still in property we could raise the value of agricultural land from £5,000 / acre to £300,000 / acre just be getting a warehouse consent - up to £1.25m / acre for a resi consent. Tax gains to pay for infrastructure.
Popular? No. Necessary? Absolutely.
We also need to address huge intergenerational inequality. That means getting those who've benefitted from the same sort of unearned windfall gains on housing (including me) to really take a good look at themselves and their responsibility towards society
Popular? God No. Necessary? Absolutely
As Matthew Syed put it in The Times earlier this week:
"Building railways, for example, represents a sacrifice in the here and now because the money to hire diggers and pay workers can’t be splurged on day-to-day consumption. But guess what: if we make this sacrifice, in a few years we will have extra connectivity to fuel growth. Similarly, weaning ourselves off low-wage immigration means paying workers more in the here and now, but it also means that we are not storing up vast fiscal liabilities and putting extra pressure on our physical infrastructure and (if these immigrants fail to integrate) cultural capital."
"We have a choice: do we resist the temptation to use the credit card today — which implies we will have less of everything else? Or do we max out the Amex, enjoy extra consumption and borrow again next year — saddling future generations with crippling interest payments and structural weakness? The latter choice is easier, but also — over time — insidious, chipping away at the vitality of a civilisation."
I have stated on here before that if you want the nice things you want in the future then we'll all have to agree to be a little bit poorer today.
You could say they're unpleasant truths.
EDIT: I was with a leading light in the property taxation field today who told me that in Whitehall Council Tax is known as the "Live Rail" which tells you all you need to know about the likelihood of reform there. It also tells you much of what you need to know about the challenge facing any party that truly wants to #change Britain. The vested interests in Whitehall can be just as insidious as those outside. Thanks Proth. As ever you say it intelligently whether people agree or not and an interesting take that I imagine is hard to deny.
Posts: 566
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(07-03-2024, 10:10 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I hope that the polls are correct and that this is the last we will ever see of the shysters, rogues and swivel eyed loons. 14 years of the most vile and reactionary government that I have ever seen in UK. From an ideological obsession with austerity, through to buses telling people to go home and preroguing parliament. Wasting billions on COVID kit that didn't work, giving contracts to their mates, then holding private parties. Telling the Unionists to rip up paperwork and throw it in the bin, knowing full well that said paperwork would need completing, and an Irish sea border was coming. From the ineptitude of Cameron and May, the lies and racism of Johnson and the fantasy economics of the lettuce Truss- it has been a shitshow and disaster throughout. Right until the very end their corruption continued with the betting scandal.
A party that was always far more interested in playing out its own internal psychodramas rather than delivering anything for the UK people. Hopefully now, they will crumble and fall away to non existence.
Starmer and Co won't set the country alight, but I hope they can bring back common decency to government. Which has been lacking for a very long time.
shysters, rogues and swivel eyed loons. But that is only the half of it. You forgot the spivs, wide boys, chancers and conmen.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
I'm another who finds it tough to disagree with a lot of what Proth has said, there. Question and the debate comes when diving into what some of those reforms and "being a little bit poorer today" actually looks like. In 2010 people may have had the patience for such a fallow period, but after 14 years of austerity and cuts (whether you say this is the most socialist Tory party ever or not), a further tightening of the purse strings is not going to wash. We're paying more tax than we have in a long time and the services it's meant to fund are as bas as they've ever been for many.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
07-03-2024, 08:59 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-03-2024, 09:00 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(07-03-2024, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-03-2024, 02:59 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Just wondering your views on what's needed? You've taken stick for being a Tory, albeit disaffected one.
Watching the Channel 4 documentary Skint it's clear beyond belief austerity has pushed us back years, with crumbling transport infrastructures and an unwillingness for many to invest in the UK due to near impossible planning regs and woefully inadequate housing. Also our taxes are at a record high in our working life times.
Unlike some voting Labour, I'm quite centrist and think business has to be backed, whilst people at the bottom should also have an opportunity to get on and get the help they need.
I've listened to Ian Hartford for years on Radio 4. I also watched that documentary.
The key quote comes very early on "you have to look back to 2008", which is what I've been banging on about since, well 2008.
The main failure is that not once does he mention debt. Even when he got those lumps of cash out to demonstrate public spending he didn't state that 8.5% of government spending is now on debt interest - over £100 billion in 2022/23 and not forecast to fall much under £90 billion for the foreseeable future. He should really have explained that this is a primary driver of the rising tax burden.
So yes. You need growth, but you also need to ensure you're not letting debt get out of control - particularly as if you're not careful growth will cause inflation which feeds into higher debt interest.
He also hits the nail on the head when talking about long term investment; this isn't merely a British problem - it's a problem in many modern democracies. In America it's known as the Build Nothing Country - https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/the-build-nothing-country.
We need huge supply side reform - particularly on planning. We need to take housing land supply away from land promoters who happen to get lucky on the occasional speculative punt and start zoning land properly. For instance BB will agree with me about the Oxford - Cambridge - London axis where we need hundreds of acres of land zoned (and if necessary CPOd) for housing and lab space to support Life Sciences. We need to be clear on the taxation of windfall gains on such land getting zoning - even when I was still in property we could raise the value of agricultural land from £5,000 / acre to £300,000 / acre just be getting a warehouse consent - up to £1.25m / acre for a resi consent. Tax gains to pay for infrastructure.
Popular? No. Necessary? Absolutely.
We also need to address huge intergenerational inequality. That means getting those who've benefitted from the same sort of unearned windfall gains on housing (including me) to really take a good look at themselves and their responsibility towards society
Popular? God No. Necessary? Absolutely
As Matthew Syed put it in The Times earlier this week:
"Building railways, for example, represents a sacrifice in the here and now because the money to hire diggers and pay workers can’t be splurged on day-to-day consumption. But guess what: if we make this sacrifice, in a few years we will have extra connectivity to fuel growth. Similarly, weaning ourselves off low-wage immigration means paying workers more in the here and now, but it also means that we are not storing up vast fiscal liabilities and putting extra pressure on our physical infrastructure and (if these immigrants fail to integrate) cultural capital."
"We have a choice: do we resist the temptation to use the credit card today — which implies we will have less of everything else? Or do we max out the Amex, enjoy extra consumption and borrow again next year — saddling future generations with crippling interest payments and structural weakness? The latter choice is easier, but also — over time — insidious, chipping away at the vitality of a civilisation."
I have stated on here before that if you want the nice things you want in the future then we'll all have to agree to be a little bit poorer today.
You could say they're unpleasant truths.
EDIT: I was with a leading light in the property taxation field today who told me that in Whitehall Council Tax is known as the "Live Rail" which tells you all you need to know about the likelihood of reform there. It also tells you much of what you need to know about the challenge facing any party that truly wants to #change Britain. The vested interests in Whitehall can be just as insidious as those outside.
Agree with pretty much all of that (though I'd like regional zoning, not national zoning).
My issue is we cannot repeat the mistakes of 2010, operational spending needs to be covered by income to the Exchequer but the only way we're going to be able to actually ensure supply side expansion is for state investment into infrastructure to enable it to come about. The private sector isn't going to invest in new rail freight corridors, for example.
|