England vs Slovakia
Amazes me that we can have so much pace and creativity yet be so slow and predictable in attack.

Feels like we've regressed back to the days of simply sending everyone out there and hoping someone does something.
Reply
A reflection removed from the emotion of yesterday

1) The system does not work. It seems obvious to everyone but the manager. We shouldn't be finding ourselves late in the game needing a goal against Slovakia. Granted, football is unpredictable and it throws up these situations, but that was not a performance that leaves anyone feeling confident.
2) Southgate has not rotated the squad enough, which is strange because he usually does in tournaments. He doesn't need to start Bellingham or Kane if they're not ready; that's for the betterment of the team. They can come off the bench. They'd have scored those goals regardless of the fact they didn't start.
3) A Southgate-managed England is capable of beating Switzerland, but he needs to change the system. That means dropping a high-profile player.
4) The Bellingham goal was brilliant. I love that he attempted that because I don't think anyone else in the team would've. His bravado informs the way he plays, and we need more of that.
5) A week is too short an amount of time to change our style of play, but we can at least try to make it make sense.
Reply
I'm not convinced it's actually the system that is the problem.

As I alluded to yesterday, the core of this squad (Pickford, Walker, Stones, Trippier, Rice, Saka, Bellingham, Foden, Kane) have been playing together in the same system for 3-4 tournaments now. They shouldn't be looking like they only met in the car park half an hour before the game. Previous tournaments may not always have been exhillerating, but we were a damn sight better than we've been this year.

Something is off, not sure if it's the personnel (again given they've been playing together for a while now this shouldn't be an issue) or if it's mental, the pressures of being favourites getting to them, but something is not working and Southgate has a week to figure it out.
Reply
(07-01-2024, 08:06 AM)Duffers Wrote: Amazes me that we can have so much pace and creativity yet be so slow and predictable in attack.

Feels like we've regressed back to the days of simply sending everyone out there and hoping someone does something.

This is what is feels like, agreed. I’ve not watched every game but it does seem like most others teams are more fluid going forwards and are on the move for the second pass, not just the first. Given the amount of time these have played together it’s not too much to expect.
Reply
(07-01-2024, 06:58 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-30-2024, 11:25 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: What surprises and disappoints me is that Southgate seems suddenly devoid of ideas. Our best player (arguably) has been Guehi - who would not have been playing if the donkey Maguire had been available. As the pundits wiffled on about the "massive half time talk" and the need to change things to get in the game - he did nothing. Just two subs, neither of them really game-changing, until the introduction of Toney with potentially just 2 minutes of our tournament remaining. How strange was that?

Had Toney even touched the ball before Bellingham worked his magic? Does Southgate get any credit for his inspired substitution? Not from me.

Phil Foden - I just don't see what the fuss is about with this strolling dilettante. Harry Kane - can't see what he offers as captain or main striker - awesome finisher but there needs to be a plan to get him the chances.

Southgate got out of jail tonight. I've not been a critic, but it's hard to draw positives from his recent efforts.

Guehi has been awful, and we miss Maguire.

Geuhi's defending for their goal last night would have made a League 1 player embarrassed

Sorry birdie but I’m with the pundits on this one, been our best player so far and without him last night we would have been 2 down but for his block. Also we would not have equalised but for his flick on. Can’t see why some dislike Guehi a great defender.
Reply
(07-01-2024, 08:06 AM)Duffers Wrote: Amazes me that we can have so much pace and creativity yet be so slow and predictable in attack.

Feels like we've regressed back to the days of simply sending everyone out there and hoping someone does something.

Exactly my thoughts on it. One thing Southgate had always done in the past is be brave with being willing to drop what may have been considered key players for the greater good of the team - eg. Rooney & Sterling. 

Now it looks as though it’s just coming down to getting all of our best players on the pitch and hoping that it somehow works.
Reply
(07-01-2024, 09:02 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(07-01-2024, 06:58 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-30-2024, 11:25 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: What surprises and disappoints me is that Southgate seems suddenly devoid of ideas. Our best player (arguably) has been Guehi - who would not have been playing if the donkey Maguire had been available. As the pundits wiffled on about the "massive half time talk" and the need to change things to get in the game - he did nothing. Just two subs, neither of them really game-changing, until the introduction of Toney with potentially just 2 minutes of our tournament remaining. How strange was that?

Had Toney even touched the ball before Bellingham worked his magic? Does Southgate get any credit for his inspired substitution? Not from me.

Phil Foden - I just don't see what the fuss is about with this strolling dilettante. Harry Kane - can't see what he offers as captain or main striker - awesome finisher but there needs to be a plan to get him the chances.

Southgate got out of jail tonight. I've not been a critic, but it's hard to draw positives from his recent efforts.

Guehi has been awful, and we miss Maguire.

Geuhi's defending for their goal last night would have made a League 1 player embarrassed

Sorry birdie but I’m with the pundits on this one, been our best player so far and without him last night we would have been 2 down but for his block. Also we would not have equalised but for his flick on. Can’t see why some dislike Guehi a great defender.

I like him, and think he will be a big player for us in future.

But his positioning has been awful, and though he's made some good blocks and tackles, same as Terry on the past, it's usually because he wasn't in the right place to begin with.

We do miss Maguire badly,  and I'd argue we'd have probably not conceded yet with Maguire looking at the goals we've conceded.
Reply
(07-01-2024, 08:20 AM)Duffers Wrote: I'm not convinced it's actually the system that is the problem.

As I alluded to yesterday, the core of this squad (Pickford, Walker, Stones, Trippier, Rice, Saka, Bellingham, Foden, Kane) have been playing together in the same system for 3-4 tournaments now. They shouldn't be looking like they only met in the car park half an hour before the game. Previous tournaments may not always have been exhillerating, but we were a damn sight better than we've been this year.

Something is off, not sure if it's the personnel (again given they've been playing together for a while now this shouldn't be an issue) or if it's mental, the pressures of being favourites getting to them, but something is not working and Southgate has a week to figure it out.

In recent tournaments we've had Sterling/Rashford who both run in behind and threaten the goal regularly. We have also had Hendo making us tick and Maguire controlling and leading from the back. 

We're struggling with the replacements not being like for like and our approach has changed somewhat. We have more players ahead of the ball now than we have for a number of years but we don't seem to have the balance in defence and midfield to break through the press.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(07-01-2024, 08:20 AM)Duffers Wrote: I'm not convinced it's actually the system that is the problem.

As I alluded to yesterday, the core of this squad (Pickford, Walker, Stones, Trippier, Rice, Saka, Bellingham, Foden, Kane) have been playing together in the same system for 3-4 tournaments now. They shouldn't be looking like they only met in the car park half an hour before the game. Previous tournaments may not always have been exhillerating, but we were a damn sight better than we've been this year.

Something is off, not sure if it's the personnel (again given they've been playing together for a while now this shouldn't be an issue) or if it's mental, the pressures of being favourites getting to them, but something is not working and Southgate has a week to figure it out.

I suppose that when I say the system, what I mean is the personnel in the positions they are currently playing. It's not that this formation doesn't work, but the roles being asked of players don't amount to much.
Reply
Wàāăąªàáâãäåaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!!!!!1!

Don't think we captured the meltdown enough and I was also concerned I wasn't actively or effectively contributing.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: