England vs Slovakia
(07-01-2024, 07:14 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: My conclusion from the games played so far is you can't play Bellingham and Kane together. But at the same time it would be very difficult to justify dropping either of them.

And success ful tournament football is not necessarily about playing attractive football, but about getting through each stage, anyway you can..

I disagree. It’s Bellingham and Foden that creates a problem. They both play in the same position - albeit a fluid one - for their clubs but Southgate’s insistence on them both playing is one of our major problems.  If there is a plan - which may be a moot point - he should drop one or other of them (I.e.not Bellingham) and put Palmer in. Palmer has shown he is willing to play wherever is needed and influence the game. I think his movement is far less predictable and his passing is probably the best of anyone bar TAA in the squad. But it won’t happen. Southgate’s stubbornness- a useful quality heretofore - and tactical inability to change won’t allow him to do so. IMO.
Reply
I wonder how many people turned off the game just before the end of stoppage time after 90 mins, to make dinner, or left a pub to go home for dinner?
Reply
(07-01-2024, 06:58 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-30-2024, 11:25 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: What surprises and disappoints me is that Southgate seems suddenly devoid of ideas. Our best player (arguably) has been Guehi - who would not have been playing if the donkey Maguire had been available. As the pundits wiffled on about the "massive half time talk" and the need to change things to get in the game - he did nothing. Just two subs, neither of them really game-changing, until the introduction of Toney with potentially just 2 minutes of our tournament remaining. How strange was that?

Had Toney even touched the ball before Bellingham worked his magic? Does Southgate get any credit for his inspired substitution? Not from me.

Phil Foden - I just don't see what the fuss is about with this strolling dilettante. Harry Kane - can't see what he offers as captain or main striker - awesome finisher but there needs to be a plan to get him the chances.

Southgate got out of jail tonight. I've not been a critic, but it's hard to draw positives from his recent efforts.

Guehi has been awful, and we miss Maguire.

Geuhi's defending for their goal last night would have made a League 1 player embarrassed

This, hundred percent. 

Every game he has gifted the opposition a clear cut chance through unforced errors. His positioning is the worst I have seen for some time. 

A blessing in disguise that he is out for the next game.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
Having reflected on the match with the benefit of a (not so) decent sleep

Performance wise we were poor against a team that man for man we were much stronger than, but we should be elated that we're still alive in the tournament and the result really is the most important thing. It's pretty obvious that things have gotten stale under Southgate but what wins a tournament is not losing games, and so far we are one of the few teams to have not lost a game. If we play like that against Switzerland we will struggle, but as a non tactical expert these are the two primary things that I think Southgate needs to improve:

1. I know this is obvious, but if we go behind don't sit quite as deep. It's fine to be a bit more defensive, it would be stupid to keep pushing everyone forwards, but don't just put EVERYONE behind the ball after we take the lead. We're good enough to not have to take the defensive shape of Andorra.

2. And this is the biggest one, trust the squad. We saw yesterday as soon as Palmer was brought on there was an impact, then Toney. I understand why Southgate wants to play Foden, Saka, Bellingham and Kane all at the same time because they are all quality players, but if it's not working we have options on the bench that are capable of changing a game. No disrespect to Slovakia, but England's second 11 are probably stronger on paper. Don't wait so long to make a change and put some faith in some of the players we have on the bench.

Thats my onions. With regard to the fans I think it's a shame that more people aren't focused on the fact that we're still in the tournament than Southgate's performance.

We're on a decent side of the draw with a good chance of progressing, and that seems to piss people off more than the excitement of going far in the competition.
Reply
(07-01-2024, 07:37 AM)Sliced Wrote: Having reflected on the match with the benefit of a (not so) decent sleep

Performance wise we were poor against a team that man for man we were much stronger than, but we should be elated that we're still alive in the tournament and the result really is the most important thing. It's pretty obvious that things have gotten stale under Southgate but what wins a tournament is not losing games, and so far we are one of the few teams to have not lost a game. If we play like that against Switzerland we will struggle, but as a non tactical expert these are the two primary things that I think Southgate needs to improve:

1. I know this is obvious, but if we go behind don't sit quite as deep. It's fine to be a bit more defensive, it would be stupid to keep pushing everyone forwards, but don't just put EVERYONE behind the ball after we take the lead. We're good enough to not have to take the defensive shape of Andorra.

2. And this is the biggest one, trust the squad. We saw yesterday as soon as Palmer was brought on there was an impact, then Toney. I understand why Southgate wants to play Foden, Saka, Bellingham and Kane all at the same time because they are all quality players, but if it's not working we have options on the bench that are capable of changing a game. No disrespect to Slovakia, but England's second 11 are probably stronger on paper. Don't wait so long to make a change and put some faith in some of the players we have on the bench.

Thats my onions. With regard to the fans I think it's a shame that more people aren't focused on the fact that we're still in the tournament than Southgate's performance.

We're on a decent side of the draw with a good chance of progressing, and that seems to piss people off more than the excitement of going far in the competition.

Sensible post.

Switzerland will be the first time in this tournament we've faced a truly strong opposition (one in the top 20 FIFA rankings) and we will need to be a little more defensive.

Guehi and Trippier (possibly) being out ought to help us as it should force Southgate into making both a shape and selection change which we sorely need. Whilst we have looked solid - individual errors aside - we simply have to carry more of a threat moving forward and the back 3 last night offered a lot more in this regard. We know the fullbacks are causing us issues with their lack of attacking threat putting pressure on Foden, Bellingham and Kane to do the creative work, who are then all making similar runs and crowding the middle.  Eze, Toney and Palmer all offered something completely different last night, Toney's physicality gave us an outlet we'd been lacking and he should be one of the first subs we make when chasing a goal, no matter what level you play at, having decent delivery into the box and a big lad to hit causes teams problems - especially after 70mins of defending, and both Palmer and Eze offer an unpredictability and ability to run with the ball that Foden seems to have lost in this set-up. Realise Konsa has been Southgate's go to, but I'd be looking at Gomez to come in for Guehi as he offers more flexibility to drop into any role across the back line.

Pickford

Gomez
Stones
Walker 

Saka 
Rice
Bellingham
Mainoo
TAA

Palmer

Kane
Reply
England remind me of us last season on a bad day.
Reply
Not so long ago we’d have been on the wrong end of a bit of magic and bemoaned our lack of it.

Southgate is doing what Southgate does. He’s a defensive negative “coach” and we progress with that extra quality. When that extra bit of tactical nous is required, as the opposing team are our equals, we struggle.

For Josh - it’s like comparing Albion under Bruce and Corberán. Same players in October 22 that went from underperforming and relegation candidates to play-off challengers. The players are petals, the 1-2% extra makes all the difference. There are very few gimmes in world football these days.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(07-01-2024, 07:57 AM)1952 Wrote: England remind me of us last season on a bad day.

I've said that before too. We / England always seem to want to pass back or at best sideways and don't look to attack. Get in their half, they've got defenders oh well we'll go back then... Our keeper's got the ball, tippy tappy it around and across the box and hope it doesn't get intercepted or someone makes a bad pass... It's dull as anything, I know some others alluded to how we(Brom) play and got shot down for it, yet oddly when the same is said about England it tends to be the shooter downers that are saying how dull it is.
Reply
(07-01-2024, 07:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-01-2024, 07:37 AM)Sliced Wrote: Having reflected on the match with the benefit of a (not so) decent sleep

Performance wise we were poor against a team that man for man we were much stronger than, but we should be elated that we're still alive in the tournament and the result really is the most important thing. It's pretty obvious that things have gotten stale under Southgate but what wins a tournament is not losing games, and so far we are one of the few teams to have not lost a game. If we play like that against Switzerland we will struggle, but as a non tactical expert these are the two primary things that I think Southgate needs to improve:

1. I know this is obvious, but if we go behind don't sit quite as deep. It's fine to be a bit more defensive, it would be stupid to keep pushing everyone forwards, but don't just put EVERYONE behind the ball after we take the lead. We're good enough to not have to take the defensive shape of Andorra.

2. And this is the biggest one, trust the squad. We saw yesterday as soon as Palmer was brought on there was an impact, then Toney. I understand why Southgate wants to play Foden, Saka, Bellingham and Kane all at the same time because they are all quality players, but if it's not working we have options on the bench that are capable of changing a game. No disrespect to Slovakia, but England's second 11 are probably stronger on paper. Don't wait so long to make a change and put some faith in some of the players we have on the bench.

Thats my onions. With regard to the fans I think it's a shame that more people aren't focused on the fact that we're still in the tournament than Southgate's performance.

We're on a decent side of the draw with a good chance of progressing, and that seems to piss people off more than the excitement of going far in the competition.

Sensible post.

Switzerland will be the first time in this tournament we've faced a truly strong opposition (one in the top 20 FIFA rankings) and we will need to be a little more defensive.

Guehi and Trippier (possibly) being out ought to help us as it should force Southgate into making both a shape and selection change which we sorely need. Whilst we have looked solid - individual errors aside - we simply have to carry more of a threat moving forward and the back 3 last night offered a lot more in this regard. We know the fullbacks are causing us issues with their lack of attacking threat putting pressure on Foden, Bellingham and Kane to do the creative work, who are then all making similar runs and crowding the middle.  Eze, Toney and Palmer all offered something completely different last night, Toney's physicality gave us an outlet we'd been lacking and he should be one of the first subs we make when chasing a goal, no matter what level you play at, having decent delivery into the box and a big lad to hit causes teams problems - especially after 70mins of defending, and both Palmer and Eze offer an unpredictability and ability to run with the ball that Foden seems to have lost in this set-up. Realise Konsa has been Southgate's go to, but I'd be looking at Gomez to come in for Guehi as he offers more flexibility to drop into any role across the back line.

Pickford

Gomez
Stones
Walker 

Saka 
Rice
Bellingham
Mainoo
TAA

Palmer

Kane

I think Shaw may play after listening to Southgate. Also Konsa came on last night over Gomez at LB so that shows it'll be Konsa to replace Guehi. Can't see him starting a back 3 as he changed it back pretty quickly after we went 2-1 up, sadly. 

Pickford
Walker Stones Konsa Shaw
Mainoo Rice
Saka Bellingham Foden
Kane

That's what he will pick. 

I would go;

Pickford
Walker Stones Konsa
Saka Mainoo Rice Eze
Foden Bellingham
Kane
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(07-01-2024, 07:57 AM)1952 Wrote: England remind me of us last season on a bad day.

I thought the same with the sloppy passing.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: