The not racist party
#21
(06-28-2024, 10:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Yet on every measure Britain remains one of the most liberal and least racist societies in the world.

If you want to see what your patronising politics of censure can lead to then just look over the channel where the beleaguered leaders of Germany & France have just been stitching up EU posts for their buddies. Italy has already moved sharply to the right. France could soon follow squeezing out Petit Napoleon's centrist dream.

Brexit was to appease the Tory right who were petrified of UKIP, it was built on lies, driven by right wing populist and Trump acolyte in Farage and then sold to those that voted for it by a serial liar in Johnson. Your ex-party has been appeasing UKiP and now Reform leaders and voters for years, what’s the result? A battered, discredited, failed government and party with a cohort of Brexit 2019 MPs like Gullis, and 30p Lee representing them or in the latter case defecting to the party/rebranded party they looked to curtail the influence of. More immigration than previously from around the globe as we end free movement in the EU which has only emboldened Reform and damaged your party further because you led people who are against immigration up the garden path with claims of controlling our borders and pretending that UK workers would suddenly all decide to pick fruit and work for minimum wage in care homes. 

Blaming those who aren’t pandering to Reform tactics and ideology, pulling their punches to appease them whilst in reality lying to them is not the ‘nuanced’ position you think it is. It’s wrecked your ex-party and it will continue to drag it further into a civil war as the dust settles after the election next week. You always try to blame the onlookers whilst excusing the architects and builders as the house of cards collapses.
Reply
#22
(06-28-2024, 10:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: If you want to see what your patronising politics of censure can lead to then just look over the channel where the beleaguered leaders of Germany & France have just been stitching up EU posts for their buddies

I do find it remarkable how fervent Brexit supporters are incapable of understanding the parallels of selections for positions in the European Commission with how government positions are selected.

I suggest you add up how many seats EPP, S&D and Renew won at the recent European elections and get back to me.
Reply
#23
(06-29-2024, 08:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Ok I’ll bite, how did Labour ‘virtually destroy company pension schemes’?

In one of his first and most damaging acts Gordon Brown took away Advanced Corporation Tax Relief. A typically crass stealth tax grab that raised little for the Treasury but led to disaster for private company DB pension funds. 

Before 1997 every £100 in dividends received by a pension fund would receive a tax credit of £25. After the tax credit was axed most employers were unable or unwilling to make up the shortfall. To 2014 it removed a cumulative £230bn from the pension system, that'll be the thick end of £500bn today.  

Rising life expectancy made the pension promises companies had made increasingly expensive. And scheme deficits ballooned in the wake of the 2007/08 financial crisis as the Brown's massive and deranged quantitative easing programme helped drive down gilt yields.

Is that enough for you?
Reply
#24
(06-29-2024, 08:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(06-28-2024, 07:46 PM)Lindenbaggie Wrote:
(06-28-2024, 06:19 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Describing Labour as too risky after the last 14 years is a hoot

Maybe so. This campaign is not too dissimilar to 1997, after 19 years of Thatcher and Major.  Blair had a massive majority, and we believed he had an opportunity to create a much fairer society, but he and Brown disappointed us by opening the gates to "rub the Tories noses in diversity". Who suffered the most from that?  He and Brown then proceeded to virtually destroy company pension schemes which their traditional working class supporters were hoping to benefit from, but maintained taxpayer funded inflation proof pensions for those around the government apparatus. Their present silence on issues in my opinion need to be taken as a warning that  very hard times are coming for the taxpayer, but they'll just say "we've been very clear all along".

Ok I’ll bite, how did Labour ‘virtually destroy company pension schemes’?

Example: Lucas industries had a highly rated pension scheme for its workforce/pensioners, and the firm itself bore all the administration costs. Pensions were paid from dividends received, which were reduced as a result of Brown's withdrawal of a tax credit in respect of such dividends. This resulted in a massive exercise to determine how the pension scheme could meet its liabiliities long term, which straightaway proved the situation was nonviable, especially if new starters were allowed to join. To be fair to Lucas, they arranged for Legal and General to take on liabilities for some pensioners should they believe their pensions offered more security. Other firms will have had to come to the same conclusion, because of unaffordability. Trusting this makes sense.

But my greatest gripe is that year on year, our union officials were pursuing improved benefits from the scheme, but took the Labour Party line after Brown's interference. The party I always believed was for the working man suddenly became anything but.
Reply
#25
(06-29-2024, 11:12 AM)Lindenbaggie Wrote: But my greatest gripe is that year on year, our union officials were pursuing improved benefits from the scheme, but took the Labour Party line after Brown's interference. The party I always believed was for the working man suddenly became anything but.

Absolutely true. Imagine the outrage from the unions if a Tory Chancellor would've vandalised DB pensions like this.
Reply
#26
(06-29-2024, 10:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-29-2024, 08:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Ok I’ll bite, how did Labour ‘virtually destroy company pension schemes’?

In one of his first and most damaging acts Gordon Brown took away Advanced Corporation Tax Relief. A typically crass stealth tax grab that raised little for the Treasury but led to disaster for private company DB pension funds. 

Before 1997 every £100 in dividends received by a pension fund would receive a tax credit of £25. After the tax credit was axed most employers were unable or unwilling to make up the shortfall. To 2014 it removed a cumulative £230bn from the pension system, that'll be the thick end of £500bn today.  

Rising life expectancy made the pension promises companies had made increasingly expensive. And scheme deficits ballooned in the wake of the 2007/08 financial crisis as the Brown's massive and deranged quantitative easing programme helped drive down gilt yields.

Is that enough for you?

So if I'm clear here, the tax payer were better off by £230Bn in 2014 and anecdotal £500Bn by today. Am I missing something here but the £25 for every £100 received from dividends was coming out of the public purse and not the company that ran the scheme. Added to that people are getting older, is that also Brown's fault?

So just to clarify are you saying that the tax payer should have been propping up private company pension schemes? That doesn't sound very Proth to me.

(06-29-2024, 11:12 AM)Lindenbaggie Wrote:
(06-29-2024, 08:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(06-28-2024, 07:46 PM)Lindenbaggie Wrote:
(06-28-2024, 06:19 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Describing Labour as too risky after the last 14 years is a hoot

Maybe so. This campaign is not too dissimilar to 1997, after 19 years of Thatcher and Major.  Blair had a massive majority, and we believed he had an opportunity to create a much fairer society, but he and Brown disappointed us by opening the gates to "rub the Tories noses in diversity". Who suffered the most from that?  He and Brown then proceeded to virtually destroy company pension schemes which their traditional working class supporters were hoping to benefit from, but maintained taxpayer funded inflation proof pensions for those around the government apparatus. Their present silence on issues in my opinion need to be taken as a warning that  very hard times are coming for the taxpayer, but they'll just say "we've been very clear all along".

Ok I’ll bite, how did Labour ‘virtually destroy company pension schemes’?

Example: Lucas industries had a highly rated pension scheme for its workforce/pensioners, and the firm itself bore all the administration costs. Pensions were paid from dividends received, which were reduced as a result of Brown's withdrawal of a tax credit in respect of such dividends. This resulted in a massive exercise to determine how the pension scheme could meet its liabiliities long term, which straightaway proved the situation was nonviable, especially if new starters were allowed to join. To be fair to Lucas, they arranged for Legal and General to take on liabilities for some pensioners should they believe their pensions offered more security. Other firms will have had to come to the same conclusion, because of unaffordability. Trusting this makes sense.

But my greatest gripe is that year on year, our union officials were pursuing improved benefits from the scheme, but took the Labour Party line after Brown's interference. The party I always believed was for the working man suddenly became anything but.

These pension schemes were unaffordable long term LB with or without the govt chucking 20% into the pot. They were set up with a view to paying out over 10 years max on a DB basis, when people started living longer then they needed more people employed to fill the gap, this was a time of automation and reducing workforces which meant it simply wasn't sustainable whether or not Brown made those changes.
Reply
#27
Proth doesn’t want people sucking on the teet of the state unless it’s the inefficient private system plumping it’s coffers at the expense of working people
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#28
(06-29-2024, 03:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So if I'm clear here, the tax payer were better off by £230Bn in 2014 and anecdotal £500Bn by today. Am I missing something here but the £25 for every £100 received from dividends was coming out of the public purse and not the company that ran the scheme. Added to that people are getting older, is that also Brown's fault?

So just to clarify are you saying that the tax payer should have been propping up private company pension schemes? That doesn't sound very Proth to me.

No, because the vast majority of DB funds closed to new members and largely divested from equities into fixed income instruments to pay pensions.

This divestment led partly to the £425bn diminution in pension fund value after Truss' mini-budget as fund managers dumped gilts, and has also directly contributed to the LSE's problems as DB pension funds were a major purchaser of UK-listed stocks, and no longer are.

An abject disaster on every level. 

Did I mention he also sold half our gold at $280/oz (currently trading at $£2,300/oz)?

Bloke's a fucking cretin.
Reply
#29
The hours must fly by…
Reply
#30
(06-28-2024, 06:28 PM)Ossian Wrote:
(06-28-2024, 06:13 PM)Lindenbaggie Wrote: Sorry but despite wishing for a change myself, Labour are far too risky for me.

Well, it's either them or 5 more years of the Tories.

There are no other outcomes available.

Jeez. So electing Cameron who walked away when he didn't see a fairly obvious outcome wasn't risky? Or electing a proven liar (and buffoon)?  Or a complete maniac that crashed the economy in a few weeks? And now an utter incompetent?  
No, FFS, don't take any risks.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)