Posts: 7,995
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
It doesn't have to be one or the other, it is possible to admit that Southgate has done well in previous tournaments, yet still raise concern that he's not, in terms of performances, doing very well in this one.
That's pretty much where I sit and I would imagine Southgate himself is having the same concerns and not just patting himself on the back for what's happened in the past.
He says though that he wants the fans on board so he has to realise that that is his responsibility and not ours. The, much slated, England fans have proved many times that it's not about winning, we've never won anything in my lifetime, and that they can be magnanimous in defeat, provided their passion is matched on the pitch. That's what he needs to take into the knockout stages. Irrespective of the bullshit churned out on here, we have some of the best fans in the world, who will rally in the face of adversity, he just needs to give us something to reignite our belief.. Whatever the result on Sunday we need to come out fighting.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
(06-26-2024, 03:03 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It doesn't have to be one or the other, it is possible to admit that Southgate has done well in previous tournaments, yet still raise concern that he's not, in terms of performances, doing very well in this one.
That's pretty much where I sit and I would imagine Southgate himself is having the same concerns and not just patting himself on the back for what's happened in the past.
He says though that he wants the fans on board so he has to realise that that is his responsibility and not ours. The, much slated, England fans have proved many times that it's not about winning, we've never won anything in my lifetime, and that they can be magnanimous in defeat, provided their passion is matched on the pitch. That's what he needs to take into the knockout stages. Irrespective of the bullshit churned out on here, we have some of the best fans in the world, who will rally in the face of adversity, he just needs to give us something to reignite our belief.. Whatever the result on Sunday we need to come out fighting. Josh thinks we are all wankers
Posts: 7,995
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(06-26-2024, 03:10 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (06-26-2024, 03:03 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It doesn't have to be one or the other, it is possible to admit that Southgate has done well in previous tournaments, yet still raise concern that he's not, in terms of performances, doing very well in this one.
That's pretty much where I sit and I would imagine Southgate himself is having the same concerns and not just patting himself on the back for what's happened in the past.
He says though that he wants the fans on board so he has to realise that that is his responsibility and not ours. The, much slated, England fans have proved many times that it's not about winning, we've never won anything in my lifetime, and that they can be magnanimous in defeat, provided their passion is matched on the pitch. That's what he needs to take into the knockout stages. Irrespective of the bullshit churned out on here, we have some of the best fans in the world, who will rally in the face of adversity, he just needs to give us something to reignite our belief.. Whatever the result on Sunday we need to come out fighting. Josh thinks we are all wankers Of course we have idiots, but every country does. The vast majority though have shelled out hard earned cash to go there in the hope of finally seeing us lift a trophy and they do so draped head to toe in England garb. They are passionate and committed, moreso than me, because I'm sat at home or in the pub, and booing does not make them "idiots" or "shameful" it's just an outpouring of passion at what is a passionate game.
Posts: 4,768
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
27
(06-26-2024, 03:10 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (06-26-2024, 03:03 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It doesn't have to be one or the other, it is possible to admit that Southgate has done well in previous tournaments, yet still raise concern that he's not, in terms of performances, doing very well in this one.
That's pretty much where I sit and I would imagine Southgate himself is having the same concerns and not just patting himself on the back for what's happened in the past.
He says though that he wants the fans on board so he has to realise that that is his responsibility and not ours. The, much slated, England fans have proved many times that it's not about winning, we've never won anything in my lifetime, and that they can be magnanimous in defeat, provided their passion is matched on the pitch. That's what he needs to take into the knockout stages. Irrespective of the bullshit churned out on here, we have some of the best fans in the world, who will rally in the face of adversity, he just needs to give us something to reignite our belief.. Whatever the result on Sunday we need to come out fighting. Josh thinks we are all wankers
Well my lad was out there and I'm pretty sure he wanks himself into oblivion so he's probably right about at least one of you  .
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(06-26-2024, 02:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: As with all things, it’s about context.
Southgate has done a great job rebuilding the England culture, uniting the team (and until recently, the fans) and structurally we look a lot more consistent between the main team and youth teams, with players coming through regularly. Behind the scenes the whole set up seems far more aligned and as if there is a plan - for this he deserves a lot of credit. He has, in the main, also picked players to fit a system and been less likely to just pick from the top clubs.
However, as he showed at Middlesbrough, he is incredibly limited when it comes to in game management, and there are question marks around his tactical abilities - even players are alluding to it now. He has been very fortunate in the tournaments to date that he’s consistently had paths to the final rounds that have avoided bigger sides, and it looks like we have the same fortune this time round. I saw a stat yesterday that suggests against sides in the top 10 ranking he has won 4 of 26 games - this is where he needs to be judged for me. In both the Croatia and Italy games the same tactical nous was lacking, and I’m yet to see him influence a game when we’ve been under the cosh. It’s very much Plan A is all he has, and if it’s wrong we need a moment of quality to get through tough game.
Overall, he probably deserved this tournament on previous form, but the cracks have been showing for some time. I think it will be a very brave club side that appoints him after his England exit, I think he’d be far better suited to another National job somewhere that’s trying to build an identity and has a long term plan to improve.
This.
Thanks to Southgate I don't laugh when England get humiliated by other teams now, and actually want us to do well. I think this is the end for him now though, but I'm not sure that whoever next will do better, but they'll at least get a chance with the fans, Southgate doesn't have that now it seems.
Posts: 3,821
Threads: 250
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(06-26-2024, 05:04 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (06-26-2024, 02:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: As with all things, it’s about context.
Southgate has done a great job rebuilding the England culture, uniting the team (and until recently, the fans) and structurally we look a lot more consistent between the main team and youth teams, with players coming through regularly. Behind the scenes the whole set up seems far more aligned and as if there is a plan - for this he deserves a lot of credit. He has, in the main, also picked players to fit a system and been less likely to just pick from the top clubs.
However, as he showed at Middlesbrough, he is incredibly limited when it comes to in game management, and there are question marks around his tactical abilities - even players are alluding to it now. He has been very fortunate in the tournaments to date that he’s consistently had paths to the final rounds that have avoided bigger sides, and it looks like we have the same fortune this time round. I saw a stat yesterday that suggests against sides in the top 10 ranking he has won 4 of 26 games - this is where he needs to be judged for me. In both the Croatia and Italy games the same tactical nous was lacking, and I’m yet to see him influence a game when we’ve been under the cosh. It’s very much Plan A is all he has, and if it’s wrong we need a moment of quality to get through tough game.
Overall, he probably deserved this tournament on previous form, but the cracks have been showing for some time. I think it will be a very brave club side that appoints him after his England exit, I think he’d be far better suited to another National job somewhere that’s trying to build an identity and has a long term plan to improve.
This.
Thanks to Southgate I don't laugh when England get humiliated by other teams now, and actually want us to do well. I think this is the end for him now though, but I'm not sure that whoever next will do better, but they'll at least get a chance with the fans, Southgate doesn't have that now it seems.
Luckily - Fat Bloke from the Pub last night will be there to step in! 
They know a lot - Fat Blokes!
Posts: 3,848
Threads: 97
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
7
It’s shocking when you look at Germany’s record:
7 x Winners (4 WC 3 EC)
7 x Runners Up ( 4 WC 3 EC)
8 x Semi-Finalists (5 WC 3 EC)
Makes you want to weep!
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
I get the feeling that Southgate just isn’t ‘blokey’ enough for some of our more Ingurland rather than England fans. He’s not a suave foreign manager, he’s not a cheeky cockernee/ or dead ard working class hero. He’s a thoughtful man who seems at ease with the modern world, dare I say he’s a bit too woke for some. If this was a Terry Venables type manager I have my doubts the criticism would be quite so loud… oi oi!
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(06-26-2024, 06:00 PM)HugeHons Wrote: It’s shocking when you look at Germany’s record:
7 x Winners (4 WC 3 EC)
7 x Runners Up ( 4 WC 3 EC)
8 x Semi-Finalists (5 WC 3 EC)
Makes you want to weep!
There’s a lot in the mentality piece and the identity of a national side - we haven’t had that in the 30 years or so I’ve watched football. This is the closest we’ve had to that, and 2 semi finals and a final in the last 2 tournaments is a testament to how far we have come - but we do now need something a little more.
That being said even putting aside the selection mistakes for this squad, I think we have 2-3 real gaps in our side that will prevent us from being a top side currently. I’m not sure winning it is a realistic goal for this tournament but playing a bit better than we are is not out of the question.
Posts: 142
Threads: 1
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
Again a very similar performance to what has gone before. The fans I thought were superb last night especially 2nd half willing them on to score and get the job done, whilst watching a poor game.
The plastic cup is becoming a symbol of the euros - success and a showering of the amber nectar or an empty vessel , the latter which pretty much sums up how the media and a large majority of the fan base feel right now.
As some have said fans go to a great expense supporting the team not just at the tournament in Germany but during the qualifiers as well, they invest a lot supporting England, they have a right to vent their frustrations.
The job ought to fit Southgate perfectly by now - 6 years in the role, plus experienced earned with near misses. I could understand if the team was in decline with players now past their prime, but we are not. The talent at his disposal grows given the rise of Bellingham and the growth of Foden at City, and more players coming into the setup Mainoo,Wharton albeit late introductions but players selected by Gareth.
All I hope, is he leaves with no regrets and opens up his approach during the knockout stage. The players look frustrated to me, and if no clear direction as he goes from TAA to Gallagher and now Mainoo.. feels, to me like a manger who is unclear what to do, and maybe that feeds into the players.
Maybe Gareth is not ruthlessness enough to make the big changes (Kane has offered little) and possibly loyalty may get the better of him. Hope not.
|