Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(06-14-2024, 05:19 PM)Morley Wrote: (06-14-2024, 05:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (06-14-2024, 04:11 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-14-2024, 04:00 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (06-14-2024, 01:48 PM)Squid Wrote: Absolutely not.
Madonna was a cultural icon, the most famous woman in the world at her peak and pretty much everyone knew several of her songs, whereas the general public might struggle to whistle more than one Taylor Swift song.
Absolutely not x 2
Difference is simply in a world where all culture, news etc came through a narrow band of TV, radio and newspapers a lot of the population were well aware of famous people. Boy George appeared on Top of the Pops and within a few weeks the whole country watching BBC, reading newspapers etc could not help but know who he is. Even people like my dad, knew who that 'quare fella who looks like a woman' was.
I now, despite having kids in their late teens, genuinely know nothing much about Taylor Swift. My kids don't rate her or have any interest in her either. My 20 year old daughter who is a regular concert goer thinks she's hyped crap- my daughter is off to see Lana Del Rey in the summer in Paris.
The parameters of fame has completely changed since many of us old gits were kids - it may affect anonymity, but saying she is bigger than Madonna is like saying One Direction were bigger than the Beatles. You deserve a cyber shoeing!
Fact is on here if we met them in a street more of us would know John Swift than Taylor Swift.
Or perhaps a West Brom forum filled almost exclusively with middle aged blokes isn’t the best place to judge the popularity of Taylor Swift?
I can’t say I’m a massive fan but there’s little doubting she’s one of the biggest pop stars who has ever lived (note: size and quality are not the same). She’s sold out 8 eight nights at Wembley on this tour, which is the joint biggest residency at that stadium by a single act. Her album releases are global events, her movements - who she dates, where she eats, every aspect of her life is documented in painstaking detail by millions of rabid fans.
We on here don’t have to get it. It’s not for us. But she is without doubt a bona fide pop culture behemoth.
And of course, the usual, all the craic I grew up with was better blah blah blah comes into play too. There's no difference between Swift and Madonna tbh.
Absolute nonsense. No difference? Madonna had cracking tits, mine are better than Taylors.
 Brilliant!!
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(06-14-2024, 04:11 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-14-2024, 04:00 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (06-14-2024, 01:48 PM)Squid Wrote: (06-14-2024, 01:17 PM)Cornflake Wrote: My daughter went and loved it. I'm too old and not my thing but she's huge - I'd say bigger than Madonna ever was now, and is a great role model so fair play I say!
Absolutely not.
Madonna was a cultural icon, the most famous woman in the world at her peak and pretty much everyone knew several of her songs, whereas the general public might struggle to whistle more than one Taylor Swift song.
Absolutely not x 2
Difference is simply in a world where all culture, news etc came through a narrow band of TV, radio and newspapers a lot of the population were well aware of famous people. Boy George appeared on Top of the Pops and within a few weeks the whole country watching BBC, reading newspapers etc could not help but know who he is. Even people like my dad, knew who that 'quare fella who looks like a woman' was.
I now, despite having kids in their late teens, genuinely know nothing much about Taylor Swift. My kids don't rate her or have any interest in her either. My 20 year old daughter who is a regular concert goer thinks she's hyped crap- my daughter is off to see Lana Del Rey in the summer in Paris.
The parameters of fame has completely changed since many of us old gits were kids - it may affect anonymity, but saying she is bigger than Madonna is like saying One Direction were bigger than the Beatles. You deserve a cyber shoeing!
Fact is on here if we met them in a street more of us would know John Swift than Taylor Swift.
Or perhaps a West Brom forum filled almost exclusively with middle aged blokes isn’t the best place to judge the popularity of Taylor Swift?
I can’t say I’m a massive fan but there’s little doubting she’s one of the biggest pop stars who has ever lived (note: size and quality are not the same). She’s sold out 8 eight nights at Wembley on this tour, which is the joint biggest residency at that stadium by a single act. Her album releases are global events, her movements - who she dates, where she eats, every aspect of her life is documented in painstaking detail by millions of rabid fans.
We on here don’t have to get it. It’s not for us. But she is without doubt a bona fide pop culture behemoth. Is c'rect, Duffers. I don't see any logic behind saying one is bigger than t'other. They are both cultural icons and huge stars. One thing we should all be thankful for is that they both (whether their music is your cup of tea or not), are original. I won't rush out to buy either but when they come on the radio it doesn't offend my ears like that Simon Cowell or Stock, Aitkin, Waterman mass produced inane drivel. Good luck to TS, she seems a decent enough role model.
Posts: 1,171
Threads: 103
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
6
It’s like Tyson v Ali, Messi v Maradona etc etc.
No real way of proving any of it as the environment is so changed.
All makes decent debate though.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
It’s like comparing Michael Jackson to Gary Glitter
Posts: 3,821
Threads: 250
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(06-14-2024, 06:01 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: It’s like comparing Michael Jackson to Gary Glitter 
But - whose gang would you rather be in??
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
06-14-2024, 06:21 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-14-2024, 06:22 PM by Squid.)
(06-14-2024, 04:11 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-14-2024, 04:00 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (06-14-2024, 01:48 PM)Squid Wrote: (06-14-2024, 01:17 PM)Cornflake Wrote: My daughter went and loved it. I'm too old and not my thing but she's huge - I'd say bigger than Madonna ever was now, and is a great role model so fair play I say!
Absolutely not.
Madonna was a cultural icon, the most famous woman in the world at her peak and pretty much everyone knew several of her songs, whereas the general public might struggle to whistle more than one Taylor Swift song.
Absolutely not x 2
Difference is simply in a world where all culture, news etc came through a narrow band of TV, radio and newspapers a lot of the population were well aware of famous people. Boy George appeared on Top of the Pops and within a few weeks the whole country watching BBC, reading newspapers etc could not help but know who he is. Even people like my dad, knew who that 'quare fella who looks like a woman' was.
I now, despite having kids in their late teens, genuinely know nothing much about Taylor Swift. My kids don't rate her or have any interest in her either. My 20 year old daughter who is a regular concert goer thinks she's hyped crap- my daughter is off to see Lana Del Rey in the summer in Paris.
The parameters of fame has completely changed since many of us old gits were kids - it may affect anonymity, but saying she is bigger than Madonna is like saying One Direction were bigger than the Beatles. You deserve a cyber shoeing!
Fact is on here if we met them in a street more of us would know John Swift than Taylor Swift.
Or perhaps a West Brom forum filled almost exclusively with middle aged blokes isn’t the best place to judge the popularity of Taylor Swift?
I can’t say I’m a massive fan but there’s little doubting she’s one of the biggest pop stars who has ever lived (note: size and quality are not the same). She’s sold out 8 eight nights at Wembley on this tour, which is the joint biggest residency at that stadium by a single act. Her album releases are global events, her movements - who she dates, where she eats, every aspect of her life is documented in painstaking detail by millions of rabid fans.
We on here don’t have to get it. It’s not for us. But she is without doubt a bona fide pop culture behemoth.
There's a difference between selling lots of records/having an ardent fanbase and changing popular culture forever. Taylor Swift is the former and Madonna is the latter.
Taylor Swift doesn't even have a big crossover, everyone knows it hit song. To contrast with Beyoncé as a modern day example, most people with ears know Single Ladies and Crazy in Love.
Also, the cultured MCW types on here should know that it takes more than record/ticket sales to be a hugely influential cultural icon. Björk won't be selling out any stadiums any time soon, but her look/artistry and vocals have influenced many, many artists.
Posts: 1,976
Threads: 163
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
I worked at a few of her shows at Wembley Stadium, last time she toured a few years ago. Not my kind of thing, but she did put on a good show. What I can't work out is why these shows are suddenly Earth shattering events. If I was working still, I'd be at the Wembley shows.
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
(06-14-2024, 03:32 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: (06-14-2024, 10:39 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (06-14-2024, 10:38 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Please continue to post on here
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/50609...r-thoughts
Gonna sign up shortly. I may have to flinch off hear and switch codes.
(06-14-2024, 10:37 AM)MrBater Wrote: Mrs is taking her kid to wembley a week on Sunday. Each to their own and whatever brings you joy, but I think all her songs sound the same and she's just a modern day Kylie / Madonna mix...
Glad you enjoyed it though...
As an aside I think the Mrs paid £100ish per ticket, on some reseller sites they were hitting almost £5k per ticket, she's got 4.... I'd be cashing in the £20k if it was me  Makes the £500 I was offered seem insulting.
You were offered £500 and turned it down
Are you nuts?
Being in attendance was priceless to me. Laugh and mock Taylor Swift, or those who like her music if you like, you're entitled to your opinion, and there's nothing outrageous being posted on here tbf, but to me she's so talented, and the only current artist I can listen to and enjoy. I couldn't name the current no.1 or any artist in the top 10, but there's something unique, to me, about Swift. I think she's superb, and have done since her Fearless album when I first heard it when I was at college.
I'm not getting embroiled in any debate comparing her to other artists. I can't comment about Mandona, anyway, she was before my time, but her music is nothing like Taylor's. I understand the argument is about how big they were. Taylor Swift has sold out Anfield for 3 consecutive dates, Wembley for numerous dates, and this is repeated across major venues around Europe and the US. Yesterday was her 100th show of this tour, all sold out, and tickets like gold dust. It was a 3.5 hour show without any meaningful break. She didn't mime, as far as I could tell, played guitar and piano at various stages, I think that's some talent and the number of stadium sells outs prove how popular and big she is.
How many acts could sell out stadiums like she is currently doing?
I've pre-ordered her vinyl releases for a number of years now, and it was brilliant I was able to get pre-sale tickets on that basis. As mentioned above it's nice to have some loyalty rewarded.
I've no idea why I'm getting so passionate about this, music really isn't that big in my life, and I'm aware how sad I'm coming across.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
If it makes you happy it's not sad.
If we disagree then we disagree.
I'm sure she puts on a cracking show with all the lights, dancing and costumes. Personally I prefer a band that puts the music first. Which is why I prefer metal.
Posts: 11,927
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
I'm here for Josh and his fandom. I'm not even taking the piss (for once). Swifty isn't my kind of thing but it there must be something about her mass appeal for her to be so popular and... see U2, Coldplay and loads of other bands that just divide opinion.
We should feel comfortable in declaring our 'uncool truths'. There is room for pop, even amongst this MCW dessert of cool.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
|