11 Year Itch
#1
It's only taken the Tories 11 years to realise the error of creating an inequitable cliff edge by gradually withdrawing Child Benefit after just one earner in a household went over an income of £50K.

I know of at least one member of this board who had to take a loan out to pay back the resulting tax charge.

But the cynicism of this announcement today, followed by the inevitable narrative of "Will Labour match this pledge" leaves me simply rolling my eyes. 

And £1.5 billion has to be found - apparently by cracking down on tax avoidance (legal) and tax evasion (illegal). This idea is doing a lot of heavy lifting for both parties, and is just bullshit. If you crackdown on legal avoidance, then individuals will either pay more tax (so a tax rise) or they'll change behaviour (so you won't raise anything) - and if you can raise so much through cracking down on evasion - then why on Earth haven't you been doing that for 14 years?
Reply
#2
Rowls, I think, if I remember rightly.

It was a daft policy in itself but the way it was drawn up was as if they’d given it to the work experience lad to work on for an hour before publishing it
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#3
Just done the numbers over lunch and it creates a 70% marginal tax rate if you're earning over £120,000 and have three children...
Reply
#4
Are you the same bloke that says those with wealth should pay their own way when it comes to pensioners?

And have you just added the negative effect of not receiving a benefit to include that in a taxation calculation?
Reply
#5
(06-07-2024, 01:10 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Are you the same bloke that says those with wealth should pay their own way when it comes to pensioners?

And have you just added the negative effect of not receiving a benefit to include that in a taxation calculation?

I don't understand the first question B1.

The 70% marginal rate calc is based the Tories press release this morning. They're saying that the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) phase out will move to £120K - £160K. Good news if you're on £60K where your marginal tax rate drops back down 42%. But that creates a new and very high marginal tax rate of 70% in my example of parents with 3 children earning between £120K - £125K.

Personal Allowance clawback already creates a 62% marginal rate for everyone earning £100K - £125K. The HICBC now partially overlaps the PA clawback. This 70% rate from £120-£125 then translates into a 55% marginal rate all the way up to £160K, reverting to 47% thereafter.

Marginal rates will be lower if you have fewer than 3 kids, higher if you have more than 3 kids.

Nor does the HMRC measure Household income. So not only does this create yet more perversity in the tax system, it would also be virtually impossible to police accurately.

There's nothing wrong with a higher rate of tax for higher earners, but there's everything wrong with marginal rate cliff faces like the HICBC and PA clawback designed by clever dicks who're too scared to increase the headline rates of tax.

Stupid. Irrational. Perverse. Impossible to implement, entirely consistent with much of the last 30 years of fiscal policy.
Reply
#6
CB should be a universal benefit. Shouldn't even be up for debate.
Reply
#7
I don’t disagree. And the personal tax system should also be simplified. The example above illustrates just how Byzantine it’s become.
Reply
#8
I agree with you
Reply
#9
The first question is your assertion that those with the affordability should pay for their own care. The parallel here is that those with the affordability should pay for their own child care.

BTW I agree the tax system is way too complex and needs to be simplified and the phased removal of benefits / allowances over a certain earning level creates confusion and unnecessary complications. My view is that PA should be kept for everyone no matter how much they earn, it is what it says on the tin, a personal allowance for everyone.

Child benefit should be capped at two kids but again a standard amount for each kid - when I started earning enough to get into that marginal allowance range for child allowance it became easier for us just to forego the whole benefit than have the tax code changing every couple of months due to the IR’s inability to calculate it properly.

And pensions should be standard for everyone over the appropriate age.

And agree over household income which has become impossible to work out in the modern world of two and three home families.

And agree on taxation thresholds
Reply
#10
I don’t agree that there’s any parallel between CB and the affluent elderly funding their own social care costs. Far from it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)