FAQ Corporate structuring spurts
#11
(06-07-2024, 12:00 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(06-07-2024, 10:24 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Massive gap in my knowledge here...

A service provider (food industry) has a director who set up 4 different companies all doing similar stuff within 6 weeks of each other last year.  He is the sole director of each and the address is the same for all companies - a warehouse/unit, not particularly big (so assuming using same infrastructure for all 4 businesses.  3 companies are in the same sector "Packaging" and the 4th looks like a side arm (Food Retail).

I assume he's trying to either a) sector off different elements of his business so if one becomes unviable then he can close it and write off liabilities whilst keeping the rest running or b) planning to shunt losses between companies for tax reasons.

Financial Spurts:  Assemble!

What's your guess as to why he's doing that and, as a potential customer of his, what should I look out for?

I can't speak with any authority on corporate accounting etc but I can on the food sector in general. On reading this I thought a couple of things.

What food is he packaging? If there are allergens (especially nuts) involved they require certain legislations with regards to keeping them separate from other foods and there are also bigger costs involved from a technical point of view so perhaps they want to keep them separate for accounting purposes?

Secondly are they dealing with multiple end users? Independent retail, food service, national retail/supermarkets, export etc? If so again they might want to keep them separate to see what arms of the business are most profitable as their 'cost to serve' models will be different for each of those.

These are just some thoughts as I work for a large cheese and fine food wholesaler who deal with multiple retail and food service sectors.

Cheers Peachy.  Yes to allergens - covers the full range.  They definitely do dry ambient stuff - don;'t think they're in cold chill etc.  Probably multiple end users - suspect there are a few retailers, D2C ecommerce etc... makes a lot of sense but no real need for me to feel concerned.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#12
(06-07-2024, 12:11 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(06-07-2024, 12:00 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(06-07-2024, 10:24 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Massive gap in my knowledge here...

A service provider (food industry) has a director who set up 4 different companies all doing similar stuff within 6 weeks of each other last year.  He is the sole director of each and the address is the same for all companies - a warehouse/unit, not particularly big (so assuming using same infrastructure for all 4 businesses.  3 companies are in the same sector "Packaging" and the 4th looks like a side arm (Food Retail).

I assume he's trying to either a) sector off different elements of his business so if one becomes unviable then he can close it and write off liabilities whilst keeping the rest running or b) planning to shunt losses between companies for tax reasons.

Financial Spurts:  Assemble!

What's your guess as to why he's doing that and, as a potential customer of his, what should I look out for?

I can't speak with any authority on corporate accounting etc but I can on the food sector in general. On reading this I thought a couple of things.

What food is he packaging? If there are allergens (especially nuts) involved they require certain legislations with regards to keeping them separate from other foods and there are also bigger costs involved from a technical point of view so perhaps they want to keep them separate for accounting purposes?

Secondly are they dealing with multiple end users? Independent retail, food service, national retail/supermarkets, export etc? If so again they might want to keep them separate to see what arms of the business are most profitable as their 'cost to serve' models will be different for each of those.

These are just some thoughts as I work for a large cheese and fine food wholesaler who deal with multiple retail and food service sectors.

Cheers Peachy.  Yes to allergens - covers the full range.  They definitely do dry ambient stuff - don;'t think they're in cold chill etc.  Probably multiple end users - suspect there are a few retailers, D2C ecommerce etc... makes a lot of sense but no real need for me to feel concerned.

No worries. Like I say I'm no legal spurt and keep well away from that side of the business. Just looking at it purely from a sales and cost angle.
Reply
#13
I'll just pay close attention to the payment terms etc and not overcommit in terms of risk
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#14
(06-07-2024, 10:31 AM)Hudds1 Wrote:
(06-07-2024, 10:24 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Massive gap in my knowledge here...

A service provider (food industry) has a director who set up 4 different companies all doing similar stuff within 6 weeks of each other last year.  He is the sole director of each and the address is the same for all companies - a warehouse/unit, not particularly big (so assuming using same infrastructure for all 4 businesses.  3 companies are in the same sector "Packaging" and the 4th looks like a side arm (Food Retail).

I assume he's trying to either a) sector off different elements of his business so if one becomes unviable then he can close it and write off liabilities whilst keeping the rest running or b) planning to shunt losses between companies for tax reasons.

Financial Spurts:  Assemble!

What's your guess as to why he's doing that and, as a potential customer of his, what should I look out for?

Check the sell by date on the sausages.

Does this explain ecoli outbreak?
Reply
#15
Possibly trying to avoid charging VAT, in order to keep the selling price down.  That would then mean each company can have annual sales of up to £85k as opposed to just the one £85k, before VAT needs to be charged.

As one of the business lines is direct to consumers, then there’s a benefit of not charging VAT.

However HMRC would want to ensure the businesses are different and that multiple companies haven’t been created just to avoid charging VAT.

But it may be the reason.
Reply
#16
(06-08-2024, 09:01 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Possibly trying to avoid charging VAT, in order to keep the selling price down.  That would then mean each company can have annual sales of up to £85k as opposed to just the one £85k, before VAT needs to be charged.

As one of the business lines is direct to consumers, then there’s a benefit of not charging VAT.

However HMRC would want to ensure the businesses are different and that multiple companies haven’t been created just to avoid charging VAT.

But it may be the reason.

Limit is 90k


Avoiding vat labilities was my first thought.
Reply
#17
Good point re vat. If he charged me VAT but was later found to be VAT excempt, what's the right of recourse?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#18
(06-08-2024, 10:00 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Good point re vat. If he charged me VAT but was later found to be VAT excempt, what's the right of recourse?

None. 

You must register for VAT if you believe your annual turnover will exceed the VAT threshold.  They might not hit the threshold, but the VAT will have been charged and passed to HMRC.
Reply
#19
Ta...
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#20
If it's a food company, the stuff may be zero rated so no VAT to added/passed on (depends what the food is).

Dodgy structure inter alia ought to fall foul of the Halifax abus de droit....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)