ICJ
#41
So is there any plan for what happens after they’ve ‘beaten’ Hamas?
Reply
#42
Get back to using Mossad to threaten the global courts for 9 more years id imagine

(05-29-2024, 01:19 PM)Pontificator Wrote:
(05-29-2024, 07:49 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: “I do wonder where you are from”. Wtf.

Same old argument isn’t it with anyone who expresses disdain for what Israel is doing - jump to claiming someone wants it wiped off the map. Pathetic. I’d like to see the two co exist in peace and for the Israeli govt to better represent its many decent people.

I’m not sure what you describe places where people of different ethnic backgrounds are given tiered rights or can’t access certain streets or services - most people call it apartheid.

I’ve answered Proths question - I would cease killing women, children and civilians, as we saw again yesterday. Would you?

"Israel is a genocidal apartheid state" to quote you correctly, (note you didn't give me the same respect) You haven't responded coherently at all. You trash Israel out of hand with no nuance whatsoever, I mean what is anyone supposed to think? I don't believe you want Israel wiped off the map because that would mean women and children being killed mind you who gives a fuck most of them are jews.

Ask me to answer the question, which I did.

What a shame you can’t maintain your own standards and state whether you’d like to see them stop bombing kids in tents or the like.

Strange thing to say about Jews - I see all the people involved primarily as humans, but clearly the religion of those involved is a bigger factor for you. Enough said.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#43
(05-29-2024, 03:20 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So is there any plan for what happens after they’ve ‘beaten’ Hamas?

There's no plan whatsoever.

People egging on, supporting and excusing what Israel is doing now are the worst possible friends for Israel.

Hamas cannot be beaten militarily, as generally guerilla terrorist groups can't. That Hamas are still able to fire rockets (however inefficient) at Tel Aviv after 8 months of war proves that. It has also set back Israel's relations with its neighbours by decades. While the 2006 Israel-Lebanon war was disastrous for the people of Lebanon, it only made Hezbollah stronger. Much stronger. Israel cannot wipe out its enemies and in trying to do so, is just making newer ones.

There has to be some deal for a genuinely independent Palestinian state or some kind of federal agreement as in Bosnia. And no, neither Gaza or the West Bank have ever come close to meeting that criteria.

All those who think that 7th October gives Israel the right to wage all-out war, really don't know your history. In Bosnia, the Muslims and Croats had to sit down and have peace talks with the Serbs, who had gleefully engaged in organised, planned genocide. But they still did it, because an imperfect peace is better than a perpetual war.
Reply
#44
(05-29-2024, 03:22 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Get back to using Mossad to threaten the global courts for 9 more years id imagine

(05-29-2024, 01:19 PM)Pontificator Wrote:
(05-29-2024, 07:49 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: “I do wonder where you are from”. Wtf.

Same old argument isn’t it with anyone who expresses disdain for what Israel is doing - jump to claiming someone wants it wiped off the map. Pathetic. I’d like to see the two co exist in peace and for the Israeli govt to better represent its many decent people.

I’m not sure what you describe places where people of different ethnic backgrounds are given tiered rights or can’t access certain streets or services - most people call it apartheid.

I’ve answered Proths question - I would cease killing women, children and civilians, as we saw again yesterday. Would you?

"Israel is a genocidal apartheid state" to quote you correctly, (note you didn't give me the same respect) You haven't responded coherently at all. You trash Israel out of hand with no nuance whatsoever, I mean what is anyone supposed to think? I don't believe you want Israel wiped off the map because that would mean women and children being killed mind you who gives a fuck most of them are jews.

Ask me to answer the question, which I did.

What a shame you can’t maintain your own standards and state whether you’d like to see them stop bombing kids in tents or the like.

Strange thing to say about Jews - I see all the people involved primarily as humans, but clearly the religion of those involved is a bigger factor for you. Enough said.

God save us from sanctimonious pacifists.
Reply
#45
Excellent paradox Ponty. Almost on a par with supporting one side of ruthless killers and condemning the other. ParadoxPonty it is.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#46
(05-30-2024, 07:19 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Excellent paradox Ponty. Almost on a par with supporting one side of ruthless killers and condemning the other. ParadoxPonty it is.

Apartheid and Genocidal State and now ruthless killers - Israel have my full support to do what they believe is necessary to defend themselves, just as the UK does.They should avoid killing civilians if they can whilst searching for their hostages and seeking out and destroying HAMAS. What would you do CraptainSanctimoneo?
Reply
#47
(05-30-2024, 07:59 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(05-30-2024, 07:19 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Excellent paradox Ponty. Almost on a par with supporting one side of ruthless killers and condemning the other. ParadoxPonty it is.

Apartheid and Genocidal State and now ruthless killers - Israel have my full support to do what they believe is necessary to defend themselves, just as the UK does.They should avoid killing civilians if they can whilst searching for their hostages and seeking out and destroying HAMAS. What would you do CraptainSanctimoneo?


In the real world, Israel have:

1)Killed tens of thousands of civilians, including children and aid workers.

2)Killed several hostages

3)Not destroyed Hamas. 


This is why people like you are terrible friends to Israel, because what Israel is doing clearly isn't working, yet you want them to do more of it.
Reply
#48
To summarise…

There is no plan after they have ‘succeeded’ in their military operation.
There is a naive or deliberate idea that they can destroy Hamas, when in reality they’ve made thousands of people more likely to join them.
There was no justification for what happened in October but you cannot bomb an ideology into submission.

Nothing has changed since I last decided to comment I imagine it’ll the same cyclical turn of events for the foreseeable future.
Reply
#49
In the real world Israel exists, if you believe in their right to exist you are a Zionist. You can criticise their government fine, but nowhere on this forum is there criticism of the Chinese and their genocidal actions against the Uyghur population There are no protest tents against China on the Brum Uni campus to influence the thousands of Chinese Students and the Chinese state.
1) Why is this?
2) what would you do?
Reply
#50
Ponti, lots of exceptionally hip folks from the likes of Moseley and Islington wear Che Guevara t-shirts despite the fact that he engaged in summary executions and was an extreme homophobe.

As Superhans once said "People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis, you can't trust people"
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: