Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-26-2024, 08:42 AM)Fido Wrote: Although I'm not really in favour per se there are some elements of this that could make sense if done in the right way, probably more in the community service area.
There are loads of kids, many of whom are from underprivileged backgrounds, who know as far as the boundaries of there own towns and that's about it. But on the flip side there are those with far more means that keep very much to their social circles and don't see the issues that others may face. School and academia might not necessarily be something that comes naturally to some so opening up options, giving an idea of self-worth within a community is not necessarily a bad thing.
With something like the DoE is that more often that not it's a suggestion by parents to have something to "put on the CV" and some kids would never see that as an option for themselves. I'm not sure what the take up is population-wise but would guess it's relatively small. There is a case to say that having something like this in place, with activities between mixes of kids from different backgrounds would be a way of broadening horizons for all. I know most will see this as solely a way of instilling discipline via the military route but it could be a lot more than that.
Make it voluntary then and get the private sector to pay for it.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-26-2024, 08:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-26-2024, 08:42 AM)Fido Wrote: Although I'm not really in favour per se there are some elements of this that could make sense if done in the right way, probably more in the community service area.
There are loads of kids, many of whom are from underprivileged backgrounds, who know as far as the boundaries of there own towns and that's about it. But on the flip side there are those with far more means that keep very much to their social circles and don't see the issues that others may face. School and academia might not necessarily be something that comes naturally to some so opening up options, giving an idea of self-worth within a community is not necessarily a bad thing.
With something like the DoE is that more often that not it's a suggestion by parents to have something to "put on the CV" and some kids would never see that as an option for themselves. I'm not sure what the take up is population-wise but would guess it's relatively small. There is a case to say that having something like this in place, with activities between mixes of kids from different backgrounds would be a way of broadening horizons for all. I know most will see this as solely a way of instilling discipline via the military route but it could be a lot more than that.
Make it voluntary then and get the private sector to pay for it.
And then next to no-one would do it. How many kids do you think wouldn't go to school if it wasn't compulsory? It's bad enough now when it is.
Have another try. Bear in mind you are the one that probably moans most about feral kids with no manners and no sense of direction, by the way.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
05-26-2024, 09:16 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-26-2024, 09:32 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(05-26-2024, 08:53 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-26-2024, 08:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-26-2024, 08:42 AM)Fido Wrote: Although I'm not really in favour per se there are some elements of this that could make sense if done in the right way, probably more in the community service area.
There are loads of kids, many of whom are from underprivileged backgrounds, who know as far as the boundaries of there own towns and that's about it. But on the flip side there are those with far more means that keep very much to their social circles and don't see the issues that others may face. School and academia might not necessarily be something that comes naturally to some so opening up options, giving an idea of self-worth within a community is not necessarily a bad thing.
With something like the DoE is that more often that not it's a suggestion by parents to have something to "put on the CV" and some kids would never see that as an option for themselves. I'm not sure what the take up is population-wise but would guess it's relatively small. There is a case to say that having something like this in place, with activities between mixes of kids from different backgrounds would be a way of broadening horizons for all. I know most will see this as solely a way of instilling discipline via the military route but it could be a lot more than that.
Make it voluntary then and get the private sector to pay for it.
And then next to no-one would do it. How many kids do you think wouldn't go to school if it wasn't compulsory? It's bad enough now when it is.
Have another try. Bear in mind you are the one that probably moans most about feral kids with no manners and no sense of direction, by the way.
Bear nothing in mind because you are making stuff up about what I think about young people. Since when did moaning about the worst government in living memory equate to having a pop at young people?
The reason no one would voluntarily do this is because it’s an ill thought out idea to appeal to people who haven’t had to do it themselves. Perhaps the over 30s who are keen on this idea such as yourself could do a similar scheme? You could go to work in the care sector 25 days a year in a deprived area for free.
Young people go to work, study, do sports and hobbies on the weekend they don’t need to made to do jobs they should be getting paid for.
Btw how are they going to enforce this? How are they going to fund this, and if they can why isn’t there any money for other more pressing concerns?
Have another try…
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
It seems to be the apparent liberals on here who would like to see a compulsory scheme introduced….
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
I think you’ll struggle to find a reference in my post that says I’m for compulsory national service.
I didn’t push my eldest into DofE, neither did I even know she’d joined a debating society and entered a debating competition until she asked for a lift. Culturally we’ve tried to bring them up to appreciate that “In this house we don’t pass up opportunities”, as neither her mum nor I had many.
There will be a huge number of kids who have very little familial and institutional structure in their lives, who would benefit the most. That’s also the reason why I was so against school closures during Covid. It is not a bad idea at all when you look at the potential outcomes for kids - particularly those horribly let down by the state during Covid.
But I’m sure cheap lazy jibes from comfortable middle class centrist Dad’s will see that it never comes to fruition in either a voluntary or compulsory form.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
So in a nutshell, you don’t want it to be compulsory and such options or very similar already exist on a non compulsory basis.
To be fair, it’s a classic headline policy of someone who knows he’s going to lose being able to spout bollocks from Rish!
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-26-2024, 09:48 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I think you’ll struggle to find a reference in my post that says I’m for compulsory national service.
I didn’t push my eldest into DofE, neither did I even know she’d joined a debating society and entered a debating competition until she asked for a lift. Culturally we’ve tried to bring them up to appreciate that “In this house we don’t pass up opportunities”, as neither her mum nor I had many.
There will be a huge number of kids who have very little familial and institutional structure in their lives, who would benefit the most. That’s also the reason why I was so against school closures during Covid. It is not a bad idea at all when you look at the potential outcomes for kids - particularly those horribly let down by the state during Covid.
But I’m sure cheap lazy jibes from comfortable middle class centrist Dad’s will see that it never comes to fruition in either a voluntary or compulsory form.
You seem to be making a lot of assumptions about working class, lower income families bringing up kids. Perhaps closing down youth centres, Sure Starts and other opportunities was a bad idea? Apparently we can’t afford them but we can afford to make kids work for free in a scheme that’s going to cost the tax payer £2.5 billion. Btw it’s either compulsory or it isn’t, if it isn’t compulsory how are you going to get kids without to use your term ‘ little familial and institutional structure’ to take part?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Yes CF, I believe all opportunities should be restricted to the kids of middle class parents who go to nice schools.
That’s the issue in a nutshell. The kids who’d most benefit are simply not aware. You don’t have to make it compulsory, but you can culturally embed it so that kids see it as a right of passage and will feel like they’re missing out if they don’t.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
So absolutely nothing like the scheme that’s being proposed. Maybe - oh I don’t know - sure start, good youth service provision, connexions that all helped with those things and we already had embedded….
It’s almost as if….
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-26-2024, 10:01 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Yes CF, I believe all opportunities should be restricted to the kids of middle class parents who go to nice schools.
That’s the issue in a nutshell. The kids who’d most benefit are simply not aware. You don’t have to make it compulsory, but you can culturally embed it so that kids see it as a right of passage and will feel like they’re missing out if they don’t.
You don’t have to be middle class or from a ‘nice’ school to volunteer to do things. There are millions of parents from lower incomes and less ‘nice’ schools that spend time and money on their kids so they can take part in cultural, sporting and other experiences. There are also charities who are setup to give young people from lower incomes opportunities but they struggle financially to keep going. Maybe they should be supported rather than this headline grabbing nonsense scheme that has pinpointed jobs in sectors that should be paid positions. Essentially working for free…
If it isn’t compulsory then the idea is never going to work and if it is compulsory how is it ever going to be enforced enforced?
|