Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
05-25-2024, 09:57 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-25-2024, 10:02 AM by CaptainFantastico.)
(05-24-2024, 04:21 PM)Fido Wrote: It’s still a fair question though. You seem a decent enough person not to have done nothing under the circumstances.
It’s classic Proth to pose a question that sounds reasonable in itself but has a proth centred twist on what it suggests.
It’s like me saying what would you have done after the Nakba. It would be an equally valid and stupid question as the one above.
(05-25-2024, 09:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-25-2024, 09:36 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: The Israel/Palestine problem no more started on 7th October than our own Irish problem started with the Birmingham bombing.
We had talks to settle our problem.
So you're in the "talks" camp after what happened on the 7th Oct? 1000 people are murdered or taken hostage and you would go to the table? I'm not saying you're wrong by the way, just wondering how that would seem to people and their families of the country you run. I know it's hard to forget the history of all this but it was a very specific question asked.
Let’s reframe it then Fido - do you consider the genocide Israel is undertaking as a reasonable and proportionate response?
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-25-2024, 09:57 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: (05-24-2024, 04:21 PM)Fido Wrote: It’s still a fair question though. You seem a decent enough person not to have done nothing under the circumstances.
It’s classic Proth to pose a question that sounds reasonable in itself but has a proth centred twist on what it suggests.
It’s like me saying what would you have done after the Nakba. It would be an equally valid and stupid question as the one above.
(05-25-2024, 09:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-25-2024, 09:36 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: The Israel/Palestine problem no more started on 7th October than our own Irish problem started with the Birmingham bombing.
We had talks to settle our problem.
So you're in the "talks" camp after what happened on the 7th Oct? 1000 people are murdered or taken hostage and you would go to the table? I'm not saying you're wrong by the way, just wondering how that would seem to people and their families of the country you run. I know it's hard to forget the history of all this but it was a very specific question asked.
Let’s reframe it then Fido - do you consider the genocide Israel is undertaking as a reasonable and proportionate response?
Reframing is the only thing that has happened on this thread, Captain, but I'll say no it is isn't. Would doing absolutely nothing in response be reasonable to Israelis or pretty much any other international observer? We've now covered both ends of the spectrum, of which neither approach is acceptable, I'd suggest. Someone must have other ideas.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(05-25-2024, 10:08 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-25-2024, 09:57 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: (05-24-2024, 04:21 PM)Fido Wrote: It’s still a fair question though. You seem a decent enough person not to have done nothing under the circumstances.
It’s classic Proth to pose a question that sounds reasonable in itself but has a proth centred twist on what it suggests.
It’s like me saying what would you have done after the Nakba. It would be an equally valid and stupid question as the one above.
(05-25-2024, 09:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-25-2024, 09:36 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: The Israel/Palestine problem no more started on 7th October than our own Irish problem started with the Birmingham bombing.
We had talks to settle our problem.
So you're in the "talks" camp after what happened on the 7th Oct? 1000 people are murdered or taken hostage and you would go to the table? I'm not saying you're wrong by the way, just wondering how that would seem to people and their families of the country you run. I know it's hard to forget the history of all this but it was a very specific question asked.
Let’s reframe it then Fido - do you consider the genocide Israel is undertaking as a reasonable and proportionate response?
Reframing is the only thing that has happened on this thread, Captain, but I'll say no it is isn't. Would doing absolutely nothing in response be reasonable to Israelis or pretty much any other international observer? We've now covered both ends of the spectrum, of which neither approach is acceptable, I'd suggest. Someone must have other ideas.
TBF, there are plenty other ideas, none of which appear acceptable to Hamas or Nettenbarmy.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
It’s asked as if the question “what would you have done instead”? is the natural reflector to the suggestion that murdering civilians is a bad idea. The two things are not sides of the same coin and so it gets the contempt it deserves.
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-25-2024, 11:38 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-25-2024, 11:40 AM by Protheroe.)
(05-25-2024, 09:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-25-2024, 09:36 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: The Israel/Palestine problem no more started on 7th October than our own Irish problem started with the Birmingham bombing.
We had talks to settle our problem.
So you're in the "talks" camp after what happened on the 7th Oct? 1000 people are murdered or taken hostage and you would go to the table? I'm not saying you're wrong by the way, just wondering how that would seem to people and their families of the country you run. I know it's hard to forget the history of all this but it was a very specific question asked.
Yes, it is a very specific question being asked. I thought this bored was against Whataboutery in all its forms?
(05-25-2024, 09:57 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Let’s reframe it then Fido - do you consider the genocide Israel is undertaking as a reasonable and proportionate response?
No, let's not reframe it for your own convenience. Let's answer the question.
(05-25-2024, 10:52 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s asked as if the question “what would you have done instead”? is the natural reflector to the suggestion that murdering civilians is a bad idea. The two things are not sides of the same coin and so it gets the contempt it deserves.
It's not what would you have done INSTEAD, it's simply what would you have done?
You're clear on what you wouldn't have done. So, what would you have done?
Posts: 6,720
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1LdYV6YX0ks
Daniel Levy knows more than i do about this. He says "talk".
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
05-25-2024, 11:54 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-25-2024, 11:55 AM by CaptainFantastico.)
(05-25-2024, 11:38 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-25-2024, 09:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-25-2024, 09:36 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: The Israel/Palestine problem no more started on 7th October than our own Irish problem started with the Birmingham bombing.
We had talks to settle our problem.
So you're in the "talks" camp after what happened on the 7th Oct? 1000 people are murdered or taken hostage and you would go to the table? I'm not saying you're wrong by the way, just wondering how that would seem to people and their families of the country you run. I know it's hard to forget the history of all this but it was a very specific question asked.
Yes, it is a very specific question being asked. I thought this bored was against Whataboutery in all its forms?
(05-25-2024, 09:57 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Let’s reframe it then Fido - do you consider the genocide Israel is undertaking as a reasonable and proportionate response?
No, let's not reframe it for your own convenience. Let's answer the question.
(05-25-2024, 10:52 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s asked as if the question “what would you have done instead”? is the natural reflector to the suggestion that murdering civilians is a bad idea. The two things are not sides of the same coin and so it gets the contempt it deserves.
It's not what would you have done INSTEAD, it's simply what would you have done?
You're clear on what you wouldn't have done. So, what would you have done?
I’d have decided perpetuating a cycle of violence, murder and rape 70 odd years go was probably likely to result in the very depressing generational cycles we see today and decided it was a bad idea.
I’d also be at ease condemning both sides rather than thinking anyone who calls out Israel for genocide is likely to be troubled by a daft question that suggests they are innocent reactionaries. Which is more telling about the person asking it than it is about those it’s intended to provoke.
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-25-2024, 11:56 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-25-2024, 11:57 AM by Protheroe.)
(05-25-2024, 11:44 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1LdYV6YX0ks
Daniel Levy knows more than i do about this. He says "talk".
Talk about what?
How you came and raped and murdered defenceless children, beheaded their grandparents, kidnappped raped and tortured kids at a music festival? Or something else?
Daniel Levy is absolutely right that ultimately this can only be solved by diplomacy, but that is so unlikely given the bad actors involved on all sides.
But "talk" the day after? Does Israel not have the right to defend itself? If not, why not?
Should Israel have capitulated every time it has suffered an attempted invasion?
I understand this is a really difficult question. But realsitically, what would you have done? Talking on October the 8th is simply not a realistic proposition.
(05-25-2024, 11:54 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I’d have decided perpetuating a cycle of violence, murder and rape 70 odd years go was probably likely to result in the very depressing generational cycles we see today and decided it was a bad idea.
I’d also be at ease condemning both sides rather than thinking anyone who calls out Israel for genocide is likely to be troubled by a daft question that suggests they are innocent reactionaries. Which is more telling about the person asking it than it is about those it’s intended to provoke.
OK, I get it - you can't answer the question. Given that some of the brightest minds in international relations can't either, it doesn't necessarily surprise me.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
There is no question required to replace the answer to whether apartheid based genocide is evil and should be simply called out as such.
Anyone who tries to circumvent it in the way you have here has a real problem
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-25-2024, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-25-2024, 08:29 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: (05-25-2024, 08:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-25-2024, 08:06 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: You do really need to move away from insinuating that this began on 7 October.
Perhaps you ought to read my post again. I insinuated nothing of the sort. You're getting as bad as Dekka. Now, now 
That was the least relevant bit of my post btw
Then perhaps you can answer the question?
If you were running Israel, how would you have reacted to October 7th?
I don't know the answer btw. It's certainly not the way Israel has responded (hindsight being the only exact science), but what would you have done instead?
It's entirely Dekka's MO to criticise an outcome without having the first clue what he would've done instead. Don't be Dekka.
What Yair Lapid and Naftali Bennett suggested back in October (so not hindsight), focus on moving Hamas out of Gaza and get the PLO in by working with the friendly Middle East countries (the non-Iranian aligned ones) and the international organisations.
I'd also suggest cutting off Qatar until they start to cooperate with Israel and the West over facilitating Hamas.
I think you'll find that I was calling out the Israeli government's complete lack of a plan back in October and that's resulted in not only Israel being called out for their shit by the US and loads of dead children that are being used as martyrs by Hamas but also killing Israeli hostages who were trying to surrender themselves back into Israel. Thanks to that the Israeli government has probably made it impossible to actually reach a solution without members of the current government being held to account under international law.
|