Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-24-2024, 11:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote: BB is also correct in that we need growth to provide everything that we want, but incorrect in the assertion that the Tories have killed the economy and prevented any growth. For the last three years rapid demand-driven growth is the last thing we needed to cure inflation. CPI is coming down but core inflation remains elevated, and services inflation even more so (and sticky).
Where BB and I agree (I think) is that growth should be led by the supply side.
I wonder what BB thinks "is necessary" to balance welfare provision with fiscal responsibility?
Point 1: This issue goes back a lot longer than 3 years, the government's short term decisions have exacerbated issues (if they'd kept the coalition insulation strategy we would have saved billions on energy support before targeting it), they have completely failed to invest in productive infrastructure, they have created unnecessary business uncertainty (I hope Claire Coutinho loses her seat, and every Energy Secretary from Claire Perry onwards) for no reason and they have actively promoted private investment away from productive areas and into unproductive areas like land and property speculation.
And in the last 3 years they have completely fucked over key growth industries (the renewable energy sector and universities) for no reason despite both those sectors propping up our nominal GDP and regional economies.
Point 2: Yes, I am generally a monetarist and tend to be reluctant regarding fiscal expansion, but I'm pro-fiscal expansion in specific areas right now (infrastructure investment into energy and transport, as well as housing and lab space in Oxford and Cambridge) because I don't see any other choice owing to how much the Tories have killed growth and there's very little room for tax rises (unless they are very specific and balanced against cuts elsewhere).
Point 3: Healthcare spending and pension spending are the big two. Redistribution away from NHS spending to primary healthcare (GPs, dentists, mental healthcare) for the first bit and transition towards means testing for the second bit with a simplified single income tax so that pensioners on £40k a year are paying their fair share so we can continue to provide welfare to pensioners that actually need it.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Tbf, I don't actually always disagree with you on things Proth.
I try not to show my hand too much with politics and my beliefs since I tend to piss off both sides of the debate with being a centrist fence sitter, apparently.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(05-24-2024, 12:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (05-24-2024, 11:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote: BB is also correct in that we need growth to provide everything that we want, but incorrect in the assertion that the Tories have killed the economy and prevented any growth. For the last three years rapid demand-driven growth is the last thing we needed to cure inflation. CPI is coming down but core inflation remains elevated, and services inflation even more so (and sticky).
Where BB and I agree (I think) is that growth should be led by the supply side.
I wonder what BB thinks "is necessary" to balance welfare provision with fiscal responsibility?
Point 1: This issue goes back a lot longer than 3 years, the government's short term decisions have exacerbated issues (if they'd kept the coalition insulation strategy we would have saved billions on energy support before targeting it), they have completely failed to invest in productive infrastructure, they have created unnecessary business uncertainty (I hope Claire Coutinho loses her seat, and every Energy Secretary from Claire Perry onwards) for no reason and they have actively promoted private investment away from productive areas and into unproductive areas like land and property speculation.
And in the last 3 years they have completely fucked over key growth industries (the renewable energy sector and universities) for no reason despite both those sectors propping up our nominal GDP and regional economies.
Point 2: Yes, I am generally a monetarist and tend to be reluctant regarding fiscal expansion, but I'm pro-fiscal expansion in specific areas right now (infrastructure investment into energy and transport, as well as housing and lab space in Oxford and Cambridge) because I don't see any other choice owing to how much the Tories have killed growth and there's very little room for tax rises (unless they are very specific and balanced against cuts elsewhere).
Point 3: Healthcare spending and pension spending are the big two. Redistribution away from NHS spending to primary healthcare (GPs, dentists, mental healthcare) for the first bit and transition towards means testing for the second bit with a simplified single income tax so that pensioners on £40k a year are paying their fair share so we can continue to provide welfare to pensioners that actually need it.
Agree with much said. Forgive my ignorance re the last sentence: Wouldn't a pensioner on £40K p.a. pay income tax anyway? With the tax threshold level not rising in years, many pensioners will pay tax on any work they are paid for. Id rather go after the mega rich.
Also. Whoever made the point about people jacking their jobs in at 52 has a good point, from my experience I know many that have taken that route and they don't appear to be doing anything remotely useful to the world. There was definitely something wrong with allowing people to cash in so young.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-24-2024, 01:05 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (05-24-2024, 12:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (05-24-2024, 11:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote: BB is also correct in that we need growth to provide everything that we want, but incorrect in the assertion that the Tories have killed the economy and prevented any growth. For the last three years rapid demand-driven growth is the last thing we needed to cure inflation. CPI is coming down but core inflation remains elevated, and services inflation even more so (and sticky).
Where BB and I agree (I think) is that growth should be led by the supply side.
I wonder what BB thinks "is necessary" to balance welfare provision with fiscal responsibility?
Point 1: This issue goes back a lot longer than 3 years, the government's short term decisions have exacerbated issues (if they'd kept the coalition insulation strategy we would have saved billions on energy support before targeting it), they have completely failed to invest in productive infrastructure, they have created unnecessary business uncertainty (I hope Claire Coutinho loses her seat, and every Energy Secretary from Claire Perry onwards) for no reason and they have actively promoted private investment away from productive areas and into unproductive areas like land and property speculation.
And in the last 3 years they have completely fucked over key growth industries (the renewable energy sector and universities) for no reason despite both those sectors propping up our nominal GDP and regional economies.
Point 2: Yes, I am generally a monetarist and tend to be reluctant regarding fiscal expansion, but I'm pro-fiscal expansion in specific areas right now (infrastructure investment into energy and transport, as well as housing and lab space in Oxford and Cambridge) because I don't see any other choice owing to how much the Tories have killed growth and there's very little room for tax rises (unless they are very specific and balanced against cuts elsewhere).
Point 3: Healthcare spending and pension spending are the big two. Redistribution away from NHS spending to primary healthcare (GPs, dentists, mental healthcare) for the first bit and transition towards means testing for the second bit with a simplified single income tax so that pensioners on £40k a year are paying their fair share so we can continue to provide welfare to pensioners that actually need it.
Agree with much said. Forgive my ignorance re the last sentence: Wouldn't a pensioner on £40K p.a. pay income tax anyway? With the tax threshold level not rising in years, many pensioners will pay tax on any work they are paid for. Id rather go after the mega rich.
Also. Whoever made the point about people jacking their jobs in at 52 has a good point, from my experience I know many that have taken that route and they don't appear to be doing anything remotely useful to the world. There was definitely something wrong with allowing people to cash in so young.
A pensioner on £40k pays income tax but not NICs unless they're still in work, despite NICs being an income tax. They may pay student loans but it's very unlikely.
The problem is that someone in work has a 10% tax liability with NICs compared to a pensioner which is seriously problematic if you have fewer people entering work and more leaving work, state pensions aren't a proper pension with a pension pot but a welfare benefit paid out of current taxation.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-24-2024, 02:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-24-2024, 02:08 PM by Protheroe.)
I don't disagree with much you have to say BB, all of Point 2 and particularly about pensioners paying NI.
The latter being one of the unspoken reasons why Jeremy Hunt is trying to make work pay by abolishing NI and letting fiscal drag do the rest. Though he'd never admit to it.
Posts: 6,722
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(05-24-2024, 07:30 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (05-24-2024, 07:27 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (05-24-2024, 07:16 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (05-24-2024, 07:12 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (05-24-2024, 05:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No one is self sufficient, if you have an accident you go to A&E, if you drive a car you use public roads, if you went to school most will have gone to a state supported school, if have your bins emptied, went to a youth club back in the day then you do have a duty of care to the rest of society. If everyone started to pick and choose which items they pay for via their tax society would break down. It’s an illogical position without bringing morality into the argument. If society functions well then the majority of the people will have a better standard of living, if people simply choose go for the ME option then you or you family will be effected even if you think you won’t.
I pay my taxes so it's not an issue so where is your argument if I didn't you would be right ......let's see in 12 months if the NHS waiting times are down.....I bet you they are not ..
£25 charity bet?
Depends how much they come down from 8 hours to 4 hours ?
You just said they won't be lower. I'm happy to choose A&E, planned surgery or cancer. Choose any and my bet is they'll (averaged across the country) be lower, at the end of May 25 than the end of May 24. I don't mind which one.
Can i join that bet? They will be lower. Work has already started on capacity and demand planning.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(05-24-2024, 02:12 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: (05-24-2024, 07:30 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (05-24-2024, 07:27 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (05-24-2024, 07:16 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (05-24-2024, 07:12 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: I pay my taxes so it's not an issue so where is your argument if I didn't you would be right ......let's see in 12 months if the NHS waiting times are down.....I bet you they are not ..
£25 charity bet?
Depends how much they come down from 8 hours to 4 hours ?
You just said they won't be lower. I'm happy to choose A&E, planned surgery or cancer. Choose any and my bet is they'll (averaged across the country) be lower, at the end of May 25 than the end of May 24. I don't mind which one.
Can i join that bet? They will be lower. Work has already started on capacity and demand planning.
So the Tories get the credit for reducing waiting times ?
Where's me tin hat?
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-24-2024, 02:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I don't disagree with much you have to say BB, all of Point 2 and particularly about pensioners paying NI.
The latter being one of the unspoken reasons why Jeremy Hunt is trying to make work pay by abolishing NI and letting fiscal drag do the rest. Though he'd never admit to it.
The issue with Jeremy Hunt's objectives is that he has zero intention to make it revenue neutral which, as you mentioned, means that you cannot uprate the thresholds.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(05-24-2024, 02:23 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (05-24-2024, 02:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I don't disagree with much you have to say BB, all of Point 2 and particularly about pensioners paying NI.
The latter being one of the unspoken reasons why Jeremy Hunt is trying to make work pay by abolishing NI and letting fiscal drag do the rest. Though he'd never admit to it.
The issue with Jeremy Hunt's objectives is that he has zero intention to make it revenue neutral which, as you mentioned, means that you cannot uprate the thresholds.
I'm not sure even he knows what his objectives are, but done on a revenue neutral basis it would have a huge impact on generational fairness.
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(05-24-2024, 01:05 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (05-24-2024, 12:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (05-24-2024, 11:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote: BB is also correct in that we need growth to provide everything that we want, but incorrect in the assertion that the Tories have killed the economy and prevented any growth. For the last three years rapid demand-driven growth is the last thing we needed to cure inflation. CPI is coming down but core inflation remains elevated, and services inflation even more so (and sticky).
Where BB and I agree (I think) is that growth should be led by the supply side.
I wonder what BB thinks "is necessary" to balance welfare provision with fiscal responsibility?
Point 1: This issue goes back a lot longer than 3 years, the government's short term decisions have exacerbated issues (if they'd kept the coalition insulation strategy we would have saved billions on energy support before targeting it), they have completely failed to invest in productive infrastructure, they have created unnecessary business uncertainty (I hope Claire Coutinho loses her seat, and every Energy Secretary from Claire Perry onwards) for no reason and they have actively promoted private investment away from productive areas and into unproductive areas like land and property speculation.
And in the last 3 years they have completely fucked over key growth industries (the renewable energy sector and universities) for no reason despite both those sectors propping up our nominal GDP and regional economies.
Point 2: Yes, I am generally a monetarist and tend to be reluctant regarding fiscal expansion, but I'm pro-fiscal expansion in specific areas right now (infrastructure investment into energy and transport, as well as housing and lab space in Oxford and Cambridge) because I don't see any other choice owing to how much the Tories have killed growth and there's very little room for tax rises (unless they are very specific and balanced against cuts elsewhere).
Point 3: Healthcare spending and pension spending are the big two. Redistribution away from NHS spending to primary healthcare (GPs, dentists, mental healthcare) for the first bit and transition towards means testing for the second bit with a simplified single income tax so that pensioners on £40k a year are paying their fair share so we can continue to provide welfare to pensioners that actually need it.
Agree with much said. Forgive my ignorance re the last sentence: Wouldn't a pensioner on £40K p.a. pay income tax anyway? With the tax threshold level not rising in years, many pensioners will pay tax on any work they are paid for. Id rather go after the mega rich.
Also. Whoever made the point about people jacking their jobs in at 52 has a good point, from my experience I know many that have taken that route and they don't appear to be doing anything remotely useful to the world. There was definitely something wrong with allowing people to cash in so young. Not sure about jacking in jobs at 52. If they can afford it, thats their choice. I, am older than 52, but due to inheriting some money following a bereavement, having a forces and a works pension to take, I am seriously thinking of finishing full time work, maybe do a bit of part time. 40 years of getting up at 4 AM, doing long shifts / 12 hour nights etc, I am knackered. Besides, these people who have retired early still pay tax every time they fill the car up, insure something, VAT on goods they buy, and probably go away at weekends spending money in coffee shops, garden centres etc, keeping someone else in a job. I have paid my share, and, when I left the forces, due to a family divorce I had nowhere to live, I was told `You`re not entitled to anything`, ending up sleeping on a sofa for months until I found a small place to rent.
|