Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
(05-24-2024, 10:11 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (05-24-2024, 09:13 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Some brave comments on here from Woodman and SuperBob. I see their point but I don't agree.
Let's consider a usually misquoted speech from Dear Margaret:
"I think we have gone through a period when too many children and people have been given to understand ‘I have a problem, it is the Government’s job to cope with it!’ or ‘I have a problem, I will go and get a grant to cope with it!’ ‘I am homeless, the Government must house me!’ and so they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first."
Now that I agree with completely, BUT Brown's tax credits, the response to the financial crisis, Covid support and Energy Price support have made us all to one extent or another a client of the state. That cannot continue, but neither can we all look to our own individual circumstances and sod the rest when the contract between the generations has been blown to pieces by successive governments and our ready compliance.
This is not me having a Damascene conversion. Far from it. Regular readers will know I have been banging on about the concentration of wealth, particularly housing wealth in the hands of the elderly and already wealthy. Every single policy contributing to generational inequality has benefitted me personally, but is it right? Of course not. Is it sustainable? No. There is no reason on God's Earth why any sentient graduate renter on a median wage in the UK would vote Tory, or indeed Labour for that matter with what is currently on offer to them.
But isnt it the privilege of us fortunate ones to take responsibility for those having a problem, a severe disability, an accident victim, a recipient of sudden ill health? Also, there are more people than houses so of course there will be homeless.
Society is neither intrinsically good nor bad. It is what we make it and it is widely believed that we are all happier by contributing to make it better than we are by treating it as a problem and hoping it goes away.
I've been disabled in the past having one arm and hand very restricted still today so I know what challenges are out there you know what I done stopped feeling sorry for myself and got on with it and I still have the same challenges today .
If you choose to feel sorry for yourself you will be in the gutter make no mistake about it .
Choosing red or blue means about as much as it does in table football.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
(05-24-2024, 10:22 AM)Slowpoke Gonzalez Wrote: Choosing red or blue means about as much as it does in table football.
What's the raving looney party colours
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
05-24-2024, 10:23 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-24-2024, 10:28 AM by Borin' Baggie.)
(05-24-2024, 10:11 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (05-24-2024, 09:13 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Some brave comments on here from Woodman and SuperBob. I see their point but I don't agree.
Let's consider a usually misquoted speech from Dear Margaret:
"I think we have gone through a period when too many children and people have been given to understand ‘I have a problem, it is the Government’s job to cope with it!’ or ‘I have a problem, I will go and get a grant to cope with it!’ ‘I am homeless, the Government must house me!’ and so they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first."
Now that I agree with completely, BUT Brown's tax credits, the response to the financial crisis, Covid support and Energy Price support have made us all to one extent or another a client of the state. That cannot continue, but neither can we all look to our own individual circumstances and sod the rest when the contract between the generations has been blown to pieces by successive governments and our ready compliance.
This is not me having a Damascene conversion. Far from it. Regular readers will know I have been banging on about the concentration of wealth, particularly housing wealth in the hands of the elderly and already wealthy. Every single policy contributing to generational inequality has benefitted me personally, but is it right? Of course not. Is it sustainable? No. There is no reason on God's Earth why any sentient graduate renter on a median wage in the UK would vote Tory, or indeed Labour for that matter with what is currently on offer to them.
But isnt it the privilege of us fortunate ones to take responsibility for those having a problem, a severe disability, an accident victim, a recipient of sudden ill health? Also, there are more people than houses so of course there will be homeless.
Society is neither intrinsically good nor bad. It is what we make it and it is widely believed that we are all happier by contributing to make it better than we are by treating it as a problem and hoping it goes away.
Yeah but you need growth to achieve that given our aging population and need to increase tax receipt and the fact Tories have completely killed the economy and prevented any growth that's very difficult.
The Nordic countries balance welfare provisions with fiscal responsibility very well but there appears to be too many people in this country vehemently opposed to doing what's necessary to enable that.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
05-24-2024, 10:23 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-24-2024, 10:24 AM by Birdman1811.)
Probably the best, most reasoned debate we've had on this subject for a long time.
Tories have fucked up so spectacularly people have come together from across the spectrum to say it's shit and needs fixing, though there are different ideas as to how too of course.
Well done modern Conservative party, you truly bought everyone together.....
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
05-24-2024, 10:29 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-24-2024, 11:34 AM by Lurker#3.)
(05-24-2024, 10:11 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (05-24-2024, 09:13 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Some brave comments on here from Woodman and SuperBob. I see their point but I don't agree.
Let's consider a usually misquoted speech from Dear Margaret:
"I think we have gone through a period when too many children and people have been given to understand ‘I have a problem, it is the Government’s job to cope with it!’ or ‘I have a problem, I will go and get a grant to cope with it!’ ‘I am homeless, the Government must house me!’ and so they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first."
Now that I agree with completely, BUT Brown's tax credits, the response to the financial crisis, Covid support and Energy Price support have made us all to one extent or another a client of the state. That cannot continue, but neither can we all look to our own individual circumstances and sod the rest when the contract between the generations has been blown to pieces by successive governments and our ready compliance.
This is not me having a Damascene conversion. Far from it. Regular readers will know I have been banging on about the concentration of wealth, particularly housing wealth in the hands of the elderly and already wealthy. Every single policy contributing to generational inequality has benefitted me personally, but is it right? Of course not. Is it sustainable? No. There is no reason on God's Earth why any sentient graduate renter on a median wage in the UK would vote Tory, or indeed Labour for that matter with what is currently on offer to them.
But isnt it the privilege of us fortunate ones to take responsibility for those having a problem, a severe disability, an accident victim, a recipient of sudden ill health? Also, there are more people than houses so of course there will be homeless.
Society is neither intrinsically good nor bad. It is what we make it and it is widely believed that we are all happier by contributing to make it better than we are by treating it as a problem and hoping it goes away.
You are both 100% correct. This is why politics is so difficult.
There are people unable to function in the society we have created, through no fault of their own. And these people should be supported and protected by the state at the more fortunates expense.
However, as a society, we have become somewhat "soft" after 30+ years of constant comfort and free money. So we have forgotten how to tighten the purse strings, go without and to some extent "suffer". We just expect our politicians and government to fix it.
I have spent the last 10 or so years working across welfare to work and social housing, and the difference now compared to when I first started in these sort of roles is staggering. The level of entitlement and lack of willingness to make difficult decisions is staggering. Benefits was a lifestyle for many during the 90s/00s and then when the financial crash happened and austerity was thrust, rightly or wrongly, upon us, that lifestyle got inflated away and the social problems began and spiraled out of control.
Add to that a rapidly shrinking workforce and tax receipt its hard to roll out true socialist policies. So you are stuck in this weird middle ground, which both the far left and far right of the political spectrum are arguing the toss as to the reasons.
(05-24-2024, 10:23 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Probably the best, most reasoned debate we've had on this subject for a long time.
Tories have fucked up so spectacularly people have come together from across the spectrum to say it's shit and needs fixing, though there are different ideas as to how too of course.
Well done modern Conservative party, you truly bought everyone together.....
Have they made a fuck up of it? Yes... Absolutely. BUT... this is a European, if not worldwide issue.
The problem we have is to properly fund public services in a socialist way, you need most people paying a fair whack of taxes at a reasonable level until they hit state pension age.
What we have now is the beneficiaries of the "easiest" period in human history, diving out of the workforce at 52/53, with hoarded wealth. So we are 10/15 years short of contributions from millions of who would have traditionally been at the top of their career path, paying lots into the system, folding their hand.
Am I mad at them? No. I want out at 50. But it highlights the issues governments face.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
(05-24-2024, 10:23 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Probably the best, most reasoned debate we've had on this subject for a long time.
Tories have fucked up so spectacularly people have come together from across the spectrum to say it's shit and needs fixing, though there are different ideas as to how too of course.
Well done modern Conservative party, you truly bought everyone together.....
Erection debates always bring the best out of us.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(05-24-2024, 11:12 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (05-24-2024, 10:23 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Probably the best, most reasoned debate we've had on this subject for a long time.
Tories have fucked up so spectacularly people have come together from across the spectrum to say it's shit and needs fixing, though there are different ideas as to how too of course.
Well done modern Conservative party, you truly bought everyone together.....
Erection debates always bring the best out of us.
I always rise to the occasion.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-24-2024, 11:45 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-24-2024, 11:51 AM by Protheroe.)
(05-24-2024, 10:23 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (05-24-2024, 10:11 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (05-24-2024, 09:13 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Some brave comments on here from Woodman and SuperBob. I see their point but I don't agree.
Let's consider a usually misquoted speech from Dear Margaret:
"I think we have gone through a period when too many children and people have been given to understand ‘I have a problem, it is the Government’s job to cope with it!’ or ‘I have a problem, I will go and get a grant to cope with it!’ ‘I am homeless, the Government must house me!’ and so they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first."
Now that I agree with completely, BUT Brown's tax credits, the response to the financial crisis, Covid support and Energy Price support have made us all to one extent or another a client of the state. That cannot continue, but neither can we all look to our own individual circumstances and sod the rest when the contract between the generations has been blown to pieces by successive governments and our ready compliance.
This is not me having a Damascene conversion. Far from it. Regular readers will know I have been banging on about the concentration of wealth, particularly housing wealth in the hands of the elderly and already wealthy. Every single policy contributing to generational inequality has benefitted me personally, but is it right? Of course not. Is it sustainable? No. There is no reason on God's Earth why any sentient graduate renter on a median wage in the UK would vote Tory, or indeed Labour for that matter with what is currently on offer to them.
But isnt it the privilege of us fortunate ones to take responsibility for those having a problem, a severe disability, an accident victim, a recipient of sudden ill health? Also, there are more people than houses so of course there will be homeless.
Society is neither intrinsically good nor bad. It is what we make it and it is widely believed that we are all happier by contributing to make it better than we are by treating it as a problem and hoping it goes away.
Yeah but you need growth to achieve that given our aging population and need to increase tax receipt and the fact Tories have completely killed the economy and prevented any growth that's very difficult.
The Nordic countries balance welfare provisions with fiscal responsibility very well but there appears to be too many people in this country vehemently opposed to doing what's necessary to enable that.
I think that's exactly what I am saying TJ. What I'm also saying very clearly is that successive governments have laid a trough in front of those of us more than capable of looking after ourselves and we have gorged ourselves often climbing over others to do so.
I'm perfectly self aware enough to know that I own more houses than I need, and that my actions have crowded out first time buyers - but the state created the situation to encourage me to do so; Brown ruining pension saving, free money for 15 years, a benign (until recently) tax regime, low returns on other low risk investments and no bloody housebuilding. I don't feel guilty about my actions as they're securing the future for my family.
It just illustrates the perverse and counter productive incentives created by the state, particularly in a period of rising taxes on income.
BB is also correct in that we need growth to provide everything that we want, but incorrect in the assertion that the Tories have killed the economy and prevented any growth. For the last three years rapid demand-driven growth is the last thing we needed to cure inflation. CPI is coming down but core inflation remains elevated, and services inflation even more so (and sticky).
Where BB and I agree (I think) is that growth should be led by the supply side.
I wonder what BB thinks "is necessary" to balance welfare provision with fiscal responsibility?
(05-24-2024, 10:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: However, as a society, we have become somewhat "soft" after 30+ years of constant comfort and free money. So we have forgotten how to tighten the purse strings, go without and to some extent "suffer". We just expect our politicians and government to fix it.
I have spent the last 10 or so years working across welfare to work and social housing, and the difference now compared to when I first started in these sort of roles is staggering. The level of entitlement and lack of willingness to make difficult decisions is staggering. Benefits was a lifestyle for many during the 90s/00s and then when the financial crash happened and austerity was thrust, rightly or wrongly, upon us, that lifestyle got inflated away and the social problems began and spiraled out of control.
Add to that a rapidly shrinking workforce and tax receipt its hard to roll out true socialist policies. So you are stuck in this weird middle ground, which both the far left and far right of the political spectrum are arguing the toss as to the reasons.
Have they made a fuck up of it? Yes... Absolutely. BUT... this is a European, if not worldwide issue.
The problem we have is to properly fund public services in a socialist way, you need most people paying a fair whack of taxes at a reasonable level until they hit state pension age.
What we have now is the beneficiaries of the "easiest" period in human history, diving out of the workforce at 52/53, with hoarded wealth. So we are 10/15 years short of contributions from millions of who would have traditionally been at the top of their career path, paying lots into the system, folding their hand.
Am I mad at them? No. I want out at 50. But it highlights the issues governments face.
It's good to know that I'm not alone on here.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
05-24-2024, 12:21 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-24-2024, 12:23 PM by Ted Maul.)
(05-24-2024, 10:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: You are both 100% correct. This is why politics is so difficult.
There are people unable to function in the society we have created, through no fault of their own. And these people should be supported and protected by the state at the more fortunates expense.
However, as a society, we have become somewhat "soft" after 30+ years of constant comfort and free money. So we have forgotten how to tighten the purse strings, go without and to some extent "suffer". We just expect our politicians and government to fix it.
I have spent the last 10 or so years working across welfare to work and social housing, and the difference now compared to when I first started in these sort of roles is staggering. The level of entitlement and lack of willingness to make difficult decisions is staggering. Benefits was a lifestyle for many during the 90s/00s and then when the financial crash happened and austerity was thrust, rightly or wrongly, upon us, that lifestyle got inflated away and the social problems began and spiraled out of control.
Add to that a rapidly shrinking workforce and tax receipt its hard to roll out true socialist policies. So you are stuck in this weird middle ground, which both the far left and far right of the political spectrum are arguing the toss as to the reasons.
It's a fair post and in fairness to Proth, he's been going on about this since well before Liz Truss broke the economy.
Surely you cannot be surprised that so many people are struggling to align "years of free money and comfort" to the current state of our public services, working poverty levels and infrastructure that is literally falling apart around us. How are years of "tightening the purse strings" and "suffering" going to improve the parts of peoples lives that need the most attention right now?
|