Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Just seen you've released Tyrese Campbell - I know injuries have taken their toll, but thought he'd been playing a lot recently?
One of those players who will pop up somewhere else in the Champ and rediscover his form, or do you see him drifting down the leagues?
Thought he looked a right player 2-3 years ago when he first broke through!
Posts: 2,270
Threads: 51
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Yeah, a bit of a strange one, this. And whatever I say, I fully expect he'll prove me wrong.
Had this reputation with quite a few of our fans of being unplayable and potentially a 20 goal a season man. And no matter what he did to dispel this reputation by being largely anonymous in most matches, he maintained the myth til the end of his time at Stoke.
Scored a couple of belting goals towards the end of the season, which led to the kind of outcry on his leaving that you get from people who forget how little he contributed until he was in the shop window.
The scorer of great goals rather than a great goalscorer. His highlights package will look magnificent, but give me the much maligned Jacob Brown and his clumsy, scuffed goals from 2 yards anyday.
I'm probably being a tad harsh. But he had this air about him of someone who thought he was doing us a favour by turning up. It didn't help that every few months he'd pile enough timber on to make him a veritable Charlie Adam tribute act. Having said that, it did appear that he was very popular generally with his teammates.
He probably has it in him physically to be a top Championship striker. Someone could very well get the best out of him, but bloody hell, he'll make them work hard for it.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-21-2024, 06:48 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Yeah, a bit of a strange one, this. And whatever I say, I fully expect he'll prove me wrong.
Had this reputation with quite a few of our fans of being unplayable and potentially a 20 goal a season man. And no matter what he did to dispel this reputation by being largely anonymous in most matches, he maintained the myth til the end of his time at Stoke.
Scored a couple of belting goals towards the end of the season, which led to the kind of outcry on his leaving that you get from people who forget how little he contributed until he was in the shop window.
The scorer of great goals rather than a great goalscorer. His highlights package will look magnificent, but give me the much maligned Jacob Brown and his clumsy, scuffed goals from 2 yards anyday.
I'm probably being a tad harsh. But he had this air about him of someone who thought he was doing us a favour by turning up. It didn't help that every few months he'd pile enough timber on to make him a veritable Charlie Adam tribute act. Having said that, it did appear that he was very popular generally with his teammates.
He probably has it in him physically to be a top Championship striker. Someone could very well get the best out of him, but bloody hell, he'll make them work hard for it.
I must have only seen him in the games where he scored a stunner…
I look forward to my annual “I think Stoke have done really decent business this summer” post which reigns true for the first 10 or so games only for you to gradually slide into the bottom half with most of the summer signings becoming injured, losing form or both!
Posts: 2,270
Threads: 51
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(05-21-2024, 09:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-21-2024, 06:48 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Yeah, a bit of a strange one, this. And whatever I say, I fully expect he'll prove me wrong.
Had this reputation with quite a few of our fans of being unplayable and potentially a 20 goal a season man. And no matter what he did to dispel this reputation by being largely anonymous in most matches, he maintained the myth til the end of his time at Stoke.
Scored a couple of belting goals towards the end of the season, which led to the kind of outcry on his leaving that you get from people who forget how little he contributed until he was in the shop window.
The scorer of great goals rather than a great goalscorer. His highlights package will look magnificent, but give me the much maligned Jacob Brown and his clumsy, scuffed goals from 2 yards anyday.
I'm probably being a tad harsh. But he had this air about him of someone who thought he was doing us a favour by turning up. It didn't help that every few months he'd pile enough timber on to make him a veritable Charlie Adam tribute act. Having said that, it did appear that he was very popular generally with his teammates.
He probably has it in him physically to be a top Championship striker. Someone could very well get the best out of him, but bloody hell, he'll make them work hard for it.
I must have only seen him in the games where he scored a stunner…
This is like how loads of Stoke fans have got it into their heads that BTA is the new Luis Suárez, due to how he terrifies us whenever we play the Albion.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(05-21-2024, 11:28 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (05-21-2024, 09:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-21-2024, 06:48 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Yeah, a bit of a strange one, this. And whatever I say, I fully expect he'll prove me wrong.
Had this reputation with quite a few of our fans of being unplayable and potentially a 20 goal a season man. And no matter what he did to dispel this reputation by being largely anonymous in most matches, he maintained the myth til the end of his time at Stoke.
Scored a couple of belting goals towards the end of the season, which led to the kind of outcry on his leaving that you get from people who forget how little he contributed until he was in the shop window.
The scorer of great goals rather than a great goalscorer. His highlights package will look magnificent, but give me the much maligned Jacob Brown and his clumsy, scuffed goals from 2 yards anyday.
I'm probably being a tad harsh. But he had this air about him of someone who thought he was doing us a favour by turning up. It didn't help that every few months he'd pile enough timber on to make him a veritable Charlie Adam tribute act. Having said that, it did appear that he was very popular generally with his teammates.
He probably has it in him physically to be a top Championship striker. Someone could very well get the best out of him, but bloody hell, he'll make them work hard for it.
I must have only seen him in the games where he scored a stunner…
This is like how loads of Stoke fans have got it into their heads that BTA is the new Luis Suárez, due to how he terrifies us whenever we play the Albion. 
Give us £15m for him and he's yours!
In all seriousness BTA has been a cracking signing when compared to the outlay. A £300k signing from div 2 who has a brilliant attitude. Works his socks off, puts himself about and bags a few goals. Some of them stunners. He's a model professional by all accounts and is great with the fans and young supporters with his time.
He comes in for some stick on here by some saying he's wasteful and can't finish but I'm not sure what people expect given what we paid. Luiz Suarez he is not but I'm glad we have him as an option. The guy has single handedly had to be our first choice striker all season and has bagged 11 goals. If we ever manage to find a first choice number 9 that can stay fit then I expect BTA to be a back up and a bloody good back up at that!
Posts: 1,906
Threads: 31
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(05-21-2024, 11:28 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (05-21-2024, 09:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-21-2024, 06:48 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Yeah, a bit of a strange one, this. And whatever I say, I fully expect he'll prove me wrong.
Had this reputation with quite a few of our fans of being unplayable and potentially a 20 goal a season man. And no matter what he did to dispel this reputation by being largely anonymous in most matches, he maintained the myth til the end of his time at Stoke.
Scored a couple of belting goals towards the end of the season, which led to the kind of outcry on his leaving that you get from people who forget how little he contributed until he was in the shop window.
The scorer of great goals rather than a great goalscorer. His highlights package will look magnificent, but give me the much maligned Jacob Brown and his clumsy, scuffed goals from 2 yards anyday.
I'm probably being a tad harsh. But he had this air about him of someone who thought he was doing us a favour by turning up. It didn't help that every few months he'd pile enough timber on to make him a veritable Charlie Adam tribute act. Having said that, it did appear that he was very popular generally with his teammates.
He probably has it in him physically to be a top Championship striker. Someone could very well get the best out of him, but bloody hell, he'll make them work hard for it.
I must have only seen him in the games where he scored a stunner…
This is like how loads of Stoke fans have got it into their heads that BTA is the new Luis Suárez, due to how he terrifies us whenever we play the Albion. 
That’s how we ended up signing big fat Victor Anichebe…
Posts: 2,270
Threads: 51
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
05-22-2024, 08:25 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-22-2024, 08:27 AM by Dreamkiller.)
(05-22-2024, 06:37 AM)Peachy Wrote: (05-21-2024, 11:28 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (05-21-2024, 09:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-21-2024, 06:48 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Yeah, a bit of a strange one, this. And whatever I say, I fully expect he'll prove me wrong.
Had this reputation with quite a few of our fans of being unplayable and potentially a 20 goal a season man. And no matter what he did to dispel this reputation by being largely anonymous in most matches, he maintained the myth til the end of his time at Stoke.
Scored a couple of belting goals towards the end of the season, which led to the kind of outcry on his leaving that you get from people who forget how little he contributed until he was in the shop window.
The scorer of great goals rather than a great goalscorer. His highlights package will look magnificent, but give me the much maligned Jacob Brown and his clumsy, scuffed goals from 2 yards anyday.
I'm probably being a tad harsh. But he had this air about him of someone who thought he was doing us a favour by turning up. It didn't help that every few months he'd pile enough timber on to make him a veritable Charlie Adam tribute act. Having said that, it did appear that he was very popular generally with his teammates.
He probably has it in him physically to be a top Championship striker. Someone could very well get the best out of him, but bloody hell, he'll make them work hard for it.
I must have only seen him in the games where he scored a stunner…
This is like how loads of Stoke fans have got it into their heads that BTA is the new Luis Suárez, due to how he terrifies us whenever we play the Albion. 
Give us £15m for him and he's yours! 
In all seriousness BTA has been a cracking signing when compared to the outlay. A £300k signing from div 2 who has a brilliant attitude. Works his socks off, puts himself about and bags a few goals. Some of them stunners. He's a model professional by all accounts and is great with the fans and young supporters with his time.
He comes in for some stick on here by some saying he's wasteful and can't finish but I'm not sure what people expect given what we paid. Luiz Suarez he is not but I'm glad we have him as an option. The guy has single handedly had to be our first choice striker all season and has bagged 11 goals. If we ever manage to find a first choice number 9 that can stay fit then I expect BTA to be a back up and a bloody good back up at that!
That's the thing though, Peachy. You clearly see him as a decent back up, whereas we were desperately looking for a main striker and thinking he would be ideal. I'll openly admit, if I didn't spend time on here and seen what you guys were saying, I'd be desperate for us to sign him at whatever the cost. He genuinely looks out of this world whenever I've seen him.
Malc - Our version is Giannelli Imbula. We spent £18m on him after he'd dazzled us playing against us for Porto in a pre-season friendly. His left foot was a wand. His right foot was a walking stick and he had the work ethic of a sloth. We spent the next four years trying to get him off the books.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-22-2024, 08:25 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (05-22-2024, 06:37 AM)Peachy Wrote: (05-21-2024, 11:28 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (05-21-2024, 09:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-21-2024, 06:48 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Yeah, a bit of a strange one, this. And whatever I say, I fully expect he'll prove me wrong.
Had this reputation with quite a few of our fans of being unplayable and potentially a 20 goal a season man. And no matter what he did to dispel this reputation by being largely anonymous in most matches, he maintained the myth til the end of his time at Stoke.
Scored a couple of belting goals towards the end of the season, which led to the kind of outcry on his leaving that you get from people who forget how little he contributed until he was in the shop window.
The scorer of great goals rather than a great goalscorer. His highlights package will look magnificent, but give me the much maligned Jacob Brown and his clumsy, scuffed goals from 2 yards anyday.
I'm probably being a tad harsh. But he had this air about him of someone who thought he was doing us a favour by turning up. It didn't help that every few months he'd pile enough timber on to make him a veritable Charlie Adam tribute act. Having said that, it did appear that he was very popular generally with his teammates.
He probably has it in him physically to be a top Championship striker. Someone could very well get the best out of him, but bloody hell, he'll make them work hard for it.
I must have only seen him in the games where he scored a stunner…
This is like how loads of Stoke fans have got it into their heads that BTA is the new Luis Suárez, due to how he terrifies us whenever we play the Albion. 
Give us £15m for him and he's yours! 
In all seriousness BTA has been a cracking signing when compared to the outlay. A £300k signing from div 2 who has a brilliant attitude. Works his socks off, puts himself about and bags a few goals. Some of them stunners. He's a model professional by all accounts and is great with the fans and young supporters with his time.
He comes in for some stick on here by some saying he's wasteful and can't finish but I'm not sure what people expect given what we paid. Luiz Suarez he is not but I'm glad we have him as an option. The guy has single handedly had to be our first choice striker all season and has bagged 11 goals. If we ever manage to find a first choice number 9 that can stay fit then I expect BTA to be a back up and a bloody good back up at that!
That's the thing though, Peachy. You clearly see him as a decent back up, whereas we were desperately looking for a main striker and thinking he would be ideal. I'll openly admit, if I didn't spend time on here and seen what you guys were saying, I'd be desperate for us to sign him at whatever the cost. He genuinely looks out of this world whenever I've seen him.
Malc - Our version is Giannelli Imbula. We spent £18m on him after he'd dazzled us playing against us for Porto in a pre-season friendly. His left foot was a wand. His right foot was a walking stick and he had the work ethic of a sloth. We spent the next four years trying to get him off the books.
The warning sign should have been that Porto were willing to part ways with him within a few months of buying him.
Much like when we signed Oli Burke on the back of a few good goals for Forest and having done nothing in Germany. The warning sign should have been when the team with arguably the best talent spotting record in terms of young players in all of Europe were happy to cut their losses citing concerns about his ability and intelligence.
Posts: 2,270
Threads: 51
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
05-22-2024, 10:14 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-22-2024, 10:15 AM by Dreamkiller.)
(05-22-2024, 08:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-22-2024, 08:25 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (05-22-2024, 06:37 AM)Peachy Wrote: (05-21-2024, 11:28 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (05-21-2024, 09:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I must have only seen him in the games where he scored a stunner…
This is like how loads of Stoke fans have got it into their heads that BTA is the new Luis Suárez, due to how he terrifies us whenever we play the Albion. 
Give us £15m for him and he's yours! 
In all seriousness BTA has been a cracking signing when compared to the outlay. A £300k signing from div 2 who has a brilliant attitude. Works his socks off, puts himself about and bags a few goals. Some of them stunners. He's a model professional by all accounts and is great with the fans and young supporters with his time.
He comes in for some stick on here by some saying he's wasteful and can't finish but I'm not sure what people expect given what we paid. Luiz Suarez he is not but I'm glad we have him as an option. The guy has single handedly had to be our first choice striker all season and has bagged 11 goals. If we ever manage to find a first choice number 9 that can stay fit then I expect BTA to be a back up and a bloody good back up at that!
That's the thing though, Peachy. You clearly see him as a decent back up, whereas we were desperately looking for a main striker and thinking he would be ideal. I'll openly admit, if I didn't spend time on here and seen what you guys were saying, I'd be desperate for us to sign him at whatever the cost. He genuinely looks out of this world whenever I've seen him.
Malc - Our version is Giannelli Imbula. We spent £18m on him after he'd dazzled us playing against us for Porto in a pre-season friendly. His left foot was a wand. His right foot was a walking stick and he had the work ethic of a sloth. We spent the next four years trying to get him off the books.
The warning sign should have been that Porto were willing to part ways with him within a few months of buying him.
Much like when we signed Oli Burke on the back of a few good goals for Forest and having done nothing in Germany. The warning sign should have been when the team with arguably the best talent spotting record in terms of young players in all of Europe were happy to cut their losses citing concerns about his ability and intelligence.
Reputable sources at the club claim that Juventus were willing to give us pretty much double what we'd paid for him just a few months after we'd signed him.
The club refused, thinking we'd got ourselves a real gem to add to players like Arnie, Bojan and Shaqiri - Imbula looked phenomenal in the first couple of months.
Then in the blink of an eye, maybe as a result of our refusal to sell, his form just dropped off a cliff and we couldn't give him away.
|