Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
The Corberan discussion on the Brighton thread seems to match what I see on social media. There is a growing, albeit still mainly a minority of fans, who are questioning his ability. Whilst questioning is fine, some of the criticism feels harsh given what he's done in a relatively short time under extremely difficult circumstances.
He's not the messiah, but we have a good un who will improve with more experience. His work ethic is astonishing, players buy in to him, he connects with fans and staff. He gets it.
Ultimately it's about results and overall he's in the positive category. Taking us from bottom to 5th in less than 2 years with an unbalanced squad and players that most had written off as not being good enough is a good achievement. Not a miracle, but still a good achievement.
I think the best judge of any coach is have the players improved under him and who have stagnated or regressed.
I'd say only a couple, 3 at most have stagnated or regressed. The rest have either improved or dramatically improved. When was the last manager you could say did that for us? Roy?
He does get things wrong. I think he overthinks things sometimes. But overall he's doing a bloody good job, he's the perfect fit for us, and I think we are lucky to have him.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
Posts: 7,866
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
Impossible to fully judge him without seeing his recruitment with some wonga to spend, which may take some time to happen with us.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 4,323
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(05-21-2024, 10:10 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The Corberan discussion on the Brighton thread seems to match what I see on social media.
Welcome new poster, villa or wolves?
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
(05-21-2024, 10:10 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The Corberan discussion on the Brighton thread seems to match what I see on social media. There is a growing, albeit still mainly a minority of fans, who are questioning his ability. Whilst questioning is fine, some of the criticism feels harsh given what he's done in a relatively short time under extremely difficult circumstances.
He's not the messiah, but we have a good un who will improve with more experience. His work ethic is astonishing, players buy in to him, he connects with fans and staff. He gets it.
Ultimately it's about results and overall he's in the positive category. Taking us from bottom to 5th in less than 2 years with an unbalanced squad and players that most had written off as not being good enough is a good achievement. Not a miracle, but still a good achievement.
I think the best judge of any coach is have the players improved under him and who have stagnated or regressed.
I'd say only a couple, 3 at most have stagnated or regressed. The rest have either improved or dramatically improved. When was the last manager you could say did that for us? Roy?
He does get things wrong. I think he overthinks things sometimes. But overall he's doing a bloody good job, he's the perfect fit for us, and I think we are lucky to have him.
I like him but he frustrates me more than he should.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(05-21-2024, 10:10 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The Corberan discussion on the Brighton thread seems to match what I see on social media. There is a growing, albeit still mainly a minority of fans, who are questioning his ability. Whilst questioning is fine, some of the criticism feels harsh given what he's done in a relatively short time under extremely difficult circumstances.
He's not the messiah, but we have a good un who will improve with more experience. His work ethic is astonishing, players buy in to him, he connects with fans and staff. He gets it.
Ultimately it's about results and overall he's in the positive category. Taking us from bottom to 5th in less than 2 years with an unbalanced squad and players that most had written off as not being good enough is a good achievement. Not a miracle, but still a good achievement.
I think the best judge of any coach is have the players improved under him and who have stagnated or regressed.
I'd say only a couple, 3 at most have stagnated or regressed. The rest have either improved or dramatically improved. When was the last manager you could say did that for us? Roy?
He does get things wrong. I think he overthinks things sometimes. But overall he's doing a bloody good job, he's the perfect fit for us, and I think we are lucky to have him.
Pretty much agree with all that. Compared to some of the rubbish we've recruited as manager over the years I'm very happy with him.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
He's doing a great job.
How did he get us to 5th with the lack of strikers?
Given the Lai shenanigans he provided a degree of stability through resoluteness that can't be underestimated.
He does things that I don't understand at times and our play can be exhilarating one match and dour the next.
A strong 8/10 for his tenure thus far.
Posts: 641
Threads: 32
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
5
(05-21-2024, 10:10 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The Corberan discussion on the Brighton thread seems to match what I see on social media. There is a growing, albeit still mainly a minority of fans, who are questioning his ability. Whilst questioning is fine, some of the criticism feels harsh given what he's done in a relatively short time under extremely difficult circumstances.
He's not the messiah, but we have a good un who will improve with more experience. His work ethic is astonishing, players buy in to him, he connects with fans and staff. He gets it.
Ultimately it's about results and overall he's in the positive category. Taking us from bottom to 5th in less than 2 years with an unbalanced squad and players that most had written off as not being good enough is a good achievement. Not a miracle, but still a good achievement.
I think the best judge of any coach is have the players improved under him and who have stagnated or regressed.
I'd say only a couple, 3 at most have stagnated or regressed. The rest have either improved or dramatically improved. When was the last manager you could say did that for us? Roy?
He does get things wrong. I think he overthinks things sometimes. But overall he's doing a bloody good job, he's the perfect fit for us, and I think we are lucky to have him.
Good post Rich.
He's still in credit in bucketloads. Factor in a new owner optimism feel - a man who also appears to connects with fans and staff and we have reason to be optimistic. Given we were in all sorts of shit, i hope people will be patient in another tough season ( at least on the pitch) to come.
The minority of naysayers will no doubt grow if we aren't 5 points ahead of the pack at Christmas!
Posts: 13,258
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
I genuinely think he's the best manager in the Championship
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
He's good, probably as good as we can get. He's made mistakes, and also delivered a decent finish. Just doesn't seem to be able to provide the gee up that's needed when the pressure is on.
He's definitely somewhere in between. I wonder if Wagner would've achieved the same, impossible to know. But I'd say they're similar levels.
|