Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
05-20-2024, 01:23 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2024, 02:19 PM by Lurker#3.)
For me I would be looking at this as our squad for next year to look like:
* EP = Experienced Pro (27 - Retirement), YP = Young Pro (22-26), HGP = Home Grown Prospect (<21)
GK:
1) Palmer (EP) / Griffiths (YP)
2) Cann (YP)
3) Cisse/Hollingshead (HGP)
LB:
1) Townsend (EP)
2) New - YP
RB:
1) Furlong (EP)
2) New - YP
CB:
1) Kipre (EP)
2) New - YP
3) Ajayi (EP)
4) Pieters (EP)
5) Taylor (HGP)
CM:
1) Okay (EP)
2) Mowatt (EP)
3) Molumby (YP)
4) New - YP
5) Mufamba/Whitwell/Deeming (HGP)
AM/W:
1) Wallace (EP)
2) Fellows (HGP)
3) Grady (YP)
4) Swift (EP)
5) New - YP (Dynamic left sided wide player)
6) Heard/Higgins (HGP)
ST:
1) BTA (YP)
2) Maja (YP)
3) Dike (YP)
4) New - EP/youth loan/free
Summary:
GK - One of Palmer or Griffiths to be sold to balance FFP, Cann to be reserve and the 2 youngsters available on rotation as #3 with one always out on loan.
CB - We need to move Bartley on as he's such a high earner sadly, we need to try and keep Kipre because he is coming into his prime, and against all my expectations has turned into our best CB. Pieters is worth another 12 months as he's cheap as chips and a good, solid, fit pro ad zero risk. Then we need to get another player to challenge Kipre/Ajayi, the senior pros and to compete with Taylor for a starting berth.
RB/LB - We need 2 young, athletic, fast, young prospects who can develop and challenge the 2 older heads at fullback. We have needed them for a few years, but now it is a must. I guess its also last chance saloon for Ethan Ingram who is highly thought of still. There is a good episode on "One Up Front" podcast by Salford FC fan with his dad, well worth a listen.
CM - As above. We need a real powerhouse, running, aggressive young midfielder. We need to balance off against the sensible, important but ploddy contributions from Okay and Mowatt.
AM/W - There is a theme with what we need. We need explosive, fast, dynamic and unpredictable. This player can be a bit of a wild card as we have so many reliable, predictable players in this area of the pitch.
ST - We need a target man in Dike's absence. Probably an older head/young player on loan or a free given the financial situation.
All together that's a 23 man squad with a handful of youngsters in CM and AM/W positions to try and break through. The most important thing is the profile of incoming players. We need to pace, aggression and dynamism.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-20-2024, 01:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For me I would be looking at this as our squad for next year to look like:
* EP = Experienced Pro (27 - Retirement), YP = Young Pro (22-26), HGP = Home Grown Prospect (<21)
GK:
1) Palmer (EP) / Griffiths (YP)
2) Cann (YP)
3) Cisse/Hollingshead (HGP)
LB:
1) Townsend (EP)
2) New - YP
RB:
1) Furlong (EP)
2) New - YP
CB:
1) Kipre (EP)
2) New - YP
3) Ajayi (EP)
4) Pieters (EP)
4) Taylor (HGP)
CM:
1) Okay (EP)
2) Mowatt (EP)
3) Molumby (YP)
4) New - YP
5) Mufamba/Whitwell/Deeming (HGP)
AM/W:
1) Wallace (EP)
2) Fellows (HGP)
3) Grady (YP)
4) Swift (EP)
5) New - YP (Dynamic left sided wide player)
6) Heard/Higgins (HGP)
ST:
1) BTA (YP)
2) Maja (YP)
3) Dike (YP)
4) New - EP/youth loan/free
Summary:
GK - One of Palmer or Griffiths to be sold to balance FFP, Cann to be reserve and the 2 youngsters available on rotation as #3 with one always out on loan.
CB - We need to move Bartley on as he's such a high earner sadly, we need to try and keep Kipre because he is coming into his prime, and against all my expectations has turned into our best CB. Pieters is worth another 12 months as he's cheap as chips and a good, solid, fit pro ad zero risk. Then we need to get another player to challenge Kipre/Ajayi, the senior pros and to compete with Taylor for a starting berth.
RB/LB - We need 2 young, athletic, fast, young prospects who can develop and challenge the 2 older heads at fullback. We have needed them for a few years, but now it is a must. I guess its also last chance saloon for Ethan Ingram who is highly thought of still. There is a good episode on "One Up Front" podcast by Salford FC fan with his dad, well worth a listen.
CM - As above. We need a real powerhouse, running, aggressive young midfielder. We need to balance off against the sensible, important but ploddy contributions from Okay and Mowatt.
AM/W - There is a theme with what we need. We need explosive, fast, dynamic and unpredictable. This player can be a bit of a wild card as we have so many reliable, predictable players in this area of the pitch.
ST - We need a target man in Dike's absence. Probably an older head/young player on loan or a free given the financial situation.
All together that's a 23 man squad with a handful of youngsters in CM and AM/W positions to try and break through. The most important thing is the profile of incoming players. We need to pace, aggression and dynamism.
I think every club wants young, fast, dynamic players the problem is they go to clubs who can afford them.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
05-20-2024, 01:32 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2024, 01:33 PM by Lurker#3.)
(05-20-2024, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think every club wants young, fast, dynamic players the problem is they go to clubs who can afford them.
I am not sure every club does. Clubs want players in a profile lacking in their squads. Many squads are littered with tall, fast, "runners" and are crying out for a Mowatt/Okay/Swift/Townsend.
We are, more than pretty much any team I have seen littered with solid, ploddy, experienced, predictable players. Nothing wrong with them but we lack balance.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-20-2024, 01:32 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (05-20-2024, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think every club wants young, fast, dynamic players the problem is they go to clubs who can afford them.
I am not sure every club does. Clubs want players in a profile lacking in their squads. Many squads are littered with tall, fast, "runners" and are crying out for a Mowatt/Okay/Swift/Townsend.
We are, more than pretty much any team I have seen littered with solid, ploddy, experienced, predictable players. Nothing wrong with them but we lack balance.
Personally I think almost every team would prefer quick, aggressive dynamic players but they come with a premium because you can usually find a player with one of those attributes but not all of them at our level.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
05-20-2024, 01:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2024, 01:42 PM by Lurker#3.)
(05-20-2024, 01:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-20-2024, 01:32 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (05-20-2024, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think every club wants young, fast, dynamic players the problem is they go to clubs who can afford them.
I am not sure every club does. Clubs want players in a profile lacking in their squads. Many squads are littered with tall, fast, "runners" and are crying out for a Mowatt/Okay/Swift/Townsend.
We are, more than pretty much any team I have seen littered with solid, ploddy, experienced, predictable players. Nothing wrong with them but we lack balance.
Personally I think almost every team would prefer quick, aggressive dynamic players but they come with a premium because you can usually find a player with one of those attributes but not all of them at our level.
The premium is on those players you mention who develop some consistency and end product too. We cant expect to get somebody with an end product like Swift who is also fast, dynamic and aggressive. We just need those physical attributes and some ability to work with in the hope they develop the consistency.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
05-20-2024, 03:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2024, 03:33 PM by SW4Baggie.)
(05-20-2024, 01:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (05-20-2024, 01:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-20-2024, 01:32 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (05-20-2024, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think every club wants young, fast, dynamic players the problem is they go to clubs who can afford them.
I am not sure every club does. Clubs want players in a profile lacking in their squads. Many squads are littered with tall, fast, "runners" and are crying out for a Mowatt/Okay/Swift/Townsend.
We are, more than pretty much any team I have seen littered with solid, ploddy, experienced, predictable players. Nothing wrong with them but we lack balance.
Personally I think almost every team would prefer quick, aggressive dynamic players but they come with a premium because you can usually find a player with one of those attributes but not all of them at our level.
The premium is on those players you mention who develop some consistency and end product too. We cant expect to get somebody with an end product like Swift who is also fast, dynamic and aggressive. We just need those physical attributes and some ability to work with in the hope they develop the consistency.
Indeed
Fortunately there isn't a shortage of powerful and fast players - it's been a profile plenty of academies have been prioritising due to the expected evolution of football - the skill is finding a player that can be coached to add composure, intelligence and technique to his game, and training them into a system that becomes second nature.
(05-20-2024, 01:02 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You cannot build for success by selling your best young players as soon as they have proven good enough for the first team. The aim has to be to build a squad to get out of this division and increase commercial revenue that doesn’t rely on us becoming a feeder club to our richer neighbours and other Prem clubs. The Championship is not self sufficient it never has been and I doubt unless you close the door to promotion that it ever will be.
Knowing when to sell is important but currently we don’t have more than a handful of players we can sell at a profit and two of them are our best players. I see very little progress made on the pitch if our ambition only stretches to hoping we find some unknown rough diamonds to replace the ones we polish every season. Where is the continuity in style and building a long term strategy if we flog our best players as soon as they deemed good enough to play regularly? Also the massive elephant in the room is many of our best young players get poached for next to nothing by clubs offering them and their families more money, again when the reality of our clubs difficulties retaining decent young players is pointed out it’s apparent we cannot rely on this route to make us a competitive Championship club who can get promotion.
We have to diversify our income streams, ticket sales and selling players to keep afloat is not a model that will see us back in the Prem and more likely than not see us flounder for years in this division at best.
I’m all for better long term football strategy, with better coaches, academy, scouting etc but I really hope our new owner has better plans than flogging a debt couple of our best young players each season and putting season ticket prices up.
Interesting you say this Derek, but generally speaking the facts don't really back this up.
If you look at the sides that have been in the playoff/promotion picture since Covid in the Champ it is either those with parachute payments, or those that have been exceptionally well run and steadily built a side through sensible sales and reinvesting along the way... Luton, Coventry, Sunderland, Barnsley, Huddersfield etc.
The road back to the PL for us from here is going to be a long one I'm afraid - I think we may have to accept a couple of seasons of transition where by we repurpose and refresh the squad though selling our best assets and having faith in our staff to design and execute a plan. I totally understand your logic in not selling our best players, but given how many of our players are currently out of contract this summer and next, and age of our squad overall, we may well have to accept that we need to raise £10m and invest £4-5m into players we believe we can sell for a profit again in 12-18 months.
As we've seen in the last 3 years, retaining our best, experienced players has hardly been a guarantee of a top 6 finish!
(05-20-2024, 01:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For me I would be looking at this as our squad for next year to look like:
* EP = Experienced Pro (27 - Retirement), YP = Young Pro (22-26), HGP = Home Grown Prospect (<21)
GK:
1) Palmer (EP) / Griffiths (YP)
2) Cann (YP)
3) Cisse/Hollingshead (HGP)
LB:
1) Townsend (EP)
2) New - YP
RB:
1) Furlong (EP)
2) New - YP
CB:
1) Kipre (EP)
2) New - YP
3) Ajayi (EP)
4) Pieters (EP)
5) Taylor (HGP)
CM:
1) Okay (EP)
2) Mowatt (EP)
3) Molumby (YP)
4) New - YP
5) Mufamba/Whitwell/Deeming (HGP)
AM/W:
1) Wallace (EP)
2) Fellows (HGP)
3) Grady (YP)
4) Swift (EP)
5) New - YP (Dynamic left sided wide player)
6) Heard/Higgins (HGP)
ST:
1) BTA (YP)
2) Maja (YP)
3) Dike (YP)
4) New - EP/youth loan/free
Summary:
GK - One of Palmer or Griffiths to be sold to balance FFP, Cann to be reserve and the 2 youngsters available on rotation as #3 with one always out on loan.
CB - We need to move Bartley on as he's such a high earner sadly, we need to try and keep Kipre because he is coming into his prime, and against all my expectations has turned into our best CB. Pieters is worth another 12 months as he's cheap as chips and a good, solid, fit pro ad zero risk. Then we need to get another player to challenge Kipre/Ajayi, the senior pros and to compete with Taylor for a starting berth.
RB/LB - We need 2 young, athletic, fast, young prospects who can develop and challenge the 2 older heads at fullback. We have needed them for a few years, but now it is a must. I guess its also last chance saloon for Ethan Ingram who is highly thought of still. There is a good episode on "One Up Front" podcast by Salford FC fan with his dad, well worth a listen.
CM - As above. We need a real powerhouse, running, aggressive young midfielder. We need to balance off against the sensible, important but ploddy contributions from Okay and Mowatt.
AM/W - There is a theme with what we need. We need explosive, fast, dynamic and unpredictable. This player can be a bit of a wild card as we have so many reliable, predictable players in this area of the pitch.
ST - We need a target man in Dike's absence. Probably an older head/young player on loan or a free given the financial situation.
All together that's a 23 man squad with a handful of youngsters in CM and AM/W positions to try and break through. The most important thing is the profile of incoming players. We need to pace, aggression and dynamism.
You lost me on keeping Pieters for another year Lurker - he's been a solid pro for us, but I think another CB is an absolute priority to pair with Kipre, with Taylor and Ajayi the other two. CT should get pre-season to prove his fitness and stake a claim, but as I've said on another thread, I wouldn't mind a loan deal for Binks from Bologna. Good in the air and has a decent pass on him. Got injuries at the wrong time, but would be a decent foil for Cedric IMO.
Power, pace, energy and aggression is needed across the board - a first choice LB, someone to push Furlong, and then some fresh legs in the middle and up top.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
05-20-2024, 03:53 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2024, 03:54 PM by Ted Maul.)
(05-20-2024, 01:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For me I would be looking at this as our squad for next year to look like:
* EP = Experienced Pro (27 - Retirement), YP = Young Pro (22-26), HGP = Home Grown Prospect (<21)
GK:
1) Palmer (EP) / Griffiths (YP)
2) Cann (YP)
3) Cisse/Hollingshead (HGP)
LB:
1) Townsend (EP)
2) New - YP
RB:
1) Furlong (EP)
2) New - YP
CB:
1) Kipre (EP)
2) New - YP
3) Ajayi (EP)
4) Pieters (EP)
5) Taylor (HGP)
CM:
1) Okay (EP)
2) Mowatt (EP)
3) Molumby (YP)
4) New - YP
5) Mufamba/Whitwell/Deeming (HGP)
AM/W:
1) Wallace (EP)
2) Fellows (HGP)
3) Grady (YP)
4) Swift (EP)
5) New - YP (Dynamic left sided wide player)
6) Heard/Higgins (HGP)
ST:
1) BTA (YP)
2) Maja (YP)
3) Dike (YP)
4) New - EP/youth loan/free
Summary:
GK - One of Palmer or Griffiths to be sold to balance FFP, Cann to be reserve and the 2 youngsters available on rotation as #3 with one always out on loan.
CB - We need to move Bartley on as he's such a high earner sadly, we need to try and keep Kipre because he is coming into his prime, and against all my expectations has turned into our best CB. Pieters is worth another 12 months as he's cheap as chips and a good, solid, fit pro ad zero risk. Then we need to get another player to challenge Kipre/Ajayi, the senior pros and to compete with Taylor for a starting berth.
RB/LB - We need 2 young, athletic, fast, young prospects who can develop and challenge the 2 older heads at fullback. We have needed them for a few years, but now it is a must. I guess its also last chance saloon for Ethan Ingram who is highly thought of still. There is a good episode on "One Up Front" podcast by Salford FC fan with his dad, well worth a listen.
CM - As above. We need a real powerhouse, running, aggressive young midfielder. We need to balance off against the sensible, important but ploddy contributions from Okay and Mowatt.
AM/W - There is a theme with what we need. We need explosive, fast, dynamic and unpredictable. This player can be a bit of a wild card as we have so many reliable, predictable players in this area of the pitch.
ST - We need a target man in Dike's absence. Probably an older head/young player on loan or a free given the financial situation.
All together that's a 23 man squad with a handful of youngsters in CM and AM/W positions to try and break through. The most important thing is the profile of incoming players. We need to pace, aggression and dynamism.
A resoundingly sensible post as ever and people are queuing up to argue with you. Don't know why you bother Lurker
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(05-20-2024, 03:53 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-20-2024, 01:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For me I would be looking at this as our squad for next year to look like:
* EP = Experienced Pro (27 - Retirement), YP = Young Pro (22-26), HGP = Home Grown Prospect (<21)
GK:
1) Palmer (EP) / Griffiths (YP)
2) Cann (YP)
3) Cisse/Hollingshead (HGP)
LB:
1) Townsend (EP)
2) New - YP
RB:
1) Furlong (EP)
2) New - YP
CB:
1) Kipre (EP)
2) New - YP
3) Ajayi (EP)
4) Pieters (EP)
5) Taylor (HGP)
CM:
1) Okay (EP)
2) Mowatt (EP)
3) Molumby (YP)
4) New - YP
5) Mufamba/Whitwell/Deeming (HGP)
AM/W:
1) Wallace (EP)
2) Fellows (HGP)
3) Grady (YP)
4) Swift (EP)
5) New - YP (Dynamic left sided wide player)
6) Heard/Higgins (HGP)
ST:
1) BTA (YP)
2) Maja (YP)
3) Dike (YP)
4) New - EP/youth loan/free
Summary:
GK - One of Palmer or Griffiths to be sold to balance FFP, Cann to be reserve and the 2 youngsters available on rotation as #3 with one always out on loan.
CB - We need to move Bartley on as he's such a high earner sadly, we need to try and keep Kipre because he is coming into his prime, and against all my expectations has turned into our best CB. Pieters is worth another 12 months as he's cheap as chips and a good, solid, fit pro ad zero risk. Then we need to get another player to challenge Kipre/Ajayi, the senior pros and to compete with Taylor for a starting berth.
RB/LB - We need 2 young, athletic, fast, young prospects who can develop and challenge the 2 older heads at fullback. We have needed them for a few years, but now it is a must. I guess its also last chance saloon for Ethan Ingram who is highly thought of still. There is a good episode on "One Up Front" podcast by Salford FC fan with his dad, well worth a listen.
CM - As above. We need a real powerhouse, running, aggressive young midfielder. We need to balance off against the sensible, important but ploddy contributions from Okay and Mowatt.
AM/W - There is a theme with what we need. We need explosive, fast, dynamic and unpredictable. This player can be a bit of a wild card as we have so many reliable, predictable players in this area of the pitch.
ST - We need a target man in Dike's absence. Probably an older head/young player on loan or a free given the financial situation.
All together that's a 23 man squad with a handful of youngsters in CM and AM/W positions to try and break through. The most important thing is the profile of incoming players. We need to pace, aggression and dynamism.
A resoundingly sensible post as ever and people are queuing up to argue with you. Don't know why you bother Lurker 
Fair assessment, but can't see Kipre or Mowatt staying.
We dumped them when the going got tough, had them back now they're free agents. Signing on fee's and more wages will be needed.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(05-20-2024, 04:28 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (05-20-2024, 03:53 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-20-2024, 01:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For me I would be looking at this as our squad for next year to look like:
* EP = Experienced Pro (27 - Retirement), YP = Young Pro (22-26), HGP = Home Grown Prospect (<21)
GK:
1) Palmer (EP) / Griffiths (YP)
2) Cann (YP)
3) Cisse/Hollingshead (HGP)
LB:
1) Townsend (EP)
2) New - YP
RB:
1) Furlong (EP)
2) New - YP
CB:
1) Kipre (EP)
2) New - YP
3) Ajayi (EP)
4) Pieters (EP)
5) Taylor (HGP)
CM:
1) Okay (EP)
2) Mowatt (EP)
3) Molumby (YP)
4) New - YP
5) Mufamba/Whitwell/Deeming (HGP)
AM/W:
1) Wallace (EP)
2) Fellows (HGP)
3) Grady (YP)
4) Swift (EP)
5) New - YP (Dynamic left sided wide player)
6) Heard/Higgins (HGP)
ST:
1) BTA (YP)
2) Maja (YP)
3) Dike (YP)
4) New - EP/youth loan/free
Summary:
GK - One of Palmer or Griffiths to be sold to balance FFP, Cann to be reserve and the 2 youngsters available on rotation as #3 with one always out on loan.
CB - We need to move Bartley on as he's such a high earner sadly, we need to try and keep Kipre because he is coming into his prime, and against all my expectations has turned into our best CB. Pieters is worth another 12 months as he's cheap as chips and a good, solid, fit pro ad zero risk. Then we need to get another player to challenge Kipre/Ajayi, the senior pros and to compete with Taylor for a starting berth.
RB/LB - We need 2 young, athletic, fast, young prospects who can develop and challenge the 2 older heads at fullback. We have needed them for a few years, but now it is a must. I guess its also last chance saloon for Ethan Ingram who is highly thought of still. There is a good episode on "One Up Front" podcast by Salford FC fan with his dad, well worth a listen.
CM - As above. We need a real powerhouse, running, aggressive young midfielder. We need to balance off against the sensible, important but ploddy contributions from Okay and Mowatt.
AM/W - There is a theme with what we need. We need explosive, fast, dynamic and unpredictable. This player can be a bit of a wild card as we have so many reliable, predictable players in this area of the pitch.
ST - We need a target man in Dike's absence. Probably an older head/young player on loan or a free given the financial situation.
All together that's a 23 man squad with a handful of youngsters in CM and AM/W positions to try and break through. The most important thing is the profile of incoming players. We need to pace, aggression and dynamism.
A resoundingly sensible post as ever and people are queuing up to argue with you. Don't know why you bother Lurker 
Fair assessment, but can't see Kipre or Mowatt staying.
We dumped them when the going got tough, had them back now they're free agents. Signing on fee's and more wages will be needed.
We didn't, Brucey did in order to leverage the club unrealistically in terms of wages and contracts with Swift and Wallace's signings.
Think Kipre will stay. Mowatt may want too much money for his age. And if he is demanding too much I wouldn't be heartbroken broken to see him leave, as well as he's done this year his skill set isn't too hard to replace.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 1,171
Threads: 103
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
6
I am not one of these financial wizards on here but I understand there’s a few windows to get finances clear. I also wonder how many other clubs in the champ have a similar conundrum.
One thing often overlooked on here is many of the signings could also be from aboard like Yokuslu was.
It’ll be an interesting summer and whist I expect guys like Phillips and Bartley to go I really expect maybe one sale of someone like Palmer or Fellows and that’s about it.
There’ll be some wheeling and dealing but suspect many clubs will be faced with similar issues.
|