Squad 2024/2025
#51
(05-20-2024, 07:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Last season Fellows came through, the season before Palmer

Next season Faal, Griffiths, Taylor, Ingram, Heard or Whitall could, if given the chance

I would estimate about 20 of our apprentices/academy graduates played in the four tiers of the football league, among them
Wood, O'Shea, Aziz, TGH and Field. For a club outside the Premier league that is good.

Our problem is we insist on giving contracts to old players past their best (Barry, Snodgrass, Kelly, Wieman etc) rather than giving our young players a go. I suspect that will not change and we will see a few more M'Villas next season.

Most agree on here we need somebody savvy to handle recruitment, I hope CC stays but his record on signing players is not that good, we need someone who knows the lower leagues and European leagues, another Ashworth.

It's not about where they play, but if we get money for them when they go. We got 0 for Aziz. 

IIRC, the only Academy players we have received money for in the post-PL era are Morgan Rogers, Sam Field, Nathan Ferguson, TGH and Dara O'Shea. Only for O'Shea did we get north of £2 million. 

While any money against FFP is a good thing, those sums are quite some way less than the £10 million a year some are hoping for. 

There's also the issue of players needing to play in order to build their value and how much that should be countered against picking the best team and if fans are really as patient about developing young talent as they claim to be.
Reply
#52
(05-20-2024, 08:31 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 07:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Last season Fellows came through, the season before Palmer

Next season Faal, Griffiths, Taylor, Ingram, Heard or Whitall could, if given the chance

I would estimate about 20 of our apprentices/academy graduates played in the four tiers of the football league, among them
Wood, O'Shea, Aziz, TGH and Field. For a club outside the Premier league that is good.

Our problem is we insist on giving contracts to old players past their best (Barry, Snodgrass, Kelly, Wieman etc) rather than giving our young players a go. I suspect that will not change and we will see a few more M'Villas next season.

Most agree on here we need somebody savvy to handle recruitment, I hope CC stays but his record on signing players is not that good, we need someone who knows the lower leagues and European leagues, another Ashworth.

It's not about where they play, but if we get money for them when they go. We got 0 for Aziz. 

IIRC, the only Academy players we have received money for in the post-PL era are Morgan Rogers, Sam Field, Nathan Ferguson, TGH and Dara O'Shea. Only for O'Shea did we get north of £2 million. 

While any money against FFP is a good thing, those sums are quite some way less than the £10 million a year some are hoping for. 

There's also the issue of players needing to play in order to build their value and how much that should be countered against picking the best team and if fans are really as patient about developing young talent as they claim to be.

Exactly
Reply
#53
(05-20-2024, 08:31 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 07:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Last season Fellows came through, the season before Palmer

Next season Faal, Griffiths, Taylor, Ingram, Heard or Whitall could, if given the chance

I would estimate about 20 of our apprentices/academy graduates played in the four tiers of the football league, among them
Wood, O'Shea, Aziz, TGH and Field. For a club outside the Premier league that is good.

Our problem is we insist on giving contracts to old players past their best (Barry, Snodgrass, Kelly, Wieman etc) rather than giving our young players a go. I suspect that will not change and we will see a few more M'Villas next season.

Most agree on here we need somebody savvy to handle recruitment, I hope CC stays but his record on signing players is not that good, we need someone who knows the lower leagues and European leagues, another Ashworth.

It's not about where they play, but if we get money for them when they go. We got 0 for Aziz. 

IIRC, the only Academy players we have received money for in the post-PL era are Morgan Rogers, Sam Field, Nathan Ferguson, TGH and Dara O'Shea. Only for O'Shea did we get north of £2 million. 

While any money against FFP is a good thing, those sums are quite some way less than the £10 million a year some are hoping for. 

There's also the issue of players needing to play in order to build their value and how much that should be countered against picking the best team and if fans are really as patient about developing young talent as they claim to be.

I agree with you Squid, but what I would say is that we are at least producing the players.

In the last 5 years we have Rodgers, O'Shea, Irobegum and Ferguson all now at PL clubs (and had we made smarter selling decisions, all could have fetched £10m+ fees) and we have Palmer, Griffiths, Fellows who will command a decent fee in the squad. Add to that the additional players we've generated and seen leave at young ages to the bigger clubs and the likes of Azaz who we failed to make the most of. 

If we'd been savvier, we could have made very generous profits from these players, and I'd say it's much easier for us to improve our selling strategy than it is to suddenly start producing players capable of delivering decent fees.

Unfortunately, we've had no long term plan as a club under Lai, it has always been short term "survive in the PL this year" or "get back to the PL this year" and this lack of a plan has led to short term thinking across the board, hence signings like Martin Kelly instead of giving younger players game time.

Whoever is in charge next season and ongoing needs to buy into the fact our academy needs to be used - we need to see 3-4 players getting game time every season and hope one of them can have the kind of impact Fellows has had. 

In our last 5 seasons in the Championship we've had: Harper break through under Big Dave and look like he would command a decent fee, O'Shea and Ferguson looking excellent under Billic, TGH the only bright point under Val, and then Palmer and Fellows in the last 2 - That's all we need, we just have to keep giving players the opportunity instead of pursuing older stop gap signings.
Reply
#54
I think CC will be aiming at this under Patel. I feel there will be a totally different strategy in the years to come.
Reply
#55
(05-20-2024, 11:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 08:31 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 07:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Last season Fellows came through, the season before Palmer

Next season Faal, Griffiths, Taylor, Ingram, Heard or Whitall could, if given the chance

I would estimate about 20 of our apprentices/academy graduates played in the four tiers of the football league, among them
Wood, O'Shea, Aziz, TGH and Field. For a club outside the Premier league that is good.

Our problem is we insist on giving contracts to old players past their best (Barry, Snodgrass, Kelly, Wieman etc) rather than giving our young players a go. I suspect that will not change and we will see a few more M'Villas next season.

Most agree on here we need somebody savvy to handle recruitment, I hope CC stays but his record on signing players is not that good, we need someone who knows the lower leagues and European leagues, another Ashworth.

It's not about where they play, but if we get money for them when they go. We got 0 for Aziz. 

IIRC, the only Academy players we have received money for in the post-PL era are Morgan Rogers, Sam Field, Nathan Ferguson, TGH and Dara O'Shea. Only for O'Shea did we get north of £2 million. 

While any money against FFP is a good thing, those sums are quite some way less than the £10 million a year some are hoping for. 

There's also the issue of players needing to play in order to build their value and how much that should be countered against picking the best team and if fans are really as patient about developing young talent as they claim to be.

I agree with you Squid, but what I would say is that we are at least producing the players.

In the last 5 years we have Rodgers, O'Shea, Irobegum and Ferguson all now at PL clubs (and had we made smarter selling decisions, all could have fetched £10m+ fees) and we have Palmer, Griffiths, Fellows who will command a decent fee in the squad. Add to that the additional players we've generated and seen leave at young ages to the bigger clubs and the likes of Azaz who we failed to make the most of. 

If we'd been savvier, we could have made very generous profits from these players, and I'd say it's much easier for us to improve our selling strategy than it is to suddenly start producing players capable of delivering decent fees.

Unfortunately, we've had no long term plan as a club under Lai, it has always been short term "survive in the PL this year" or "get back to the PL this year" and this lack of a plan has led to short term thinking across the board, hence signings like Martin Kelly instead of giving younger players game time.

Whoever is in charge next season and ongoing needs to buy into the fact our academy needs to be used - we need to see 3-4 players getting game time every season and hope one of them can have the kind of impact Fellows has had. 

In our last 5 seasons in the Championship we've had: Harper break through under Big Dave and look like he would command a decent fee, O'Shea and Ferguson looking excellent under Billic, TGH the only bright point under Val, and then Palmer and Fellows in the last 2 - That's all we need, we just have to keep giving players the opportunity instead of pursuing older stop gap signings.

This...

We need to look at three pillars in terms of the squad. And it should be as close to 1/3 each as possible. 

1 - Home grown talent from the academy

2 - 20-25 year old, low fee signings, such as BTA who have the potential to fetch a decent sell on but are equally as likely to have a long stay at the club and develop in our senior pros.

3 - Experienced pros - Whether that be the ones we keep who develop into the senior pros such as; Townsend, Furlong, Palmer. Or low risk, short term deals like Pieters/M'Vila.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#56
(05-20-2024, 11:56 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 11:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 08:31 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 07:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Last season Fellows came through, the season before Palmer

Next season Faal, Griffiths, Taylor, Ingram, Heard or Whitall could, if given the chance

I would estimate about 20 of our apprentices/academy graduates played in the four tiers of the football league, among them
Wood, O'Shea, Aziz, TGH and Field. For a club outside the Premier league that is good.

Our problem is we insist on giving contracts to old players past their best (Barry, Snodgrass, Kelly, Wieman etc) rather than giving our young players a go. I suspect that will not change and we will see a few more M'Villas next season.

Most agree on here we need somebody savvy to handle recruitment, I hope CC stays but his record on signing players is not that good, we need someone who knows the lower leagues and European leagues, another Ashworth.

It's not about where they play, but if we get money for them when they go. We got 0 for Aziz. 

IIRC, the only Academy players we have received money for in the post-PL era are Morgan Rogers, Sam Field, Nathan Ferguson, TGH and Dara O'Shea. Only for O'Shea did we get north of £2 million. 

While any money against FFP is a good thing, those sums are quite some way less than the £10 million a year some are hoping for. 

There's also the issue of players needing to play in order to build their value and how much that should be countered against picking the best team and if fans are really as patient about developing young talent as they claim to be.

I agree with you Squid, but what I would say is that we are at least producing the players.

In the last 5 years we have Rodgers, O'Shea, Irobegum and Ferguson all now at PL clubs (and had we made smarter selling decisions, all could have fetched £10m+ fees) and we have Palmer, Griffiths, Fellows who will command a decent fee in the squad. Add to that the additional players we've generated and seen leave at young ages to the bigger clubs and the likes of Azaz who we failed to make the most of. 

If we'd been savvier, we could have made very generous profits from these players, and I'd say it's much easier for us to improve our selling strategy than it is to suddenly start producing players capable of delivering decent fees.

Unfortunately, we've had no long term plan as a club under Lai, it has always been short term "survive in the PL this year" or "get back to the PL this year" and this lack of a plan has led to short term thinking across the board, hence signings like Martin Kelly instead of giving younger players game time.

Whoever is in charge next season and ongoing needs to buy into the fact our academy needs to be used - we need to see 3-4 players getting game time every season and hope one of them can have the kind of impact Fellows has had. 

In our last 5 seasons in the Championship we've had: Harper break through under Big Dave and look like he would command a decent fee, O'Shea and Ferguson looking excellent under Billic, TGH the only bright point under Val, and then Palmer and Fellows in the last 2 - That's all we need, we just have to keep giving players the opportunity instead of pursuing older stop gap signings.

This...

We need to look at three pillars in terms of the squad. And it should be as close to 1/3 each as possible. 

1 - Home grown talent from the academy

2 - 20-25 year old, low fee signings, such as BTA who have the potential to fetch a decent sell on but are equally as likely to have a long stay at the club and develop in our senior pros.

3 - Experienced pros - Whether that be the ones we keep who develop into the senior pros such as; Townsend, Furlong, Palmer. Or low risk, short term deals like Pieters/M'Vila.

Agree with this too… we’ve had the oldest squad in our relative division for quite time time now, or at least been one of the top 2-3 and that has to stop. There’s a time and a place for older, experienced heads but for too long we’ve relied on them.

The next step then becomes a consistent playing style throughout the club, and coaching recruitment based on this, not based on whoever is available and whether or not they did a decent job 10 years ago.

To lurch from Pulis to Pardew, then from Moore/Jones to Billic to Allardyce, then Val to Bruce to Carlos just can’t continue.

Defensively sound, aggressive pressing, pace on the break, that’s how a club with our limited resources can be successful.
Reply
#57
(05-20-2024, 12:03 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Agree with this too… we’ve had the oldest squad in our relative division for quite time time now, or at least been one of the top 2-3 and that has to stop. There’s a time and a place for older, experienced heads but for too long we’ve relied on them.

The next step then becomes a consistent playing style throughout the club, and coaching recruitment based on this, not based on whoever is available and whether or not they did a decent job 10 years ago.
To lurch from Pulis to Pardew, then from Moore/Jones to Billic to Allardyce, then Val to Bruce to Carlos just can’t continue.

Defensively sound, aggressive pressing, pace on the break, that’s how a club with our limited resources can be successful.

Agree with everything you say, pal. I know some people don't like it. But you HAVE to have an identity and philosophy within a club. It hasn't got to be completely rigid and closed down to new ideas, but you have to have a framework to work from. 

I think operating in those 3 "pillars" and having a club identity in terms of the way you operate and play which can always evolve over the years is fundamental and we have been a long time without any such strategy.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#58
Our problem is that we have had far too many in 3, a lot of those short-term deals have not worked out and we have far too many players on the "way down" e.g. Chalobah, Weimann, Pieters and Kelly.

Would we have better giving Heard a go rather than M'Villa
Reply
#59
You cannot build for success by selling your best young players as soon as they have proven good enough for the first team. The aim has to be to build a squad to get out of this division and increase commercial revenue that doesn’t rely on us becoming a feeder club to our richer neighbours and other Prem clubs. The Championship is not self sufficient it never has been and I doubt unless you close the door to promotion that it ever will be.

Knowing when to sell is important but currently we don’t have more than a handful of players we can sell at a profit and two of them are our best players. I see very little progress made on the pitch if our ambition only stretches to hoping we find some unknown rough diamonds to replace the ones we polish every season. Where is the continuity in style and building a long term strategy if we flog our best players as soon as they deemed good enough to play regularly? Also the massive elephant in the room is many of our best young players get poached for next to nothing by clubs offering them and their families more money, again when the reality of our clubs difficulties retaining decent young players is pointed out it’s apparent we cannot rely on this route to make us a competitive Championship club who can get promotion.

We have to diversify our income streams, ticket sales and selling players to keep afloat is not a model that will see us back in the Prem and more likely than not see us flounder for years in this division at best.

I’m all for better long term football strategy, with better coaches, academy, scouting etc but I really hope our new owner has better plans than flogging a debt couple of our best young players each season and putting season ticket prices up.
Reply
#60
We will be forced into playing our academy lads. Sadly many of us have been advocating for years we should feed them into the first team. Now we won't have an option which IMO is great news. I'm still of the opinion Pearce is a complete failure and needs binning asap.
I fail to see a single player he has identified who has come in and we've sold on at a profit. He's he'd plenty of time. Get rid and bring someone in who can pluck hidden gems from the lower leagues.
Our new owners have already stated they will bring extra funds to the club via more sponsorship and increasing merchandise sales globally, maybe even increased use of the Hawthorns away from football. All positives, they will be working hard on increasing incomings and reducing debt. However I certainly don't see them chucking money at inflated transfer fees.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: