Premier League Clubs VAR vote
#31
(05-16-2024, 04:37 PM)oldun Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 08:02 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Only my opinion, but, I think most fans would vote to get rid, at least until it's more fit for purpose, so it will be interesting to see if the actual clubs go the same way.
Doubt it.

Sadly then back to crap referees and linos, the same ones working the VAR. The main issue is offside go back to the daylight and not the toenail rule and it might just work

Yep,simple isn’t it.Daylight- offside, everything else onside. They’ve made it more ridiculous.
Reply
#32
(05-16-2024, 04:37 PM)oldun Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 08:02 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Only my opinion, but, I think most fans would vote to get rid, at least until it's more fit for purpose, so it will be interesting to see if the actual clubs go the same way.
Doubt it.

Sadly then back to crap referees and linos, the same ones working the VAR. The main issue is offside go back to the daylight and not the toenail rule and it might just work

yes, and no. I'm all for the daylight rule but I don't think that's the main issue. The toenail rule is harsh but if it's off then it is off. I'm more disturbed by the VAR's interpretation of the ref's decisions. If it ain't a clear and obvious error, leave it alone.
Reply
#33
(05-16-2024, 05:31 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 04:37 PM)oldun Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 08:02 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Only my opinion, but, I think most fans would vote to get rid, at least until it's more fit for purpose, so it will be interesting to see if the actual clubs go the same way.
Doubt it.

Sadly then back to crap referees and linos, the same ones working the VAR. The main issue is offside go back to the daylight and not the toenail rule and it might just work

yes, and no. I'm all for the daylight rule but I don't think that's the main issue. The toenail rule is harsh but if it's off then it is off. I'm more disturbed by the VAR's interpretation of the ref's decisions. If it ain't a clear and obvious error, leave it alone.

You're contradicting yourself. You say if it's a toenail, it's offside, yet say if it isn't a clear and obvious error then leave it alone. Being a toenail offside is about as far from a clear and obvious error as you can get.
Reply
#34
(05-16-2024, 05:35 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:31 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 04:37 PM)oldun Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 08:02 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Only my opinion, but, I think most fans would vote to get rid, at least until it's more fit for purpose, so it will be interesting to see if the actual clubs go the same way.
Doubt it.

Sadly then back to crap referees and linos, the same ones working the VAR. The main issue is offside go back to the daylight and not the toenail rule and it might just work

yes, and no. I'm all for the daylight rule but I don't think that's the main issue. The toenail rule is harsh but if it's off then it is off. I'm more disturbed by the VAR's interpretation of the ref's decisions. If it ain't a clear and obvious error, leave it alone.

You're contradicting yourself. You say if it's a toenail, it's offside, yet say if it isn't a clear and obvious error then leave it alone. Being a toenail offside is about as far from a clear and obvious error as you can get.

Clear and obvious doesn't apply to the objective yes/no decision of offside/onside. The margin of error is already built into the system whether that's the framerate of the footage or the thickness of the line.

It's the seemingly arbitrary refereeing decisions that it applies to and these that need revamping if they're going to vote down the d1ngle5 motion.
Reply
#35
(05-16-2024, 05:35 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:31 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 04:37 PM)oldun Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 08:02 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Only my opinion, but, I think most fans would vote to get rid, at least until it's more fit for purpose, so it will be interesting to see if the actual clubs go the same way.
Doubt it.

Sadly then back to crap referees and linos, the same ones working the VAR. The main issue is offside go back to the daylight and not the toenail rule and it might just work

yes, and no. I'm all for the daylight rule but I don't think that's the main issue. The toenail rule is harsh but if it's off then it is off. I'm more disturbed by the VAR's interpretation of the ref's decisions. If it ain't a clear and obvious error, leave it alone.

You're contradicting yourself. You say if it's a toenail, it's offside, yet say if it isn't a clear and obvious error then leave it alone. Being a toenail offside is about as far from a clear and obvious error as you can get.

Maybe I should have worded it better. I'm saying although I favour the daylight rule, it is not the offsides that bother me. It is the interpretations of other rules, decisions that could be called either way, fouls, penalties etc.
Reply
#36
(05-16-2024, 05:51 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:35 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:31 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 04:37 PM)oldun Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 08:02 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Only my opinion, but, I think most fans would vote to get rid, at least until it's more fit for purpose, so it will be interesting to see if the actual clubs go the same way.
Doubt it.

Sadly then back to crap referees and linos, the same ones working the VAR. The main issue is offside go back to the daylight and not the toenail rule and it might just work

yes, and no. I'm all for the daylight rule but I don't think that's the main issue. The toenail rule is harsh but if it's off then it is off. I'm more disturbed by the VAR's interpretation of the ref's decisions. If it ain't a clear and obvious error, leave it alone.

You're contradicting yourself. You say if it's a toenail, it's offside, yet say if it isn't a clear and obvious error then leave it alone. Being a toenail offside is about as far from a clear and obvious error as you can get.

Clear and obvious doesn't apply to the objective yes/no decision of offside/onside. The margin of error is already built into the system whether that's the framerate of the footage or the thickness of the line.

It's the seemingly arbitrary refereeing decisions that it applies to and these that need revamping if they're going to vote down the d1ngle5 motion.

I absolutely think it does. If someone is so tight to offside/onside that it takes 4 minuets to make a decision, just stick with the on field linesman. The Coventry FA Cup Semi goal is the perfect example. It takes too long to come to a decision, it ruins the game completely and it ISNT a clear error.
Reply
#37
(05-16-2024, 06:26 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:51 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:35 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:31 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 04:37 PM)oldun Wrote: Sadly then back to crap referees and linos, the same ones working the VAR. The main issue is offside go back to the daylight and not the toenail rule and it might just work

yes, and no. I'm all for the daylight rule but I don't think that's the main issue. The toenail rule is harsh but if it's off then it is off. I'm more disturbed by the VAR's interpretation of the ref's decisions. If it ain't a clear and obvious error, leave it alone.

You're contradicting yourself. You say if it's a toenail, it's offside, yet say if it isn't a clear and obvious error then leave it alone. Being a toenail offside is about as far from a clear and obvious error as you can get.

Clear and obvious doesn't apply to the objective yes/no decision of offside/onside. The margin of error is already built into the system whether that's the framerate of the footage or the thickness of the line.

It's the seemingly arbitrary refereeing decisions that it applies to and these that need revamping if they're going to vote down the d1ngle5 motion.

I absolutely think it does. If someone is so tight to offside/onside that it takes 4 minuets to make a decision, just stick with the on field linesman. The Coventry FA Cup Semi goal is the perfect example. It takes too long to come to a decision, it ruins the game completely and it ISNT a clear error.

Couldn't agree more. If its so marginal that it takes 4 minutes to make an offside decision then its just not worth doing, it detracts far more from the game than it adds. If we must keep var then if they can't decide within a minute then go with the refs on field decision
Reply
#38
(05-16-2024, 06:39 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 06:26 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:51 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:35 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-16-2024, 05:31 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: yes, and no. I'm all for the daylight rule but I don't think that's the main issue. The toenail rule is harsh but if it's off then it is off. I'm more disturbed by the VAR's interpretation of the ref's decisions. If it ain't a clear and obvious error, leave it alone.

You're contradicting yourself. You say if it's a toenail, it's offside, yet say if it isn't a clear and obvious error then leave it alone. Being a toenail offside is about as far from a clear and obvious error as you can get.

Clear and obvious doesn't apply to the objective yes/no decision of offside/onside. The margin of error is already built into the system whether that's the framerate of the footage or the thickness of the line.

It's the seemingly arbitrary refereeing decisions that it applies to and these that need revamping if they're going to vote down the d1ngle5 motion.

I absolutely think it does. If someone is so tight to offside/onside that it takes 4 minuets to make a decision, just stick with the on field linesman. The Coventry FA Cup Semi goal is the perfect example. It takes too long to come to a decision, it ruins the game completely and it ISNT a clear error.

Couldn't agree more. If its so marginal that it takes 4 minutes to make an offside decision then its just not worth doing, it detracts far more from the game than it adds. If we must keep var then if they can't decide within a minute then go with the refs on field decision

Perhaps they ought to not draw the lines and the VAR just goes with what he can see.

"Is it definitely onside/offside?" (i.e. the opposite of what the linesman has called)
"Fuck knows. I can't tell for sure"
"Then we go with the linesman's call"
Reply
#39
I think one possible solution is for each team to have one VAR call per half/two per match. Teams wouldn't be quick to use these except for what they perceived to be obvious, game-changing mistakes, in case of a more egregious decision was more costly later on in the game. This would reduce the amount of nitpicky checks we currently have in matches.

I don't think the 'daylight' rule would make a bit of difference to offside decisions. You'd just be moving one arbitrary marking point for another. If anything, it would make it much harder. There would be far more contestable VAR offside decisions than there are now, IMO.
Reply
#40
Klopp said he'd vote to get rid of it...I testing.

I note the vote is on DDay, June 6, will the newly promoted sides get a vote on it then?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: