Natalie Elphicke MP
#41
(05-13-2024, 09:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-13-2024, 07:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(05-11-2024, 11:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote: In what world is accepting Natalie Elphicke into his ranks going to "appease Tory right voters"? Can you explain please?

You're betraying your naivety again. Every political party exists to win elections. A moral or intellectual compass is worth nothing without power. It's why people like you enjoy being in opposition. You can wrap yourself up in your self righteous safe space knowing full well you don't have to face the difficult decisions of governance.

You've never been more right than this. This is why Labour First exists and it is why Starmer is leader. If you don't want Tories stfu and vote Labour.

The main objective of the Labour Party is to be elected and to stay in power and to govern in the interests of everyone

Purity - makes me sick

I welcome Natalie into the Labour Party and hope she finds a home amongst us good people where she can be rehabilitated. On that note Mr P is also welcome, he too, could begin his journey

Why are you welcoming an apologist for a rapist and someone that lobbied in an attempt to prevent the course of justice? How can you possibly trust that they believe in the rule of law?

To err is human to forgive is devine

And I just saw this on twitter: This line from Rishi Sunak helps Labour: Keir Starmer has gone from embracing Jeremy Corbyn to Natalie Elphicke- Keir Starmer’s most important sell to voters is that he has changed his party. And hearing his opponent spell it out like this does the work for him.
Reply
#42
That doesn't wash with me, and quite frankly trying to push that as an attempt to avoid answering the question is pathetic. This isn't like Wakeford or Poulter where this is about relativistic morals in regards to policy. Elphicke lobbied in an attempt to obstruct justice, she clearly doesn't believe in the rule of law and she is an apologist for a sexual assaulter.
Reply
#43
Moreover, the Tories should have done something about her a few years ago.

Let's be honest BB though, it's all optics. Starmer gets a quick 1-0 for those that noticed. Most of those who noticed know nothing about Natalie Elphicke which merely then feeds into the narrative that MPs are abandoning the Tories.
Reply
#44
(05-12-2024, 04:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote: That's spot on. All politics is simply managerialism these days. There's no soaring oratory, no attempt to win philosophical arguments. Those days are gone, for now.

Starmer is as much a victim of the system that created the opportunity for him as Major, Blair, Brown, Cameron, May or Sunak. I'm not sure what he's doing that so upsets you beyond trying to get elected.

But elected to do what?

I might be old fashioned but politics should work in this way.

Political parties set out their vision for the country and  provide policies that will realise that vision. We the electorate vote for the party whose vision we like best and give us confidence that they have policies that can achieve that vision.

Currently Labour are not providing that vision...how can they when the church is so broad that apparently Natalie Elphicke and John Mcdonnell are both mps for the party..

I can't vote for Labour I no longer have any understanding of what their core beliefs and philosophy are anymore.
Reply
#45
All 3 polls since the switch have Labour making 2 point gains.

Not that it justifies the decision, but it does give you context on the 'optics'.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#46
Let's just get these bastards out.

That's the full extent of my political analysis.

The monster raving looney party would have done a better job than this lot of crooks and gobshites.
Reply
#47
What we are seeing - not for the first time - is the inherent weakness of FPTP.

The electoral system exercises a gravitational pull on both of the potential parties of government; right now it just happens to be the Tories' turn to spiral out of control and Labour's to return to orbit. We need something better; just a pity we don't seem to want it.
Reply
#48
(05-13-2024, 10:17 AM)Bromley Baggie 2 Wrote: Couldn't Starmer have just told her "Bugger off, We don't want your sort in our party" when she crossed the floor?

  That is what should have been done.  Labour should not want to be associated with her or anyone of that ilk.    She's clearly a wrong 'un.
Reply
#49
(05-13-2024, 05:13 PM)Ossian Wrote: We need something better; just a pity we don't seem to want it.

What is "something better"?

The Tories returned to the centre ground in 2010, and would've remained there were it not for the unexpected election of large and clearly lunatic fringe in 2019.

Labour has returned to the centre ground after a disastrous flirtation with the very worst lunatic aspects of the Labour movement. 

The problem now, unlike in 2010 - is that the fiscal and monetary straitjacket is so tight that state-led attempts to escape will be futile. In an era of deglobalisation growth is likely to further stagnate in mature economies.

People simply won't vote for "something better". Except in a crisis, like they have in Argentina....

(05-13-2024, 01:57 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I can't vote for Labour I no longer have any understanding of what their core beliefs and philosophy are anymore.

I refer you to the answer above. 

Their core beliefs stretch to being a little more interventionist than a reasonably interventionist Tory government. They will also flirt with tiny, easy and popular tax increases on pantomime villians a little more than the Tories have done.

If they plan out brave supply side measures for housing / financial / professional services I may vote for them (the Tories won't).

If they plan out brave measures to fundamentally reform the NHS and Social Care I may vote for them (the Tories won't).

Core beliefs don't matter to most voters. What matters are outcomes - a roof over their head, a job, decent healthcare & pensions. The Tories have proven themselves to be pretty hopeless at 3 of those in the last 14 years. That will be enough for most voters to put Labour into power.
Reply
#50
Did you not notice that the post was about the electoral system, not the parties?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: