Ratings
#21
(05-12-2024, 04:36 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 04:28 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: That BTA rating is criminal. Otherwise, fair enough.

He touched the ball 15 times, that's got to be one of the lowest of any striker in any game this season in the championship and we weren't pinned in and defending for 90 minutes.....we had 14 shots.

Out of those 15 touches; 4 of those he managed to pass to our own player, the other 11 times he lost it.

I have nothing against BTA, I think he's done a great job this season and we wouldn't be in the playoffs without him.....but he was bad today.
 Think that is fair assessment of today , tbf he has performed above and beyond all expectations this season in a very difficult and alien role for him, but today was just one of those off days.
Reply
#22
7's all round except Grady and BTA who get a 6
Reply
#23
Palmer 7 (haven’t seen the save again yet)
Furlong 8
Townsend 7
Kipre 7
Bartley 7.5
Okay 6
Mowatt 8.5
Tom 6
Diangana 7
Mikey 8
BTA 6

Mvila 7
Others 6
Reply
#24
I think people are being a bit harsh on Grady. V strong on the ball to day and at the heart of everything good that we did.
Reply
#25
BTA has done his best today and done what we've seen all season. There was a chance early on where he decided to volley instead of pass. Despite almost 2 seasons with Corberán he's not developed the intelligence to play the best option which is his major downfall. Everything else he's as solid as anybody else and anything less than a 6 would be harsh. He's a massive asset for us and thank fugg we didn't sell him when we had the chance or else we'd not be where we are. A player I like to watch every game. Smashing effort and his goal return ay bad either.
Reply
#26
Scoring BTA as low as 4 is just stupid. His movement in the first 15 minutes when we battered them was excellent. Yes, he disappeared in the second half - let's not forget he came from League 2 and has punched above his weight from the start. Not his fault that he's the only striker in the squad.

On which subject, it's a bit surprising that Maja wasn't even on the bench. Has he had a knock in training? I want to believe that he's had two injuries from shocking challenges and will return. But he needs to get fit and play. I have zero expectation that we'll ever get value out of Dike, but we'd be doubly unlucky if Josh turned out to be another dud.
Reply
#27
For me

Palmer 8
Furlong 8
Townsend 7
Kipre 7
Bartley 9 MOM
Okay 6
Mowatt 7
Fellows 8
Diangana 6
Mikey 8
BTA 6
Reply
#28
(05-12-2024, 09:45 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Scoring BTA as low as 4 is just stupid. His movement in the first 15 minutes when we battered them was excellent. Yes, he disappeared in the second half - let's not forget he came from League 2 and has punched above his weight from the start. Not his fault that he's the only striker in the squad.

That’s a good point. I didn’t take into account that he played for Salford a couple of years ago when rating him. I’ll give him a 7 then
Reply
#29
(05-12-2024, 06:40 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Largely agree with Slice marks.  Thought we were excellent for first 15 and edged 2nd half.  For an open team - they took few risks. Thought we had better chances and deserved the win. Marks

Palmer 7.5. Largely untroubled but great save.  Distribution was good - could of communicated better a couple of times to prevent corners

DF 8. Excellent today and kept some good players v quiet.  Got crucial touches and blocks in that minimised their chances.

Townsend 7.5.  Like last week, aggressive and defended well. Might have supported MJ a touch more but won a number of corners

Bart 8.  The best game I’ve seen from him for a while. Kept AA v quiet and defended long balls well. Should of done better with headers  Less comfortable against subs

Kipre 7.5.  Solid and physical against their strikers. Got done couple of times by Mara. Might of done better with set piece chances

Okay 6.5. Solid first 45 but Leggy again 2nd half when their no 4 kept breaking. Won key defensive headers from their corners - that were all on the money

Mowatt. 7.5.  Quiet first half but got on the ball second. Good energy and barely gave it away. Might have got a few more shots off

Grady 6.5. Decent shift off the ball but didn’t move it quickly enough when on it. Got crowded a lot when a quick layoff was needed. Should of done better with both chances

Tom 7.  Some excellent crosses and cutbacks that should have been finished off. Disciplined against Manning - just got muscled a couple of times

MJ 6.5.  Good outlet first half but really wasteful with end product. Better after the break and central to our good spell. Overhit crosses even then however

BTA. 6. V difficult role in the heat against 3 c halves. In fairness, when he did get possession we were slow to support and he lost it. Just needs to make more runs when we do have it - just to make the pitch bigger

Jed 6. Good running and closing but limited impact. Was raging on Friday after being left out

Swift 6.  Tidy on the ball but no penetration with passes or end product. Need more from him

Semi 6.5. Solidified us after their attacking changes and used ball well. Bart may be a doubt Friday

Yann 6.5. Has looked sluggish but v aggressive in his cameo and put himself about and pressed really well

Reach 5.5. Slotted in ok for CT. Loses a mark for that ridiculous volley

These ratings are closer to how I saw it. I'm in a minority of one in that I'd put Kipre higher than Bartley. I base this on Kipre's reading of the game made his partner's job easier. Bartley won a good few headers in their box though and credit to him for that.
Reply
#30
BTA 6 - his hassling of their defenders was really good in the first half but inevitably, in the hot weather, he eventually wilted.

I'd start Jed ahead of him on Friday though. I just think BTA is more effective coming on against tired defenders.

I'd also start Phillips over Johnston. Smallbone and Walker-Phillips were a handful on that left flank.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)